To our knowledge, this is the first study to assess the diagnostic performance of CMR strain imaging with a standardized breathing maneuver in patients with acute chest pain. The main findings of our study are:
1) The diagnostic performance of a visual evaluation of fSENC maps before and after HVBH was very high (accuracy 95.4%). In all but 5 patients, an ischemic cause of the acute chest pain could be correctly ruled in or ruled out. There were no false negative results.
2) The number of dysfunctional segments before and after hyperventilation may serve as a quantifiable surrogate marker for ischemic burden.
3) fSENC and HVBH correctly diagnosed all 20 patients within one hour who were assigned to the observe zone according to the hscTnT 0h/1h algorithm.
4) Additionally, visual analysis of the fSENC images accurately identified the culprit coronary artery and relevant stenoses in most patients.
Our results may have significant clinical implications. As early revascularization in NSTEMI patients reduces all-cause death in comparison to delayed invasive strategy 1, an accelerated diagnostic workup would shorten time to treatment and thus have a strong positive impact on patient outcome. Early rule-out diagnostic tests such as fSENC may significantly reduce staff time and save hospital costs by shortening the length of stay in the CPU and reducing procedural costs. 23
In a recent study we could demonstrate the feasibility of fSENC for diagnostic triage of patients presenting with acute chest pain. Global strain measurements allowed for a safe identification of obstructive CAD – even outperforming ECG and serial hscTnT measurements. 12 Although fSENC images at rest achieved a good diagnostic performance when compared to serial hscTnT measurements in our study, the added input of the images after hyperventilation improved diagnostic performance, especially regarding sensitivity. Major advantages of the protocol are its safety, completely non-invasive setup, the lack of radiation exposure, and its low rate of only minor, transient adverse effects. 17 Confirming previous studies, hyperventilation was well tolerated in our study, despite consisting of a patient population with acute/ recent onset of symptoms. Only 3 out of the 108 patients were unable to perform the hyperventilation maneuver.
In a recent study conducted by Fischer et al., it could be shown that Oxygenation-Sensitive CMR in combination with hyperventilation allows for the detection of regional myocardial abnormalities related to multi-vessel CAD without the need of medication or contrast agent. 17 Accordingly, in our study we combined the HVBH with strain imaging and received similar results thereby underlining the clinical impact of the HVBH as a non-invasive stress test in combination with novel emerging imaging techniques.
Ochs et. al compared standard adenosine perfusion stress CMR to strain imaging after adenosine infusion as well as strain imaging after hyperventilation. Both, adenosine-strain and HVBH-strain were found to be superior to standard adenosine first-pass perfusion for identification of obstructive CAD. 18 Our data demonstrate that this approach is safe and applicable in an acute setting as well.
Of particular importance, patients assigned to the observe zone may have a specific additional benefit from fSENC-CMR and HVBH. In studies on the utility of 1-hour protocols, the percentage of patients assigned to the observe-zone varied between 30.5% 24 and 33% 25, effectively leaving one third of all patients with thoracic pain in the ED without a clear diagnosis after one hour. Therefore, appropriate treatment often is delayed, negatively affecting patient outcome, wait times, and costs. Studies have shown a relatively high prevalence of myocardial infarction in the observe zone group 26,27. In our study population the prevalence of ischemia within the observe zone was 35%. Of note, the mean time-to-treatment (coronary intervention) of the 7 patients within the observe zone diagnosed with ischemia was 54.0 ± 37.6 hours – significantly higher than the 8.1 ± 6.8 hours required for patients with positive hscTnT kinetics (rule-in according to 0h/1h algorithm).
Additionally, of the 20 patients classified to the observe zone, 10 underwent coronary angiography – 3 of whom were discharged thereafter. For these 3 patients, invasive diagnostic procedures including radiation could have been avoided based on hyperventilation CMR strain imaging results alone. Thus, this approach could be of particular value in this high-risk patient group.
Furthermore, hyperventilation CMR strain imaging allowed the correct identification of severe stenoses in most cases. There were inaccuracies with lesions in the LCX territory in patients with three-vessel disease, although variations of RCA and LCX territories are well known and could explain the observed discrepancies. 28 Although coronary angiography remains the gold standard, hyperventilation CMR strain imaging may provide strong clues regarding possible culprit coronary lesions.
Comparatively, strain analysis tools based on analyzing standard cine images such as feature tracking do not require additional sequences and thus allow for shorter scan times which may be useful and efficient. Strain imaging based on cine images however is hampered by through-plane motion artifacts and partial volume effects. 29
Study limitations:
We excluded patients with history of PCI/ bypass operation and with heart failure (EF < 40%). The study population and the final sample size of those deemed to have ACS was modest and confined to a single center, hence no significant difference within the ROC curve analysis could be registered. Findings need to be confirmed in bigger study population. Furthermore, CAD was determined by visual assessment of the angiographer, and its hemodynamic relevance was not quantified by Fractional Flow Reserve or instantaneous wave-free ratio. No additional standard stress CMR protocols for comparison to our proposed protocol were performed.