Literature Review on Affecting Factors of Poor Clinical Prognosis in Post-MI Patients
Summary results of 21 cohort studies that identified factors affecting the clinical prognosis of post-MI patients are presented (Table 2). Although follow-up subjects in most studies included all age groups, one study included women aged 60–80 years [17] and four studies included patients with ST-elevated MI [18–21]. The follow-up duration after MI was approximately 1 year in 6 studies [21–26] with the longest follow-up period being 13 years [27], followed by 10 years [17, 28] and 8 years [20]. Adverse clinical outcomes as dependent variables were all-cause mortality [17, 19–24, 28–33], cardiovascular mortality [18, 28, 34], recurrent cardiovascular events or HF [2, 18, 21, 26, 27, 29], unplanned readmission [22, 25], and reduced health-related quality of life [35].
Table 2
Long term follow-up cohort study analysis and affecting factors in patients with MI
Authors
(year)
|
Source country
|
Subjects
|
Follow- up year
|
Adverse clinical outcomes (incidence rates)
|
Major affecting factors
|
Koren et al. (2012)27
|
Central Israel,
8 hospitals
|
1,164 first MI
patients
|
13yrs
|
Recurrent MI or angina
(45.6%)
|
Low education, low income, hypertension, diabetes, hypercholesterolemia, smoking, PCI, comorbidity index, Killip class, previous coronary heart disease
|
Kim et al. (2019)22
|
Korea (KAMIR-NIH, nationwide registry)
|
13,104 MI patients
|
1yr
|
Readmission & cardiac or cerebrovascular mortality (10.9%)
|
Age > 70, male, Killip class > 1, previous MI, previous angina, serum creatinine, PCI, PARADOCS (Pressure of ARtery elevAtion, Diabetes, Obesity, Cholesterol, Smoking) score
|
Norekvål et al. (2010)17
|
Norway
1 hospital
|
145 female MI patients(60-80y)
|
10yrs
|
All-cause mortality
(41%)
|
Old age, living alone, serum creatinine,, LVEF < 30%, marital status(divorced/widowed), low perceived health and quality of life
|
Daida et al. (2013)30
|
Japan
(nationwide registry)
|
3,597 ACS patients
|
2yrs
|
All-cause mortality
(6.3%)
|
Female, age ≥ 75, histories of MI, atrial fibrillation and cerebral infarction, hypertension, hyperlipidemia, smoking, eGFR < 60ml/min, Killip class ≥ 2, peripheral arterial disease
|
Alhabib et al. (2019)23
|
Saudi Arabia
(nationwide registry)
|
2,233 ACS patients
|
1yr
|
All-cause mortality (8.1%)
|
Recurrent cardiac ischemia, recurrent MI, atrial fibrillation/flutter, previous stroke
|
Antoni et al. (2012)18
|
Netherlands
1 hospital
|
1,453 STEMI patients
|
4yrs
|
Cardiovascular mortality (4%) Hospitalization for HF (3%)
|
Age ≥ 70, Killip class ≥ 2, diabetes, left anterior descending coronary artery as the culprit vessel, multivessel disease, peak troponin T level ≥ 3.5µg/L, LVEF ≤ 40%
|
Henderson et al. (2015)28
|
England and Scotland (National Statistics)
|
1,810 NonST-ACS patients
|
10yrs
|
All-cause mortality, (25.1%)
Cardiovascular death (15.1%)
|
Age, previous MI, heart failure, smoking status, diabetes, heart rate, and ST-segment depression
|
Steele et al. (2019)19
|
United Kingdom
1 hospital
|
3,133 STEMI patients
|
3yrs
|
Mortality (13.9%)
|
Old age, current smoker, ex-smoker, female, dyslipidemia, diabetes, previous MI, family history of chronic heart disease, chronic kidney disease stage IV or V, peripheral vascular disease
|
Barchielli
et al. (2012)20
|
Italy
(nationwide registry)
|
875 STEMI patients
|
8yrs
|
All-cause mortality (49%)
|
Old age, Killip class > 1, cardiovascular or non-cardiovascular comorbidities, in-hospital cardiogenic shock, LVEF < 30%, treatment with aspirin and statin during hospitalization.
|
Dohi et al. (2015)33
|
United States & Germany
(multicenter registry)
|
8,454 MI patients
|
2yrs
|
Mortality (17.3%)
Recurrence of MI (3.3%)
|
Recurrent MI of unstable anagina, diabetes, current smoker, multi-vessel disease, treatment of an in-stent re-stenotic lesion, low baseline hemoglobin & reduced creatinine clearance, antiplatelet agent factors, no use of statin at discharge.
|
Chiang et al.
(2014)24
|
Taiwan
(multicenter registry)
|
3,080 ACS patients
|
1yr
|
Mortality (22.4%)
|
Dual antiplatelet therapy ≥ 9 months, drug-eluting stents, chronic renal failure, in-hospital bleeding, NSTEMI, and antiplatelet discontinuation
|
Docherty et al. (2020)36
|
United Kingdom
|
13,202 MI patients
|
2yrs
|
Sudden cardiac death (3.3%)
|
Old age, heart rate, smoking, Killip class, LVEF, history of prior atrial fibrillation, MI, HF, diabetes, eGFR
|
Pocock et al.
(2020)29
|
Europe, America, Asia,Australia(Global registry in 25 countries)
|
9,027 MI patients
|
3yrs
|
Mortality (7.2%)
Recurrent cardiovascular events (1.4%)
|
Age ≥ 65 years, diabetes, second prior MI, chronic kidney disease, history of peripheral arterial disease or HF, cardiovascular hospitalization, diuretics, poor self-reported health
|
Munyombwe et al. (2020)35
|
England
(nationwide registry)
|
9,566 Survivors of MI patients
|
4yrs
|
Reduced Health-
related quality of life (HRQoL)
(69.1%)
|
Women, diabetes, previous MI & angina, chronic kidney disease, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, cerebrovascular disease
|
Shah & Keeley (2019)25
|
United States
|
261 MI patients
|
1yr
|
Unplanned readmission (34%)
|
Recurrent MI, decompensated HF, low LVEF; diabetes
|
Carrick et al.
(2018)21
|
United Kingdom
|
324 STEMI patients
|
1yr
|
All-cause mortality or HF(15%)
|
Hypertension, previous MI
|
Lopes et al. (2016)31
|
Global registry in 24 countries
|
14,703 MI patients
|
3yrs
|
Mortality (2.2%)
|
Old age, baseline heart rate, creatinine clearance, new onset diabetes, previous MI
|
Gerber et al.
(2016)32
|
Minnesota in United States
|
2,596 MI patients
|
7.6yrs
|
Mortality(42.9%)
|
Post-MI HF, MI severity, recurrent MI, comorbidity,
|
Jernberg et al. (2015)26
|
Sweden
|
97,254 first MI patients
|
1yr
|
Cardiovascular events
(18.3%)
|
Old age, prior MI, stroke, diabetes, HF, no index MI revascularization
|
Chen et al.
(2017)2
|
Taiwan
|
11,183 Post MI patients
|
3yrs
|
Cardiovascular events
(13.8%)
|
Age, post-MI HF, hypertension, diabetes, prior stroke, chronic kidney disease, arterial fibrillation, underutilization of guideline-based medication
|
Park et al. (2018)34
|
Korea (KAMIR-NIH, nationwide registry)
|
10,455 MI patients
|
3.5yrs
|
All-cause/ cardiac death, MACE, HF (20.5%)
|
Old age(> 60), male, known/ new onset diabetes, low BMI, low LVEF, multi-vessel disease, hypertension, dyslipidemia, prior stroke/angina/MI, renal failure
|
ACS, acute coronary syndrome; ACEi, angiotensin converting enzyme inhibitor; STEMI, ST-segment elevation myocardial infarction; NSTEMI, non ST-segment elevation myocardial infarction; MI, myocardial infarction; ARB, angiotensin receptor blocker; eGFR, estimated glomerular filtration rate; HF, heart failure; KAMIR-NIH, Korea acute myocardial infarction registry-national institute of health; PCI, percutaneous coronary intervention;; and TIMI, thrombolysis in myocardial infarction. LVEF; left ventricular ejection fraction; MACE ; major adverse cardiovascular events |
Older age [2, 17, 18, 20, 22, 26, 28–31, 34, 36] and the recurrence of MI or angina [18, 22–28, 32–36] were the most frequent factors affecting the adverse outcomes of post-MI patients, followed by diabetes prevalence [2, 18, 19, 22, 25–29, 31, 33, 35, 36], high Killip class [18, 20, 22, 27, 31, 36] and LVEF [17, 18, 20, 25, 31]. As prevalent diseases, hypertension [2, 21, 27, 30, 32], chronic kidney disease [2, 24, 29, 33, 35], prior stroke [19, 30, 35] and HF [25, 26, 28, 29], atrial fibrillation [2, 25, 35] and multi-vessel involvement during infarction [19, 36] were also found to be affecting factors. Smoking as a lifestyle factor was identified as a factor that negatively affects the prognosis in several studies [19, 22, 27, 28, 30, 33, 36]. As demographic factors, poor socioeconomic status such as low education level [17, 27] and low income [27], marital status (divorced or widowed) [17], living alone [27] and poor self-reported quality of life [17] or health [29] were identified.
Disease Perception and Self-care Experience in Post-MI Patients Who Progressed to HF
After analyzing the perception of the disease and self-care experience through an in-depth interview with the patients, 6 subthemes emerged and were subsequently grouped into 3 broader themes that encompassed them (Table 3).
Table 3
Disease perception extracted from in-depth interviews with post-MI patients
Themes
|
Sub-themes
|
Statements
|
Exhaustion from endless treatment
|
Initially shocked but soon became oblivious the disease
|
“It was a bit shocking at first. I had an ordinary life just like everyone else, but wow, things that I only saw on TV do really happen to me all of a sudden…. But now, some time has passed, and I’ve become somewhat oblivious...”
|
|
Getting tired from repeated hospitalizations
due to recurrence
|
“I took my meds and went to my hospital appointments just as told by my doctor, but this disease I guess is hard to cure. Recently, I just watch TV all day without anything else to do and am depressed. I’m in so much pain even when I do everything.”
|
Lack of understanding about the
Disease
|
Inadequate self-care despite long term progression
|
“I thought all I have is to quit smoking for AMI…. They tell me to eat my food with less salt, but that’s hard. What’s most important is to take my meds but I forget that often….”
|
Becoming passive in disease management
|
“They told me I need to control my diabetes well so I think I take my prescriptions well but I don’t know why it’s not controlled well. I just eat whatever I want because I’m taking meds. I don’t check my blood sugar.”
|
Desperately seeking help from healthcare providers
|
Difficulty in approaching busy
healthcare providers
|
“Even if I wanted to ask about something, I forget about all that when I meet my doctor. Everyone’s so busy and there are so many patients waiting. I just see the doctor for a few minutes during my appointment, so I just get my medications and come home….”
|
Desire for continuous attention and management from healthcare providers
|
“I think I’m doing well but I don’t know if I’m really doing well because no one monitors me whether I’m doing well or not…”
|
MI, myocardial infarction |
Theme 1. Exhaustion of endless treatment
Initially shocked but soon became oblivious to the disease: The patients were initially shocked by the diagnosis of MI, but forgot the severity of the disease as the symptoms such as chest pain and shortness of breath disappeared and resumed daily activities.
It was a bit shocking at first. I had an ordinary life just like everyone else, but wow, things that I only saw on TV do really happen to me all of a sudden…. But now, some time has passed, and I’ve become somewhat oblivious...But it’s still scary.
Getting tired from repeated hospitalizations due to recurrence: Majority of patients expressed burden with increasing cost, felt sorry to their family, and became tired from repeated readmissions and procedures due to recurrent heart disease during treatment.
I have to take medications every day so I get frustrated. I underwent stenting a couple times already. I feel sorry to my family. I don’t want to do anything because it doesn’t seem like I’m improving.
Theme 2. Lack of understanding about the disease
Inadequate self-care despite long term progression: Patients had a poor understanding about how to manage their disease or had no idea what to specifically do. Some patients expressed that even when they have retrieved information, they are clueless as to how to apply the obtained information to themselves.
I thought all I have is to quit smoking for treatement…. They tell me to eat my food with less salt, but that’s hard. What’s most important is to take my meds but I forget that often. I don’t know how long I have to keep taking medications.
Becoming passive in disease management: While suffering from their condition for a long period, the patients frequently missed their medications, felt annoyed about having to modify their lifestyle, and became passive in disease management. Patients did not have an accurate understanding about MI and thought that they only needed to correctly take the prescribed medications.
They told me I need to control my diabetes well so I think I take my prescriptions well but I don’t know why it’s not controlled well. I just eat whatever I want because I’m taking meds. I don’t check my blood sugar.
Theme 3. Desperately seeking help from healthcare providers
Difficulty in approaching busy healthcare providers: The patients expressed that asking about matters that they had in mind or about their treatment was difficult even when they met with their healthcare providers during their appointments because the they seemed busy with all waiting patients.
Even if I wanted to ask about something, I forget about all that when I meet my doctor. Everyone’s so busy and there are so many patients waiting. I just see the doctor for a few minutes during my appointment, so I just get my medications and come home.
Desire for continuous attention and management from healthcare providers: Most patients desired that their healthcare providers pay close attention to them and take care of them. Additionally, they wanted healthcare providers to monitor whether their self-care is sufficient and whether they are adequately managing their condition.
I’m worried about how I should live from now on. I wish the hospital staff would take care of me better. But I forget on my own and even when I decide to do well, it’s hard to maintain….
Experts’ Perspectives on Factors Affecting the Poor Prognosis of Post-MI Patients
FGIs conducted on a panel of healthcare providers (physicians, nurses) who treated and provided care to MI patients resulted in 11 subthemes, and these subthemes were grouped into 4 themes (Table 4).
Table 4
Perspectives of physicians and nurses on the prognosis of post-MI patients
Themes
|
Sub-themes
|
Statements
|
Patients and situational factors in the acute phase increase the risk of poor prognosis.
|
Irreversible acute-phase situational factors
|
“Failure to manage diabetes and continuation of smoking exacerbate the lesions and increase the chance for a second procedure.” (Physician)
|
Patient's underlying chronic disease
|
“The readmission rate is higher in individuals with uncontrollable diabetes and hypertension. Patients experiencing frequent relapses often progress to HF.” (Nurse )
|
Self-awareness as a chronic condition that must go together for a lifetime needed.
|
Entering a new disease management
|
“In many cases, patients falsely believe that their illness is completely cured after the procedure.” (Physician)
|
Recognition that the
disease can recur at
any time
|
“It’s imperative that patients are aware that it can relapse at any time if they do not engage in self-care after the procedure and that they must manage the condition throughout their lives.” (Nurse)
|
Importance of maintaining healthy behavior after the acute phase
|
Difficulty in self-care compliance
|
“Medication adherence, regulation of risk factors such as smoking cessation, and ensuring that patients don’t miss their hospital appointments determine their prognosis. Nevertheless, these are really difficult for patients to comply with.” (Physician)
|
Meaning of first discharge education from hospital
|
“I believe that properly educating patients after an acute-phase procedure before they are discharged determines their first year.” (Physician )
|
Strategies and educational efforts are needed for lifelong self-care of high risk patient
|
Tailored education on risk factors of patients for behavioral change
|
“Most physicians do educate patients somewhat. However, we need to ensure that patients understand and comply with it with adequate education using learning materials, but we actually don’t have much time for that.” (Physician)
|
Importance of cardiovascular nurses for continuous monitoring
|
“Even if the patient does not see the doctor often, it can be changed positively if the outpatient nurse keeps track of progress and monitors changes in condition along with training on lifestyle modification.” (Nurse)
|
MI, myocardial infarction |
Theme 1. Patients and situational factors in the acute phase increase the risk of poor prognosis Uncorrectable acute-phase situational factors and the patient's underlying chronic disease influence prognosis: Physicians and nurses said the timing of coronary ischemia, the time of arrival at the hospital, and the patient's health status, with or without appropriate treatment, are unavoidable factors that determine the outcome and prognosis of treatment. They also said that older post-MI patients have chronic conditions such as diabetes or high blood pressure, and if these conditions are not effectively controlled, relapses can lead to repeated hospitalizations, which can eventually lead to HF.
In the acute phase, how quickly the patient comes to the hospital and what vessels are involved are extremely critical.”, “The readmission rate is higher in individuals with uncontrollable diabetes and hypertension. Patients experiencing frequent relapses often progress to HF.
Theme 2. Self-awareness as a chronic condition that must go together for a lifetime needed
Recognition of entering a new disease management: Physicians and nurses believed that MI is an entry to a new disease that must be managed with medications throughout one’s lifetime. In particular, it is important for patients to have self-awareness that it is a disease that requires lifelong treatment rather than ending with acute treatment.
“With advances in medical technology, patients stay in the hospital for a shorter period of time. This makes them think that this is a manageable and their treatment is now over, but it’s important to instill that heart diseases must be managed as chronic conditions.” (Physician)
Theme 3. Importance of maintaining healthy behavior after acute phase
Difficulty in self-care compliance: They thought that the degree to which patients modify their lifestyle after treatment beyond simply not missing any medications and hospital appointments is important.
“Compliance with medication and lifestyle management such as smoking cessation has an impact from 1 year after the acute phase.” (Physician)
Meaning of first discharge education from hospital: They thought that the discharge education provided to patients after MI treatment is crucial and that the patients’ acquisition of a correct perception about their disease and the implementation of necessary measures in their lifestyle during this period are important predictors of long-term prognosis.
“I believe that properly educating patients after an acute-phase procedure before they are discharged determines their first year.” (Physician)
Theme 4. Strategies and educational efforts are needed for lifelong self-care of high risk patients
Physicians said that all they had to do was check the symptoms and prescribe medication because the waiting list was long and the treatment time was short due to the unrealistic medical bills in Korea. So, it is impossible to monitor the patient's medication compliance or lifestyle. However, both nurses and doctors agreed that the following strategic efforts based on close interaction with patients are needed to improve the patient's prognosis.
Tailored education on risk factors of patients for behavioral change: Physicians and nurses agreed that an education and counseling through which they can provide patients with immediate feedback and promote active patient participation is necessary.
“People have different risk factors. Thus, it’s important that when providing individual education, the patient’s risk factors must be identified first and emphasized in the education.” “An environment (time, space, medical fee) where healthcare providers can provide adequate education needs to be fostered.”(Nurse)
Importance of cardiovascular nurses for continuous monitoring: Nurses and physicians agreed that in-hospital professional cardiovascular care nurse intervention is essential to help improve medication and lifestyle modification in post-MI patients, particularly those with poor prognostic factors.
“Due to the short time with the physician in outpatient care, patients have a hard time asking questions that they had. If an outpatient cardiovascular nurse is designated, they can meet with patients before and after they meet with the doctor, and it would have a positive impact on patients’ prognosis.” (Nurse)