This is the first prospective cohort screening for late-onset Pompe disease in a high-risk population in China. In our study, the prevalence of adult Pompe disease is 1.6% in patients with unclassified axial or limb-girdle muscle weakness/ hyperCKemia/ respiratory insufficiency. This finding is slightly lower compared with previous published studies in other populations, with a combined prevalence of 2.4% (Table 3) [8–15]. Although it was reported that there is a higher prevalence of Pompe disease in Taiwan, the patients with LOPD in Taiwan often showed onset of symptoms in their second decade of life with rapid disease progression[17, 21]. In this study, since most centers involved are adult neurology departments, the prevalence of younger LOPD patients might largely be overlooked.
Table 3
High risk screening studies in late-onset Pompe disease
Year of publication
|
Country
|
Inclusion criteria
|
No. of investigated patients
|
Patients DBS positive
|
Patients with confirmed Pompe
|
LOPD prevalence (%)
|
HyperCKemia (%)
|
LGMW/AW (%)
|
Respiratory insufficiency (%)
|
Present study
|
China
|
LGMW/AW, hyperCKemia, RI
|
492
|
26
|
8
|
1.6
|
5 (62.5)
|
8 (100)
|
8 (100)
|
2019
|
Poland
|
LGMW, hyperCKemia, RSS, dyspnea, myalgia
|
337
|
18
|
10
|
3.0
|
10 (100)
|
7 (70)
|
1 (10)
|
2018
|
Turkey
|
>18 years, undiagnosed myopathic syndrome
|
350
|
21
|
4
|
1.1
|
0
|
4 (100)
|
0
|
2017
|
Korea
|
Proximal muscle weakness, axial muscle weakness, lingual weakness, RI, hyperCKemia
|
90
|
16
|
2
|
2.2
|
2 (100)
|
2 (100)
|
1 (50)
|
2017
|
Portugal
|
LGMW, hyperCKemia±hypotonia
|
99
|
4
|
4
|
4.0
|
4 (100)
|
4 (100)
|
2 (50)
|
2016
|
Germany and UK
|
LGMW, unexplained hyperCKemia
|
3076
|
232
|
74
|
2.4
|
74 (100)
|
63 (85.1)
|
47 (63.7)
|
2015
|
Spain
|
>18 years, LGMW, asymptomatic or pauci-symptomatic hyperCKemia
|
348
|
20
|
16
|
4.6
|
12 (75)
|
14 (87.5)
|
10 (62.5)
|
2015
|
Italy
|
>5 years, hyperCKemia, LGMW
|
1051
|
30
|
17
|
1.6
|
15 (94)
|
11 (65.05)
|
14 (82)
|
2014
|
Denmark
|
Unclassified LGMD, hyperCKaemia, unexplained myopathy on muscle biopsy, unexplained RI, unspecified myopathy
|
103
|
3
|
3
|
2.9
|
3 (100)
|
3 (100)
|
0
|
AW, axial weakness; LGMW, limb-girdle muscle weakness; RI, respiratory insufficiency; RSS, rigid spine syndrome; UNL, upper normal limit |
The efficacy of DBS has been described in newborn screening and other studies in Pompe disease[8–15]. Deficient DBS GAA activity can be caused by incorrect DBS spotting and sampling, and environmental circumstances such a high temperature during transport. In the Asian population, the high prevalence of the pseudodeficiency allele, which lowers GAA activity to near the Pompe disease range in normal individuals, complicated the screening for Pompe disease[10, 21–23] The pseudodeficiency variant p.[G576S; E689K] (c.[1726G>A; 2065G>A]) has been identified at high frequency in the Japanese and Chinese populations[24]. Since newborn screening study in Taiwan indicated that mass spectrometry distinguished affected and pseudodeficiency patients well[21], we chose GAA sequencing as the second test for confirmation of the diagnosis. In this study 11 of the 18 false positive samples carried at least one pseudodeficiency allele. In previous Asian studies, pseudodeficiency heterozygote/homozygote was reported to complicate Pompe disease screening[10, 21, 22]. However, mass spectrometry could help distinguish between patients with LOPD and carriers of pseudodeficiency.
In our cohort, axial/proximal limb muscle weakness remained as the core feature of LOPD. However, the serum CK levels in the newly diagnosed LOPD patients were generally low. Five out of 8 patients presented with a CK level above 1.5-fold the UNL, and only 2 patients above 2-fold the UNL. None of the patients with “asymptomatic hyperCKemia” proved to have LOPD. In contrast, in the Spanish cohort, CK was elevated, in a variable manner, in 13 of the 16 patients, with values between 2 and 8 times the upper limit of normal (UNL) [25]. In the Italian study, 5/17 (29.4%) were identified as presymptomatic LOPD patients with isolated hyperCKemia[14]. Another Spainish study revealed 2.2% prevalence of LOPD in isolated hyperCKemia[26]. Caucasian patients with LOPD have a higher prevalence of c.-32–13 T > G (around 40%). Moreover, all those presymptomatic patient were heterozygous for the common c.−32−13T>G mutation[14, 26], which is at a very low frequency in Chinese LOPD cohort[16]. This difference of mutational spectrum may explain the lower CK level observed in Chinese patients.
In LOPD, as respiratory dysfunction progresses patients develop sleep disordered breathing which progresses to nocturnal hypoventilation, and eventually development of diurnal respiratory failure. The addition of ventilation use is a significant event in disease progression, negatively affecting quality of life. The respiratory involvement in the 8 newly diagnosed patients is earlier and more severe compared to previous high risk screening studies[8, 12, 14]. One patient (Pt.3) initially manifested with exertional dyspnea with preserved limb-girdle muscle strength and biceps muscle biopsy showed no vacuolar pathology. This was in accordance with a recent report that, compared with patients in other parts of the world, the lung function of Chinese patients with LOPD were worse, manifested by lower forced vital capacity and maximum expiratory and inspiratory pressure[7]. Generally, the predictive threshold of FVC-U for nighttime ventilation was 39% of predicted[27]. However, hypercapnia could happen in patients with larger ventilatory reserve, as Pt 2 and 6 in our study. It may involve both the presence of sleep-disordered breathing and blunted ventilatory responsiveness[27, 28]. Monitoring of respiration and/or gas exchange during sleep is especially of importance for the onset of sleep disordered breathing can be easily missed.
In conclusion, we recommend that DBS and tandem mass spectrometry test be undertaken early in the diagnosis workup of high-risk patients to exclude LOPD. Extension to patients with sleep disordered breathing rather than isolated hyperCKemia is recommended in Chinese population. Such approach will facilitate early diagnosis and allows to start the treatment at less advanced stages of the disease.