Pak choi with cold treatment shows great biomass under heat stress
Environmental stresses have become an important constraint impacting grain yields in crops. Perception mechanism of plant involved in heat stress is very complicated, which has not been fully understood yet. Plasma membranes sense heat stress and cause the elevated level of Ca2+, which can act as a second messenger to induce the expression of heat stress response genes (Ma et al, 2020). We assumed that cooling can instantly reduce the plant surface temperature in order to reduce the damage of high temperature to plant plasma membrane. To investigate this possibility, we set the temperature of water as 15, 20 and 25 ℃, which were applied to the seedlings divided into T1, T2 and T3 groups respectively. The morphological indexes of three treatments of pak choi under heat stress were examined (Table 1). The phenotypes of the three groups of seedlings are shown in Figure 1. The T2 seedlings shows greater growth vigor than T1 and T3. the T3 seedlings showed slower growth rate and smaller leaves, which can be explained that the low temperature water alleviates the damage of heat stress to the growth and metabolism of pak choi to a certain extent.
Table 1
The growth index of pakchoi seedlings on water of varying temperatue.
water temperature(℃)
|
dry weight(g)
|
fresh weight(g)
|
leaf area(cm2)
|
leaf number
|
Stem diameter (mm)
|
15
|
0.2767±0.0723a
|
3.23±0.9522b
|
72.1077±10.6058b
|
8±0.0000b
|
2.5700±0.6128a
|
20
|
0.2433±0.0513a
|
2.5967±1.1926b
|
93.5547±16.7950a
|
8.3333±0.5773b
|
2.98±0.6605a
|
25
|
0.3167±0.0450a
|
4.86±0.1852a
|
82.6599±7.0193b
|
9±0.000a
|
2.2767±0.2103b
|
water temperature(℃)
|
Total root length
|
Root surface area
|
root tip number
|
Plant height (cm)
|
15
|
31.8757±0.949a
|
8.648±0.4825a
|
378±2.6457b
|
13.3667±1.8448a
|
20
|
26.2±1.5488b
|
8.6223±0.2100a
|
298±12.49a
|
13.1673±1.1676a
|
25
|
28.3433±0.9342b
|
7.1828±0.4015b
|
241.333±6.429c
|
10.0652±1.1471b
|
Leaf is responsible for photosynthesis of the crop, and the leaf area affects light absorption directly. We counted the leaf number and area of pak choi within the three groups. The result suggested that there is no significant difference in the leaf number among the three groups of pak choi. The leaf area of the T2 group has increased by 13.18% compared to the T1 group, and has increased by 29.74% compared with the T3 group (Table 1). Larger leaf area is conducive to the accumulation of crop assimilation. Root is an important plant organ which has multiple functions, including acquisition and fixation of water and nutrient, perception of environment changes in soil, and synthesization of phytohormone (Ma et al, 2018). Thus, root branching and root surface are important aspect of root system architecture which directly affect the absorption of water and nutrients. We then measured the total root surface area, root length, as well as root tip number. The cold water treatment has no obvious effect on the root surface area, but the root length and root tip number are significantly increased. Compared with the control, the root length of T1 and T2 increased by 7.56% and 12.46% respectively. Concerning root tip number, T1 and T2 increased by 19.01% and 26.84% compared to control, respectively (Table 1). We guess that longer root length and more root tips will help plants absorb more water and nutrients.
Chlorophyll is the main pigment for photosynthesis of plants, which functions in harvesting light energy and driving electron transfer (Wang et al, 2018). Accumulating evidence suggested that chlorophylls were degradated and the photosynthetic machinery was dismantled in plants under heat stress (Wang et al, 2018). The chlorophyll breakdown into nonphototoxic pigments in combination with carotenoid retention or anthocyanin accumulation (Hörtensteiner, 2009; Hörtensteiner, 2006; Stefan and Urs, 2002; Ginsburg and Matile, 1997). We next analyzed the chlorophyll content in treated seedlings. In light of our results, the content of chlorophyll a, chlorophyll b and carotenoid in pak choi treated with low temperature water were significantly higher than control. The level of Chl a in T1 and T2 seedlings increased by 11.03% and 38.19% compared to control respectively. Moreover, the ratio of Chl a/ Chl b in T2 was significantly higher than control. Meanwhile, a decrease in Carotenoid level was observed in T2 compared to control (Figure 2 ).
To confirm the greater biomass accumulation in pak choi treated with low temperature water, we measured the the content of soluble sugar, protein and Vitamin C (Figure 2), which affects the osmotic pressure in plant cells. In the experimental results presented in Figure 2, T2 plant leaves accumulated about 1.5 fold increase in soluble sugar and about 1.22 fold increase in soluble protein than control. It suggests that more soluble sugar and soluble protein are synthesized when treated with cold water. The level of Vitamin C was also enhanced under cold water treatment. On the other hand, The altered level of soluble sugars and proteins are is advantageous to regulate osmotic pressure within the cell.These data suggested that the nutritional content of pak choi has been improved under cold water treatment.
Cold treatment enhances the activities of ROS-scavenging enzymes
In plants, ROS are generated in the redox reactions, like respiration and photosynthesis. ROS participate in all aspects of growth and development, such as cell proliferation and differentiation, gravitropism, programmed cell death, seed germination, root hair growth and pollen tube development, senescence (Singh et al, 2016). In many cases, heat stress contribute to various metabolic changes, known as elevated ROS levels which generates mainly in PS II and PSI (Asada et al, 2006). To enhance the heat tolerance and detoxify ROS under environmental stress, plants recruit the antioxidant enzymes including superoxide dismutase (SOD), ascorbate peroxidase (APX), catalase (CAT). To confirm whether alternative detoxification pathways were activated under low temperature water treatment, we measured the activity of ROS-scavenging enzymes. We found that the activity of SOD, APX, CAT in T2 seedlings were highest than T1 and T3 seedlings (Figure 3), which is line with previous findings (Ara et al, 2013). On top of this, we determined the release of H2O2 and O2− from the three group of pak choi. In our study, these data suggest that H2O2 production decreased 32.32% in T2 compared to control (Figure 4). It showed that plants under low temperature treatments had the stronger ability to remove H2O2 and O2− compared to control. In order to detect the level of membrane lipid peroxidation in plants, we also tested the differences in plant malondialdehyde (MDA) content and relative electrical conductivity (REC) between treatments. We found that plants have lower MDA content and lower relative electrical conductivity under low temperature treatment (Figure 4). MDA is a substance produced by membrane lipids under the action of reactive oxygen species(Djanaguiraman et al, 2010). Its content reflected the degree of plasma membrane damage. It is proposed that the REC of the leaves can be measured to determine the damage of the high temperature to the leaves. In accordance with these above findings, our study suggested that low temperature water treatment on the one hand reduces the damage of high temperature to leaf cell membrane lipids, on the other hand, it improves the activity of various enzymes to scavenge free radicals to avoid damage to plants.
Enhanced photosynthetic capacity in pak choi with cold water treatment under heat stress
Multi environmental stresses can alter the activity of the photosynthetic electron transport chain, which can reduce photochemical reaction efficiency, create excess absorption of light energy, and induce aggravated photoinhibition (Xalxo et al, 2020). Recent research showed that elevated ambient temperature have profound effects on photosynthetic capacity of plants (Wahid et al, 2007; Allakhverdiev et al, 2008; JA et al, 1980). It affects the chlorophyll content, photosynthetic enzyme activity, stomatal opening as well as hormone secretion of plant. High temperature seriously impede photosynthetic efficiency, diminishes productivity and shortens the plant life cycle (Xalxo et al, 2020). To get detailed information about gas exchange parameters, we measured the net photosynthetic rate (Pn), stomatal conductance (gs), transpiration rate (E) and intercellular CO2 concentration (Ci) [Figure 5]. The Pn of pak choi under low temperature water treatment was significantly higher than the control. the Pn of pak choi was 12.61 µmol m−2∙s−1 (T1), 13.75m−2∙s−1(T2), 11.33m−2∙s−1(T3) 6h later. E and gs of T1 and T2 was significant higher than control while Ci of T1 and T2 is significantly lower than control. The above findings suggested that low temperature water treatments can enhance the gas exchange capacity of pak choi under heat stress.
Fv/Fm and Pm of pakchoi under cold water treatment
Fv/Fm is an important indicator for studying the effects of photoinhibition or various environmental stresses on photosynthesis. As the strong evidence supports that the Fv/Fm value of plants will decrease under various environmental stresses. Thus we measured the maximum photochemical efficiency of PSII (Fv/Fm) of pakchoi leaves with three treatments.
We found that the Fv/Fm of pak choi under low temperature water treatment was higher than that of control. It is worth noting that the Fv/Fm of T1 is lower than the T2 (Figure 6). This may be explained that extremely low temperature water will inhibit plant photosynthetic activity. Meanwhile, the maximum oxidation state of PSI (Pm) of three treatment was measured (Figure 6). The Pm of the pakchoi under low temperature water treatment is approximately 1.45 time that of control. These results indicated that low temperature treatment counteract the inhibition of redox state of PSI and reduced the damage induced by heat stress. Thus we proposed that short time heat adjustment improved the maximum light energy conversion efficiency of PS II in pak choi leaves.
In order to clarify the potential photosynthetic activity of pak choi under varying temperature of water treatment, we measured the rapid light curves of plants under different ambient light intensity. photochemical quenching coefficient (qP) of pak choi leaves show a rapid elevation at all illumination conditions (Figure 7). Many studies showed that qP reflects the photosynthetic activity of plants. The result suggested that the activity of PSII photochemical reactions under low temperature water treatment was higher than that under room water treatment.
Effect of cold water treatment on the PSII and PSI Activity of pak choi Leaves under heat stress
Previous reports demonstrated that heat stress damaged thylakoid membranes, reduced the activities of membrane associated electron carriers and enzymes (Zhao et al, 2020; Hasanuzzaman et al, 2013). Under heat stress, the Fv/Fm and PSII electron transfer efficiency in plants was decreased, and the formation of NADPH and ATP was prevented which further resulted in the reduced photosynthetic rate. Since PSII is the most heat-sensitive complex within the chloroplast thylakoid membrane protein complexes (Hasanuzzaman et al, 2013; Szymańska etal, 2017), we measured the photosynthetic quantum yields for PSI and PSII (Figure 8). We observed that the effective quantum yield of PSII gradually decreased with increasing light intensity in three treatment, while the Y(II) was significantly higher under the cold water treatments compared to control (Figure 8). Our results showed cold water treatment caused a modest elevation in the quantum yield of non-regulated energy dissipation in PSII [Y(NO)](Figure 1). The higher Y(NO) of control compared to T1 and T2 indicated that control lost the ability to protect themselves in excess light. Y (NPQ) represents the energy dissipated into heat through the regulatory photoprotection mechanism. It has been proposed that plants can avoid ROS damage caused by excessive light excitation through antioxidant system and NPQ mechanism (Zhang et al, 2014). In our research, the quantum yield of regulated energy dissipation in PSII [Y(NPQ)] was highest in T2 seedlings. The NPQ was increased at almost all light intensities in three treatments. It indicated that the low temperature water treatment enhanced the capacity to induce photoprotection of PSII. Additionally, The quantum yield of PSI [Y(I)] increase first and then decrease rapidly with the increasing light intensity. The Y(I) of T2 was higher than T1 and T3 especially under high light intensities. It suggested the low temperature water treatment increase the the quantum yield of PSI. In addition, we observed that cold water treatment significantly reduced the quantum yield of non photochemical energy dissipation caused by donor side restriction (ND) while the quantum yield of PSI non-photochemical energy by the receptor side restriction (NA) has no significant difference between treatments (Figure 7). All of these observations strengthen that the cold water treatment.
Effect of cold water treatment on the Electron Transport Rate of pak choi Leaves under heat stress
The electron transfer rate of PSII [ETR (II)] and PSI [ETR (I)] were measured to evaluate the photosynthetic performance. As shown in Figure 8, electron transport rates of both PSII and PSI, ETR (I) were significantly higher with CWT compared to those of control plants under high light level. The ETRI and ETRII of pak choi leaves rapidly increased with increasing light intensity in all treatments. We also found the low temperature water treatment significantly improve the cyclic electron flow around PSI (CEF) (Figure 1). Previous studies demonstrated that CEF compel the excess electron flow to NADPH and O2, avoiding the generation of ROS. Besides, CEF deplete the excess reducing power of NADPH via NADPH dehydrogenase-dependent pathway. The stimulated CEF contributed the high level of Y (NPQ). Thus we induced that the CWT can stimulate the CEF to protect the PSI from photo-inhibition.
Redox state of PSI and PQ pool size
The response of P700 redox kinetics to diverse water temperature was measured with applications of ST or MT flashes on an FR light background. In the experimental results presented in Figure 6, The plastoquinone (PQ) pool size in the pak choi leaves under cold water treatments exhibited a 1.48 fold larger functional PQ pool in comparison with control. We supposed that the reduction of PQ is responsible for the blocking of the electron transport. As Figure 1 shown, Turn on the far red light, the P700 signal rises, turn off the far red light after it is stable, and P700+ quickly restores until the signal is stable. Illumination of the sample with FR light contributes to the change in A820 which reflects the dynamic changes of P700 to P700+. Our result showed that there was no significant difference in the rate of dark reduction between treatments according to the initial slope method.