Policy Discourse: Shifting the burden of healthcare from state to market in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia

doi:10.21203/rs.3.rs-150963/v1

Download PDF

Research Article

Policy Discourse: Shifting the burden of healthcare from state to market in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia

https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-150963/v1

This work is licensed under a CC BY 4.0 License

Version 1

posted

You are reading this latest preprint version

Saudi Arabia has modified from a predominantly free, public and comprehensive system under a welfare model to more of a mixed-economy model of healthcare. The welfare state slowly moved to a liberal model, emphasising market forces to dominate, and the private sector was trusted to provide better provision of healthcare. The country has confronting enormous problems in the health sector due to population growth, lifestyle changes, shift of disease pattern, elevated expectations, escalated healthcare costs, limited infrastructure and resources, and poor management practice in the provision of healthcare. Moreover, the government has been emphasizing on the need to bring in private sector investment to improve quality and efficiency, development of manpower, and standardization of services. As the current pattern of healthcare is unsustainable, the country is planning to restructure the present healthcare system towards institutionalizing it to meet the future challenges. The governments must make an appropriate amount of effort to build its healthcare systems by transforming and modifying the challenges faced by the society and its political-economic systems. The government should encourage equity, and fairness in the provision of healthcare.

Other Public Policy

Healthcare

State

Market

Private and Public Sectors

Economy

Saudi Arabia.

Internationally, many countries have shifted from a predominantly free, public and comprehensive system under a welfare model to more of a mixed-economy model of healthcare and further advanced to a liberal model emphasizing on market forces to dominate where the private sector was trusted for development [1]. This shift is not due to government policy alone and can be attributed to a variety of national and international attributes. The oil-rich Gulf Cooperative council (GCC) countries [Bahrain, Kuwait, Oman, Qatar, Saudi Arabia and United Arab Emirates (UAE)] embraced a public sector welfare system financed by its oil economy. Most of these countries included health in their constitution as a basic right. Government facilities provided free services to patients [2]. For example, Saudi Arabia established its public health system and the Ministry of Health (MOH) in 1925 and 1949, correspondingly, to dispense unrestricted healthcare to its population [3, 4] and accepted the primary healthcare approach [5]. Similar policy was accepted by other GCC countries. Kuwait and United Arab Emirates established a comprehensive public health system in 1950 based on the principle of generous welfare system and catered free healthcare services to all citizens [2]. Oman also established free services for its population. Discovery of oil and subsequent social and economic plans promoted to develop public healthcare system [2]. The development of healthcare in these countries is impressive and their governments have done a lot to improve the health status of the populations [6].

This article focuses on the factors that have promoted in shifting the burden of the state to market forces and allow the private healthcare sector to grow in Saudi Arabia. The author followed the political economy approach to analyse private sector growth fostered by allowing the market to play a prominent role [7, 8]. This approach helps shed light on connections between the political and economic means of advancement [9]. The current article examines the enhancement of private sector healthcare not only within the healthcare context, but also within the wider social, economic, international, and political contexts of Saudi Arabia.

Inclusion and exclusion criteria

The current study’s initial search strategy helped find 967 articles. This was followed by scanning and screening of 23 peer-reviewed journal articles and other documents. The literature search was carried out between May 2019 and December 2019 and the collected literature was analysed. The review involved two stages: the author first conducted an extensive search of the existing literature, and then screened it in terms of its relevance to issues of private sector healthcare growth and development. During the review process, efforts were made to synthesize relevant material to gain a comprehensive understanding of the various challenges and issues.

Figure 1: Scoping literature review to determine appropriate articles for review

Search strategy

Scoping literature review is used in find the appropriate articles for the study [10]. This study is based on literature and documents published in English and made available in Google, Google Scholar, PubMed Central, Web of Science, Current Contents and Directory of Open Access Journals. The Boolean operators AND, OR and NOT were used in synthesizing the search. Relevant keywords such as “Saudi Arabia” “health” “healthcare” “health sector” “state” “policy” “market” “liberal” “reform” “private sector” “development” and “quality” “{state” AND “healthcare”} {“health” AND “development”} {“market” and “private sector” NOT “public sector”} were used in the search. The search helped to find relevant documents; including journal articles, government reports, policy and planning documents of Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. In addition, available secondary non-government documents were minutely reviewed.

Data extraction and composition

Before complete revival of the full version of the selected texts, the author screened prospective abstracts based on the precise information. Descriptive design and analytical methods were used to complete the study. Thematic data analysis techniques were used, which involves finding informative segments in the text, rearranging them, and finally reducing them to interpretive truth through focused reading and re-reading of the text as well as coding and category development [11, 12]. It helped to identify, analyze and report patterns (themes) within data [13, 14]. The study provides authentic and valid results, where the researcher maintained high levels of objectivity and sensitivity [11].

Saudi Arabia has delivered comprehensive and universal access to healthcare for many decades to its entire population, including non-nationals, without external aid or collection of taxes due to the country’s welfare state model of governance enabled by oil revenues [4, 15]. However, this has also brought about its own set of challenges including increasing costs of healthcare, dip in oil revenues, changes in the country’s demographics, changing lifestyles and disease patterns, and lack of management in the delivery of healthcare services [16, 17]. Moreover, provision of healthcare services to the expatriate community that comprises almost a third of the country’s population has also posed an issue. To tackle these, the Saudi government has been pushing through reforms to provide the best health services at affordable costs while meeting the changing needs of its growing population [18].

Government Policy

In 1999, the government invited the private health sector to contribute citing the need to improve availability and establish parity with international medical advances [4]. This led to the establishment of New Saudi Health System (NSHS). Under NSHS, insurance companies, both local and foreign, were given permission to deal with expatriates and Saudi nationals who work in the private sector. “Health insurance companies act as a buffer between healthcare service providers and patients or their employers” [4]. Health insurance is also seen as a solution for greater access to healthcare [19].

Private health insurance in Saudi Arabia was founded through the enactment of Labour Law in 1999. This legislation allowed private healthcare providers to enter the healthcare market [19], while making it compulsory for both expatriates and Saudi employees to be insured by their private employers for health insurance [20]. The Compulsory Employment Based Health Insurance (CEBHI) was recommended by the Cooperative Health Insurance Act of 2003 [21, 22]. This has helped lift the burden off the public health system to a large extent. While insurance companies are flourishing, private hospitals are mushrooming and generating more income from the outflow of private patients. This is evidenced by the sector’s growth from SAR14.61 billion [1US$=3.75 SAR] in 2009 to SAR21.104 billion in 2012, marking a compounded annual growth rate of 13.04% [23]. As of December 2018, there were 35 operational insurance companies providing coverage to 11 million beneficiaries for provision of healthcare from the private sector [24, 25].

Leadership plays a contributory role in shifting the burden from state to market in the policy process. A turning point in the nation’s development trajectory was the year 2016, when the new leader laid out a visionary outlook to uplift the nation from its traditional way of thinking and modernize its people by establishing a new economic system of self-reliance away from oil-dependence [26]. Following the declaration of Vision 2030 and National Transformation Plan (NTP) of 2020, the leadership reaffirmed the role of the private sector’s in meeting healthcare demands from a growing population by encouraging its involvement [27]. The Crown Prince advocated reforms in the rentier welfare state such as privatizing state assets and withdrawing subsidies [26]. Moreover, the King, Ministers, Shura Council memebers and other important functionaries underlined the importance of the private sector in reliasizing the Vision of 2030, which is expected to contribute to economic growth and sustainable development [28, 29]. The government wanted to break the cyclical nature of its expenditure pattern and overcome ‘oil addiction’ to build a self-reliant economy. The government believes a self-reliant economy would encourage its private healthcare sector to flourish along a path of accountability, transparency, communication and public engagement. Vision 2030 highlights the role of the private sector as an engine for social and economic reforms to transform its economy towards multi-dimensional growth with improved competitiveness [30]. It also emphasizes on fostering private investment in sectors previously funded by the government [30]. Besides, it expects the private sector to contribute to sustainable development by connecting the public and private sectors. This connection will help improve the levels of care, increase patient satisfaction, and reduce financial risks in the public sector [28].

Around the world, governments are looking for means to strike a balance between rising healthcare costs and dipping government budgets [31]. Pushing for a greater role for the private healthcare sector based on its perceived flexibility, managerial capacities and entrepreneurship [2, 16], Saudi Arabia, offered incentives to private investors in the form of tax credits and other benefits [32]. While Saudi Arabia’s public healthcare system is financed by oil revenues, expenditures on private sector healthcare are borne through a combination of employee insurance and out-of-pocket payments [16]. It is expected that Public Private Partnership model will help to unlock greater value in the healthcare system and allow private sector contribution to total healthcare spending. A market-based healthcare system is seen to be more beneficial for the Saudi economy, and international entrepreneurs and healthcare providers. It enables entrepreneurs to access investment and venture into the largest healthcare market in the region. This liberalization will lead to provision of quality healthcare for both Saudi [33] and foreign nationals, giving a boost to medical tourism as well. While provision of basic health services will be fulfilled by the government, the Ministry of Health will gradually shift towards a largely policymaking and regulatory role. The ministry is expected to establish standards for affordable, quality and appropriate care [28].

The government also plans to privatize all public hospitals and build public-private partnerships. At present, the public sector contributes to 80% of the total bed capacity, which is expected to increase to 73,768 beds in 2020. Meanwhile, the private sector is expected to add 26,000 beds by 2020. It was reported that a private group of investors is building eight 130-bedded hospitals, 60 out-patient clinics, and other necessary amenities in a medical village in Riyadh. On its part, the government is constructing 36 new hospitals with 8,950 beds, and two medical cities. Moreover, the government plans to build another 18 hospitals, adding 9,904 beds over the next two years. In April 2018, Saudi Arabia announced an ambitious privatization plan involving 14 PPPs investments to be completed across 10 sectors, including healthcare, by 2020. In July 2018, the government signed an agreement with the private sector for a SAR407 million-loan to establish hospitals and medical facilities to fulfil the objectives of Vision 2030 [34].

Economic Factors

Constant fluctuations in oil price in the international market have posed a challenge to most oil-reliant gulf economies. Heavily dependent on oil revenues since the 1970s, Saudi Arabia’s oil revenue comprises about 80% of the government’s total earnings [35]. This resulted to minimise subsidies and limited spending in different sectors of its governance [35].The country’s oil exports account for about 88% of all export earnings and the sector accounts for about 35% of Saudi Arabia’s GDP [36]. Private investors were recently asked to expand their roles in the health, education and tourism sectors as well [37].

As of 2019, Saudi Arabia’s GDP per capita stood at US$20,912, while its rate of inflation was 2.46%. Though GDP grew at 0.33%, the country’s public debt stood at 18.98% of GDP. Saudi Arabia is one of the largest economies in the region with a national budget of SAR1020 billion (US$272 billion) as of 2020 [38]. Yet, the country faced a budget deficit of SAR367 billion in 2015 and SAR297 billion in 2016, SAR174 in 2018 and SAR187 billion in 2020 [38].

Saudi Arabia’s healthcare expenditure was approximately US$35.4 billion in 2014 and increased to US$46.66 billion in 2020 [38]. The country aims to attain a balanced budget by 2020. To stabilize its economy in this direction, the government withdrew welfare benefits and subsidies from different sectors, while also warning its people about more radical changes in the offing, including reduction in government spending and plans to stimulate increased efficiency, fiscal discipline, and non-oil revenues [17, 26, 39, 40]. The budget deficits of GDP amounted to 2% in 2014, 15% in 2015, 17.3% in 2016 and 6.4% in 2020 [38]. Saudi Arabia experienced 22 budget deficit years in the range of 2-25% between 1998 and 2017. In the same time period, there were 13 fiscal years with budget surpluses between 1% and 32% [40]. Besides, the government introduced a value added tax to tackle the fiscal deficit [41]. The political instability in the region also adversely affected Saudi Arabia’s financial stability. The current war with Yemen and proxy war threat from Iran pursue Saudi Arabia’s government to invest in war equipment and ammunition for protection. The defence budget of the government is SAR242 billion compare to SAR174 billion for health and social development in 2020 [38]. Unable to maintain sustainable budgets and tackle economic uncertainties, the government shifted a part of the burden of managing the country’s health system on to the consumers [16]. Policy that was subsequently made favoured the shifting burden to the market from the state.

The ability and desire of Saudi nationals to pay for healthcare are contributing factors in the development of the private sector in healthcare [42]. Statistics available currently show that total government expenditures increased from US$1.6 billion in 1970 to US$158.9 billion in 2010 and US$287 billion in 2020 to meet the demands of a growing population and their rising standards of living [36, 38]. People are increasingly dependent on the private sector for their healthcare needs due to demands driven by accessibility and essential parameters such as better life expectancy, population growth and patients’ need for treatment [18]. Private hospitals are equipped with necessary instruments, and have medical and administrative personnel who facilitate quality and timely healthcare. Moreover, patients find it easier to book an appointment for a time of their convenience at a private clinic or hopsital [43]. A study revealed that 52.2% citizens of the country preferred paying a mandatory health insurance fee on a monthly basis, while 62% citizens felt health insurance will help reduce the current load on the public sector [44]. As much as 75% of the patients use private healthcare [45], contributing to reduce burden on the state.

Social Factors

Saudi Arabia has a population of more than 34.4 million. The country’s life expectancy is expected to increase to 75.2 in 2020 [46]. That portion of the population aged between 40 and 59 years is expected to increase 1.5 times and over the age of 60 is forecast to increase more than 3 times. With 44% of its population over the age of 40 and 14% over the age of 60 in 2035, there will be huge demand for healthcare to deal with lifestyle and NCDs [24]. With NCDs expected to account for 73% of all deaths by 2025 [47], WHO has indicated that this trend will trigger a renewed demand for specialized medical and surgical care in the country [48] which will possible meet by the non-state resources.

Beyond existing human resources, the government needs additional 13,700 doctors by 2030 [49]. To meet the needs of its growing population, the country will need 5,000 more beds by 2020 and 20,000 beds by 2035. As of 2016, Saudi Arabia faced a shortfall of 14,000 beds in 2016 based on the global average for bed density. This figure is expected to rise to 40,000 by 2035 [24]. On the other hand, the government will face difficulty in providing access to efficient and quality healthcare for all residents even if it is successful in financing healthcare through privatization and public private partnerships [50]. It is suggested that the government should accelerate the shift from its current government-led economic model to a more market-based approach [51] which will be filled by private sector.

Saudi Arabia has one of the highest prevalence rates for non-communicable diseases (NCDs). With increased awareness about public healthcare services, consumers are now demanding better effectiveness, improved quality of services, advanced hospital management systems, enhanced organizational factors, provision of adequate levels of evidence-based medicine, and expansion of professional development strategies for secondary care [32]. The public sector is currently confronting the twin challenges of high prevalence of NCDs and renewed public demand for better care. This lead to demand of care moved to market forces where private sector currently caters to health needs brought about by lifestyle diseases [52].

The socio-political and economic-administrative factors shape the health system of a country [53]. In Saudi Arabia, the government has been influencing various ways and means to shift the burden to market forces, due to prioritisation of effectiveness, efficiency, and rationality of choice [16]. Moreover, successive budget deficit, fluctuation and turmoil of oil prices, corona pandemic together with looming economic uncertainties, the government focused on shifting some of the burden to the consumers. This contributes to inequity, limited access, and disparity in overall distribution of healthcare services [16]. If the market plays a dominant role, it establishes state-of-art technologies and equipment and the consumer will bear the burden of increased cost of healthcare and public healthcare will be left over to the state to provide services. Currently, public sector healthcare pronounces that it will engage with only policy planning, regulation and provide only public health aspect of healthcare services [27] which means the state wants most of the burden on the market. This shift of healthcare does not provide positive benefits to consumers [54, 55].

Increased use of private healthcare facilities is linked to consumer dissatisfaction, various constraints and poor management practice with the public sector [18, 56, 57]. A study in Taif found that 77% of patients who sought treatment at private healthcare facilities were satisfied with the level of care, whereas it was only 59% in the public sector [58]. The private sector in Saudi Arabia has been engaged in a range of activities related to direct provision of healthcare services, administration and management of healthcare facilities, manufacturing of healthcare products and financing of the healthcare systems [59]. These are carried out by various non-state actors; including national and multinational companies, non-governmental organizations, non-profit entities and private individuals working as a general practitioners and consultants in the provision of healthcare services [18]. There seems to be an increasing reliance on private actors to provide finance, and supply of healthcare goods and services. The private sector is preferred due to management inefficiency of the public sector [60], consumer dissatisfaction with public sector services [61], organizational behaviour of private sector [62], improved performance in terms of access [63], better drug supply and responsiveness [64], greater patient satisfaction or competence [65] as well as user friendliness [64].

However, complaints are several about the many inadequacies of the private sector; including poor infrastructure without registration [66], poor quality of equipment [67, 68], lack of qualified personnel [68], poor service conditions [66], higher treatment costs [69], wrong diagnosis of diseases, commission-based services, over-servicing, excessive prescription of drugs and tests [70], overuse of technology [71], fee-splitting, profit motivation, negligence in patient care, poor quality and standards [54, 65], lack of business ethics, dearth of accountability [72] and overall deficiency in the expected service quality [55, 73]. In global context, evidence on the relative effectiveness, efficiency and overall advantages of private sector healthcare has been largely inconclusive with no study bringing in clear findings in support of or against increased private sector participation [42, 55]. Therefore, there is no consistent manner in which one can measure the value of the private sector’s contribution to the provision of healthcare [42, 74]. Overall, studies have found that the Saudi healthcare system is suffering from issues rising due to long waiting periods, shortage of required human resources, medical errors, poor communication between physician and patent, and deteriorating services [75, 76]. A study revealed that in 2009, there were 1,510 cases reported medical errors which increased to 2,002 in 2012. Most cases, i.e. 163 out of 356 cases, were in the public sector [77]. A survey of both public and private hospitals indicates that about 70% of hospitals do not have medication safety committees and 90% of studied hospitals do not have medication safety officers [78]. Medical errors are common in both public and private hospitals [79]. It is found that multiple factors impede the quality of care being provided by health professionals [80]. Cooperative Health Council announced a decree to overcome problems with quality and medical error in the provision of healthcare services [81]

Driven by several social and economic factors, the Saudi Arabian government has taken persistent efforts to develop its private healthcare system. These factors include economic reforms, public-private partnerships, the rising middle class and its demand for better health, challenges faced by the public sector as well as macroeconomic stability and liberalization. Though successive regimes continued to implement policy that boosted private sector growth, several inadequacies have been identified within the private sector healthcare. Besides failing to bring about equity, cost-effectiveness and accountability in its provision of services, the private healthcare sector has also seen more frequent violations of medical standards of practice and poorer patient outcome [42]. The public sector has an important role to play in financing and delivering universal health coverage. The government should, therefore, bring about reforms in administration, management, governance and stewardship such that quality healthcare can be provided to all. Growth of the private health sector is not the panacea for sub-optimal healthcare services in Saudi Arabia. On the other hand, it contributes to increased costs, widened inequity and overall consumer dissatisfaction. It is pertinent that the government intervenes in a timely manner to mitigate the detrimental effects of this growth. However, inadequacies within the public sector in terms of delivery of quality services, patient safety and clinical effectiveness can be mitigated only by actions stemming from strong political will [59, 82, 83].

POLICY RECOMMENDATIONS

Thanks to limited partnerships, insufficient structures and processes, lacking political commitment and inadequate resources, the improvement of healthcare quality, performance management and accreditation have not yet been fully institutionalized in Saudi Arabia [84]. The government should try to tackle new challenges in socio-political, economic, financial and cultural fields to build a better and efficient healthcare system that protects the values of equity and fairness in the dispensation of services. The leadership may face problems in different sectors of the economy, but MOH must continue playing its role in the health sector’s development in coordination with other government ministries; agencies and stakeholders; including academia, professional associations, the private sector and civil society organizations. In socio-economic development context, healthcare must be placed at the centre of all development though the private sector assumes a greater role in financing and delivering healthcare services [85]. However, care should be taken to ensure that such development initiatives are implemented under strong leadership and good governance [2]. The government should emphasise qualitative improvement of the system to improve equity, access and to minimise disparity through structural and financial reforms of the system. Studies suggested that commercialization of healthcare failed to improve the performance of the healthcare system. Moreover, the preference of private sector over the public sector healthcare may not be the answer for the growing difficulties confronting public sector healthcare services[55].

Conflict of interest: The authors declare no conflict of interest

Funding: No

Ethics approval

Not applicable

[1] D. Swank, "Globalisation, domestic politics, and welfare state retrenchment in capitalist democracies," Soc Pol Soc, vol. 4, pp. 183–195, 2005.

[2] N. M. Kronfol, "Historical development of health systems in the Arab countries: a review," Eastern Mediterranean Health Journal, vol. 18, no. 11, pp. 1151-1156, 2012.

[3] Z. A. Sebai, W. A. Milaat, and A. A. Al-Zulaibani, "Health care services in saudi arabia: past, present and future," Journal of family & community medicine, vol. 8, no. 3, pp. 19-23, Sep-Dec 2001.

[4] O. Alsharqi, "An analysis of access to, and the quality of the new health system in Saudi Arabia: Mixed methodology study," PhD, Monash University Clayton 2006.

[5] WHO, "Bahrain: a vital role for nurses in the provision of primary care nationwide. In: A compendium of primary care case studies: 38 case studies submitted by 29 countries across the 6 WHO regions. Geneva, World Health Organization,," ed, 2009.

[6] WHO, "The World Health Report 2000. Health systems: improving performance," in " " Word Health Organization, Geneva2000.

[7] B. Jones, The Worlds of Political Economy. London: Printer Publisher, 1988.

[8] M. Staniland, What is Political Economy - A Study of Social Theory and Underdevelopment. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1985.

[9] M. Bueuran, G. Raballand, and K. Kapoor, "Political Economy Studies: are They Actionable? Some Lessons from Zambia," The World Bank, Washington DC2011.

[10] Z. Munn, M. D. J. Peters, C. Stern, C. Tufanaru, A. McArthur, and E. Aromataris, "Systematic review or scoping review? Guidance for authors when choosing between a systematic or scoping review approach," BMC Medical Research Methodology, vol. 18, no. 1, p. 143, 2018/11/19 2018.

[11] G. Bowen, "Document Analysis as a Qualitative Research Method," Qualitative Research Journal vol. 9, no. 2, pp. 27-40, 2009.

[12] R. Rahman and D. Caulley, "The Methodology of a Study of the Regulatory Practices in the Private Health Care Sector of Bangladesh," Qualitative Research Journal vol. 6, no. 2, pp. 67-88, 2006.

[13] M. Vaismoradi, H. Turunen, and T. Bondas, "Content analysis and thematic analysis: Implications for conducting a qualitative descriptive study," Nursing & health sciences, vol. 15, no. 3, pp. 398-405, 2013.

[14] V. Braun and V. Clarke, "Using Thematic Analysis in Psychology," Qualitative Research Psychology vol. 3, no. 2, pp. 77–101, 2006.

[15] K. Young, "The Difficult Promise of Economic Reform in the Gulf," James A. Baker III Institute for Public Policy. Rice University, Houston, Texas2018.

[16] R. Rahman and O. Alsharqi, "What drove the health system reforms in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia? an Analysis " International Journal of Health Planning and Management vol. 34, no. 1, pp. 100-110, 2019.

[17] K. Young, "Markets Serving States: The Institutional Bases of Financial Governance in the GCC," Kuwait Programme on Development, Governance and Globalisation in the Gulf States, 38. The London School of Economics and Political Science, London, UK2015.

[18] N. Yusuf, "Private and public healthcare in Saudi Arabia: future challenges," International Journal of Business and Economic Development, vol. 2, no. 1, pp. 114-118, 2014.

[19] L. Lethbridge, "Health Care Reforms and the Rise of Global Multinational Health Care Companies," PUBLIC SERVICES INTERNATIONAL RESEARCH UNIT (PSIRU ) www.psiru.org, London2015.

[20] Y. Al-Mazrou, T. Al-Ghaith, A. Yazbeck, and T. Rabie, "How Labor Laws Can Transform Health Systems: The Case of Saudi Arabia," Health Systems & Reform vol. 3, pp. 26-33, 2017.

[21] A. Alkhamis, A. Hassan, and P. Cosgrove, "Financing healthcare in Gulf Cooperation Council countries: a focus on Saudi Arabia," Int J Health Plann Manage, Aug 28 2013.

[22] D. M. Barakah and S. A. Alsaleh, "The Cooperative Insurance in Saudi Arabia: A Nucleus to health Reform Policy," presented at the 2011 International Conference on Information and Finance, 2011.

[23] J. Jedidia and I. Medhioub, "The Efficiency of Saudi Arabia Insurance Companies," International Journal of Management Sciences, vol. 5, no. 3, pp. 237-248, 2015.

[24] Knight Frank, "Healthcare in Saudi Arabia Opportunities in the Sector available in https://content.knightfrank.com/research/1526/documents/en/healthcare-in-saudi-arabia-opportunities-in-the-sector-may-2018-5563.pdf accessed 4th January 2019," 2018.

[25] PWC, "Middle East Financial Services Point of View:Will KSA lead the region on insurance reform? available on https://www.pwc.com/m1/en/publications/documents/will-ksa-lead-the-region-on-insurance-reform-full.pdf accessed om June 01 2020," in " " Middle East Financial Services Point of View, Riyadh2020.

[26] L. Gengler and L. Lambert, "Renegotiating the Ruling Bargain: Selling Fiscal Reform in the GCC," Middle East Journal, vol. 70, no. 2, 2016.

[27] KSA, "National Transformation Program 2020," Ministry of Planning and Economic Development Riyadh 2016.

[28] Ministry of Health, "Private sector participation available on https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/Ministry/vro/Private-Sector-Participation/Pages/default.aspx Accessed o 27 November 2019," Ministry of Health Riyadh2019.

[29] Oxford Business Group, "Saudi Arabia's new development plan shows clear commitment to education and the private sector available on https://oxfordbusinessgroup.com/analysis/long-game-new-development-plan-shows-clear-commitment-education-and-private-sector accessed on 12 December 2019," 2019.

[30] KSA., "Vision 2030," Ministry of Planning and Economic Development Riyadh 2016.

[31] A. Blanken and G. Dewulf, "PPPs in Health: Static or Dynamic? ," Australian Journal of Public Administration, vol. 69, no. 1, pp. 35–47, 2010.

[32] S. Walston, Y. Al-Harbi, and B. Al-Omar, "The changing face of healthcare in Saudi Arabia," Annals of Saudi Medicine vol. 28, no. 4, pp. 243-250, 2008.

[33] W. Kirsten and R. C. Karch, Global perspectives in workplace health promotion. Sudbury, MA: Jones & Bartlett Learning, 2012.

[34] Arab News, "Saudi finance ministry signs SR755M financing for health, education and hospitality projects available on http://www.arabnews.com/node/1349001/saudi-arabia accessed on 22 Jan 2019," Ministry of Finance, Jeddah 2019.

[35] A. Alharbi, "Economic effects of low oil prices in Saudi Arabia," International Journal of Information Technology, 2020/02/11 2020.

[36] S. Alshahrani and A. Alsadiq, "Economic Growth and Government Spending in Saudi Arabia: an Empirical Investigation " International Monetary Fund, Washington 2014.

[37] Forbes, "Saudi Arabia Best Countries for Busines, no.80 ", ed, 2017.

[38] Ministry of Finance, "Budget statement Fiscal year 2020," Ministry of Finance, Riyadh2020.

[39] Allurentis, "Saudi Arabia - 2016|2017 Discovering Business," Allurentis Limited, United Kingdom2016.

[40] Trading Economics, "Government budget by country available on https://tradingeconomics.com/saudi-arabia/government-budget accessed August 7, 2017," ed, 2017.

[41] Ministry of Finance, "Budget 2018," Ministray of Finance, , Riyadh2018.

[42] S. Basu, Andrews J, S. Kishore, R. Panjabi, and D. Stuckler, "Comparative Performance of Private and Public Healthcare Systems in Low- and Middle-Income Countries: A Systematic Review.," Plos Medicine, vol. 19, p. E1001244., 2012.

[43] S. Ibraheem and S. Al-Hawary, "Health care services quality at private hospitals, from patients’ perspective: A comparative study between Jordan and Saudi Arabia," African Journal of Business Management, vol. 6, pp. 6516-6529, 2012.

[44] A. Al-Salem, "Renovation of Financing Healthcare Services in Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, by Implementing National Health Insurance (NHI)," World Journal of Pharmaceutical Research, vol. 7, no. 15, pp. 1247-1268, 2018.

[45] A. S. Al Otaibi, "An overview of health care system in Saudi Arabia," International Journal of Management and Administrative Sciences, vol. 4, no. 12, pp. 1-12, 2017.

[46] IMF., "Country Information: Saudi Arabia " International Monetary Fund, Washington2016.

[47] WHO., " Noncommunicable Diseases (NCD) Country Profiles, 2018. available on https://www.who.int/nmh/countries/sau_en.pdf accessed 8 December 2019," 2018.

[48] Saudi Gazette, "Saudi healthcare market to expand 12.3% till 2020 reaching $71.2bn: Report available on http://saudigazette.com.sa/article/172230/Saudi-healthcare-market-to-expand-123-till-2020-reaching-$712bn-Report accessed on Dec 29, 2018," Kuwait 2017.

[49] Global Health Saudi, "2019 Saudi Arabia Healthcare Industry Overview: Towards the healthcare goals of Saudi Vision 2030 A report by Global Health Exhibition available on https://www.globalhealthsaudi.com/content/dam/Informa/globalhealthsaudi/downloads/GHE19-KSA-HEALTHCARE-INDUSTRY-OVERVIEW.pdf accessed 29 November 2019," Global Health Exhibition Riyadk 2019.

[50] F. Albejaidi, "Emerging Role of Cooperative Health Insurance in Achieving Health System Goals under Saudi Vision - 2030 " Journal of Biology, Agriculture and Healthcare, vol. 8, no. 2, pp. 1-8, 2018.

[51] G. Al-Kibsi, J. Woetzel, T. Isherwood, J. Khan, J. Mischke, and H. Noura, "Saudi Arabia Beyond Oil: The Investment and Productivity Transformation," McKinsey Global Institute (MGI) 2015.

[52] A. Ahmad, " Macro-environment Influences on Health Service Strategy in Saudi Private Sector Hospitals: An Empirical Investigation," International Business Research, vol. 5, no. 5, pp. 49-64, 2012.

[53] M. Moran, "Understanding the Welfare State: The Case of Health Care," British Journal of Politics and International Relations, vol. 2, no. 2, pp. 135–169, 2000.

[54] J.-P. Unger and P. De Paepe, "Commercial Health Care Financing: The Cause of U.S., Dutch, and Swiss Health Systems Inefficiency?," International Journal of Health Services, vol. 49, no. 3, pp. 431-456, 2019.

[55] V. C. Nwagbara and R. Rasiah, "Rethinking health care commercialization: evidence from Malaysia," Globalization and Health, journal article vol. 11, no. 1, p. 44, November 19 2015.

[56] F. S. Alghamdi, "The impact of service quality perception on patient satisfaction in government hospitals in southern Saudi Arabia," (in eng), Saudi medical journal, vol. 35, no. 10, pp. 1271-1273, 2014.

[57] A. Zamil, A. Areiqat, and W. Tailakh, "The Impact of Health Service Quality on Patients’ Satisfaction over Private and Public Hospitals in Jordan: A Comparative Study " International Journal of Marketing Studies, vol. 4, no. 1, pp. 123-137, 2012.

[58] W. Mohamed, K. Swat, M. Wahab, A. Alsulaimani, and A. Portugal, "Patient satisfaction: a comparison between governmental and private out-patient clinics in Taif, Saudi Arabia," Madridge J Case Rep Stud, vol. 1, no. 1, pp. 1-6, 2017.

[59] A. Alkhamis, "Critical analysis and review of the literature on healthcare privatization and its association with access to medica care in Saudi Arabia," Journal of Infection and Public Health vol. 10, p. 258—268, 2017.

[60] World Health Organization, Bangladesh health system review, https://apps.who.int/iris/handle/10665/208214, accessed on 21 April 2019. Manila: WHO Regional Office for the Western Pacific, 2015.

[61] H. Al-Borie and A. Damanhouri, "Patients' satisfaction of service quality in Saudi hospitals: a SERVQUAL analysis. ," Int J Health Care Qual Assur., vol. 26, pp. 20–30., 2013.

[62] M. Mackintosh, A. Channon, A. Karan, S. Selvaraj, E. Cavagnero, and H. Zhao, "What is the Private Sector? Understanding Private Provision in the Health Systems of Low-Income and Middle-Income Countries," The Lancet, vol. 388, no. 10044, pp. 596-605, 2016/08/06/ 2016.

[63] J. Yoong, N. Burger, C. Spreng, and N. Sood, "Private sector participation and health system performance in sub-Saharan Africa," PLoS One, vol. 5, no. 10, p. e13243, 2010.

[64] T. Joarder, A. George, M. Sarker, S. Ahmed, and D. H. Peters, "Who are more responsive? Mixed-methods comparison of public and private sector physicians in rural Bangladesh," Health Policy and Planning, vol. 32, no. suppl_3, pp. iii14-iii24, 2017.

[65] S. Berendes, P. Heywood, S. Oliver, and P. Garner, "Quality of private and public ambulatory health care in low and middle income countries: systematic review of comparative studies," PLoS medicine, vol. 8, no. 4, p. e1000433, 2011.

[66] P. Bhate-Deosthali, R. Khatri, and S. Wagle, "Poor standards of care in small, private hospitals in Maharashtra, India: implications for public–private partnerships for maternity care," Reproductive Health Matters, vol. 19, no. 37, pp. 32-41, 2011.

[67] H. Arasli, E. Haktan Ekiz, and S. Turan Katircioglu, "Gearing service quality into public and private hospitals in small islands: empirical evidence from Cyprus," International journal of health care quality assurance, vol. 21, no. 1, pp. 8-23, 2008.

[68] J. Das, A. Holla, V. Das, M. Mohanan, D. Tabak, and B. Chan, "In urban and rural India, a standardized patient study showed low levels of provider training and huge quality gaps," Health affairs, vol. 31, no. 12, pp. 2774-2784, 2012.

[69] K. Hanson et al., "Is private health care the answer to the health problems of the world's poor?," PLoS Medicine, vol. 5, no. 11, p. e233, 2008.

[70] L. J. Komape, "Exploring public perceptions of South African private and public hospitals and preferences for health care providers," 2014.

[71] S. Grobler, "Private practice review: the Samaritan's Dilemma: private practice review," South African Gastroenterology Review, vol. 10, no. 1, pp. 36-38, 2012.

[72] D. Berlan and J. Shiffman, "Holding health providers in developing countries accountable to consumers: a synthesis of relevant scholarship," Health Policy and Planning, vol. 27, no. 4, pp. 271-280, 2012.

[73] R. Rahman, "The State, The Private Health Care Sector And Regulation In Bangladesh," The Asia Pacific Journal of Public Administration vol. 29, no. 2, pp. 191-206, 2007.

[74] B. Hollingsworth, "The measurement of efficiency and productivity of health care delivery," Health Economics, vol. 17, pp. 1107–1128, 2008.

[75] A. Al Rabeah, S. Ogden, D. Edgar, and K. Fryer, "TQM in the Saudi Health Care System: A National Cultural Perspective," World Review of Business Research, vol. 5, no. 2, pp. 120 – 136, 2015.

[76] M. Senitan and J. Gillespie, "Health-Care Reform in Saudi Arabia: Patient Experience at Primary Health-Care Centers," Journal of Patient Experience, pp. 1-6, 2019.

[77] M. Alshammari and D. Mital, "Medical errors in Saudi Arabia: understanding the pattern and associated financial cost," International Journal of Medical Engineering and Informatics, vol. 8, no. 1, pp. 41-48, 2016.

[78] H. Aljadhey, A. Alhusan, K. Alburikan, M. Adam, M. Murray, and D. Bates, "Medication safety practices in hospitals: A national survey in Saudi Arabia. ," Saudi Pharm J, vol. 21, pp. 159-164, 2013.

[79] J. Al Jarallah and N. Al Rowaiss, "The pattern of medical errors and litigation against doctors in Saudi Arabia," Journal of Family and Community Medicine, vol. 20, no. 2, pp. 98-105, May 1, 2013 2013.

[80] F. Alshammari et al., "A survey of hospital healthcare professionals’ perceptions toward patient safety culture in Saudi Arabia," International Journal of Africa Nursing Sciences, vol. 11, p. 100149, 2019.

[81] R. EstimoJR., "Decree issued to improve services of health care providers available https://www.arabnews.com/saudi-arabia/news/906761 accessed on March 20, 2020," Arab News, April 7, Riyadh2016.

[82] M. Berer, "Who has responsibility for health in a privatised health system?," Reproductive Health Matters, vol. 18, no. 36, pp. 4-12, 2010.

[83] J. Oh, J.-S. Lee, Y.-J. Choi, H.-K. Park, Y. K. Do, and S.-J. Eun, "Struggle against privatization: A case history in the use of comparative performance evaluation of public hospitals," International Journal of Health Services, vol. 41, no. 2, pp. 371–388, 2011.

[84] H. Novaes, "Report on the Expert Group Meeting on Hospital Accreditation. Cairo, Egypt, 23–26 September 2002. World Health Organization, Regional Office for the Eastern Mediterranean, 2002 (WHO.EM/HCD/044/E/L)." 2002.

[85] S. Siddiqi, T. Masud, and B. Sabri, "Contracting but not without caution: experience with outsourcing of health services in countries of the Eastern Mediterranean Region," Bulletin of the World Health Organization, vol. 84, no. 11, pp. 867–875, 2006.

Download PDF

Version 1

posted

You are reading this latest preprint version

Policy Discourse: Shifting the burden of healthcare from state to market in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia

Status:

Version 1

Abstract

Figures

Introduction

Materials And Methods

Shifting Burden From State To Market

Discussion

Conclusion

Declarations

References

Status:

Version 1