3.1 Effect of typical factors on the MB degradation
3.1.1 Effect of VUV power
The influence of VUV power on degradation of MB by VUV/UVC irradiation was investigated. As shown in Fig. 1a, the MB degradation process was conformed to the pseudo-first order reaction. The reaction kinetics constant of MB degradation increased from 0.0235 to 0.1729 min-1 with the VUV power increasing from 10–100% (VUV full power was set as 100%). In the VUV/UVC system, the energy of photon from VUV irradiation at 185 nm reaches 6.7 eV, it is higher than the threshold energy for photochemical induced splitting of water (Nikogosyan &Görner 1992) and the bond dissociation energy (BDE) of MB molecular (Huang et al. 2013). More photon generated to destroy MB directly increase with the VUV power. The increasing VUV power also enhances the yield of ·OH and HO2·, resulting in higher degradation efficiency of MB.
3.1.2 Effect of temperature
The effect of temperature on the degradation efficiency of MB was investigated, and results are shown in Fig. 1b. The MB degradation process at various temperature followed pseudo-first-order reaction kinetics, and the constants increased from 0.132 to 0.239 min-1 when temperature increased from 288 to 318 K. Furatian (Furatian &Mohseni 2018) reported that the 185 nm photolysis of H2O is fairly insensitive to temperature due to the absorbance of water is negligible. In VUV/UVC irradiation system, two ·OH can merge into one H2O2 molecule (Eq. 3). As the previous reported, the rise of temperature results in an enhancement in the generation and reactivity of ·OH together with a decomposition of H2O2 (Sanz et al. 2013). Moreover, the quantum yield of ·OH and molecular diffusion higher with the sequential increase of high temperature (Cao et al. 2020). It was attributed to the radiation intensity of the ultraviolet lamp enhanced by the rise of temperature. To the light source, the optimum working temperature range of LPUV is 313 ~ 315 K (40 ~ 42 ℃) (Masschelein 2002) and the efficiency could be increased with the rise of temperature during 288 ~ 318 K. The Arrhenius plot for the MB degradation is displayed in Fig. S2. According to Arrhenius formula, the apparent activation energy of MB degradation was calculated 14.72 kJ·mol-1. This data is similar to the degradation of MB in the UV/TiO2 photocatalytic system (14.45 kJ·mol-1) (Lee et al. 1999) and in the electrical discharge plasma (13.09 kJ·mol-1) (Benetoli et al. 2011).
3.1.3 Effect of initial pH
To further explore the rule of MB decomposition in VUV/UVC irradiation system at different conditions, degradation of MB was evaluated at different initial pH values. As shown in Fig. 1c, MB was degraded entirely at various initial pH in 30 min, but initial pH has different effects on the degradation rates. When solution pH increased from 3.02 to 9.19, the pseudo-first-order reaction kinetics constant increased from 0.123 to 0.203 min-1, though to a lesser extent, and then reduced to 0.181 min-1 as pH increased to 10.98. It should be noted that the effect of pH on MB photodecomposition was not significant except at high pH values. The improvement of MB degradation with increase of pH can be attributed to either consumption of ·OH by OH- (Eq. 4). As initial pH increased from 3.03 ~ 9.19, few of ·OH were quenched by OH- (Zhang et al. 2020) and leading to MB degradation. However, as pH increased to 10.98, too much ·OH quenched by OH- and inhibited the MB degradation. For the oxidizing nature of ·OH, the oxidation potential of ·OH reduced with pH from 2.59 V (pH 0) to 2.18 V (pH 7.0), and ·OH could be further converted to O·- (E0 = 1.64 V) under alkaline conditions (Koppenol &Liebman 1984). In addition, the light screening effect of OH- (ε185 > 3099 M-1 cm-1) (Sauer et al. 2004) also reduced the ·OH generation (ε185 > 1.8 M-1 cm-1) (Weeks et al. 1963).
\(2·OH\leftrightarrow {H}_{2}{O}_{2}\)
k = 5.5 × 109 M− 1s− 1 (3)
\(\bullet OH+{OH}^{-}\to {H}_{2}O+{O}^{\bullet -}\)
k = 1.2 × 1010 M− 1s− 1 (4)
3.1.4 Effect of initial MB concentration
Figure 1d shows the degradation process of MB at the different initial concentration in VUV/UVC irradiation system. Apparently, the MB degradation rate decreased gradually with increased initial MB concentration, the pseudo-first-order reaction kinetics rate constant reduced from 0.554 to 0.058 min-1 when the initial MB concentrations increased from 10 to 70 mg/L. Yang et al. (Yang et al. 2020) observed the same trends in the degradation of atrazine using VUV/UVC/Fe. In the VUV/UVC system, MB achieved effective degradation at low MB concentration due to the relative abundant photons and ROS. However, as initial concentration of MB increased, MB and its products compete with photons and ROS. Furthermore, the VUV photons was absorbed by MB and its products, and inhibited the generation of ROS by the light screening effect (Li et al. 2017).
3.2 Degradation mechanism of MB in different reaction process
VUV/UVC radiation process is a complex reaction system due to the coexist of radical reaction and photochemical reaction. In addition to VUV induced ROS processes and UVC photolysis, the generation of H2O2 cannot be neglected. Through combination of ·OH and HO2· species (Eqs. 4 and 5), H2O2 could be generated in the VUV/UVC photolysis water process. As shown in Fig. 2a, H2O2 concentration increased and leveled off at a quasi-stationary concentration of 15.15 × 10− 6 M (0.52 mg/L), and the maximum concentration was 38.56 × 10− 6 M (1.31 mg/L) at 5 min. H2O2 concentration raised continuously until to the maximum in a circular photo-reactor also reported on previous study (Moussavi et al. 2018). In this process, the H2O2 was formed mostly by recombination of ·OH (Zhang et al. 2020). After that, H2O2 was decomposed with other reactions (Eqs. 6 and 7) and UVC photolysis (Eq. 8), then secondary radical generated. Ultimately, Formation and decomposition of H2O2 form a dynamic equilibrium, resulting in a steady-state concentrations.
\({2HO}_{2}\text{·}\to {H}_{2}{O}_{2}+{O}_{2}\)
k = 8.4 × 105 M− 1s− 1 (5)
\({H}_{2}{O}_{2}+\bullet OH\to {HO}_{2}^{\bullet }+{H}_{2}O\)
k = 3.3 × 107 M− 1s− 1 (6)
\({e}_{aq}^{-}+{H}_{2}{O}_{2}\to \bullet OH+{OH}^{-}\)
k = 1.1 × 1010 M− 1s− 1 (7)
\({H}_{2}{O}_{2}+\underleftrightarrow{\lambda \text{=}254nm}2·OH\)
Φ(H2O2) = 0.5 (8)
To investigate the individual contribution of UVC photolysis, and UVC/H2O2 to MB degradation in VUV/UVC system, the degradation experiments were conducted individually in above three systems. As shown in Fig. 2b, direct photolysis by UVC caused slight degradation of MB, where only 6.96% of MB was removed after 30 min. By contrast, MB was degraded quickly in both VUV/UVC irradiation process and UVC/H2O2 process. The remove rate of MB was 100% and 96.82% for VUV/UVC and UVC/H2O2 process, respectively.
Sodium bicarbonate (SB) and 1, 4-benzoquinone (BQ) were respectively selected as organic quencher for ·OH and HO2·. As shown in Fig. S3, MB removal efficiency and pseudo-first-order kinetic constant k reduced leveled off as SB and BQ concentration were 60 and 0.5 mM, respectively, suggesting that ·OH and HO2· were the ROS in VUV/UVC irradiation process. The degradation of MB in UVC alone, VUV/UVC alone and UVC/H2O2 process are shown in Fig. S4. MB degradation by UVC irradiation, VUV/UVC irradiation and UVC/H2O2 system well followed a pseudo-first-order kinetics and the degradation rate constant were 0.002, 0.168 and 0.161 min-1, respectively. As shown in Fig. S4 (a), no obvious effect on MB degradation was found in the UVC irradiation process with addition of quenchers. It was confirmed that quenchers had negligible influence on the degradation of MB in UVC process. As can be seen in Fig. S3 (b and c), degradation of MB has been inhibited in VUV/UVC irradiation and UVC/H2O2 process observably when SB or BQ added. It demonstrated that ·OH and HO2· had been generated in VUV/UVC irradiation and UVC/H2O2 process. Additionally, it should be noted that the weak MB degradation was observed though ·OH and HO2·has been quenched, which indicated the effect of direct photolysis on MB degradation.
The contribution of ·OH, HO2· and UVC photolysis to degradation of MB was further evaluated with experiments performed with the ROS quenching tests. The contribution ratios of ·OH, HO2· and UV photolysis were calculated as below equations: (Zhang et al. 2019b):
\({R}_{·\text{O}\text{H}}=\frac{{k}_{MB}-{k}_{SB}}{{k}_{MB}}\) (9)
\({R}_{{\text{H}\text{O}}_{2}·}=\frac{{k}_{SB}-{k}_{BQ}}{{k}_{MB}}\) (10)
Where R·OH and RHO2· represent the contribution ratios of ·OH and HO2· in the overall MB degradation, respectively; kMB, kSB, and kBQ are the degradation rate constants of MB with or without the presence of SB and BQ, respectively. As shown in Fig. 2c, the contribution ratios of ·OH, HO2·, and UVC photolysis were 90.12%, 3.85%, and 6.03% in VUV/UVC irradiation process and 50.92%, 41.83%, and 5.25% in UV/H2O2 process. These results suggested that ·OH played a significant role on MB degradation in VUV/UVC irradiation process. Unlike this result, Li et al. (Li et al. 2016) reported that HO2· was the predominant ROS leading to MB degradation in VUV/UVC/Fenton process. Huang et al. (Huang et al. 2013) reported that ·OH and energetic photons were the primary ROS on MB degradation in VUV/UVC/TiO2 process. In the UVC/H2O2 process, ·OH can be produced through direct dissociation of H2O2 under UVC irradiation. In this process, numerous H2O2 reacted with ·OH, and generated a great deal of HO2·. Although the oxidizing power of HO2· is lower than ·OH (Haji et al. 2011), its lifetime is several orders longer than that of the ·OH [26, 44], and played remarkable role on MB degradation. Therefore, it concluded that both ·OH and HO2· were the main active specie for degradation of MB in UVC/H2O2 process. In VUV/UVC irradiation process, ·OH formation firstly by VUV photochemical ionization of water, and then HO2· formatted by ·OH reacting with H2O2. However, the concentration of H2O2 was lower and resulted in a small quantity of HO2· generation. Thus, the contribution of ·OH to the degradation of MB is expected to be much higher than that of HO2·.
UV-Vis spectrum evolution of MB in degradation process in VUV/UVC and UVC/H2O2 systems have been presented in Fig. 3. A rapid decrease of the absorbance of MB was observed in VUV/UVC and UVC/H2O2 system (Fig. 3a and 3d). The absorbance of MB was slightly decrease as addition of SB and BQ in VUV/UVC irradiation system (Fig. 3b and 3c). In the UVC/H2O2, the absorbance of MB decreased significantly as addition of SB and have no evident changes with BQ addition (Fig. 3e and 3f).
The maximum absorption peak blue-shifted in various systems were shown in Fig. S5. The blue-shifted was observed in maximum absorption wavelength at 664 nm in VUV/UVC and UVC/H2O2 system, the same phenomenon were found in photocatalytic degradation of MB process (Mir et al. 2017). The blue-shifted intensity was followed the order: VUV/UVC > UVC/H2O2 > UVC/H2O2 + SB, and other systems could be negligible. In UVC/H2O2 + SB process, ·OH was quenched and blue-shifted was significantly suppressed in contrast to UVC/H2O2 system. Moreover, the formation of demethylate products during the MB degradation process induced blue-shift of UV-Vis spectra (Rauf et al. 2010, Sandoval et al. 2017). It indicates that ·OH was the main active species for demethylation of MB. In other words, HO2· degraded MB by destroy the chromophores.
3.3 Products and proposal of MB degradation pathway
Since the mineralization of MB results in the formation of S and N containing intermediates, the concentration of NH4+, NO2-, NO3-, SO42-, and HCOO- in the VUV/UVC irradiation system were measured (Fig. 4). NH4+ was produced due to the oxidation of the nitrogen-containing groups in MB molecules, but NO2- and NO3- were not generated. SO42- was not detected at the initial stage of the reaction until 10 min. In other words, nitrogen-containing groups were oxidized easier than the sulfur-containing groups in VUV/UVC irradiation system. Additionally, HCOO- generated and remarkably increased during MB degradation, indicating that demethylation was one of the pathways for MB degradation. In addition, TOC removal rate of MB was observed low to be only 15.64% (Fig. S6).
To clarify the degradation pathway of MB by UVU/UVC irradiation, the degradation intermediates were detected by LC-MS analysis. According to the typical total ion chromatogram (TIC) shown in Fig. S7, the abundance of the intermediates during MB degradation variable in time (Fig. 5a-5f). Six major intermedias of MB degradation were identified in VUV/UVC irradiation process ([M + 1]+= 272, 290, 304; [M]+= 242, 256-1, 256-2). Abundance of all the intermediates first accumulated and then their abundance decreased with prolonged irradiation time.
The degradation pathway of MB under VUV/UVC irradiation is proposed in Fig. 5g. Based on the intermediates, the two possible major photo-degradation pathways of MB are proposed. In the pathway I, the parent of MB was attacked by ·OH and formatted the demethylated intermediate [M]+= 256-1 or [M]+= 256-2. Intermediates [M]+= 242 formed from [M]+= 256-1 or [M]+= 256-2 by further demethylation, and then intermediates [M]+= 272 were produced from [M]+= 256-1 by oxidation. In the pathway II, parent MB were oxide and produced [M + 1]+= 304, which was further demethylated to [M + 1]+= 290.
To further elucidate the degradation pathway, DFT calculation was used and the optimized structure of the MB molecule shows in Fig. 6a. As shown in Fig. 6c, the calculating Fukui functions showed that the most prominent regions of f- are localized in N and S, which indicates that these sites are susceptible for ·OH attacks. According to the MB degradation products, ·OH tended to attack the N15 and N18, agreement with the results of theoretical calculation.