The effect Deletion of several extracellular protein genes and its effects
B.subtilis G423, a host of the γ-PGA synthase expression plasmid, its genes encoding neutral metalloprotease NprE (EC: 3.4.24.28), alkaline serine protease AprE (EC: 3.4.21.62), xylanase XynA (EC:3.2.1.8), chitosanase Csn (EC:3.2.1.132) and hypothetical proteins (YolA, YolB and YncM) had been deleted in our previous work. Based on the physiological functions and 2D-PAGE of the extracellular proteins (Tjalsma H et al. 2004; Yamane K et al. 2000), it could be confirmed that the biofilm constituent proteins TasA and YqxM, lipase LipA (EC: 3.1.1.3), serine proteases Epr (EC: 3.4.21.-), bacillus peptidase Bpr (EC: 3.4.21.-) and the unknown proteins YlqB and YweA were the retained extracellular proteins with high content in B.subtilis G423 broth. Therefore, it is necessary that the genes encoding the above proteins should be deleted in G423 strain to prevent their synthesis.
As a result, the tasA-yqxM operon, lip, epr, bpr, ylqB and yweA genes was successively knocked out from G423 strain and the deficient strain GH16 was obtained. After introducing the γ-PGA expression plasmid pHPG into the GH16 strain, shake flask fermentation of G423/pHPG and GH16/pHPG showed that the deletion of these genes had no significant effect on cell growth and γ-PGA synthesis (Fig. 2A). Also, the conversion rate, ratio of γ-PGA production to glucose and glutamate consumption, only changed slightly (Fig. 3A and Table 1). However, the protein content in γ-PGA produced by G423/pHPG and GH16/pHPG was 1.48% and 1.39% respectively, and the decline was 6.08%(Fig. 3B and Table 1). SDS-PAGE analysis of the extracellular proteins extracted from the fermentation broth of G423 strain and GH16 strain showed no significant difference in the protein bands (Fig. 4). Consequently, TasA, YqxM, Epr, Bpr, LipA, YlqB and YweA were not the major extracellular proteins and had a slight effect on improving the purity of γ-PGA with the deletion of the above genes.
Table 1
Comparison of γ-PGA fermentation results between G423/pHPG and mutant strains
Strains
|
γ-PGA
yield
(g·L-1)
|
Protein
content
(%)
|
Polysaccharide content
(%)
|
conversion rate
(glucose-based)
(%)
|
conversion rate
(glutamic-based)
(%)
|
G423/pHPG
|
24.67±0.89
|
1.48±0.07
|
2.21±0.09
|
74.02±1.02
|
95.25±0.57
|
GH16/pHPG
|
24.52±1.01
|
1.39±0.08
|
NA
|
72.33±1.66
|
94.67±1.21
|
GH17/pHPG
|
25.51±0.85
|
1.24±0.07
|
NA
|
80.22±0.98
|
97.00±0.89
|
GH18/pHPG
|
24.82±0.94
|
1.07±0.1
|
2.17±0.14
|
77.56±0.79
|
96.58±0.43
|
GH19/pHPG
|
25.22±0.73
|
0.83±0.05
|
NA
|
78.57±1.32
|
96.63±0.93
|
GH21/pHPG
|
22.40±0.38
|
NA
|
1.93±0.11
|
74.42±0.65
|
96.55±1.13
|
Effects of deleting the fla-che operon
The fla-che operon of B. subtilis, consisting of 31 coding sequences, encodes hook-basal body (HBB), RNA polymerase recognition factor SigD and other proteins related to chemotaxis (Estacio W et al. 1998). In addition, the flgM operon, hag gene and yvyC-fliT operon are responsible for synthesizing the filament proteins and junction proteins(Estacio W et al. 1998). The above flagellar proteins are present in the fermentation broth of Bacillus subtilis with a high content (Tjalsma H et al. 2004; Yamane K et al. 2000), which may affect the purity of the γ-PGA product. Coincidentally, the expression of flgM operon, hag gene and yvyC-fliT operon are all dependent on the presence of SigD factor (Mukherjee S and Kearns DB 2014). Therefore, as long as the fla-che operon was deleted, these genes encoding flagellar proteins will be silenced.
The flagellar deficient strain GH17 was constructed by deleting the front 30 genes of the fla-che operon in GH16 strain and terminal ylxL gene was retained. As a result, the deletion of fla-che operon reduced the protein content in γ-PGA to 1.24% and promoted the synthesis of γ-PGA (Table 1 and Fig. 3A). Compared to the GH16/pHPG strain, the decrease rate of protein content was 10.8% (Fig. 3B). It indicated that the deletion of fla-che operon can help to reduce the synthesis of extracellular proteins and improve the purity of γ-PGA product.
The biomass of GH17 strain in shaker fermentation was slightly higher than that of the GH16 strain (Fig. 2A). The defect of flagella was likely to reduce the metabolic load of cells so that lead to a higher biomass. This view could also be supported by the fact that the glucose conversion rate based on γ-PGA production had increased from 72.33–80.22% (Table 1). At the same time, the conversion rate of glutamic acid increased from 94.67–97% (Table 1) and this might be related to the inhibition of the synthesis of a large number of flagellin. In addition, the GH17 cells was filamentous during exponential growth phase (Fig. 5), however, the cells gradually became shorter as its propagation and returned to normal when it reached exponential phase. This phenomenon was clearly associated with the presence of autolysin which expressed by the gene lytA-lytF in Bacillus subtilis. It was worth noting that the sigD factor was necessary for lytA-lytF expression and the separation of the daughter cells formed by cell division requires the autolysin in the growth process (Mukherjee S and Kearns DB 2014). However, in GH17 strain, the lytA-lytF genes could not be expressed because of the defect of SigD and thus the daughter cells cannot separate normally. Furthermore, the mechanism by which cell morphology returns to normal in the stationary phase may be related to the function of peptidoglycanase gene cwlO (Mitsui N et al. 2011). Our team will pay more attention to the dominant of morphological change in the future.
Partial deletion of PBSX and its effects
PBSX was resident as a prophage on the chromosome of B. subtilis 168, with a size of 28 kb (Krogh S et al. 1996). Some proteins encoded by genes from PBSX, such as XkdG, XkdK and XlyA were also detected in the fermentation broth of Bacillus subtilis (Tjalsma H et al. 2004; Yamane K et al. 2000). Therefore, it might be necessary to delete part of the PBSX sequences to reduce the amount of extracellular proteins.
A total of 26.1kb PBSX sequences from xkdB to xlyA gene were deleted from GH17 strain and the resultant strain GH18 was obtained. We found that the biomass of GH18 was always slightly lower than that of GH17 throughout the fermentation process(Fig. 2B) and the maximum biomass of GH18 was 1.37 OD lower than that of GH17. At the same time, the γ-PGA yield of GH18/pHPG also decreased slightly with a rate of 2.7% (Fig. 3B and Table 1). Those apparent changes could be attributed to the large-scale absence of PBSX, which reflected the complexity of the physiological relationship between the prophage and the host. However, it maked sense that the protein content in γ-PGA extracted from fermentation broth of GH18/pHPG was 1.07%, which was decreased by 13.7%. On the whole, in order to reduce extracellular proteins and improve the purity of γ-PGA product, PBSX defect is necessary and its mild negative effects can be ignored.
The extracellular proteins secreted by the GH18 strain
In the γ-PGA extracted from fermentation broth of GH18/pHPG strain, about 1.0% of the proteins still remained. Therefore, the advanced high-resolution mass spectrometry was used to analyze the extracellular proteins of GH18 strain. As a result, a total of 449 kinds of proteins were identified in the protein extract. The abundance of each protein was characterized by the peak area of the mass spectrum, and the results showed that Yrpd was the most abundant protein. Then we used the peak area of Yrpd as a benchmark, and defined the ratio of the peak area of a protein to the peak area of Yrpd as the relative abundance of the protein. Finally, there were 60 proteins with a relative abundance of more than 0.2% (Supplementary Table 4). Among them, some proteins had a relative abundance of more than 3%, which were Yxal, Ywof, YjdB, L-lactate dehydrogenase Ldh (EC:1.1.1.27) and YoqM. However, YjdB, Ldh and YoqM had never been isolated or identified by the 2D-PAGE (Tjalsma H et al. 2004; Yamane K et al. 2000). In addition, the order of protein spot size was Yxal>YrpD>Ywof in the previous 2D gel map, which was different from our observation. It was worth noting that the proteins whose encoding genes had been deleted in the strain GH18 such as Hag, FlgK, FliD, XkdG, XkdK and XlyA were not detected. This confirmed the validity of the previously performed gene knockout at the translation level.
From Table 3, a number of non-secretory proteins with high abundance were identified by mass spectrometry,such as L-lactate dehydrogenase (relative abundance 3.3%), Acetolactate synthase (relative abundance 1.8%) and Enolase (relative abundance 1.4%). Those proteins, which were intracellular proteins involved in central carbon metabolism, had not been shown to exist in Bacillus subtilis fermentation broth. We assumed that they came from autolyzed cells or leaked from cells under the fermentation conditions.
Defects of extracellular proteins YrpD, YwoF and YclQ
Based on the results of mass spectrometry, the encoding genes of three unknown proteins YrpD, YwoF and YclQ were selected to be deleted in the GH18 strain and the resultant strain GH19 and GH19/pHPG were fermented, respectively. The results of fermentation showed that the biomass of GH19 strain was slightly higher than that of GH18 and was slightly lower than that of GH17 (Fig. 2B). Also, there was no any adverse effect on γ-PGA yield and on the conversion rate of glucose and glutamic acid. (Table 1). The protein content in γ-PGA produced by the GH19/pHPG strain was 22.4% lower than that of GH18/pHPG. From the perspective of the relative abundance of proteins, the decrease of protein content in the γ-PGA product of GH19/pHPG was mainly attributed to the absence of YrpD and YwoF. As shown in Fig. 4, the SDS-PAGE results of extracellular proteins also support this conclusion that the bands of proteins around 17 kDa and 58 kDa almost disappeared. The size of these two protein bands was closed to the size of YrpD and YwoF, whose theoretical molecular mass was 24.9 kDa and 51.4 kDa respectively.
Obviously, the high resolution mass spectrometry provided us with precise and reliable data. It was expected that the purity of the γ-PGA product will be further improved by further reducing the synthesis of extracellular proteins based on the reliable data.
Deletion of the epsA-O operon and its effects
Using phenol-sulfuric acid method, it was found that the γ-PGA product contained 2.21% polysaccharides (Table 1) which were apparently originated from extracellular polysaccharides secreted by Bacillus subtilis. EPS was one of the major polysaccharides believed to be present extracellularly (Nagorska K et al. 2010), and it was the main component of the biofilm. In this study, the EPS coding gene epsA-O was knocked out to prevent the synthesis of such extracellular polysaccharides.
The 15 kb epsA-O operon was deleted in GH18 strain so that EPS-deficient strain GH21 and GH21/pHPG was obtained. Shake flask fermentation showed that the deletion of the epsA-O operon did not affect cells growth (data not shown). The polysaccharide content in γ-PGA product was reduced to 1.93% and the decrease rate was 11%. At the same time, the γ-PGA yield of GH21/pHPG was unexpectedly reduced by 9.8% compared to that of GH18/pHPG (Table 1). Therefore, considering the deletion of epsA-O operon could not effectively reduce the content of polysaccharide in the γ-PGA product and it would also bring down the γ-PGA yield, it was not necessary to knock out the epsA-O operon from the γ-PGA production strain.
In addition, the surface of the colony of GH21 still showed the characteristics of glossy and moist, and there was no difference with GH18 strain. This results were not identical to previous observation in the Bacillus amyloliquefaciens (Feng J et al. 2015) and it showed that in addition to EPS, Bacillus subtilis 168 secreted a considerable amount of other types of polysaccharides. Previous data had shown that B. subtilis could also secrete fructans with the medium contained sucrose (Dedonder R 1966). Since sucrose was not used as a carbon source in this study, the polysaccharide in theγ-PGA product was unlikely to be levan. Therefore, exploring the types of polysaccharides that exist extracellularly and affect the purity of γ-PGA is a problem worth studying in the future.