This experiment demonstrates that following ventricular fibrillation at 27 °C (hypothermic cardiac arrest) and 3-h of CPR, O2 delivery and organ blood perfusion were reduced but that ECMO rewarming provided CO, MAP, and O2 delivery to support global aerobic organ metabolism. After rewarming to 38 °C, organ blood flow was unequally restored, but with an apparent preference to essential parts of the brain and heart indicating the patency of autonomic blood flow regulation to support O2 delivery to critical organs. The results of this study also demonstrate that 3-h of continues CPR at 27 °C maintained MAP, CO, and blood flow to the brain, heart, liver, and spleen at the same reduced level, with adequate O2 delivery to enable aerobic metabolism. In this respect, the findings of the present study are consistent with those of a previous study [21].
Resuscitation during hypothermia and normothermia
The results of the present study confirm that after ECMO rewarming, prognostic outcome markers are favourable as compared to survivors of normothermic cardiac arrest [26]. These markers include higher pH, low level of plasma lactate, and a shockable cardiac rhythm. In fact, the low core temperature present in hypothermic cardiac arrest, may provide protective effects that would mitigate the complex pathophysiologic processes created by the actual prolonged low-flow condition. Protective mechanisms created by low temperatures relate to the general slowing of enzymatic activities particularly those that are ATP-dependent. On the other hand, the protective effects of hypothermia may be partly offset by harmful effects created during exposure to low core temperature in the absence of ischemia or hypoxia, which may cause end-organ dysfunction. We previously have documented hypothermia-rewarming induced cardiac dysfunction in both in vivo and in vitro models [20, 27–31]. Underlying pathophysiologic mechanisms include derangement in metabolism and calcium homeostasis [20, 27, 28, 32], elevated protein kinase A levels with increased phosphorylation in myocardial contractile proteins [30, 31, 33], and reactive oxygen species formation [34]. Likewise, after rewarming, we have documented derangements in renal [35] and nervous tissue morphology [36]. Severity of these different pathophysiologic elements are closely related to duration and level of the hypothermic exposure with similarities to what takes place during normothermic low flow ischemia.
Reperfusion
Rewarming from hypothermia and reperfusion after ischemia share the same treatment strategy; to restore blood flow at the macro-vascular level in an attempt to optimize blood flow at the micro-vascular level to minimize end organ dysfunction. However, alterations in micro-vascular function frequently occur in critically ill patients and with clear implications to development of organ failure. Although reperfusion is the ultimate constituent when resuscitating an ischemic or hypoxic organ as during prolonged cardiac arrest, we still have limited knowledge about how the different organs respond to reperfusion. However, all reperfused organs are exposed to complex pathophysiologic processes causing uneven alterations in organ function, collectively termed the post-cardiac arrest syndrome [22]. We still do not understand how different organs respond to reperfusion after prolonged periods of ischemia or limited blood flow, as following hypothermic cardiac arrest. However, considerable variability in metabolic responses in critical organs was recently reported to take place after 30 min of cardiac arrest, as well as after CPB, in an experimental model of cardiac arrest during normothermia [37].
Restitution of organ blood flow after rewarming
In the present experiment ECMO rewarming restored MAP and CO in parallel with a return to well below critical value for extraction ratio (0.6–0.7) [25], return of SvO2, whereas global V̇O2 remained reduced. The reduced global V̇O2 may well be a mirror image of reduced organ function as heterogeneity in the recovery of organ blood flow was evident in most organs investigated.
The brain is the organ most sensitive to ischemic injury and is therefore the limiting organ for survival after cardiac arrest in general [38]. We observe that cerebral O2 delivery and V̇O2 were both significantly reduced in parallel with a reduction in extraction ratio to far below critical levels. Also, if we compare to human data after cardiac arrest, a patent autoregulation of cerebral blood flow after reperfusion is suggested if decreased cerebral blood flow is matched to decreased V̇O2 [39]. Deliberate hypothermic cardiac arrest is used for repair of complex cardiovascular conditions, and for cerebral protection the safe use of cardiac arrest for up to 60 min at 8–13 °C [40–42] has been documented. In the present experiment biomarkers of brain injury disclose no pathological changes as GFAP and UCHL1 (Table 3), both highly selective for CNS injury [24], are within normal control levels in pigs [43].
Myocardial blood flow was normalized after the return of spontaneous electro-mechanic activity despite that external heart work was reduced as global circulation was provided by the ECMO circuit indicating the occurrence of reactive hyperaemia. Biomarkers of cardiac injury, CK-MB and Troponin T, were both within normal levels. The significant increase in ASAT is most probably caused by trauma of the thoracic muscles from the automated compression devise.
Reduced renal blood flow appears to be a consequence of the well-documented physiologic mechanisms that compensates for a sudden drop in MAP and/or CO as during cardiac arrest. The biomarker activin-A, also reported to be increased during acute renal failure, was beyond detection levels in our experiment. Reduced blood flow to the spleen can be observed after circulatory shock secondary to emptying stored erythrocytes into the blood stream as a compensatory mechanism [44]. However, the immediate restoration of blood flow to the small intestine and stomach, while liver blood flow was significantly reduced, is more difficult to interpret.
Adequacy of extracorporeal rewarming for macro- and micro-vessel reperfusion
The recommended treatment for hypothermic cardiac arrest patients is rapid transfer under continuous CPR to a hospital capable of rewarming by use of extracorporeal circulation [7]. The safe use of extracorporeal circulation, routinely applied as CPB during cardiac surgery, is supported by extensive preclinical and clinical research over the past 60 years. This would suggest that extracorporeal circulation/CPB would also be safe for rewarming accidental hypothermia patients. However, a comprehensive preclinical study is lacking. Obvious differences between cardiac surgery patients and accidental hypothermia patients include the way cooling takes place, duration of the hypothermic insult, and patency of O2 transport during the insult, factors that also may warrant different approaches for the use of extracorporeal circulation for rewarming.
Restitution of capillary flow is a key element when rewarming accidental hypothermia patients with extracorporeal circulation. Even after exposure to short-term hypothermia with maintained spontaneous circulation, intravascular erythrocyte aggregation has been reported [45], and other studies have documented that the size of intravascular erythrocyte aggregates during hypothermia was inversely related to blood flow [46]. These changes create a heterogeneous micro-vascular blood flow with perfused capillaries in close vicinity to non-perfused capillaries, which subsequently may cause alterations in tissue O2 transport and hypoxia in organs despite restitution of global O2 transport. In our effort to restitute systemic hemodynamic function, the micro-vascular hemodynamic function may suffer, a fact that underlines the existence of an uncoupling between macro and micro-vascular circulation [47]. Another important factor to compromise capillary integrity during hypothermia with spontaneous circulation is that increased extravasation of plasma from the intravascular to the interstitial space [48, 49] regularly takes place, and this extravasation is substantially increased when applying extracorporeal circulation for rewarming [49]. Extracorporeal circulation has evolved to become the method of choice for rewarming patients with hypothermic cardiac arrest. However, a recent review has documented impaired micro-vascular integrity as a consequence of CPB during cardiac surgery [50]. By use of sublingual micro-circulatory measurements, numerous reports have documented impaired micro-circulatory perfusion with subsequent reduction of functional capillary density, and these changes may last 24 h after CPB [50]. The reduction in functional capillary density after CPB shear great similarities with those taking place during hypothermia with spontaneous circulation mentioned above.
Taken together, this information points at alterations in capillary integrity taking place during accidental hypothermia, most likely due to spontaneous circulation with low CO and perfusion pressure, and the compromised microcirculatory function may be prolonged and even aggravated by adding extracorporeal circulation for rewarming. Therefore, future aim must be to establish a refined extracorporeal circulation system for rewarming, using CPB or ECMO, which has the ability to support micro-vascular integrity rather than prolong micro-vascular dysfunction. Based on promising clinical reports [16] the use of ECMO for rewarming from accidental hypothermia has been recommended as ECMO can also be continued after rewarming for cardio/respiratory support for days, if needed [16, 51].
Limitations. Perhaps as a consequence of using an automated chest compression device designed for human CPR [52], the use in our pig model resulted in multiple costa and sternum fractures in all animals. Furthermore, as a consequence of these fractures, blood congesting in the mediastinum and in pericardium necessitated surgical evacuation to manage cardioversion in three out of eight animals during rewarming. This may well be due to the prolonged 3-h period of CPR, although fatal injuries in human patients have not been documented [53] after conventional CPR using a compression device [54]. To determine organ blood flow, microspheres were injected into the left ventricle during cooling and CPR, but injected directly into a port on the arterial cannula during ECMO rewarming. This may have altered the way microspheres were introduced into the circulation, which may have had impact on blood flow measurements.