The results of the ecologic and pedologic transect suggest a significant (ɑ = 0.05) linear relationship exists between the prevalence of clay in the soil and percent cover of Japanese knotweed (p < 0.01), and that this is a strongly positive relationship (r = 0.7). Other properties of the soil were also found to relate to the proportion of clay, such as porosity (Fig. 3). Since porosity values were calculated from soil texture, and porosity is inversely proportional to grain size, this porosity percentage increase as clay percentage increases is well understood and expected (Fennell, Wade, and Bacon 2018). Due to this connection, the relationship between porosity percentage in the top 40 cm of soil and the mean percent Japanese knotweed coverage is also found to be a significant (p = 0.04) and positive relationship (r = 0.47).
Results on infiltration rate indicate that Japanese knotweed stem presence correlates with a longer average infiltration rate (Fig. 4). This was shown for both Plot A (riparian site) and Plot B mid-slope terrestrial site), but there was only a significant difference (p = 0.05) shown in Plot A between the infiltration rates with and without the stems present (Fig. 4). Plot B did not show a significant difference (p = 0.88) between infiltration rates of sampling locations with knotweed stems present or absent. The riparian site (Plot A) also had a higher proportion of fine sediment when compared to the other location (Fig. 5) and the mid-slope terrestrial site (Plot B) had a higher percentage of coarse-grained particles (Fig. 5).
These findings showed the potential for this invasive species to relate to physical changes in the soil and its hydrologic properties.
Past studies have also investigated infiltration rates, and have attributed lower infiltration rates for invasive species to physical disturbances (Vanderklein, Galster, and Scherr 2014) but have not examined the relationship between soil texture as closely. As stated in the Lavoie (2017) literature review, there have been very few studies that have looked at the physical changes to the environment due to knotweed invasions. Our study also demonstrates that knotweed plots had increased amounts of the fine-grained soil component, common in the organic-rich soil A horizons, showing a strong similarity to Maurel et al. (2010). Together, these findings suggest physical changes to the soil under Japanese knotweed are a feature of this particular invasive.
In the finer-textured riparian site (Plot A), knotweed appeared to drastically change infiltration rates between areas with or without stems. Due to Japanese knotweed growth influencing soil properties, finer-grained soils (such as in our riparian Plot A) may allow this invasive to have a higher competitive advantage. By creating a more sub-optimal soil pore environment via the introduction of extensive subsurface biomass, Japanese knotweed can continuously compact pore space, which can limit infiltration rates and deplete water storage capacity for competitors. Through our findings, and knowing they are in relative similarity to others, we believe a previously unidentified positive feedback mechanism is likely occurring to support the competitive expansion of knotweed invasions in finer-textured soils (Fig. 6).
Known mechanisms that allow for a successful Japanese knotweed invasion are shown on the right in Fig. 6. Alongside these known feedback mechanisms, we have illustrated our own newly proposed positive feedback mechanism demonstrating the uniquely competitive advantage knotweed has in fine-grained soils. Starting at the first stage (A), Japanese knotweed is introduced to a new area. From here, the extensive rhizome network of large rhizomes (the ‘knots’ of the knotweed root system) causes the soil to compact, limiting water holding capacity in fine-textured soils (B), whereas in coarser soils containing a lesser proportion of flat clay and organic particles comprising the soil matrix, this compaction would not have the same impact in removing soil pore space due to the higher proportion of spherical soil particles, and therefore would not limit soil water holding capacity as greatly. This soil pore compaction also causes a decrease in infiltration capacity, limiting the ability for additional water to enter these fine-tectured soils as easily. Because of the soil compaction and decreased infiltration in organic and clay-rich soils, knotweed has a competitive advantage and can outcompete other plants (C) because native plants are no longer able to as easily acquire the needed soil moisture from the newly compacted clay-rich soil matrix, whereas knotweed has its ‘knots’ to store and release water from within its own rhizome network. Through this (and other feedback mechanisms), knotweed outcompetes the other vegetation and the abundance increases in the soils that have a finer texture and higher percentage of clay (D). The knotweed then continues in this loop where it invades an area with clay-rich soils, changes the soil water holding capacity, and outcompetes the other vegetation struggling to survive in the surface soils, forming a successful invasion (E).