4.1 Drivers (D) of land use, land cover, and climate change
Drivers are essential societal needs like food, shelter, energy, and transport that have to be met regularly, and are in two categories, namely proximate (Dregne 2002; Lambin and Geist 2008) and underlying (Tiffen et al., 1994; Kabubo-Mariara 2007). The requirements for meeting these needs vary from one country to another and from urban to rural settings. In the less developed countries, like Uganda, especially in rural settings, the immediate needs are met mainly by using natural resources (Reynolds et al., 2007; Bremner et al., 2010). During data collection, six significant drivers were identified by the local communities. These included population increase (Figure 3), climate change, economic development, politics, low education levels, and land tenure.
The population increase was identified as a number one driver in eight of the nine FGDs carried out, except in Nakapiripirit (Karamoja region), where low education levels/high illiteracy rates ranked highest. Population pressure has impacted land, wetlands, and forests, which have been degraded to meet the essential human needs, primarily through agriculture. UBOS data indicates the study area as one of the most populated regions in the country (UBOS, 2020) as shown in figure 4.
Whereas high population impacts LULC change and CC, the youthful population structure in Uganda and in the study area in particular, where up to 78% of the population is below 30 years of age, is worrying. Uganda’s average population density is estimated at 228/Km2, with a growth rate of 3.32% and a fertility rate of 4.78 births per woman, hence ranking among the highest globally UBOS (2020). Such population growth rate is associated with rapid urbanization and high poverty levels observed in the study area. With an unemployment rate of over 2.9%, which is higher than the national rate of 2.44, this population is now heavily dependent on natural resources as sources of income or doing petty jobs in the urban centers. Therefore, the young, energetic population, dependent on parents, has become a real burden to the natural resources, as they are being used as human labor to degrade natural resources, which in turn has resulted in CC, as has been observed by other studies (Reynolds et al., 2007; de Sherbinin et al., 2008; Alemayehu et al., 2009; Bremner et al., 2010; Akhtar et al., 2011; Kirui and Mirzabaev 2015; Ashfaq et al., 2019).
Population-related drivers also act synergistically with other community aspects, like poverty, socio-economics, and environmental factors, causing LULC change and CC. Poverty, an underlying driver, in synergy with other factors was the second driver of LULC changes and CC, as poor people depend on natural resources, as pointed out by other authors in Kenya (Kirui et al 2015), the USA (Bremner et al., 2010) and Germany, (Biraso et al 2014). National poverty indices showed Eastern alongside the Northern regions as one of the poorest in Uganda (UBOS 2020; UNICEF 2020).
The need for shelters, energy in the form of firewood and charcoal and hunger, low education levels, weak law enforcement, urbanization for alternative income, lack of cash crops, loss of cultural values, and high cost of land were other drivers of LULC change and CC; all these factors are related to the high youthful population. This agrees with what was found by other authors (Lambin et al., 2001; Geist and Lambin 2002; Harte 2007). In Nakapiripirit and Karamoja areas, low education level, hence high illiteracy, was the number one driver. Production of domestic and industrial effluents from Karamoja mineral mining, and domestic effluents from urban centers, including Mbale, Soroti cities, Iganga, and Tororo municipalities, impacted the land and water resources, as pointed out by other studies (Kristensen 2004; Anaba et al., 2016). Climate change was also identified as one of the significant drivers of LULC changes in the study area. This was in agreement with the findings of CC in the study area, reported in the related study (Obubu et al., 2021). Deforestation and wetland degradation, aggravated by high population, lead to CC; meanwhile, CC leads to forest and wetland loss, a vicious cycle that is observed globally (Bremner et al., 2010 Nkonya et al., 2011; Biraso et al., 2014). Political interference was cited as one of the drivers of LULC changes, especially in wetland and forest degradation. This was cited in Pallisa, Kibuku, Kumi, and other districts, where politicians would urge their constituents to defy regulations and encroach on wetlands and forests for political gain, especially during elections. Limoto wetland, located between Pallisa and Kibuku, is an example where political interference seriously compromised conservation activities.
Land tenure systems were also pointed out as drivers of LULC change and CC. There were four types of land tenure systems in the study area: customary ownership; which was the most dominant type, community; leasehold in urban centers; and cultural land ownerships. Customary tenure was identified as a driver of LULC change as parents have to keep on sub-dividing the finite land to the infinite number of children. This would result in land fragmentation and conflicts between families. This study revealed that, in Bududa, the amount of land a son inherits is dependent on how well-behaved his wife is to the parents-in-law. The participants noted the difficulty in commercializing customary, communal, and cultural lands without the parents' permission, community and cultural leaders, and the result was land fragmentation for agriculture and settlement. In Nakapiripirit, the communities accused the local government leaders of taking advantage of communal land tenure by selling and leasing it to commercial developers like companies and academic institutions without consulting them, thus changing LU’s purpose. Acerer village and Nakapiripirit town council were cited as examples where such abuse of land tenure systems was rampant. These findings agree with what was found in Kenya by Kakubo-Mariana (2007) where issues of land rights and land conservation were discussed.
4.2 Pressures of land use, land cover changes, and climate change
The need to meet the drivers of LULC change and CC results in exploiting natural resources; these exploitative activities place pressure on the environment (land and water) (Kelble et al., 2013). The pressures were grouped into thematic areas, with agriculture, urbanization, and economic development identified and leading pressures (Figure 3). Many people are entirely dependent on agriculture, just like it is the mainstay in the country, where it supports over 70% of the local economy (Ojara et al., 2020). Although maize, sorghum, rice, and millet were cultivated across the study area, Arabica coffee was unique to the mid and upstream districts on Mt. Elgon like Mbale, Bududa, Kapchorwa, as the weather here and high altitudes above 1,600 m.a.s.l favors it (MWE 2015). Cassava was dominant in the downstream districts of Serere, Kumi, and Palissa. The demand for food resulted in the conversion of wetlands, riverbanks, l, and forests into agricultural lands as observed in Limoto wetland in Palissa, a situation observed in Kampala, Uganda (Matagi 2002), in Kenya, Malawi, and Tanzania (Kirui et al., 2015). There was also reported cultivation on the steep slopes of Mt. Elgon with minimum terracing, a practice that has resulted in the mud and landslides during rainy seasons, with many damages to infrastructure and deaths almost on an annual basis as was also pointed out by Dregne (2002).
Boosting agricultural production to meet food demands is now supported by applying agrochemicals, as reported by the participants (Table 1). These included fertilizers, herbicides, and pesticides. The participants emphasized that, without their use, the farmers get poor and low yields. Other reasons for using these chemicals included loss of soil fertility, losses due to pests and diseases, and CC. It was only in Nakapiripirit, where agrochemicals were not being used yet, due to land availability, small population, good soil fertility, and nomadic lifestyle.
Table 1
Agricultural chemicals used in L. Kyoga Basin
SN
|
Fertilizers for agriculture
|
Pesticides trade name
|
Herbicides trade name
|
1
|
Nitrogen, phosphorus, and potassium (NPK) based e.g., Sukulu
|
Super grow
|
Roundup contains glyphosate
|
2
|
Organic/Manure
|
Dudu cipher
|
Weed master contains glyphosate
|
3
|
Urea
|
Rocket
|
2-4 Dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2-4-D)
|
4
|
Diammonium phosphate (DAP)
|
Striker
|
Diamine
|
5
|
Calcium ammonium nitrate (CAN)
|
Tafgor/dimethoate (Organophosphate)
|
Force up, contains glyphosate
|
6
|
Vegimax (Organic-NPK)
|
Ambush
|
Ametrine
|
7
|
Evergreen
|
Dudumaki
|
|
8
|
Allwin gold super
|
Golden drop, an organo-silicon based
|
|
9
|
Rhizobium (biological fertilizer)
|
|
|
10
|
Digrow (Organic Plus foliar fertilizer)
|
|
|
11
|
Aminocop
|
|
|
12
|
TAP Triamide phosphoryl
|
|
|
The communities started using these chemicals at varied times; the upstream districts over 30 years ago, while the downstream districts started as recently as five years ago. This confirmed the argument that upstream districts lost fertility earlier due to soil erosion, while the downstream district had fertile soils due to deposition of nutrients and sediments from upstream districts. Land fragmentation has affected most parts of the study area as shown by the widespread use of agrochemicals, except in Nakapiripirit. This was confirmed by the KIs, who indicated that the land was in plenty and fertile in the past 30-40 years. Fallowing eliminated the need for the use of agrochemicals. These agrochemicals affect soils, but especially the water quality of the receiving water resources, like rivers Awoja and Mpologoma and L. Kyoga, through run-off, facilitated by CC (Obubu et al., 2021). Similar observations were also made in Qatar and Ethiopia (Akhtar et al., 2011; Gebremedhin et al., 2018).
Urban centers have put pressure on land as agricultural land, forests, and in some cases, wetlands have been converted into urban centers, like Imatakojo forest in Pallisa district, which was converted into an urban center, as has also been observed in other areas (McKinney 2002; Tang et al., 2005; Akhfar et al., 2011; Rawat and Kumar 2015; Gebremedhin et al., 2018). Forests have been degraded to provide timber for construction and energy in form of charcoal and firewood. Meanwhile, domestic wastes from these centers are also sources of contamination of land and water resources. Sewerage effluent data from Soroti and Mbale cities and Tororo and Iganga municipalities were obtained from the MWE from 2014 to 2021. The mean annual values for Electrical conductivity (EC), pH range, Total Suspended Solids (TSS), Total Phosphorus (TP), Total Nitrogen (TN), and Biochemical Oxygen Demand (BOD) were compared with the National Environment (Standards for discharge of effluent into water or land) Regulations 2020, (Table 2).
Table 2
Domestic effluents against wastewater discharge standards
Year
|
EC (µS/cm)
|
pH (pH units)
|
TSS (mg/l)
|
TP (mg/l)
|
TN (mg/l)
|
BOD (mg/l)
|
COD (mg/l)
|
2014
|
884
|
8.0-10.0
|
|
3.16
|
|
35
|
231
|
2015
|
612
|
7.1-9.2
|
75
|
|
|
12
|
144
|
2016
|
1039
|
6.8-9.4
|
136
|
3.6
|
|
187
|
1438
|
2017
|
837
|
6.8-8.6
|
210
|
|
|
18
|
152
|
2018
|
1098
|
6.9-9.1
|
|
|
75.7
|
7
|
264
|
2020
|
|
6.8-9.9
|
|
|
|
69
|
156
|
2021
|
1059
|
5.3-11.0
|
309
|
7.9
|
52.8
|
26
|
366
|
Effluent Standard
|
750
|
5.0-8.5
|
50
|
5
|
10
|
50
|
70
|
Data source: Ministry of Water and Environment |
All the parameters were at least above the standards in different years, putting pressure on the water quality of L. Kyoga and land. The EC met the standards in 2016, and pH tended to alkalinity in all the years. TSS, COD, and TN did not meet the standards; BOD in two years (2016 and 2020) out of the seven years did not meet the standards, the result is the pollution of water resources and land. According to local communities, other economic activities in the study area that exerted pressure on natural resources were the development of agro-processing industries like distilleries, where raw hot waste was released into the environment without treatment, affecting receiving water ecosystems such as River Nakibiso in Mbale district. As a result, parts of the river had been seriously contaminated, rendering the water unfit for any use. The participants in Nakapiripirit district also reported pollution from artisanal mining activities of minerals like gold. Meanwhile, most industries in Mbale and Tororo districts were found to operate dry processes, hence the need to monitor gaseous emissions and their effects on the atmosphere and CC, which was not done in the study.
4.3 State of land use, land cover change, and climate change
Given that drivers are the human needs, and pressures are the activities carried out using the natural resources to satisfy the needs, the transformation of natural resources, hence the loss of quality ecosystem services they provide, represents the state of particular natural resources. (Kristensen 2004, Gessesew 2017).
4.3.1 State of water and environment
Participants ranked land, wetlands, forests, and riverbanks as the most degraded land uses, especially for agriculture. Soil erosion, bare land, and formation of gullies, especially in the upstream districts at the slopes of Mt. Elgon, but also in Pallisa was reported. Protected areas are getting degraded by displaced people as the population keeps increasing. There was also a reported increase in pests and diseases, although this could not be independently verified due to a shortage of data. One of the salient issues discovered by this research was the conversion of the most revered cultural land/sites into agriculture, especially in Pallisa, Bududa, and Nakapiripirit districts. Some of these cultural sites included Nashinda, Nashoba, Yerakha, Namasho, Nameremu, and Nehoyo in Bududa, which were hitherto protected by the communities. Up to 30 years ago, they were sites of sacrifices and celebrations during catastrophes and in plenty respectively. Indirectly, they became bushy and forested, thus refugia for biodiversity (wild animals and birds), a situation reported in Burkina Faso, Benin, and Togo in Weste Africa (Juhe-Beaulaton 2006; Kokou and Sokpon 2006). Some elderly participants and KIs associated the current droughts, floods, and diseases with the encroachment to these sites as they believe the “gods are annoyed.” Government and other stakeholders should take advantage of these cultural values and beliefs and integrate them into conservation policies and laws to protect the environment and natural resources in the study area and beyond.
Field observations during data collection also confirmed the degradation of natural wetlands through rice growing (Figure 5). These findings agree with the work done in the Namataba wetland, (Namaalwa et al., 2013) and Naigombwa wetland (Were et al., 2020), which are parts of this study area.
Meanwhile, the National Water and Sewerage Corporation (NWSC), the water supply agency for Mbale City, reported increased siltation, sedimentation, and coloration of water in River Manafwa, an intake point, during wet seasons, due to soil erosion, especially from artisanal sand and iron mining in the upstream areas (Table 3).
Table 3: Seasonal variation of water quality in R. Manafwa (intake for Mbale water supply)
Season
|
pH
|
EC (µS/cm)
|
Turbidity (NTU)
|
Colour-app (PtCo)
|
TSS (mg/l)
|
Wet
|
7.1
|
113
|
1,348
|
10,843
|
1,900
|
Dry
|
7.2
|
171
|
475
|
5,179
|
774
|
Data source: NWSC, Mbale district
There was a distinct variation in water quality parameters in wet seasons (March-May) and dry seasons (June to August), with the management reporting an increase in the quantities of water treatment chemicals, hence potentially increasing the cost of water supplied to consumers (Table 4). Indeed, some participants in this area reported that tap water supplied by NWSC was often brownish, especially during heavy rainy seasons.
Table 4
Seasonal variations in water treatments cost
season
|
Chemical
|
dosage (mg/l)
|
Weight (Kgs)
|
Raw water m3
|
Amount/Kg (UGX)
|
Total amount
|
Amount in (UDS)
|
Wet
|
Chlorine
|
2.050
|
546
|
300,000
|
15,000
|
8,190,000
|
2,307
|
Alum
|
70.000
|
12,320
|
300,000
|
1,200
|
14,784,000
|
4,165
|
Polymer
|
15.000
|
1,651
|
300,000
|
5,000
|
8,255,000
|
2,325
|
Sub-total
|
|
|
|
|
|
31,229,000
|
8,797
|
Dry
|
Chlorine
|
1.803
|
485
|
300,000
|
15,000
|
7,275,000
|
2,049
|
Alum
|
25.378
|
6,988
|
300,000
|
1,200
|
8,385,600
|
2,362
|
Polymer
|
2.388
|
714
|
300,000
|
5,000
|
3,570,000
|
1,006
|
Sub-total
|
|
|
|
|
|
19,230,600
|
5,417
|
Total
|
|
|
|
|
50,459,600
|
14,214
|
Data source: NWSC, Mbale City |
There was also reported loss of biodiversity, especially wild animals like leopards, antelopes, baboons, and wild birds like eagles that dwelt in wetlands, forests, and woodlands, due to clearance of their habitats. These were pointed out by the KIs, who were knowledgeable about these animals before they disappeared.
4.3.2 State of livelihoods in the study area
There is a growing number of internally displaced people by floods, land, and mudslides, especially from Bududa district located at the slopes of Mt. Elgon. These people are relocated into camps in protected areas, in Kiryadongo with over 500 people and Bulambuli with over 600 people. These people lack some of the basic needs, including sanitation, food, and water supply for domestic purposes. There was also reported damage to homes and infrastructure including, roads and water supply lines, affecting livelihoods. This shows that CC is acting synergistically with LULC changes, exacerbating the damage to the environment and negatively impacting human livelihoods through poor sanitation, shortage of food, and shelter. Further, participants, especially in the downstream districts of Serere, Kumi, and Palissa, the traditional cattle-keeping communities, reported a reduction in domestic animals due to a shortage of grazing land.
4.4 Impacts of LULC change and CC on the environment, water, and livelihoods
4.4.1 Impacts on land
Loss of soil fertility was reported across the study area as a number one impact of LULC change and CC. The participants reported low harvests now compared to what they used to get from the same acreages of land 30 years ago. They are reported poor quality of crop and animal yields, as a result of low soil fertility, which agrees with findings by Osbahr et al., (2011) in Mbarara district, western Uganda. The local communities noted that soil erosion had eroded the topsoil, especially in the steep slopes of Mt. Elgon, leaving infertile underground soil, which agrees with what was reported by other authors (Alemeyehu et al., 2009; Porta and Claret 2011; Anaba et al., 2017). Expect in Nakapiripirit where land is still fertile, the rest of the study are reported increased application of agrochemicals to boost agricultural production, which is in line with a study by Akhtar et al., (2011).
The land resources have been degraded and no longer support the population; hence the local communities are encroaching on protected lands, like forests and wetlands, for crop production. The clearance of forests and degradation of wetlands has resulted in erratic precipitation and droughts (climate change), and the vicious cycle is getting worse every year, as also reported by Bremner et al., (2010) and Obubu et al., (2021). At the national level, forest coverage has reduced from 24% in the 1990s to 12.4% in 2020 (MWE 2020). Relatedly, wetland coverage has reduced from 15.6% in 1994 to 8.9% in 2020 (MWE 2020). The conversion to agricultural land is the main LULC change, as reported in the tropics (Geist and Labin 2002). There was also reported loss of biodiversity in forests and wetlands. Further, the poor-quality crops and animals are more vulnerable to infestation by pests and diseases, with participants reporting an increased outbreak of pests and diseases exacerbated by CC; this was also observed by Hisali et al., (2011). These observations were proved by the increasing use of pesticides over the last five years generally and over 30 years in the upstream district which experienced the loss of soil fertility earlier due to soil erosion as a result of steep terrain. There were also reported increased costs incurred by the respective local government authorities and members of communities in the maintenance, repair, and replacement of damaged infrastructure and facilities, including roads, homes, health centers, and schools.
4.4.2 Impacts of LULC change and climate change on livelihoods
There were displacements from land and mudslides and deaths in different communities. A total of 427 people were reportedly killed by floods, land, and mudslides in the recent past (Table 5).
Table 5
Recent deaths from floods, land, and mudslides in the study area
District
|
Sub-counties
|
year
|
No. of deaths
|
Bududa
|
Bundesi
|
2010
|
300
|
Bushika
|
2020
|
15
|
Bumwalu
|
2020
|
4
|
Buwali
|
2020
|
57
|
Bukalasi
|
2020
|
40
|
Nakapiripirit
|
Diyok
|
2020
|
2
|
Lokeruman
|
2020
|
2
|
Chosan
|
2019
|
2
|
Kapchorwa
|
Kaptanya
|
2019
|
3
|
Mbale
|
Nambale
|
2021
|
2
|
Total
|
|
|
427
|
Data source: FGDs in the study area |
There was an increase in temperature including warm nights, and the presence of mosquitoes due to CC, thus malaria in areas that used to be cool, e.g Kapchorwa, as reported in a related study (Obubu et al 2021). There were increased conflicts within communities and between communities and law enforcement agencies like National Forest Authority (NFA), National Environment Management Authority (NEMA), over natural resources like wetlands, fertile land, and forests; for example, Limoto wetland in the border between Pallisa and Kibuku districts. These conflicts were also reported in the fishing communities in Lake Tana, Ethiopia (Gebremedhin et al., 2018), Uganda (Hisali et al., 2011; MWE 2015), and in Southeast Asia (Francisco 2008). Measures should be undertaken to ensure that conservation and sustainable resource utilization co-exist.
Increased poverty among the local communities was reported as agriculture was not adequately productive. Lack of not only cash crops but also markets for agricultural produce was affecting family income. Hunger was reported to increase as LULC changes and CC impacts ravaged the study area in the form of floods and droughts. As a consequence of poverty and hunger, there were reported school dropouts, child labor, early child marriages, and pregnancies, and gender-based violence, where women reported husbands abandoning homes, leaving women with the burden of raising children, as was also observed in Ethiopia (Gessesew 2017), and other developing countries (Bremner et al., 2010). Participants reported increased disease outbreaks, including malaria and trachoma, with some claiming that even the covid-19 pandemic could be related to CC.
4.4.3 Impacts of LULC change and climate change on water resources
When the participants were asked about the impacts of LULC change and CC on the water resources, especially Lake Kyoga, those from Serere, Kumi, and Pallisa districts near the lake, pointed out several impacts. For example, flooding at the lake shores, especially following the heavy rains was more frequent now than 40 years ago. Indeed, the years 2007, and 2020 were pointed out as having had the most damaging floods, with the floods of the year 2020 leading to the breaking of the water level record of 1964 (Table 6). Meanwhile, the data obtained from the MWE was used to map the 2020 floods to show the extent of spread and was found to support the observation from the local communities, (Figure 6). The analysis showed that the spatial extent of the lake expanded by 12.2%.
The 2020 floods did not affect only L. Kyoga but also other major lakes in the country. A summary of the water levels of three major lakes in Uganda is given in Table 6.
Table 6
Record-breaking water level trends for major Ugandan lakes
Water levels (m)
|
SN
|
Lakes
|
1964 (an old record)
|
2020 (new record)
|
Difference
|
1
|
Kyoga
|
13.25
|
14.41
|
1.16
|
2
|
Victoria
|
13.41
|
13.48
|
0.07
|
3
|
Albert
|
14.2
|
14.68
|
0.48
|
Data source: MWE |
Lake Kyoga was the most affected by these floods, as pointed out by the participants during the FGDs and KIIs, which agreed with the data from the MWE (see Table 6 and Figure 7). The water level data gaps in the 1980s to 1990s were caused by the insurgency, which interrupted data collection. Lakes Kyoga and Victoria reached new record levels in May 2020; meanwhile, L. Albert, located downstream of the two lakes, broke the record in October 2020.
The participants and the literature reviewed on the floods in L. Kyoga agreed on the damages caused by floods on people, infrastructure, animals, and crops, which resulted in hunger, poverty, and malnutrition, especially among children. They also affected fishing through floating suds, which blocked landing sites, interfered with boat landing and leaving, and water supply to the riparian communities as observed in Mugarama and Iyingo landing sites, in Serere and Buyende districts respectively. This was also observed in other parts of the world (Keskinen et al., 2010; Kundzewicz et al., 2014). The fishing community also reported a reduction in fish catches, destruction of fish breeding sites, increase in siltation of the lake and wetlands, poor water quality, increased risks of attack from reptiles like crocodiles, snakes, and monitor lizards. Further, the area witnessed a higher abundance of mosquitoes, with increased incidences of malaria according to participants.
Application of agrochemicals in the catchment and soil erosion contributes to pollution of Lake Kyoga and the observed brown water in the rivers laden with sediments, as has been pointed out by other authors (Ogutu-Ohwayo et al., 2013; Andama et al., 2017). On the other side, floods helped drown and flush out the invasive weed, Salvinia molesta from L. Kyoga, although it also helped spread it into the catchment and could indeed lead to its reinvasion later, as reported in other studies (Oliver 1993; McFarland et al., 2004; Lal 2016). The FGDs confirmed that the local communities had rich knowledge and experience of environmental issues. This presents an opportunity for engaging the community members in environmental protection and conservation practices.
Pollution of L. Kyoga has exposed it to invasion by invasive water weeds like S. molesta. When the participants however were asked why L. Kyoga was invaded by invasive water weeds, especially S. molesta and water hyacinth; there were varied responses. Some participants thought minister Nankabirwa brought it, others said it was from L. Victoria, while some pointed out nutrient enrichment from the catchments, warm water, the many bays where the weeds are protected, slow water flow as contributing factors, and others said it was the act of ‘god.’ These responses were similar to the scientific findings (Ogutu-Owahyo et al., 2013; Wanda et al., 2015; Andama et al., 2017), although the local community knowledge showed more details, which are often missed when only scientific approaches are used. This research shows the importance of integrating scientific knowledge with social or community-based perceptions, observations, and experience to identify causative factors for environmental degradation, hence developing more reliable and lasting sustainable solutions to the environmental and CC issues. The participants listed consequences of invasion by the weeds, including fish kills, reduced oxygen, and difficulty in navigation.
On the massive fish kills especially of Nile perch in Lake Kyoga in 2020, the participants outlined the possible causes as pesticides in household sprays and from the gardens in the catchments drained to the lake through floods, increased heat in the water, Nile perch diseases, and poison fishing was. Meanwhile, the joint report on the massive death of Nile perch issued by the Ministry of Agriculture, Animal Industry and Fisheries (MAAIF 2020) pointed out reduced dissolved oxygen levels. The reduction in dissolved oxygen could have been caused by deposits of organic matter drained by the floods and drowned S. molesta. The decomposition of these organic matter by aerobic bacteria could have resulted in the reduction of dissolved oxygen, hence the death of Nile perch, which is sensitive to low oxygen levels of less than 2.5 mg/l (hypoxia condition) (Goudswaard et al., 2011). Both the community and scientific views are in consonance, hence are important for management purposes.
4.4.4 Linkage of LULC change and CC from catchments to the lake
One of the main objectives of this social part of the research was to find out whether the local communities were aware that LULC change activities in the catchment and CC had an impact on the water quality of rivers and L. Kyoga. When the question of connectedness was posed to the FGDs and KIIs, the response was a resounding no. The participants in all groups, from the upstream, mid, and downstream, even those at the landing sites, were unaware that catchment activities were impacting the water quality of Lake Kyoga. As a result, the researcher educated the participants on the relationship between LULC changes and CC in the catchment and their adverse impact on water ecosystems. This finding exposed a perception gap in the connectivity between land and water and calls for awareness of the linkage. There was, therefore, a strong recommendation by participants on sensitization of the local communities on this matter. The issue of LULC change activities in the catchments being responsible for the water quality of the receiving water bodies has been well researched and proven elsewhere (Donohue et al., 2006; Miranda et al., 2014), but are still a challenge in Uganda. These findings illustrate the importance of integrating scientific and local knowledge to manage natural resources better. The participants requested feedback on the research findings and increased the extent of sensitization.
4.5 Responses to LULC change and climate change impacts
This component of the DPSIR has responses from different sections of society, including local community coping mechanisms, central and local government responses.
4.5.1 Local community coping mechanisms
The participants gave a list of coping mechanisms to alleviate the impacts of LULC changes and CC, shaped by prolonged exposure to these impacts. These included moving to urban centers for business purposes since the land was too fragmented for agriculture. The use of agrochemicals to improve crop and animal production, tree planting to combat CC impacts, and meeting timber and firewood demands. For those communities near water bodies, migration and land acquisition from other safer areas and even in other districts were reported. For example, people from Pallisa reported moving to nearby districts like Serere. Use of crop rotation, although they still said this was ineffective since the soils had lost fertility. Planting of quick maturing and drought-resistant crops, like the peanut variety “Serenut” was reported in Kumi and Serere, and eating once a day during a food shortage, or the use of relief foods from the government for seriously affected communities. Some people often resort to offering cheap labor to those who can provide for their needs, as was also reported by Hisali et al., (2011). Others have reduced the number of domestic animals, especially cattle, goats, and sheep, due to shortage of grazing land, especially in the districts of Serere, Kumi, Ngora, and Soroti, which used to be semi-nomadic. Others have resorted to dairy farming, reared on the zero-grazing regime, reducing the number of animals. People hire gardens for a season(s) from those with more land, while others practice aquaculture in wetlands as an alternative livelihood. Small scale irrigation, using valley tanks and solar-powered pumps like in Limoto wetland in Pallisa has been used to mitigate LULC change and CC impacts. The respondents, however, wanted more significant irrigation projects from the MWE. In Kameke Pallisa, the Kameke wetland was protected by the local community, as they appreciated its value, a rare positive occurrence that needs to be promoted in other areas. Other farmers have formed cooperative societies like Pallisa to improve their income through agriculture. Unfortunately, some families give up their girl children to early marriages to earn money to live on, and participants also reported child labor. Given the increasing community and individual conflicts due to the shortage of land resources, the communities adopted several conflict resolutions approaches, including mediation. It was important to note that the elite need consultancies to develop these measures, but the local communities apply them regularly. They may not have the resources to implement all their coping mechanisms, but they have a wealth of experience that needs to be tapped for better LULC change and CC management.
The local communities expressed challenges about coping mechanisms; these included the unreliability of fast-maturing, drought-resistant crops and exotic tree varieties. Participants in Kumi, Serere, and Pallisa districts, noted that the improved crops (cassava and groundnuts) showed a reduction in productivity within two years and were vulnerable to pests and diseases. Meanwhile, exotic trees were destructive to the environment. Relief food for the hungry was not always forthcoming unless major disasters, like landslides in Bududa, attracted the national public concerns and humanitarian response from the central government. Some interventions, like irrigation at a small scale, needs capital, which was not readily available for the local farmers unless external assistance was offered.
Participants agreed that family planning was a better approach to managing the ever-growing population, but the negative perceptions prevented its implementation. Negative perceptions included adverse effects, including over bleeding, failure to conceive following their use, or giving birth to deformed children, and the demand by men for more children. Relatedly, many women feared that when they adopted family planning measures, their husbands would engage in extra-marital affairs with other women to produce children. There is a need for the Ministry of Health (MoH) to carry out more sensitization to both women and men to assure the public about the benefits and how to mitigate any side effects of different family planning measures. This could help reduce the ever-growing population in the study area, expected to reach over 12 million in 2030 (UBoS 2020). This study has shown that family planning approaches are not being applied.
4.5.2 Institutional responses
There were several institutional response activities in the study area led by the MWE, through its regional offices under KWMZ. This office works with other agencies like NEMA, NFA; ministries like Ministry of Trade and Cooperatives (MTC); Local governments (LGs); research institutions like National Semi-Arid Resources Research Institute (NaSARRI) in Serere, universities, religious and cultural institutions, local councils (LCs) and the media. These institutions work together with various projects which are focused on mitigation of LULC changes and CC impacts. The sources of funds are mainly from the Government of Uganda (GoU), grants, and donor funds acquired through projects (Table 7), like the Enhancing Resilience of Communities to Climate Change through Catchment Based Integrated Management of Water and Related Resources in Uganda (EURECCCA).
Table 7
Response to LULC changes and CC impact projects in L. Kyoga basin
SN
|
Project
|
Source of funding
|
Area of interest
|
Catchment (s)
|
1
|
KWMZ
|
GoU-MWE
|
Drawing CMPs
|
Awoja and Mpologoma
|
2
|
EURECCCA
|
Green Adaptation
|
CC resilience
|
Awoja
|
3
|
Green future farming, AID environment
|
Dutch government
|
Agriculture
|
Awoja
|
4
|
Integrated Water Management Development Project (IWMDP)
|
World Bank
|
Water supply
|
Awoja
|
5
|
International Union for conservation of nature (IUNC)
|
IUCN
|
Drawing CMPs
|
Awoja, Mpologoma, and Lhakhakha
|
6
|
Support to resilient initiatives in vulnerable entities (STRIVE) project
|
Water aid
|
CC resilience, WASH facilities
|
Mpologoma
|
|
CMPs
|
Catchment Management Plans
|
|
|
GoU
|
Government of Uganda
|
|
The responses focused on the restoration of degraded wetlands, forests, and land, although they had different focus components. Their scope was small, and most of them were pilot projects covering small areas. The MWE, through KWMZ, used funds from the EURECCCA project, acquired from Adaptation Fund through Sahara and Sahel Observatory (OSS), to demarcate and restore some wetlands in Awoja catchment, including Oongino in Kumi, Kamurojo in Serere, Adoka in Ngora, Asubakiakiteng in Katakwi, and Limoto in Pallisa-Kibuku. Sections of riverbanks have also been restored, such as rivers Manafwa, Kere, Tabagon-chepiakamit, and Siti-Greek, to reduce siltation on the downstream lakes, protect river banks, and reduce floods. Water soil conservation activities by the construction of soil and water retention pits, and flood control structures, were implemented to increase groundwater recharge and soil moisture, increasing crop production. This was aimed at controlling rampant soil erosion, especially on the slopes of Mt. Elgon. Demonstration wetlands were also established in Amurojo, Serere, and Adoka to teach local communities how to co-exist and use wetland resources sustainably. Further, the wetlands department of the MWE has developed an inventory of wetlands with risks in the country and is implementing a global CC project which, encourages vegetation growth and tree planting in river banks, wetlands, and bare land.
Communities that depended on these wetlands and riverbanks as their source of livelihoods, hence degraded them, were given alternative livelihoods. These included the formation of a water and environment cooperatives society revolving funds planned by the EURECCCA project, facilitated by MTC and LGs. Construction of fish ponds in Limoto wetland and introduction of piggery as a source of income was done. Others included mushroom farming, in Kumi, Ngora, Soroti, and Serere districts. Restoration and conservation of forests have been done by the planting of indigenous trees and bamboos on the steep slopes and critically degraded catchments by the EURECCCA project. Individuals, groups, and schools participated, with over 725,000 trees planted and about 660 ha of bare land restored. Seedlings and extension services were provided locally by NaSARRI. Relatedly, the production of energy-saving stoves, called ‘Lorena’ fire-shielded (target was 4,200) to local community women groups was also done to conserve forests and trees, improve health by reducing smoke and save time used while looking for firewood. Most of the interventions have not emphasized measures that encourage terracing in the steep slopes, yet they are essential.
Response contributions of other projects like IUCN in developing catchment management plans (CMPs) for implementation by other projects were necessary. Projects like IWMDP, and STRIVE focused on increasing community resilience to CC by supplying drinking water to households and livestock to mitigate water scarcity caused by CC impacts. These interventions were vital in mitigating the impacts of LULC change and CC and achieving sustainable development goals (SDGs). Goal 6, focused on clean water and sanitation for all in 2030, and goal 15, aimed at protecting, restoring, and promoting sustainable use of terrestrial ecosystems, especially forests and land, including combating desertification and reversing biodiversity loss (UNCCP 2018), are prime targets. However, during the FGDs and KIIs, communities appreciated the Lorena energy-saving stoves, but also recognized tree planting efforts, although they said the survival rate was low.
4.5.3 Policy and regulation response
Uganda has good Policies, Acts of Parliament, and Regulations regarding environment protection and CC; the challenge is their weak implementation. If they were implemented effectively, the observed adverse impacts would be reduced. For example, the Uganda National Policy on Climate Change calls on all stakeholders to manage CC impacts and causes through the promotion of a green economy for sustainable development (UNCCP 2018), which is not being realized. Uganda is also a signatory to many CC conventions and protocols, like the Kyoto protocol of 1997, on the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions and the Rio Summit of 1992. The National Environment Act, Cap 153, through the National Environment (wetlands, riverbanks, and lakeshores management) regulations, No. 3 of 2000 sets buffer zones for rivers, and wetlands at 100 meters, lakes at 200 meters (NER 2000), but these are not being followed. The National Forestry and Tree Planting Act of 2003 encourages all people to plant trees and also prohibits the destruction of forests, except under authorization by the responsible authorities. National Agricultural Policy recognizes agriculture as a driver of national economic growth, the biggest source of food and employment. It also recognizes the vital role environment and natural resources play in achieving agricultural objectives. It, therefore, recommends sensitization of the population on the use and conservation of the critical resources, which are soils and water, through extension services (NAP 2013). The National Urban Policy (NUP), through the Town and Country Act of 2000, the National Urban Policy (NUP), and the Physical Planning Act of 2010, are responsible for urban land use and planning (NUP 2017). Among other objectives, the policy seeks to promote urban environmental protection and conservation, develop adaptation and mitigation measures against CC. Through the National Environment (standards for discharge for effluents into water or land) Regulations (NWR 2020), the Water Act prohibits the discharge of industrial and domestic point source effluents into the environment or water that does not meet the set standards. But most of the effluent quality of the domestic wastes in the study area did not meet these standards, over the years, without any punitive action taken against the companies responsible.
The most significant challenge is the implementation of these legislations since the enforcement arms are either missing or weak. Where the penalties are provided for defaulters, they are not adequately punitive or are not enforced. Meanwhile, some of the provisions of legislation need to be revised to include critical missing areas. For example, the national forestry and tree planting Act should include a section on the follow-up of the people or organizations that plant trees to make sure trees are cared for and survive. Local communities also recommended punishment for individuals and organizations that fail to care for trees and reward the responsible tree planters. There should be regulations on the application of agrochemicals to operationalize National Agricultural policy since there are fake products in the market.
4.5.4 Challenges of mitigation of land use, land cover, and climate change impacts
The institutional response interventions were short-lived and only covered small areas as pilot projects. Therefore, there is a need to expand them, which requires more funds given the expansive nature of LULC change and CC impacts. When the interventional projects reach their lifetime, it is often expected that GoU, through MWE, LGs, and communities, would continue implementing the objectives to ensure the sustainability of their outputs, but this is seldom the case due to a shortage of technical, financial, and infrastructural resources. As a result, in most cases, the end of pilot projects’ lifespan implies the end of implementing their respective ideas, hence limiting their impact. Meanwhile, the Covid-19 pandemic was one of the challenges that affected the effective implementation and supervision of the project activities. Shortage of land, lack of alternative livelihoods, and the ever-growing population have made the population encroach on protected areas. Hence, the restoration of wetlands and forests is not entirely accepted by local communities, even when involved in these interventions. Local communities often have resistance and incidences of violent confrontation against law enforcement officers and intervention staff, exposing them to danger during demarcation exercises, as was reported in Adoka and Oongino villages during wetland demarcation and restoration.
Since the constitution gives land rights to individuals, restoration interventions are often viewed by the public as schemes to ‘grab’ land and are resolutely resisted. Climate change itself was identified as a challenge to the interventions because prolonged dry weather affects the survival of planted trees. Also, superstitious beliefs and attitudes of some of the members of the communities, which are generally “resigned to fate as it were,” are unhelpful for conservation efforts since they do not accept that interventions such as tree planting and restoration of wetlands can mitigate against effects of LULC change and CC impacts. Therefore, to ensure the adoption of recommended interventions by local communities, such attitudes need to be changed through sensitization, which takes time. In some cases, seedlings were supplied to the communities during the dry season or towards the end of rainy seasons, which would substantially reduce the chance of survival since there were no options for irrigation. New fast-growing crops promoted as coping measures against CC were prone to pests and diseases, thus requiring the use of agrochemicals to ensure good production. Therefore, the communities recommended indigenous trees, such as fruit trees, and reintroducing indigenous crop varieties, like cassava, including cash crops, like cotton.
There was a strong sentiment by institutions and the local communities on political interference of environmental management activities. To gain popularity, often politicians conveyed conflicting ideas and signals to the public, leading to incitement, resistance to restoration, and conservation efforts by the government and other stakeholders. These political leaders often hold more power over their constituents and are respected by the communities, who are therefore negatively influenced, leading to low adoption of appropriate LULC and CC mitigation measures. This was reported in Ngora, Pallisa, Kibuku, and Kumi districts.