3.1 FT-IR
Figure 1 shows FT-IR spectra of prepared ZnO, Fe2V4O13, and X-AZF (X = 1, 1.5,2 and 2.5 wt%). The stretching vibration of surface hydroxyl group was appeared in the range between 3453 and 3405 cm-1 for all the samples[18, 19]. In Fig. 1a, peaks observed at 420, 447, and 543 cm–1, which could be attributed to the Zn–O stretching modes [19–21].In Fig. 1b, the peaks at 1028,711 and 510 cm–1 are assigned to V–O, V–O–Fe and Fe–O stretching modes, respectively[19].Bands at 474 and 426 cm–1are attributed to the characteristic stretching mode of Ag–O and Zn–O bonds[22]. Figure 1c–f show various functional groups of AZF and the metal oxide bond present in the compound, Fe–O, Ag–O, and Zn–O vibrations are observed at 1015, 1100, 474, 426, and 413 cm–1. This indicates that Ag was effectively loaded on the ZnO/Fe2V4O13 nanocomposite.
3.2 XRD
Figure 2 show the typical X-ray diffraction (XRD) patterns of the prepared ZnO(Fig. 2a),Fe2V4O13 (Fig. 2b)[19] and ZnO/Fe2V4O13 samples with different loading concentrations of Ag (X = 1, 1.5, 2 and 2.5 wt%) (Fig. 2c–f). The wurtzite ZnO (JCPDS Card No. 36-1451) planes were observed for the prepared ZnO at 2θ values of 31.75, 34.40, 36.23, 47.53, 56.60, and 62.34° corresponds to (100), (002), (101), (102), (110), and (103) planes, respectively[23, 24].In Fig. 2b, Fe2V4O13 shows three diffraction peaks at 2θ angles of 12.5, 22.7, and 26.7° that correspond to (002), (022), and (014) planes of Fe2V4O13, respectively and the peaks are well matched to the monoclinic phase of Fe2V4O13 (JCPDS Card No. 00-039-0893). The good crystallinity is confirmed by high and narrow diffracted peaks[19]. Face centered cubic (FCC) geometry is indexed to the three additional peaks at 38.06, 44.29, and 64.43° corresponding to (111), (200), and (220) planes of ZnO/Fe2V4O13 doped with silver nanocomposites (JCPDS Card No. 4-0783)[25, 26] inFig. 2c–f. The average crystallite size of 2 wt% of AZF was 28.5 nm.
3.3 BET surface area
The pore structure and surface area of the prepared Ag-ZnO/Fe2V4O13 was analyzed using N2 absorption-desorption isotherms are shown in Fig. 3. The Ag-ZnO/Fe2V4O13 is type II isotherm at IUPAC level[27]and the distribution of pore size is given in the inset of Fig. 3. The BET surface area and pore volume of Ag-ZnO/Fe2V4O13 are given in Table 1.
Table 1
Texture parameters of 2 wt% Ag-ZnO/Fe2V4O13
SBET (m2 g− 1)
|
Vp (cm3 g− 1)
|
Dp (nm)
|
Smicro (m2 g− 1)
|
Vmicro (cm3 g− 1)
|
0.9043
|
0.1044
|
461.86
|
16.53
|
0.0089
|
SBET = BET surface area, Vp = total pore volume, Dp = average uniform pore size distribution, Smicro = surface area of micropores, Vmicro = pore volume of micropores. |
Table 2
Mass spectral data of intermediates (MO)
Compounds
|
Retention time (min)
|
m/z values
|
C13H13N3O3S (D1)
|
19.796
|
292.0 (M + 1), 258.0, 229.0, 181.0, 152.0, 126.0, 111.0, 75.0
|
C12H9N2NaO3S (D2)
|
18.533
|
284.0 (M+), 282.0, 211.0, 111.0, 85.0, 71.0, 57.0, 54.0
|
C6H5N2NaO3S (D3)
|
16.665
|
209.0 (M+), 111.0, 97.0, 85.0, 71.0, 57.0
|
C6H7NO (D4)
|
15.512
|
109.0 (M+), 83.0, 71.0, 67.0, 57.0
|
3.4 SEM-EDX with color mapping
SEM measurements have described the surface morphology of the AZF. Figure 4shows that the 2 wt% Ag-loaded ZnO/Fe2V4O13 with different magnifications. The irregular-shaped ZnO/Fe2V4O13 agglomerates are shown in all SEM images.EDX can generally accurately detect up to trace amount of metal present on the surface of base materials. Figure 5 shows the EDX recorded from the selected area, which reveals that the presence of Zn, Fe, V, Ag, and O in the catalyst. The presence of these elements in Ag-ZnO/Fe2V4O13 was also confirmed by elemental color mapping. The different color areas in Fig. 6 indicate Ag, Zn, Fe, V, and O enriched areas of the Ag-ZnO/Fe2V4O13 sample.
3.5 HR-TEM
Figure 7shows that the HR-TEM images of the 2 wt% Ag-ZnO/Fe2V4O13.From Fig. 7a, some of the hexagonal particles are clearly seen, and corresponding to ZnO in Ag-ZnO/Fe2V4O13, although the identification of Fe2V4O13 in Ag-ZnO/Fe2V4O13 was impossible. The lattice fringes of the Ag-ZnO/Fe2V4O13 catalyst are shown inFig. 7d. The interplanar spacing values for the nanocrystalline Ag-ZnO are shown in Fig. 7e. From the HR-TEM images, the average diameters (28.545±5.453nm) of the nanoparticles (Ag-ZnO/Fe2V4O13nanocomposite) were computed by Image J analysis. The histogram shows that the average particle diameter of 2wt% Ag-ZnO/Fe2V4O13in Fig. 7f.
3.6 UV-vis-DRS
Figure 8Ashows the DRS results of ZnO, Fe2V4O13, and samples with various wt % of X-Ag-loaded ZnO/Fe2V4O13 (X = 1.0, 1.5, 2 and 2.5 wt%) catalyst. In visible regions, Ag-ZnO/Fe2V4O13 composites display higher absorption than ZnO, resulting in higher visible light active catalytic behavior and also an increase in the absorption at 350–380 nm (UV-region) this can contribute to enhanced e-/h+pair production, which consequently improvesthe photocatalyticactivity under UV light[28]. Figure 8B shows K-Mplots for ZnO, Fe2V4O13, and ZnO/Fe2V4O13 with various wt % of Ag loading. The band gap energies of ZnO, Fe2V4O13, and X-Ag-ZnO/Fe2V4O13 (X = 1, 1.5, 2, and 2.5 wt%) were 3.25, 2.21, 3.23, 3.23, 3.15, and 3.16 eV, respectively.
3.7 Photoluminescence (PL) emission spectra
The effective suppression of photogenerated charge carriers and the transfer of the photogenerated e-/h+were investigated by photoluminescence (PL) emission spectra[29]. Figure 9 shows the PL spectra of the prepared ZnO (Fig. 9a) and 2 wt% Ag-ZnO/Fe2V4O13 (Fig. 9b). Three emission bands are observed at 395, 431, and 586 nm. Although all the peaks are almost identical, PL intensities are different. The higher intensitywas observed in bare ZnO at 395 nm due to high e-/h+recombination than Ag-ZnO/Fe2V4O13. The Ag particles loaded with the ZnO/Fe2V4O13nanocompositeact as trapper for photo-generatedelectrons, and quench the PL emission [30].The maximum intensity shows the higher e-/h+ recombination and resultslow photocatalytic activity[31, 32].The lowest intensity shows that the well suppression of e-/h+recombination and results higher photocatalytic activity[33].
3.8 Primary analysis
The photocatalytic behavior of nanocomposite Ag-ZnO/Fe2V4O13 with 1, 1.5, 2, and 2.5 wt percent of Ag loading was assessed in terms of MO degradation.Controlledexperimentswere conducted under different reaction conditions (Fig. 10). The dye/ZnO/UV-A process underwent 68% degradation in 90 min (curve a). The dye/ZnO/Fe2V4O13/UV light process showed curve b, which yielded 75% degradation in 90 min. Only 19% adsorption was observed in dye/2 wt% Ag-ZnO/Fe2V4O13/dark process (curve e).Curves c, d, f, and g demonstrate the degradation of dye on irradiation with the Ag-ZnO/Fe2V4O13 catalyst with different percent wt of Ag loading. The 2 wt% Ag-ZnO/Fe2V4O13hybrid-heterojunction catalyst showed higher MOdegradation (curve f, 93%) in 90 min and also almost complete degradation was achieved at 120 min. Hence, 2 wt% of Ag is the optimum loading of Ag-ZnO/Fe2V4O13.
3.9 Effect of pH
pH is the important parameters for the application of industrial point of view.By adjusting the pH of the MO solution, the effect of pH on the MO photodegradation was studied. Fig. S2demonstrates that pH has an important effect on the rate of photodegradation and decolorization. The maximum degradation and decolorization of MO is observed at pH 7. Above pH 7, the rate of degradation and decolorization decreases. Effect of catalyst loading (Fig. S3) and initial dye concentration (Fig. S4) are discussed in supporting information’s.
3.10 Reusability
Figure 11 shows the stability of the catalyst for the degradation of MO. In the first run, approximately 99% of MO degradation achieved. The same catalyst was again reused for further runs. All the remaining cycles gave almost 98.5% of degradation in 90 min. Hence, the 2 wt% Ag-ZnO/Fe2V4O13 is stable, recoverable and reusable.
3.11 Mineralization studies
3.11.1 GC-MS analysis
Sometimes intermediates are more hazardous than starting materials, so it is necessary to analyze the intermediates for the degradation process. An attempt has been made to find out the degradation intermediates of MO photodegradation with 2wt% Ag-ZnO/Fe2V4O13 (AZF) hybrid-heterojunction/UV process. GC-MS studied performed with the solutions obtained after 30 and 60 minutes of irradiation and predicted a degradation pathway for MO by AZF based on the m/z ratio, retention time and molecular weight(Scheme 1). For these identified intermediates, molecular ion and fragmentation peak values are stated inTable 2.Although, in photocatalytic degradation of azo dyes, it was expected that the cleavage of azo bond take place first, however, formation of compounds observed (D1 and D2)with azo groups at the retention time of 19.796 and 18.533 min, respectively. Hydroxyl radicals were thus considered to be the most reactive species for degradation, the compound D1 undergoes azo link cleavage and replacement of sulfonic acid group by hydroxyl group through the repetitive attack of •OH radicals produced intermediates N′-methylbenzene-1,4-diamine (Compound I) and 4-aminophenol (D4). The intermediate product D2 further undergoes C–N cleavage produced D3 which on further undergoes azo link cleavage produced 4-aminophenol (D4). Finally, it is expected that the compound D4 and compound I would be mineralized to CO2, water and mineral acids [34, 35].
3.11.2 FT-IR spectral analysis
The early adsorption of the dye under dark by 2 wt% Ag-ZnO/Fe2V4O13nanocomposite is 33.4%, although complete degradation occurred at 90 min irradiation. The experiments were carried out to determine whether the adsorbed dye molecules had been degraded completely. Comparisons made with FT-IR spectra of the fresh dye and catalyst ((Fig. S5a and S5b), and dye adsorbed composite before and after irradiations (Fig. S5c and S5d). The characteristic bands of MO (Fig. S5a) are observed at 1604, 1366, and 1042 cm–1 due to N = N stretching, C–N bond vibrations, and S = O bond of MO, respectively [36].When compared Fig. S5a and Fig. S5c, the characteristic MO dye peaks are observed in the dye adsorbed catalyst. However, upon irradiation,ie after complete degradation, the FT-IR spectrum of the composite (Fig. S5d) resembles with fresh catalyst (Fig. S5b) revealed that the adsorbed dye molecules underwent complete degradation.Thus, the 2 wt% Ag-ZnO/Fe2V4O13nanocomposite shows better catalytic performance for MO.
3.11.3 UV-Vis spectral analysis
Figure 12 shows UV-vis spectra for the degradation and decolorization of MO by 2 wt% Ag-ZnO/Fe2V4O13nanocomposite under UV-A light irradiation for 0–90 min. UV-vis spectrum of MO shows strong absorption in the range of 200–600 nm with λmax at 464 nm, which is due to the presence of the azo group (N = N), and another band is observed at 272 nm in the UV region due to aromatic part of the dye. Upon continues irradiation with2 wt% Ag-ZnO/Fe2V4O13nanocomposite, both peaks were diminished with respect to time, and finally almost completely disappeared. From these observations we conclude that the degradation of the dye with respect to time[37].Moreover, no new peakswere observed during irradiation, indicating that MO was degraded gradually and intermediates do not absorb at analytical wavelengths. The color of the suspension changed from the orange to colorless (inset of Fig. 12).
3.11.4 Chemical oxygen demand (COD) measurements
The mineralization of the dye further confirmed with reduction of COD values. Under optimum condition, COD measurements were made and the percentageof COD reduction of thedye at different times of UV-A light irradiation is given in Table 3. Percentages of COD reduction increases with respect to irradiation time reveals that the mineralization of the dye.
Table 3
Percentages of COD reduction at different irradiation times for the degradation of MO by 2 wt% Ag-ZnO/Fe2V4O13 catalyst
Dye
|
0 min
|
30 min
|
60 min
|
90 min
|
120 min
|
MO
|
0
|
31.6
|
57.4
|
79.3
|
88.0
|
[MO] = 4⋅10− 4 M, 2 wt% Ag-ZnO/Fe2V4O13 = 3 g L− 1, airflow rate = 8.1 mL s− 1, pH = 7, IUV = 1.381 ⋅ 10− 6 einstein L− 1 s− 1. |
3.12 Mechanism
Under light irradiation, the photoexcited electrons in the CB of Fe2V4O13 can jump to the CB of ZnO. The CB potential of ZnO was found to be more electronegative than the reduction potential of O2/O2•– (–0.34 eV vs NHE), and therefore, the electrons concentrated in the CB of ZnO can generate O2•– for dye degradation(Fig. 13). Further, Ag can shuttle the photogenerated electron from ZnO in Ag-ZnO/Fe2V4O13 and reduces the recombination of electron-hole pair effectively. However, owing to the less positive VB potential of Fe2V4O13, the holes do not generate •OH. Meanwhile, Fe2V4O13's holes created in the VB would be transferred to its surface and then directly involved in the MO degradation.By these two processes the lifetimes of electron and hole increase, leading to enhanced photocatalytic activity.
The increased transfer of charge between the interface of Fe2V4O13 and ZnO strongly suppressed the rate of recombination, which is beneficial to improve the photocatalyticability. The reduction of PL intensity in Ag-ZnO/Fe2V4O13 as compared to that of pure undopedZnOreveals the effective prohibition of recombination of e-/h+pairs, indicating thatloadingof Ag and Fe2V4O13 could substantiallysuppress the charge transfer rate in ZnO. The band gap energy of Ag-ZnO/Fe2V4O13lowered than that of pure ZnO.
In general, for a higher formation rate of •OH radicals, a separation efficiency of electron-hole pairs would be greater. The photocatalytic activity therefore shows a positive association with the rate of radical formation of •OH, i.e., a faster rate of radical formation of •OH contributes to a higher photocatalytic activity of the nanocomposite. Moreover, the formation of superoxide radical anions increased due to electrons transferred to the adsorbed oxygen molecules by Ag via the ZnO conduction band. Hydroxyl radicals and superoxide radical anions are potent oxidants, so that organic molecules and intermediate species can completely oxidizedtotheir respective end-products.
Trapping experiments were performed to identify the active species involved in photocatalytic degradation process[38–40] and the results are shown in Fig. 14. No scavenger, the degradation efficiency is 99% at time of 90 min. Under the same condition, with TBA (•OH scavenger), KI (h+ scavenger), BQ (O2•– scavenger) and AgNO3 (e– scavenger) gave 93.9, 86.8, 84.6 and 89.6 percentages of degradation, respectively. From these values, more or less all the species are equally contributed in the degradation process. However, the addition of BQ suppress the photocatalytic activity of the composite insomewhat extent, hence superoxide radical anion (O2•–) has been consider as a most active species for this degradation process.