Tuberculosis involves complex Mtb-human interactions, in which many different cell types, including T cells, dendritic cells, macrophages, and natural killer cells, participate in the progression from asymptomatic form to clinical disease20. As a cell-surface receptor expressed on most of these cells, PD-L1 exerts a modulatory role in human innate and particularly adaptive immune responses by binding to PD-1, expanding Tregs, and suppressing efficient clearance against pathogens and tumor cells2,21. The human gene PD-L1 is located on chromosome 9p24.222, where numerous variants are associated with several diseases, except TB9,23. Therefore, this study aimed to evaluate the possible relationship between PD-L1 polymorphisms and TB and gene-environment interactions with cooking with solid fuel.
The results showed that mutations of rs4143815 in the PD-L1 gene were associated with susceptibility to TB. Individuals with GG/CG + GG genotypes at the locus displayed a significantly increased vulnerability to TB than those carrying the CC genotype. To our knowledge, this finding is novel, since no relevant study has been reported previously. The variant rs4143815 is located at the 3'-untranslated region (3'-UTR) of the PD-L1 gene, and previous investigations have shown that structural variations such as duplications and translocations would cause aberrant PD-L1 expression in several cancers24. Furthermore, studies have shown that miRNAs can bind to the 3'-UTR of messenger RNA (mRNA) and regulate gene translational repression22,25. As a genetic variation within 3'-UTR of the PD-L1 gene, SNP rs4143815 is supposed to disturb the suppressive function by affecting the binding capacity of PD-L1 mRNA to its corresponding miRNA miR-570, thus leading to aberrant PD-L1 expression.
To date, numerous cancer types have been associated with the rs4143815 variant. Xie et al.26 found that the rs4143815 GG genotype had higher levels of PD-L1 and was associated with an increased risk of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) compared with CC genotypes, whereas individuals with the CC genotype displayed better prognosis compared with the CG and GG genotypes. Similarly, several studies have demonstrated that G allele carriers confer an increased susceptibility to cancers including gastric adenocarcinoma, ovarian cancer compared with CC genotypes25,27. Moreover, an elevated PD-L1 expression among them was reported, suggesting that the G allele in rs4143815 of PD-L1 may increase PD-L1 expression by affecting the binding force between miR-570 and mRNA25,27. In addition, pathological features, including tumor size, differentiation degree, and tumor node metastasis (TNM) stage, were associated with mutations at the locus26. However, controversy still exists regarding the function of PD-L1 rs4143815 in diseases. In a previous study, the GG genotype of rs4143815 decreased the risk of breast cancer28. In addition, an insignificant association of mutations in rs4143815 with the risk of colorectal cancer, non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC), and esophageal squamous cell carcinoma has been reported in previous studies29–31. Further, research on type 1 diabetes suggested a larger stem-loop structure for G allele carriers, which might facilitate the interaction between the 3'-UTR of PD-L1 and miR-570, resulting in lower PD-L1 expression9. Overall, discrepancies among studies may be attributed to the essential differences between these diseases, and the substantial heterogeneity of study designs, ethnicities, and confounders control might have some role. In this study, the mechanism mentioned above may explain our findings; however, further investigations on genetic mutations and PD-L1 expression among TB patients should be conducted to confirm this.
In the rs2297136 variant in PD-L1, our results suggested no significant association with TB risk. However, previous studies showed that it is a binding site for miR-324-5p located in the 3'-UTR of the PD-L1 gene. The mechanism by which the rs2297136 polymorphism acts on the expression of PD-L1 protein is supposed to be similar to that of the rs4143815 SNP, with the vital step being the interaction between miR-324-5p and PD-L1 mRNA8,26. Several studies have been performed to confirm the process and examine the associations of the rs2297136 SNP with multiple diseases. Previous studies proposed that rs2297136 TT and TC genotypes contributed to the poor prognosis of multiple myeloma (MM) and colorectal cancer, respectively32,33, and a higher level of PD-L1 mRNA was demonstrated34. In contrast, Xie et al.26 revealed a significant association between the TT/TC genotypes and better prognosis of HCC. In non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC), Du et al.30 reported a higher risk of NSCLC among G allele carriers, with the transcriptional activity of the PD-L1 gene being suppressed in a luciferase assay. Lee et al.35 found a better prognosis for patients carrying the C allele after chemotherapy. In addition, another study showed that individuals with GG genotypes had lower PD-L1 expression levels and poor prognosis of gastric cancer8, indicating the complex role of mutation genotypes on PD-L1 expression and disease progression. Moreover, the current knowledge regarding the correlations between rs2297136 and infectious diseases, including TB, is limited, more studies should be conducted despite a preliminary view of the field provided by this study.
Furthermore, marginal structural linear odds model analysis suggested that rs4143815 of the PD-L1 gene had positive interactions with cooking with solid fuel on TB susceptibility. It is well known that cooking with solid fuel is one of major sources of indoor air pollution, which has been implicated in the occurrence and sequela of various diseases. However, evidence remains inconsistent in TB research currently. Many epidemiological studies have attempted to clarify the dose-response relationship but the results were equivocal. Some studies reporting a significant association10,11, whereas others did not36. The discrepancy among studies may be due to the substantial heterogeneity in exposure definitions, accuracy of exposure monitoring, and quantitative effect estimates. In addition, kitchen ventilation facilities and room structures may have indirect effects by altering the exposure concentration. Although conflict exists in population studies, biological evidence supports these associations. Basic studies have shown that biomass smoke from different types of solid fuels contains a complex mixture of approximately 200 chemicals, such as carbon monoxide, varying sizes of particulate matter (PM), sulphur and nitrogen oxides, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAH), aldehydes, free radicals and non-radical oxidising species and volatile organic compounds. Chronic exposure to these hazardous substances can impair mucociliary clearance of the lung and facilitate persistent inflammation through the secretion of pro-inflammatory cytokines17. PAH can inhibit the immune function thereby weakening the immunity of the human body11. In addition, particulate matter such as PM2.5 can act as a carrier for several toxic components, promote inflammatory responses, and influence gene transcription17. These mechanisms provided the biological plausibility for associations between the risk factor of interest and Mtb infection. They revealed that there might be some cross-talk in the mechanism between the environmental factor and the PD-L1 pathway. In this regard, our findings indicate that those with mutations in rs4143815 of the PD-L1 gene are at a higher risk of contracting TB if exposed to cooking with solid fuel, and behavioral interventions in these aspects may lower TB incidence. The novel linkages between modifiable factors and gene mutations may provide new directions for TB prevention and are helpful in understanding precise prevention strategies among different populations.
This study had some limitations. First, we detected limited SNPs of the PD-L1 gene, and many other genetic and environmental backgrounds among the population may cause some improbability in the study. Hence, more studies on gene-gene, gene-environment, and environment-environment interactions should be conducted to better elucidate the etiology of TB. Second, this study did not examine the relationships between levels of PD-L1 protein and mutations in specific SNPs, leaving deep mechanisms behind the observed associations on TB susceptibility not been determined. Thus, further in-depth studies are still needed to validate our findings on molecular levels. Third, the participants were all limited to Chinese Han population. Considering the probable existence of genetic deviations among different ethnic populations, our results might only apply to the specific population studied. Thus, external validation studies in other populations are still required to determine the generalisability of our findings. Despite these limitations, this study precisely defined exposure to cooking with solid fuel, and adjusting for covariates such as age, smoking, alcohol consumption, and kitchen ventilation facilities, the results should be reliable.