Who will be blinded {17a}
Due to the open-label nature of this study, no blinding will be used.
Procedure for unblinding if needed {17b}
Due to the open-label nature of this study, no blinding will be used.
Data collection and management
Plans for assessment and collection of outcomes {18a}
Mobility data will be collected throughout the study using the GPS tracking feature of the CareConekta app.
For recording participant characteristics, several study measures have been used previously by the study investigators in similar populations at the study site and in other areas of South Africa. In addition, we are using the following widely-used, validated measurement scales:
- ART adherence: 3-item self-report measure (Wilson, et al.)[49]
- Alcohol use: Alcohol Use Disorders Identification Test-Concise (AUDIT-C)[50]
- Drugs: Question 1 from Drug Use Disorders Identification Test (DUDIT)[51]
- Depression: Patient Health Questionnaire-4 (PHQ-4)[52]
- Intimate partner violence: World Health Organization Violence Against Women (WHO VAW) measurement[53]
- Life events[54]
- Patient-Healthcare provider relationship[55]
- Perceived availability of support[56]
- Social impact scale[57]
Study forms are available by request to the investigators.
Plans to promote participant retention and complete follow-up {18b}
In order to maximize the potential of re-contacting each participant and accessing medical records, we will collect identifying information on a separate paper-based linkage form, including contact information, name, study number, clinic record number, phone number, national identification number, address, date of birth, and we will also update this form with infant information, when available. As is standard practice for research studies at the study site, the participant may also provide details for an alternative contact person in the event that we are unable to reach the participant after multiple attempts. No details about the participant will be shared with the alternative contact; study staff simply will ask that the participant return to the clinic when she can. For the interim phone call and follow-up visit, a minimum of three contact attempts by phone and/or home visit will be made for each participant. If participant mobility data ceases to transmit at least once per day, the study team will follow up with the participant to find out if there are problems with her phone.
Data management {19}
All hard copies of study documents, including signed consent forms, linkage forms, and logs will be stored in locked cabinets in the study office with only the study team having access to the data. For increased protection, the linkage form and signed consent forms will be stored separately from other study documents.
Enrollment and follow-up questionnaires are designed in REDCap and will be administered electronically using the REDCap mobile app. REDCap (Research Electronic Data Capture) is a secure, web-based application designed to support data capture for research studies, providing 1) an intuitive interface for validated data entry; 2) audit trails for tracking data manipulation and export procedures; 3) automated export procedures for seamless data downloads to common statistical packages; and 4) procedures for importing data from external sources [58]. Range checks for numerical values and prompts about skipped questions are built into the REDCap database. The data will be collected with the study interviewer/fieldworker – who is fluent in isiXhosa and English – during a face-to-face interaction with the participant. The study coordinator will review all participant data to ensure completion. The PI also will monitor the study safety data on an ongoing basis. The encrypted REDCap data servers will be housed at Vanderbilt University Medical Center. Participant questionnaire data and medical record data will be exported from REDCap, and mobility data from CareConekta will be imported from .csv files to SAS for data analysis.
The transmission and storage of sensitive participant information will follow best practices regarding smartphone app confidentiality. All information collected by CareConekta, including location, device ID and timestamp, will be encrypted and transmitted to secure study servers using the secure https protocol. Time-stamped GPS coordinates will be stored in a longitudinal history. Electronic mobility data will be stored on a back-end storage system at the South African Medical Research Council (MRC) that meets Health Normative Standards Framework guidelines, which call for restricted access, and the separation of patient demographics and health data. The user reference (unique ID or demographic information of the patient) is separated from the user’s cell number and phone ID, as well as separated from the location information for security and purposes.
Confidentiality {27}
Certainly the concept of tracing an individual’s personal location is one that must address substantial protections of human subjects. First, our formative research with potential users in focus group discussions specifically addressed issues of privacy regarding a mobility-tracing app and notifications. For both issues, we found high acceptability [59].
While we feel that our formative research clearly indicates initial acceptability of mobility tracing and notifications, we have designed this work with a strong commitment to offering the highest level of protection of our participants’ privacy and confidentiality. First, the location data of interest is at the macro-level, showing movement between towns, cities or regions, not at the micro-level, showing specific whereabouts. Thus, to protect participants’ privacy, the transmitted location information will be made “fuzzy” by transmitting a random location within 1 km of each participant’s exact location. Any participant’s exact location within that radius will be unknown. All information collected by the app, including location, device ID and timestamp, will be transmitted to secure study servers using the secure https protocol. The participant’s numerical study ID number will be used during installation; and no identifiable participant information will be recorded in the app.
There is always the possibility of a breach of confidentiality of study materials when conducting research. While this is acknowledged, there is very low likelihood because of the precautions that will be taken to protect confidentiality. Study staff will be trained on the expectations that they are not to disclose any information collected in the study to anyone outside the study team. All identifying information associated with the study participants will be maintained in locked storage cabinets and password-protected computers that themselves are kept in locked rooms or cabinets. All participants will be encouraged to contact the clinic staff, principal investigators, or other staff to report any undesirable conduct associated with the study. These reports will be brought to the attention of the PI.
Another risk to participants is that an HIV-positive status may be discerned through disclosure of participation in the study. However, we will do everything possible to minimize the risk of disclosure. No communication, whether on the phone or by text message, will identify the participant as HIV-positive. Importantly, among participants in the intervention arm who receive notifications of new facilities and phone calls and/or WhatsApp messages, the study staff will not use HIV-specific language. To avoid the possibility of inadvertent disclosure, ART facilities will only be referred to generically as “clinics” and any reference to ART will be to “tablets,” a common term for any medication that we demonstrated was acceptable in an earlier mHealth study in South Africa [46].
Risk to subjects will be minimized by: 1) training research staff in the ethical conduct of research; 2) strict protection of confidentiality by detailed standard operating procedures and on-site monitoring; 3) careful handling of sensitive data, procedures and processes in place to ensure data is securely stored and transferred; and 4) referral of participants to appropriate social and health services when necessary. The study site is well connected with the social worker and psychology services at the site as well as local non-governmental organizations providing counselling and support. While the potential risks to subjects are low, any social harm will be reported to the PI and a serious event will be reported to the Vanderbilt University and University of Cape Town IRBs within 48 hours of becoming aware of the event. Should any respondent experience discomfort or distress from participation in the study, we will provide the participant with the appropriate referral needed for follow-up and care.
Risk to subjects from participation in the study is minimal. All possible precautions will be taken to ensure complete confidentiality and protection of study participants. Given the minimal risk, the overall benefit of the study outweighs the risks
Plans for collection, laboratory evaluation and storage of biological specimens for genetic or molecular analysis in this trial/future use {33}
We will not collect blood or other biological specimens during this study. In routine care in this setting, viral load tests are to be repeated every three months in pregnancy and every six months during breastfeeding, so we expect that most women will have a routine viral load completed before six months postpartum. To avoid additional blood draws for the participant, at the follow-up visit, the study staff will check electronic health records to determine the most recent viral load test. If the participant has had no viral load test within three months prior to the six-month study follow-up visit, she will be referred for a blood draw for routine viral load testing at the clinic. Study staff will not conduct the blood draw and blood will not be stored.