3.1 Microstructure of as-annealed TA2/15CrNi3MoV explosive welding interface
Fig .2 shows the SEM-BSE images of the as-annealed TA2/15CrNi3MoV explosive welding interface. It can be clearly observed that there was a typical wave structure at the explosively welded TA2/15CrNi3MoV interface, as shown in Fig. 2(a). Microstructures investigation also has shown vortex generated in the TA2/15CrNi3MoV interface region. Fig. 2(b) shows a vortex structure at the interface, where brittle IMCs and micro-cracks exist. The generation of IMCs at the explosively welded Ti/steel interface can be related to the intense impact during the explosive welding process. The intense collision induced by explosive welding will have led to rapid and severe plastic deformation in the interface region, promoting the heat generated at the interface [23–25]. Previous study [16] reported that the explosively welded interface undergoes fast heating and cooling, leading to the formation of melted zone at the interface. Zhang et al. [23] revealed that the melted zone at explosively welded Ti/steel interface mainly consisted of FeTi. In addition, during the rapid cooling process, the mismatch in mechanical properties (e.g., heat transfer and thermal expansion) between the base plate and the flyer plate caused micro-cracks generated at the interface. Previous studies indicated that the micro-cracks were restricted within the IMCs and did not expand into the base materials [17]. The elemental distribution maps of the vortex region are indicated in Fig. 2(c-d). Fe-Ti intermetallic compounds were detected in the vortex. The generation of Fe-Ti IMCs can be related to the heating generation and accumulation caused by the severe plastic deformation during the explosive welding process.
To determine the phase composition at the wave peak region of the explosively welded TA2/15CrNi3MoV interface, the phase structure of the various region of the interface was confirmed by TEM. Fig. 3(a-b) shows the fabrication procedure of the TEM lamella. It can be clearly observed that the TEM lamella was prepared by FIB in the explosively welded TA2/15CrNi3MoV interface. Fig. 3(c) shows the HAADF images of the wave peak interface region. At the interface region, two reaction layers existed, namely 2 and 3. Fig. 3(d-e) shows high-resolution TEM (HRTEM) images of layer 2 and layer 3. Analysis of HRTEM images by fast Fourier transform (FFT) showed that layers 2 and 3 were TiC and FeTi, respectively. The thickness of the FeTi and TiC were about 0.095µm and 0.118µm, respectively. The formation of the FeTi and TiC was mainly induced by explosive welding and annealed process, respectively [23, 26]. This will be analyzed in detail later in this paper. Thus, for the as-annealed sample, the phases from the 15CrNi3MoV side to the TA2 side were α-Fe, TiC, FeTi and α-Ti, respectively.
Figure 4 shows the EBSD results of the wave peak region of the explosively welded TA2/15CrNi3MoV interface. The image quality (IQ) maps and inverse pole figure (IPF) images demonstrated two distinct grains on the steel side: equiaxed grains and elongated grains. The elongated Fe grains were mainly distributed in the steel side away from the explosive welding interface. In contrast, the equiaxed Fe grains were distributed primarily in the steel side near the interface. The elongated Fe grains were mainly caused by the severe plastic deformation during the explosive welding [27]. At the same time, heat generated and accumulated at the Ti/steel interface due to the rapid and severe plastic deformation [16, 23]. This deformation heating resulted in the recovery and recrystallization occurring at the explosive welding interface, and then the equiaxed Fe grains were generated, as shown in Figure 4. In addition, the annealing treatment also facilitated the recovery and recrystallization. Figure 4(c,f) shows the kernel average misorientation (KAM) maps of the interface, which reflects the dislocation density/local strains [3]. It can be found that a substantial number of local strains were distributed at the elongated Fe grains, while few amounts of local strains were distributed at the equiaxed Fe grains. The elongated grains experienced intense plastic deformation and contained a great number of local strains. However, at the equiaxed Fe grains, the local strains were sharply decreased due to the recovery and recrystallization.
3.2 Microstructure evolution of explosively welded TA2/15CrNi3MoV interface after heat treatment
Figure 5 shows the Back-scattered SEM images of the explosively welded TA2/15CrNi3MoV interface after different heat treatment processes. The microstructure of the TA2/15CrNi3MoV interface changed significantly with the elevation of the heating temperature. For the samples heat-treated at 700 ℃, a grey layer was formed at the interface. This reaction layer, which can be determined by Akbari Mousavi’s [20] research, was β-Ti. According to these previous researches [10, 20], β-Ti stabilizer elements (e.g., Fe, Cr and Ni) diffused from the steel side to the titanium side during the heat treatment, resulting in a decrease in the phase transformation temperature of α-Ti to β-Ti. Hence, the β-Ti layer was produced at the interface after heat treatment. When the temperature of the heat treatment was increased to 800 ℃, continuous β-Ti layer and Widmanstatten α-β structure were generated at the TA2 side, as shown in Figure 5(c). On the TA2 side away from the explosively welded interface, the amount of β-Ti stabilizer was not enough to retain the β-Ti to natural temperature and hence the Widmanstatten α-β structure were generated. Continuing to increase the heat treatment temperature, the β-Ti layer at the interface became thicker. When samples were heat-treated at 1000℃, the SEM-BSE images clearly indicated that the Ti/steel explosive welding interface region consisted of several layers, as shown in Figure 5(h). The generation of these layers will be analyzed in detail later in this paper.
Figure 6 shows SEM-BSE images of the explosively welded TA2/15CrNi3MoV interface at higher magnification. For the samples heat-treated at 700 ℃, a continuous black reaction layer was generated at the interface. According to the TEM (see Fig. 3) results and previous studies [26, 28], it can be determined that this black layer was TiC. TiC was a diffusion barrier, which hampered the diffusion of Fe atoms from the steel side to the titanium side [28–30]. Hence, the Fe-Ti IMCs (i.e., Fe2Ti and FeTi) and β-Ti layer increased slowly when the heat treatment temperature was lower than 700 ℃. When the heat treatment temperature was 800 ℃, the TiC layer was broken and existed in a semi-continuous state. This indicated that the Fe atoms diffusion barrier was disappeared, and then the Fe-Ti IMCs increased sharply to 1.2 µm, as shown in Figure 6(c). For the samples heat-treated at the temperature of 1000 ℃, Fe-Ti IMCs were generated at the interface, which contained fine blocky TiC inside (see Figure 6(f)). At this condition, the explosively welded Ti/steel interface region can be divided into several different layers. The chemical compositions of different layers are presented in Table 2. Layer Ⅰ was mainly contained Fe atoms (95.99 at%), which indicated that this layer was α-Fe. Layer Ⅱ in Figure 6 was composed of Fe (65.93 at%), Ti (30.87 at%) and C (3.20 at%) and layer Ⅲ was composed of Fe (43.44 at%), Ti (51.98 at%) and C (4.58 at%), both of which contains tremendous of Ti and Fe atoms, indicating that Fe-Ti was existing on these layers and was the primary phase. Layer Ⅳ and layer Ⅴ were mainly contained Ti atoms, while the Fe atoms in layer Ⅳ (10.21 at%) were more than layer Ⅴ (4.18 at%). Combined with the SEM-BSE images of the interface, it can be predicted that layer Ⅳ and layer Ⅴ was β-Ti and β-Ti + α-Ti, respectively. Hence, the explosively welded TA2/15CrNi3MoV interface from the 15CrNi3MoV side to the TA2 side can be divided into five layers, namely a-Fe, Fe2Ti, FeTi, β-Ti and α-Ti + β-Ti, as shown in Table 2.
Table 2
chemical composition of various phases in the 1000 ℃ heat-treated specimens (at%)
position
|
Ⅰ
|
Ⅱ
|
Ⅲ
|
Ⅳ
|
Ⅴ
|
Ti
|
0.36
|
30.87
|
51.98
|
87.45
|
93.56
|
Fe
|
95.99
|
65.93
|
43.44
|
10.21
|
4.18
|
C
|
3.65
|
3.20
|
4.58
|
2.34
|
2.26
|
Potential phase
|
α-Fe
|
Fe2Ti
|
FeTi
|
β-Ti
|
β-Ti + α-Ti
|
To investigate the chemical distribution in the Ti/steel interface, the Fe, Ti and C element distribution graphs across the interface were illustrated in Fig. 7. The line profiles of the Fe, Ti and C element distribution graph presents several platforms at the interface, proving the formation of IMCs. For the as-annealed sample, the line profile of Fe and Ti elements possesses a significant gradient, indicating that the diffusion of Fe and Ti elements was limited. For samples heat-treated at the temperature of 700 ℃, C enrichment was observed at the interface. This approved that the TiC layer was generated at the TA2/15CrNi3MoV interface. In contrast, this phenomenon was not observed in the processing temperature range of 800-1000 ℃. This may be attributed to the dissolve and broken-up of the TiC layer. It can be clearly observed that after the TiC layer broken-up, the diffusion distance of Fe atoms in titanium increased significantly [28–30]. For samples heat-treated at 1000 ℃, the Fe and Ti element distribution presented two platforms, indicating that the Fe-Ti IMCs generated at the interface.
The XRD patterns of the explosively welded TA2/15CrNi3MoV interface at different temperatures are shown in Fig. 8. The change of diffraction peak intensity reflects the change of corresponding phase content [3]. The as-annealed specimens show the typical diffraction peaks of α-Fe and α-Ti. After heat treatment, new IMCs (e.g., FeTi, Fe2Ti and TiC) were detected. For the samples heat-treated at 700 ℃, the diffraction peak intensities of Fe-Ti IMCs were small. In contrast, it can be clearly observed that for samples heat-treated at 800 ℃ and 1000 ℃, the FeTi and Fe2Ti were the main IMCs at the explosively welded TA2/15CrNi3MoV interface. In addition, it can be observed that the diffraction peak intensities of FeTi and Fe2Ti increased with the temperature, indicating that the content of FeTi and Fe2Ti increased with temperature.
To determine the microstructure evolution of the explosively welded TA2/15CrNi3MoV interface after the subsequent heat treatment process, standard free Gibbs energy (∆Gθ) changes with the temperature of the IMCs (i.e., TiC, FeTi and Fe2Ti) should be considered [28, 31], as shown in Fig. 9. It can be observed that the formation of TiC was the lowest value of ∆Gθ in the temperature range of 200 ℃-1400 ℃. This implied that TiC is preferentially formed at the interface compared to the FeTi and Fe2Ti. After the continuous TiC layer was generated, the formation of Fe-Ti IMCs (i.e., FeTi and Fe2Ti) was hindered due to the continuous TiC layer hampered the diffusion of Ti and Fe atoms across the TA2/15CrNi3MoV interface [29, 30]. Hence, the generation of IMCs (i.e., TiC, FeTi and Fe2Ti) in the Ti/steel interface can be divided into two stages.
For the as-annealed sample, there were two reaction layers (i.e., FeTi and TiC) generated at the TA2/15CrNi3MoV interface (see Fig. 3(c)). During the explosive welding, the intense plastic deformation of the welded materials caused substantial amounts of heat at the TA2/15CrNi3MoV interface. This leads to the formation of local melting zones at the TA2/15CrNi3MoV interface region, where FeTi were observed [23]. During the annealing process, the C element diffused from the steel side toward the Ti side and finally caused the formation of TiC [26]. Hence, the formation of FeTi and TiC at the TA2/15CrNi3MoV interface was mainly induced by explosive welding and stress-relief annealing treatment process, respectively.
The continuous TiC layer hampered the diffusion of constituent elements (e.g., Ti and Fe) across the bonding interface, which hindered the formation of Fe-Ti IMCs at the TA2/15CrNi3MoV interface [29, 30]. For the TA2/15CrNi3MoV interface heat-treated at the temperature of 700 ℃, continuous TiC hampered the formation of FeTi and Fe2Ti, as shown in Fig. 6(b). For the TA2/15CrNi3MoV interface heat-treated in the temperature range of 800 ℃-1000 ℃, continuous TiC layer broken up, leading to the barrier of the formation of FeTi and Fe2Ti at the interface disappeared, as shown in Fig. 6(c-f). Due to this reason, the thickness of FeTi and Fe2Ti layer increased significantly with the temperature in the temperature range of 800 ℃-1000 ℃. According to previous studies, Fe-Ti IMCs were very hard and brittle, which deteriorated the combination of the explosively welded TA2/15CrNi3MoV interface. Furthermore, the increase of the β-Ti layer also confirmed the accelerated diffusion of Fe atoms after the TiC layer broke up.
3.3 Mechanical properties and fracture analysis
The tensile strength of the explosively TA2/15CrNi3MoV interface at different conditions is presented in Fig. 10. It can be observed that the tensile strength decreased with the increase in temperature. The tensile strength of the as-annealed samples was 385.3 MPa, which was the maximum tensile strength of the explosively welded TA2/15CrNi3MoV interface. For the TA2/15CrNi3MoV interface heat-treated at 700 ℃, the tensile strength slowly decreased to 329.2MPa, which was 14.56% lower than that of the as-annealed samples. However, when the temperature of heat treatment was 800 ℃, the tensile strength sharply decreased to 247.3MPa, which was 35.82% lower than that of the as-annealed samples. It can be attributed to the substantial number of IMCs (i.e., TiC, FeTi and Fe2Ti) was existed at the interface, which deteriorates the combination of the TA2/15CrNi3MoV interface. During the tensile tests, the stress concentration generated at the TA2/15CrNi3MoV interface due to the deformation mismatch between IMCs and base materials, which eventually caused the explosively welded Ti/steel interface to fracture under a lower load [21]. For samples heat-treated at 850 ℃ and 900 ℃, the tensile strength of the explosively welded TA2/15CrNi3MoV interface sharply decreased to 232.6 MPa and 222.9MPa, respectively, due to the increase of IMCs. When the temperature of the heat treatment was 1000 ℃, the thickness of the Fe-Ti IMCs at the bonding interface increased to 4.23 µm, leading to the tensile strength of the explosively welded TA2/15CrNi3MoV interface sharply decreased to 163.6 MPa.
Figure 11 shows the fracture surface of the explosively welded TA2/15CrNi3MoV clad plates. It can be clearly observed that all the tensile test samples are fractured in the Ti/steel interface. For the as-annealed samples, some bulk fragments were existed on the fracture surface, as shown in Figure 11(a). For specimen heat-treated in the range of 700-1000 ℃, the failure mechanism of the explosively welded TA2/15CrNi3MoV interface was the brittle fracture. Chemical compositions measured by EDS reveal that the fracture surfaces were mainly contained FeTi and Fe2Ti.