The selected genotypes showed seedling length variation at 4DAG with synthetics having minimum length of 8.27cm (syn14128) to maximum length of 14.17cm in PBW114 (Fig. S1, S2, Table S1, S2). The other SHW, syn14170 reported seedling length similar to that of HD2967 (10.53cm) at 4DAG. The maximum per cent of length increment on 5th DAG and 6th DAG was in syn14128 (38.71%, 46.80%, respectively), while minimum per cent increment in PBW114 (10.55%, 26.17%, respectively) (Fig. 2, Table S1, S2). Syn14170, on the other hand, reported a sharp increase of 31.01% in seedling length at 5th DAG, which was further slowed down to 19.81% at 6 DAG (Fig. 2). Syn14128 reported a significant better seedling length (56.45% and 59.68%, respectively) at 12HS and 20HS stage as compared to other synthetic, durum and checks. Still, it was not able to maintain this increment rate under the recovery period (15.21% and 5.05% decrease compared to control respectively) (Fig. 2). However, at 24R12HS and 24R20HS stage, syn14170 reported a better recovery (24.33% and 25.68%) than all the other genotypes. Selected ABLs and durum wheat, on the contrary, reported an 8-12% decrease in the seedling length after HS indicating severe damage to plant cellular machinery.
Heat stress-induced oxidative stress in wheat seedlings
The increase in MDA content was observed in seedlings after 12HS and 20HS as compared to control, followed by a decrease in the MDA content at 24R12HS and 24R20HS (Fig. 3a, Table 1). Under the control conditions, no significant difference in MDA content was observed among selected genotypes. When exposed to 12HS, ABLs and durum wheat reported an abrupt increase in MDA content with the maximum increase in PBW114 (0.061µmoles/g FW, 91.06%), followed by HD2967 (0.052µmoles/g FW, 77.36%) (Fig. 3a, Table 1). Syn14128 reported the minimum increase in MDA content after 12HS as well as 20HS (33.08% and 68.25%, respectively). At 24R12HS, MDA content decreased by 20-40% in SHWs while ABLs and durum wheat still reported higher MDA content (30-56%). However, at 24R20HS only HD2967 had higher MDA content while the rest of the genotypes indicated a decreased MDA level.
Table 1
Percent change in different parameters as compared to 4 DAG control after different treatments
Genotype
|
DAG
|
Treatment
|
MDA
|
H2O2
|
DPPH
|
O2−
|
NO
|
OH•
|
TP
|
TF
|
TSS
|
Starch
|
Amy
|
Syn14128
|
5
|
12HS
|
33.08
|
-53.76
|
-45.02
|
84.84
|
97.68
|
245.60
|
90.82
|
-29.88
|
-21.72
|
-14.72
|
-38.41
|
Syn14170
|
5
|
12HS
|
33.27
|
-71.91
|
-44.28
|
53.08
|
139.27
|
158.10
|
97.54
|
-37.67
|
-53.31
|
-12.60
|
-49.22
|
PBW114
|
5
|
12HS
|
91.06
|
-54.20
|
-63.03
|
137.66
|
97.38
|
367.63
|
221.12
|
-13.84
|
-10.77
|
-9.40
|
-26.76
|
HD2967
|
5
|
12HS
|
77.36
|
-84.27
|
-72.56
|
82.56
|
59.74
|
482.11
|
164.88
|
-28.01
|
-40.17
|
-21.70
|
-56.13
|
PBW343
|
5
|
12HS
|
69.54
|
-80.52
|
-82.81
|
18.05
|
72.33
|
283.95
|
272.31
|
-32.98
|
-10.05
|
-23.62
|
-50.09
|
Syn14128
|
6
|
24R12HS
|
-20.69
|
47.48
|
1.13
|
17.23
|
6.29
|
-12.36
|
-38.12
|
2.69
|
-28.17
|
-52.03
|
-10.35
|
Syn14170
|
6
|
24R12HS
|
-21.24
|
12.97
|
1.49
|
6.61
|
4.95
|
-45.53
|
-60.99
|
-8.25
|
-64.48
|
-65.33
|
-31.28
|
PBW114
|
6
|
24R12HS
|
50.34
|
45.43
|
3.36
|
-14.43
|
-15.18
|
-15.98
|
-21.12
|
21.10
|
-39.38
|
-45.98
|
-3.22
|
HD2967
|
6
|
24R12HS
|
32.33
|
-13.68
|
2.81
|
-18.12
|
-27.96
|
-1.79
|
-9.65
|
6.46
|
-63.68
|
-53.78
|
-22.67
|
PBW343
|
6
|
24R12HS
|
56.19
|
12.41
|
2.98
|
-38.33
|
-15.85
|
-25.04
|
-8.08
|
2.02
|
-40.42
|
-43.38
|
-32.26
|
Syn14128
|
5
|
20HS
|
68.25
|
-67.58
|
-61.90
|
258.59
|
86.42
|
107.30
|
20.56
|
-23.09
|
-53.39
|
14.09
|
-49.01
|
Syn14170
|
5
|
20HS
|
73.07
|
-71.20
|
-56.55
|
122.16
|
71.42
|
256.12
|
49.08
|
-27.59
|
-48.72
|
4.87
|
-59.17
|
PBW114
|
5
|
20HS
|
105.64
|
-75.62
|
-66.89
|
170.37
|
41.71
|
227.18
|
165.02
|
4.68
|
-3.00
|
2.88
|
-45.56
|
HD2967
|
5
|
20HS
|
106.41
|
-65.49
|
-70.58
|
188.85
|
21.83
|
293.49
|
127.88
|
-29.46
|
-7.28
|
-20.00
|
-69.90
|
PBW343
|
5
|
20HS
|
150.58
|
-82.55
|
-74.21
|
249.84
|
23.63
|
89.44
|
207.31
|
-32.05
|
-33.03
|
-22.33
|
-66.13
|
Syn14128
|
6
|
24R20HS
|
-54.98
|
-9.74
|
-18.02
|
-7.51
|
59.93
|
-31.94
|
-47.90
|
-11.51
|
-55.14
|
-8.13
|
-39.04
|
Syn14170
|
6
|
24R20HS
|
-39.28
|
0.09
|
-10.28
|
-49.78
|
72.28
|
50.68
|
-51.75
|
-16.53
|
-57.91
|
-7.82
|
-49.76
|
PBW114
|
6
|
24R20HS
|
-16.80
|
-8.80
|
-9.75
|
-50.76
|
24.16
|
44.19
|
19.47
|
17.95
|
-25.62
|
-39.03
|
-35.75
|
HD2967
|
6
|
24R20HS
|
29.32
|
-6.01
|
-12.07
|
24.77
|
0.89
|
55.79
|
3.75
|
-12.19
|
-12.37
|
-39.63
|
-57.83
|
PBW343
|
6
|
24R20HS
|
-3.21
|
-17.14
|
-14.87
|
6.30
|
20.09
|
-18.52
|
32.69
|
-28.23
|
-40.07
|
-30.13
|
-63.88
|
Values represented as percent increase or decrease as compared to control. |
The different alphabetical letters in superscript indicate the significant differences with Duncan test at p value 0.05. |
DAG: days after germination, MDA: Malondialdehyde content, H2O2: Hydrogen peroxide content, DPPH: percent DPPH content, O2−: superoxide anion free radical scavenging activity, NO: nitric oxide free radical scavenging activity, OH•: hydroxyl anion free radical scavenging activity, TP: total phenol content, TF: total flavanol contents, TSS: total soluble sugar content, Starch: starch content, Amy: amylase activity |
H2O2 level of control set was lower in PBW114 as compared to other genotypes (1.57µmoles/g FW, Fig. 3b, Table 1). 12HS and 20HS resulted in a significant decrease in H2O2 content in the seedlings. After 12HS, syn14128 reported a minimum reduction in the H2O2 content (0.98µmoles/g FW, 53.76%) while syn14170 had a 71.92% decrease in H2O2 content compared to the control set. However, durum wheat, PBW114, reported a reduction similar to that of syn14128 (54.20%, Fig. 3b). At 24R12HS, H2O2 content increased significantly with no significant difference in syn14128 (47.48%) and PBW114 (45.43%). However, at 20HS, HD2967 reported maximum H2O2 content (0.83 µmoles/g FW; 82.55% decrease compared to control) and at 24R20HS syn14170 was able to recover its H2O2 content similar to that of control conditions (0.09%) (Fig. 3b, Table 1). Both the synthetics had minimum per cent increase in the MDA content along with lower H2O2 content under 12HS, 20HS as well as 24R12HS and 24R20HS.
Free radical scavenging activities in wheat seedlings under heat stress
Free radical scavenging activities were estimated for four different radicals viz., DPPH, O2−, NO and OH•. Under the control conditions, all selected lines had statistically similar DPPH scavenging activities ranging from 76-79% (Fig. 4a, Table 1). While after 12HS, DPPH scavenging activity was reduced with lowest in PBW343 (13.37%), followed by HD2967 (21.34%) with a significant reduction (82.81% and 72.56%; Table 1) as compared to the control. In synthetics, ~43% per cent decrease in DPPH scavenging activities was recorded at 12HS with ~45% reduction as compared to control. A similar trend was also observed at 20HS, with maximum DPPH reduction in PBW343 (74.21%) followed by HD2967 (70.58%), while syn14170 had the minimum reduction (56.59%) in the DPPH scavenging activity followed by syn14128 (61.90% reduction). However, no significant change in DPPH scavenging was observed at 24R12HS and 24R20HS.
Further, O2− radical scavenging activity was low in the control set and increased significantly after HS (Fig. 4b, Table 1). At 12HS, PBW114 reported a maximum spike in the level of O2− radical scavenging activity (137.66% increase) followed by syn14128 (84.84%). In the case of 20HS, an abrupt per cent increase in O2− radical scavenging activity was observed in all the genotypes with the maximum growth in the case of PBW343 (249.84%). However, increased O2− radical scavenging activity was observed in case of two selected synthetics, syn14128 (17.23%) and syn14170 (6.61%), in 24R12HS, while other three genotypes indicated a decreased per cent scavenging (Fig. 4b). 24R20HS indicated decreased O2− radical scavenging activity as compared to control in case of synthetics and PBW114, while increased scavenging in case of ABLs.
Syn14170 and syn14128 had significantly lower (P<0.05) (~37%) NO scavenging activity than elite (~55%) and durum (47%) wheats under control condition which was increased further as the genotypes were exposed to HS (Fig. 4c, Table 1). After 12HS ABLs showed minimum per cent increase (59.74% and 72.33%, respectively) followed by syn14128 and PBW114 (97%). Although syn14170 reported maximum per cent increase (139.27%) after 12HS, syn14128 reported the overall maximum per cent after 20HS (86.42%). ABLs again had the minimum increase (~22%) at 20HS. In the case of 24R12HS, NO free radical scavenging activity was decreased (15-27%) in ABLs and durum wheat while SHWs had 4-6% higher scavenging as compared to control set. At 24R20HS, an overall percentage increase of NO scavenging was observed in all the genotypes.
OH• radical scavenging had an activity pattern similar to that of O2− scavenging activity, with lower levels of scavenging in control and recovery stages but higher scavenging after HS (Fig. 4d, Table 1). In control, PBW343 showed maximum OH• radical scavenging activity (19.84%), while HD2967 had the lowest (11.72%) (Fig. 4d). At 12HS treatment, PBW114 reported maximum levels of OH• scavenging (78.87%) followed by PBW343 (76.17%). However, the maximum per cent increase compared to control was reported in HD2967 (482.11%) followed by PBW114 (367.63%). Both the SHWs had minimum OH• scavenging (45.43% syn14128, 54.36% syn14170) and minimum per cent change (245.60%, 158.10%, respectively) compared to control. At 24R12HS syn14170 indicated a better recovery (45.55%) than syn14128 (12.36%). However, a significant difference in the OH• free radical scavenging activity was observed for all the lines after 20HS, and 24R20HS with a maximum per cent change was observed in HD2967 (293.49%, 55.79%) followed by syn14170 (256.12%, 50.68%). Overall DPPH scavenging was decreased, while O2−, OH• and NO scavenging increased under both 12HS and 20HS. Syn14170 had a minimum decrease in the DPPH scavenging (44.28%) along with maximum NO scavenging (139.27%) for 12HS set, while a better OH• radical scavenging (256.42%%) in this synthetic was observed in 20HS set. On the other hand, syn14128 also reported a minimum decrease in the DPPH scavenging (45.02%) along with the highest OH• radical scavenging (245.60%%) for 12HS set. In the case of 20HS syn14128 had maximum O2− radical scavenging (258.59%), maximum NO scavenging (86.42%) and average OH• radical scavenging (107.30%%).
Total phenol and total flavanol content in wheat seedlings under heat stress
In the present study, TP increased under HS condition while the TF decreased when seedlings were exposed to HS. TP content was significantly higher in SHWs in the control set (~3mg/g FW) as compared to ABLs and durum wheat (1-2mg/g FW) (Fig. 5a, Table 1). An overall increase in the phenolic content was observed at 12HS, but there was no significant variation among selected genotypes (~6mg/g FW). PBW343 (272.31%) followed by PBW114 (221.12%) showed a significantly higher increase in the phenolic content, while SHWs reported the minimum per cent change in total phenol content under 12HS (Table 1). However, syn14170 recovered back quickly from heat damage after 24R12HS with minimum phenolic content (1.23mg/g FW) and maximum per cent decrease in total phenol content (60%). SHWs reported significantly less phenolic content (3-4mg/g FW) as compared to the elite and durum wheat (~5mg/g FW) in 20HS treatment. Syn14170 was still observed to recover back quickly after 24R20HS with minimum phenolic content (1.53 mg/g FW, 51.75%) followed by syn14128 (1.70mg/g FW, 47.90%) (Fig. 5a). An increase in total phenol levels was observed in ABLs and durum wheat with a maximum per cent increase in PBW343 (32.69%) followed by PBW114 (19.47%) in recovery post 20hr HS.
On the other hand, TF content decreased after HS. In control set, there was no significant difference SHWs and ABLs (~1mg/g FW), while durum wheat had minimum TF content (0.82mg/g FW) (Fig. 5b, Table 1). All the genotypes showed a decrease in flavanol content at 12HS, with maximum percent decrease in syn14170 (0.72mg/g FW, 37.67%) followed by PBW343 (0.73mg/g FW, 32.98%) and syn14128 (0.73mg/g FW, 29.88%). However, syn14170 reported 8.25% decrease in the TF content at 24R12HS, and in all the other genotypes 2-21% increase in TF content was recorded as compared to control set. Durum wheat, on the other hand, reported an increase in the TF content (4.68%) for 20HS treatment, while ABLs and SHWs reported a 23-32% decline in the levels of flavanol content. A similar trend was observed when these seedlings were given a recovery period of 24 hours.
Effect of heat stress on total soluble sugars and total starch
In the control set, total soluble sugar (TSS) was highest for syn14170 (21.90mg/g FW) followed by syn14128 (19.78mg/g FW) (Fig. 6a, Table 1). However, at12HS, a decrease in TSS was observed for all the genotypes with a maximum per cent decrease in syn14170 (53.31%) followed by HD2967 (40.17%). At 24R12HS treatment, syn14128 reported the highest recovery potential with only 28% decline in the amount of available sugars, while syn14170 reported the minimum recovery with 64.48% decline in TSS. Further, TSS content was decreased by ~50% in the case of SHWs for 20HS and 24R20HS.
Selected wheat genotypes did not show a significant difference in the levels of starch content in the control set (Fig. 6b, Table 1). However, at 12HS, minimum starch content was observed in case of syn14128 (9.26mg/g FW) followed by syn14170 (9.87mg/g FW) which was further decreased (52.03% and 65.33%, respectively) when at 24R12HS, indicating a better utilisation of starch under HS. At 20HS and 24R20HS, ABLs reported a decline in starch content (~21%) while SHWs and durum wheat reported an increased starch availability, indicating a decreased starch metabolism in these genotypes.
Amylase activity and gene expression of α-Amylase under heat stress
Syn14170 (2.09µmoles/min/g FW) and PBW343 (2.07µmoles/min/g FW) reported the highest activity of amylase in the control set. At 12HS, reduced activity of amylase was observed in all the genotypes, but the reduction was more significant in HD2967 (56.13%) followed by PBW343 (50.09%) and syn14170 (49.22%) (Fig. 6c, Table 1). Amylase activity was least affected in PBW114 (1.25µmoles/min/g FW, 26.76% reduction) followed by syn14128 (1.18µmoles/min/g FW, 38.41% reduction) at 12HS and a similar trend was observed at 24R12HS. In 20HS set, PBW114 (0.93µmoles/min/g FW) again showed minimum reduction (45.56%) in amylase activity, followed by syn14128 (0.98µmoles/min/g FW, 49.01% reduction) and a similar trend was observed for 24R20HS.
In real-time PCR expression profiling of α-amylase targeting amy4 gene (Fig. 6d). a general trend of downregulation due to HS was observed in all the selected wheat lines. However, syn14128 reported significant minimum down-regulation in amy4 activity than the other selected lines at both 12HS as well as 20HS. Further, amy4 expression in syn14128 also recovered back quickly to control level for 24R12HS as well as 24R20HS (Fig. 6d). Syn14170, however, has low expression than durum as well as ABL checks.