The results suggest that the Longshi Scale was a novel pictorial scale of ADL in efficiently distinguishing the degree of daily living activities ability of the elderly disabled. Data also demonstrated that this Longshi Scale had a positive correlation with Barthel Index in assessing the functional disability among the older patients.
In current study, we analyzed the BI scores based on the groups of LS. Patients of community group had the highest mean BI total scores (95.01, SD = 8.16), while those of bedridden group had the lowest (19.99, SD = 19.32). There was a significant difference of the BI scores between the three groups of LS (P < 0.001, Table 3). As shown in Table 3, participants classified to the bedridden group were associated with lower BI scores, indicating more severe functional loss, whereas patients in the community group had higher BI scores, representing minor functional loss. The finding revealed that the performance of ADL in the three groups of LS was significant different. The ADL of three LS groups gradually improved as the BI scores increased. Our finding consistent with previous researches [17, 18] that the ability of ADL in elderly patients is positively related to their scope of activity. It indicated that the categorization and scoring system of Longshi Scale make it easier to assess and understand the elderly patient’s function status.
Meanwhile, patients were further divided into 4 groups based on the normalized BI scores: slight dependence group (91–100), moderate dependence group (61–90), sever dependence group (21–60), total dependence group (0–20). In present study, the LS scores of three separated groups showed significant differences between the 4 BI subgroups (slight dependence, moderate dependence, severe dependence, and total dependence), respectively (P < 0.001). The scores of three LS groups had gradually increased from total dependence group to slight dependence group. It showed that each LS group with the picture-based items can reflect the differences of ADL among older patients, which might superior to those word-based scales especially for elderly patients[19–21].Therefore, the results indicated the LS score can distinguish the ADL level of the elderly disabled in three functional groups (bedridden, domestic, and community group) respectively.
The Spearman correlation coefficients between the LS scores of three groups (bedridden, domestic and community group) and BI scores were 0.869, 0.848 and 0.828 (P < 0.001, respectively). The results revealed that there were strong positive correlations between the Longshi Scale and Barthel Index in all three groups, which indicated Longshi Scale can effectively reflect the ADL ability in elderly patients and has good validity among elderly disabled. The strength may facilitate the application of Longshi scale in future research.
Though hospitalized elderly patients may be suffering from a severe acute or chronic condition or infectious disease[22, 23], it is noteworthy that the assessment of Longshi scale for the community-dwelling elders who may have an undiagnosed chronic illness or disability is of great importance[24, 25]. Indeed, elders from either group may be at great risk of having a low level of self-care agency, which can have a profound effect of their quality of life [26, 27]. The LS measure might be useful for evaluating their level of self-care agency that may indicate a need for intervention[28]. The Longshi-scale has potential applicability at various phases of the nursing process. It can be used to assess the Chinese elder’s ability to perform selfcare activities to promote their health, whether health conditions exist or not.
Previous studies showed that the Longshi Scale was a simple, reliable and scientific ADL tool, which can be used by different groups of people such as medical and non-medical professionals as well as patients[15, 29]. Moreover, to deal with an aging society, it is necessary to establish a long-term care service system medical security system to formulate relevant policies and meet the basic life demand of the elderly [30]. Hence, this pictorial-based Longshi scale would be of great significance especially for the elderly disabled with complications. Through the quick and effective assessment of ADL, the elderly can enjoy appropriate and effective care, and further save the cost of care, reduce the pressure on elderly care services[31, 32]. Therefore, it would be benefit to improve the rehabilitation treatment, guide continuity of care and ensure adequate social support and disability benefits for the elderly patients[27].
There are several limitations of this study. This was a cross-sectional cohort study without examining the longitudinal change of the LS scores of the elderly disabled. Therefore, the sensitivity to change of the LS was not examined. The assessment of the LS item scores of the elderly disable patients was assumed to be accurate and reliable, though interrater reliability testing had not been performed in the present study. Despite of the above limitations, this is the first study to examine the ability of Longshi scores to distinguish the level of the disability among the elderly disabled after careful data examination in defining the favorable outcome of elderly disabled. It is a multicenter study including different ethnic groups, locations and broader training level of evaluators.