Two gas stations (P02 and P06) presented radargrams which had a region of attenuated reflections or low amplitudes in the vadose zone. The GPR profiles of station P02 were obtained from transects of between 10 m and 16 m in length, while at P06, the profiles were between 30 m and 43 m long. The electromagnetic signal was generated at 2 m intervals along the length of each profile.
At gas station P02, hyperbolic electromagnetic signals were identified parallel to the location of the fuel pumps in the radargrams of profile L1 (Fig. 3), which correspond to the storage tank caps. Hyperbolic electromagnetic signals corresponding to the storage tank caps were also identified in the radargrams of profile L3 (Fig. 4), which is perpendicular to L1, together with responses that correspond to the pipes in the ground in the vicinity of the fuel pumps. Hyperbolic electromagnetic signals were also identified in the radargrams obtained from profile L4 at gas station P06 (Fig. 5), which corresponded to the locations of the storage tanks and pipes, as well as responses that correspond to the base of the support column of the gas station.
The radargrams collected during the dry season also revealed the presence of low amplitude zones and hyperbolic electromagnetic signals, indicating the location of the underground tanks and their connecting pipes (Figs. 3, 6 and 7). These areas of low reflection are located in close proximity to the storage tanks. Castro and Branco (2003) concluded that these features correspond to a hydrocarbon vapor phase in the vadose zone or the region between the surface and the water table, in which the pores in the rock are not completely filled with water.
Daniels et al. (1995) reported that these areas of low reflection may be attributed to the reduced plane wave reflection coefficients from unsaturated sand filled partially by the vapor phase of LNAPLs. Gas station P02 has been in operation for 33 years, and P06, for 31 years, which implies that the age of the tanks may be a key factor, given that corrosion and cracks tend to arise after 20 years of use (Blackman Jr 2001; Cole 1994).
Profile L2 (Fig. 6) was used to calculate the propagation velocity (0.081 m s-1), the electrical conductivity (50 S m-1), and the relative dielectric permittivity (13.8 F m-1) of the saturated clayey soil, at depths of below 2–2.4 m in the saturated zone (Table 1). Profile L3 at station P06 (Fig. 7) was used to determine the physical properties of the organic contaminants in the low reflection zone, including the electromagnetic wave velocity (0.19 m s-1), the electrical conductivity (0.27 S m-1), and the dielectric permittivity (2.4 F m-1) of the dry, clayey soil. Castro and Branco (2003) concluded that the attenuation of the GPR signal near the surface is due to the low permittivity of the hydrocarbon product (gas vapor) relative to water.
Table 1
Dielectric permittivity (ε), electrical conductivity (σ), and electromagnetic wave velocity (v) measured from the vadose and saturated zones.
Property | Vadose zone | Saturated zone |
Dielectric permittivity (ε) | \(2.4 F {m}^{-1}\) | \(13.8 F {m}^{-1}\) |
Electrical conductivity (σ) | \(0.27 S {m}^{-1}\) | \(50 S {m}^{-1}\) |
Electromagnetic wave velocity (\(v\)) | \(0.19 m {s}^{-1}\) | \(0.081 m {s}^{-1}\) |
The results of the GC-MS analyses of the groundwater samples collected during the present study are shown below. In December 2017 (Table 2), toluene and xylene were detected in the samples from gas station P01. In sample A01, toluene was present at a concentration of 0.26 µg L-1and xylene at 0.46 µg L-1. The same monoaromatic hydrocarbons were identified in sample A02 from the same gas station (P01), at concentrations of 0.13 µg L-1(toluene) and 0.34 µg L-1(xylene). All the other samples from this site presented values below the Detection Limit (< DL). While these concentrations are considerably higher than those recorded in any of the other samples collected during the present study, they are much lower than those (MVA) defined by the Brazilian legislation for drinking water (BRASIL 2021). As gas station P01 has been in operation for 35 years, the age of the tanks may, once again, have provoked corrosion and cracks that would give rise to fuel leakage.
Table 2
Results of the analysis of BTEX in the water samples collected during the present study in Bragança, Pará, Brazil, in December 2017 (dry season).
Sample | Site | Benzene (µg L-1) | Toluene (µg L-1) | Ethylbenzene (µg L-1) | Xylene (µg L-1) |
A01 | Gas station P01 | < DL | 0.26 | < DL | 0.46 |
A02 | Home near gas station P01 | < DL | 0.13 | < DL | 0.34 |
A03 | Gas station P02 | < DL | < DL | < DL | < DL |
A04 | Gas station P03 | < DL | < DL | < DL | < DL |
A05 | Gas station P04 | < DL | < DL | < DL | < DL |
A06 | Gas station P05 | < DL | < DL | < DL | < DL |
A07 | Gas station P06 | < DL | < DL | < DL | < DL |
A08 | Gas station store P06 | < DL | < DL | < DL | < DL |
Intrinsic bioremediation (natural attenuation) involves the application of endogenous microorganisms to degrade hazardous compounds, such as BTEX, present in aquifers (Corseuil and Alvarez 1996; Borden et al. 1995). The absence of BTEX concentrations higher than the MVA established by the Brazilian legislation (BRASIL 2021) indicates the occurrence of the natural attenuation of BTEX in the subsurface. It is nevertheless important to understand the factors that determine this process, and its potential risks to humans and the environment (Borden et al. 1995).
None of the samples collected in May (rainy season) 2018 exceeded the DL for any of the BTEX in the CG-MS analysis. Given this, none of the samples can be considered to be contaminated by these compounds.
Similar values (< DL) were also recorded in most of the samples collected in the dry season month of December 2018 (Table 3), although benzene was recorded in sample A02 (0.558 µg L-1), from gas station P01, and toluene was found in sample A03 (10.390 µg L-1), from gas station P02. All the other samples were below the Detection Limit (< DL). While these values are much higher than those recorded in December 2017, they are still well below the MVAs defined by Brazilian legislation (BRASIL 2021).
Table 3
Results of the analysis of BTEX in the water samples collected during the present study in Bragança, Pará, Brazil, in December 2018 (dry season).
Sample | Site | Benzene (µg L-1) | Toluene (µg L-1) | Ethylbenzene (µg L-1) | Xylene (µg L-1) |
A01 | Gas station P01 | <DL | < DL | < DL | < DL |
A02 | Home near gas station P01 | 0.558 | < DL | < DL | < DL |
A03 | Gas station P02 | < DL | 10.390 | < DL | < DL |
A04 | Gas station P03 | < DL | < DL | < DL | < DL |
A05 | Gas station P04 | < DL | < DL | < DL | < DL |
A06 | Gas station P05 | < DL | < DL | < DL | < DL |
A07 | Gas station P06 | < DL | < DL | < DL | < DL |
A08 | Gas station store P06 | < DL | < DL | < DL | < DL |
All the samples collected in the rainy seasons of 2017 and 2018 were below the Detection Limit (< DL) for all the BTEX compounds. These findings may reflect a natural biodegradation process, provoked by a combination of intense rainfall and chemical reactions, through which the hydrocarbons may be transformed into electron acceptors and absorbed by microorganisms. Electron acceptors include oxygen, nitrate, iron oxides, water, and carbon dioxide (Borden et al. 1995; Weelink et al. 2010). Hydrocarbon compounds may disperse in the environment due to a number of processes, such as the drainage of intense precipitation and seasonal variations in the hydrological gradient (Danielset al. 1995).