Our retrospective study addressed repeated SRT sessions for BMs in patients with local or distant brain recurrence without previous WBRT. The purpose was primarily to analyze neurological symptoms and acute toxicity during each SRT session and the cumulative risk of acute toxicity during any SRT session and secondly to analyze the cumulative dose to the brain.
Few studies have examined acute toxicity during SRT, and most of these studies were conducted on a single SRT session or even irradiation to a single BM [19–21]. Studies of repeated SRT sessions have paid little attention to acute toxicity during radiotherapy [22–29].
This is the first study to address the potential impact of repeated irradiation to multiple BMs. Moreover, no study has investigated the dose to the brain and to the healthy brain in cases of repeated SRT [30].
First, this study included many patients and a large number of BMs. The neurological symptoms experienced by patients were recorded before and after irradiation. The monocentricity of this study appears to be an advantage, since it allowed us to collect the same symptoms at each session, have very few missing data and use a homogeneous prescription dose for most patients. We highlight that all the neurological symptoms collected, except for confusion, experienced by the patients before irradiation were stable over time. This observation is comparable to those reported in the study of Kuntz et al. based on the same population, which showed that WHO grade, DS-GPA and RPA were stable between each session of SRT (article in submission).
First, only grade 1 and 2 confusion was increased at SRT2 compared to SRT1. However, this increase is likely multifactorial. This higher confusion rate can be explained by age, progressive brain disease, corticosteroid therapy, and leukoencephalopathy [31, 32]. Indeed, confusion before SRT1 tends to be more frequent for patients older than 65 years. The occurrence of ≥ grade 1 confusion was 5% for patients aged under 65 years and 13.6% for patients aged 65 years and over (p = 0.17). Chemotherapy-induced cognitive impairment (chemobrain) could also explain this increased confusion from SRT2, although it was not representative in our series [33].
Furthermore, by taking an interest in the neurological status of patients before and after stereotaxis, it is realized that symptoms such as epilepsy, sensorimotor disorders and confusion are less important after treatment. This finding is most likely related to the effect of corticosteroid therapy, which was systematically prescribed during SRT in our center.
Moreover, no patient developed grade 3 or grade 4 acute toxicity, and the incidence of acute toxicity was stable over the course of the SRT sessions. According to the European Association of Neuro-Oncology, multiple courses of SRT for new BMs after an initial course of SRT with avoidance of WBRT could provide a low risk of toxicity [34]. Our acute toxicity results are similar to those reported in the study by Jimenez et al. [19] Indeed, they studied the acute toxicity of SRT among 156 patients treated for a single BM. Twenty-four percent of patients experienced at least one adverse symptom potentially associated with SRT, and the most common symptoms were fatigue and headache. In the final report of RTOG protocol 90–05, toxicity was significantly associated with the maximum GTV diameter, and larger tumors had a greater risk of unacceptable neurotoxicity than smaller tumors [35]. However, in this trial, the patients were reirradiated. The data did not show a correlation between local reirradiation and acute toxicity. Among the 184 patients, 58% received corticosteroid therapy before at least one SRT session because of symptomatic BM. Corticosteroid therapy limits the edema induced by BM [36, 37] and the early edema induced by SRT [38], but it can also increase confusion, especially in elderly patients [39]. Indeed, symptomatic patients tend to be older, have a poorer performance status, and tend to have more numerous and larger BMs.
Finally, we studied the cumulative dose to the brain. The objective was to determine whether repeated SRT sessions could lead to cumulative brain doses equivalent to those of WBRT. SRT is known to cause less cognitive deterioration than WBRT, even for patients treated for up to ten BMs [40–45], but no study has examined the neurocognitive impact of repeated SRT sessions. Hatiboglu et al. simulated different treatment plans by varying tumor volumes, tumor numbers and prescribed doses for patients treated for BMs by SRT [46]. The GTVsum was a good predictor of the mean whole brain dose. We found the same results in the case of repeated SRT sessions, as the BEDmean brain and BEDmean healthy brain and VWBRT were significantly associated with the GTVsum and total number of BMs.
However, progressive BM per se can impact cognitive function. A prospective trial with dedicated neurocognitive tests would be desirable to better evaluate the impact of repeated SRT sessions on cognition and possibly compare repeated SRT to WBRT with hippocampal preservation.