Survey
In this study, a total of 418 leaf samples were collected to investigate the presence of viruses during the survey (Table 2). Potato plants exhibited a wide range of symptoms like yellowing, stunting, leaf deformation, necrotic spots on the leaves (Fig. 1).
Total RNA extractions and RT- PCR were done to determine the presence of potato viruses (PVY, PLRV, PVX, and PVS). According to RT-PCR results, a total of 220 leaf samples were determined to be infected with one or more viruses. The rates of viruses were 47.12%, 16.74%, 5.98%, 5.26% for PVY, PVS, PVX, PLRV, respectively (Table 2). The incidences of viruses according to the district are shown in Table 2. PVY and PVS were the most common potato viruses in the surveyed potato plantations in Tokat province.
Table 2
The occurrence rates of detected viruses.
District
|
Number of
collected samples
|
Number of
infected samples
|
Infected samples and rates (%)
|
PVY
|
PVS
|
PVX
|
PLRV
|
Center
|
116
|
64
|
63
|
1
|
-
|
-
|
Niksar
|
92
|
47
|
38
|
8
|
-
|
1
|
Erbaa
|
101
|
14
|
14
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
Başçiftlik
|
65
|
60
|
52
|
47
|
3
|
18
|
Artova
|
44
|
35
|
30
|
14
|
22
|
3
|
Toplam
|
418
|
220
|
197
|
70
|
25
|
22
|
Double infections with PVY + PVS, PVY + PVX, PVY + PLRV, PVS + PVX, and PVS + PLRV were detected as 6.9, 2.39, 2.15, 0.23, 0.47 and 1.19%, respectively (Table 3). Triple infections of PVY + PVS + PVX and PVY + PVS + PLRV were determined as 2.39% for both. The 3 samples were detected with mixed infection of four viruses (PVY + PVS + PVX + PLRV) tested.
Table 3
The number of mixed virus infections
District
|
Number of
collected samples
|
Number of
infected samples
|
Infected samples and rates (%)
|
PVY + PVS
|
PVY + PVX
|
PVY + PLRV
|
PVS + PVX
|
PVS + PLRV
|
PVY + PVS + PVX
|
PVY + PVS + PLRV
|
PVY + PVS + PVX + PLRV
|
Center
|
116
|
64
|
1(0.86)
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
Niksar
|
92
|
47
|
1(1.08)
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
Erbaa
|
101
|
14
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
Başçiftlik
|
65
|
60
|
25(38.46)
|
-
|
1(1.53)
|
-
|
5(7.69)
|
1(1.53)
|
10(15.38)
|
2(3.07)
|
Artova
|
44
|
35
|
2(4.54)
|
9(20.45)
|
|
2(4.54)
|
-
|
9(20.45)
|
-
|
1(2.27)
|
Total
|
418
|
220
|
29(6.93)
|
9(2.15)
|
1(0.23)
|
2(0.47)
|
5(1.19)
|
10(2.39)
|
10(2.39)
|
3(0.71)
|
Phylogenetic analyses
To determine the evolutionary relationship of viruses, three samples for each of PVY and PVX, eight for PVS, seven for PLRV were selected. The RT-PCR products of selected isolates were sequenced bidirectionally using the specific primers.
Sequence data belonging to 3 Turkish PVY isolates were obtained and submitted to GenBank under the accession numbers: MW699160 (PM1-6), MW699161 (PA1-1), MW699162 (PE2-6). According to nucleotide sequence analysis, 2 PVY isolates showed 99% nucleotide similarity with isolates from Poland, Germany, and the United States, and the remaining isolate showed 99% similarity with isolates from India, the United Kingdom (UK), and China isolates. The phylogenetic tree based on the partial sequences of the P1 gene of Turkish PVY isolates and 12 reference isolates derived from GenBank represented different groups (Figure. 2). Two PVY isolates were clustered with Group PVYN−WI, and one isolate clustered with PVYNNTN isolates.
The sequences analysis was performed based on the CP gene of eight Turkish PVS isolates. The nucleotide sequences of PVS isolates were compared with reference PVS isolates derived from GenBank. Eight Turkish PVS isolates were submitted to GenBank under the accession numbers: MW699152 (PA3-2), MW699153 (PB5-4), MW699154 (PB6-2), MW699155 (PB7-1), MW699156 (PN3-6), MW699157 (PA3-3), MW699158 (PN5-2), MW699159 (PN14-3). PVS isolates were grouped into two major clusters, one of which included PVS ordinary strains (PVSO), and the other contained PVS Andean strains (PVSA). All Turkish PVS isolates were grouped into the PVSO cluster (Fig. 3). Four isolates (PA3-3, PN3-6, PN5-2, PN14-3) obtained in this study were clustered with Yunnan isolate from China and Sam-24 isolates from the UK. Scotland and other strains (PB71-1, PB5-4, PA3-2, PB6-2) were grouped with Irena, Valery, and Alex isolates from Ukraine and Sam-13-O7 isolate from the UK. In genetically defined PVSO, the nucleotide identity ranged from 92.6 to 100%. Cox and Jones (2010) reported that all PVSO isolates could be classified into seven subclusters and the PVSA into three groups. In our study, PVS isolates were separated into three subclusters (Fig. 3).
The accession numbers of three Turkish PVX isolates were MW699163 (PA1-5), MW699164 (PA3-3), MW699165 (PB7-6). The PVX isolates are clustered into two groups as reported before by Santa Cruz and Baulcombe [29]. Group 1 consisted of isolates from the UK, Asia, and Europe, whereas Group 2 consisted of isolates from the USA. Turkish PVX isolates were grouped into Group I and type X (Fig. 4). Two PVX isolates showed 98% nucleotide similarity with isolates from the UK, and China, and one isolate (PA1-5) showed 98% similarity with the UK, Colombian isolates. Santa Cruz and Baulcombe [29] reported that the distinction between type B and type X coat proteins correlated with the ability or inability, respectively, of the different strains to overcome Nx-mediated resistance.
The accession numbers of seven Turkish PLRV isolates were MW699145 (PA3-4), MW699146 (PA4-4), MW699147 (PA4-10), MW699148 (PB2-1), MW699149, (PB4-2), MW699150 (PB5-1), MW699151 (PB5-9). A comparison of CP region sequences of PLRV isolates showed that Turkish PLRV isolates shared 97–100% nucleotide identity. The phylogenetic analysis was based upon the partial sequences the of CP gene of Turkish PLRV isolates and 15 reference isolates from GenBank represented different groups (Fig. 5). The Turkish isolates were divided into two major groups in the phylogenetic tree. Six isolates obtained from this study were grouped into Group 1 and one isolate was clustered into Group 2. In Group 1, the isolates were divided into three subgroups. Six isolates showed high homology with the isolates from China, Bangladesh, Iran, India, and one isolate (PB5-1) was grouped with Ireland and Colombia isolates. PB2-1 isolate showed 100% similarity with the isolates from Saudi Arabia (KC875235) and China (KR051194). The four isolates (PA3-4, PA4-4, PB4-2, PB4-10) showed 99% similarity with Bangladesh and Chinese isolates and grouped (Fig. 5).