This report describes the use of third-generation methods in a patient that presented with clinical characteristics consistent with CD19-deficiency. We used nanopore sequencing to perform rapid low-cost whole-gene analysis and identified a homozygous frameshift mutation, c.622del (p.Ser208Profs*19), establishing a precise molecular diagnosis. The data processing pipeline we established was integrated with our standard variant annotation tools, enabling identified variants to be rapidly interpreted. Targeted genetic assays may therefore be more appropriate for patients presenting with well-defined clinical symptoms, or in whom prior investigations have revealed pathognomonic features, indicative of the underlying molecular lesion. Moreover, this experience highlights how nanopore sequencing could also be deployed as an orthogonal technology for the verification of sequence variants initially identified by short-read sequencing.
To date, as few as 10 CD19-deficient cases have been reported in the medical literature 16. In agreement with the other cases, the patient described herein presented with hypogammaglobulinaemia and a history of recurrent infections. Previous investigations have attributed antibody deficiency to reduced activation following antigenic stimulation, focussing on the role of CD19 in the regulation of BCR signalling thresholds. B cells from Cd19−/− mice also respond poorly to mitogenic signals but can still differentiate and class switch when additional signals are provided 38. Similarly, we found that CD19-deficient human B cells are capable of generating fully mature plasma cells that secrete IgG using in vitro conditions optimised to promote maturation and viability.
During the transition to becoming plasma cells, the responding B cells use conserved signalling pathways to integrate external information, which has the potential to impact on the differentiation process. This may be due to collaboration between surface receptors and modulation of signal strength and timing.
CXCR4 is a chemokine receptor present on a multitude of cell types, often mediating cell movement to specific niches crucial for further development and prolonged survival. Indeed, B cells utilise the CXCR4/CXCL12 axis to migrate between the light zones and dark zones of germinal centers 39 and subsequently antibody secreting cells use CXCR4/CXCL12 to migrate towards survival niches within the bone marrow to support long-term immunity 40–43. CXCR4 signalling can also promote survival, adhesion or proliferation and its expression and downstream signalling capabilities can be modulated by co-receptors present on the cell surface 44, 45.
In B cells there is evidence that CXCR4 works in concert with CD19 13 and the IgD-BCR 10. However, unlike B cells that express surface IgD, antibody secreting cells are fully capable of transmitting CXCR4 signals without the requirement for surface immunoglobulin. As CD19 acts as a central hub for relaying the downstream signal, we postulated that plasmablasts and plasma cells may continue to utilise CD19 in this capacity. In keeping with this idea, antibody secreting cells from the CD19-deficient patient displayed reduced activation of both PI3K and MAPK pathways. This was particularly evident in mature plasma cells.
As B cells transition to the plasma cell stage, the cells undergo extensive reprogramming to reach a non-dividing, antibody secreting phenotype and with this, the function of CXCR4 and CD19 adapt accordingly. We have shown that AKT and ERK signalling downstream of CXCR4 is generally enhanced as the cells terminally differentiate and also more dependent on the presence of CD19. Given that plasmablasts and plasma cells exhibit distinct differences in cell cycle status, longevity and location in vivo, it is reasonable to suggest that they are potentially wired differently for downstream signalling events.
CD19 down-regulation is consistently observed in a fraction of normal plasma cells and may relate to longevity 23, 24, 46. However, very few differences in gene expression have been detected between CD19 + and CD19- fractions and long-term protective immunity has been documented from both types of cells 47, 48. Our data suggests that CD19 on plasma cells does indeed have the potential to function as a signalling element in this terminally differentiated effector population. In plasma cells, a shift in the amplitude and timing of CXCR4 and CD19 signals could lead to acute or transient changes in gene expression profiles, metabolic activity and functional behaviour.
In summary, identification of a CD19-deficient patient enabled the exploration of CD19 function in late stages of B cell differentiation, providing evidence to support a role for CD19 as a key response regulator throughout B cell ontogeny. Thus, the hypogammaglobulinemia observed in CD19-deficient individuals is likely to reflect not only changes in early activation events but also the impact of diminished signalling competence to a range of ligands required to sustain humoral immunity.