3.2. Spectral, visible, and molecular orbital response of AD1 towards Hg2+
The metal screening studies of colorimetric sensor AD1 were carried out in acetonitrile at room temperature. The metal cations chosen for screening included Hg2+, Ag+, Fe3+, Pb2+, Cd2+, Cu2+, Ba2+, Zn2+, Ca2+, Co2+, Cr2+, Al3+, K+, Ni2+, and Na+. The UV-Vis spectral and “naked-eye” colorimetric observations of the metal screening studies of AD1 in acetonitrile is shown in Fig. 1. The absorbance spectral results displayed the characteristic azo-derived absorption band from 340 nm to 540 nm with Amax set at 422 nm. This could be attributed to the intra-molecular charge transfer (ICT) of the azo skeleton (π-π* and/or n-π*) electronic transitions.45,66 Notably, after the immediate addition of Hg2+ to AD1, a striking colour change from yellow to red; and a new charge transfer band with Amax of 520 nm was observed. The newly generated absorbance peak is indicative of the AD1-Hg2+ complex formation. The large bathochromic shift gives rise to the visible colour change upon Hg2+ complexation. This red-shift is necessary for selective colorimetric “naked-eye” response systems.67 This rapid, notable spectral shift was not observed for other cations under analogous conditions. Although the remaining cations did induce a weak colorimetric response, the change is not as striking as that seen with Hg2+. This standalone colour and bathochromic shift for Hg2+ is indication of the affinity of chemosensor AD1 towards Hg2+ cations.56,67 Time-dependent absorbance fluctuation studies show the rapid response upon Hg2+ addition (Figure S.14). It could be found that the absorbance of AD1 decreased rapidly and reached steady-state, at 422 and 520 nm, within the first minute interval. The result is consistent with the swift naked-eye response and displays the sensing efficiency and affinity of the chosen chemosensor towards Hg2+ sensing strategies. The proposed selectivity of AD1 towards Hg2+ was verified by competition studies.
Compound AD1 contains a strong push-pull π-conjugated electronic system with the coumarin moiety postulated as the acceptor (pull) species and the N,N-dimethylaniline derivative as the donor (push) species. The chemosensor was thought to exhibit strong ICT characteristics with a prominent colour change due to the large extent of π-conjugation of the donor-π-acceptor (D-π-A) system. This arrangement is a poignant property for effective ICT.68 It is proposed that the coordination between AD1 and Hg2+ could enhance the π-delocalization, thereby reducing the energy of the π-π* transitions accounting for the new observable absorption band and visible colour change.54 This visible red-shift in absorbance wavelength is proposed to be due to analyte interaction with the acceptor unit in the D-π-A conjugated system. Upon complexation, the electron withdrawing character of the acceptor unit increases, leading to a red-shift in the absorbance spectrum.69–71 Had complexation occurred on the N,N-dimethylaniline substituent, a blue-shift in Figure 2. Proposed ICT mechanism of AD1-Hg2+ complexation resulting in bathochromic shift from 422-520 nm and the observable colour change from yellow to red.
absorbance wavelength would occur. The proposed ICT mechanism for AD1-Hg2+ complexation is shown in Figure 2.
Moreover, calculated HOMO and LUMO energies of AD1 and the AD1-Hg2+ complex confirmed the spectral shift and resulting colour change. In an ICT mechanism, red-shift occurs when the energies of the HOMO and LUMO of the resulting sensor-analyte complex are lower in energy relative to that of free chemosensor The HOMO and LUMO energy diagram of AD1 and AD1-Hg2+ complexation and calculated orbital energies are shown in Figure 3. Evidently, the HOMO of AD1 resides on the substituted N,N-dimethylaniline and azo-group (donor species) whilst the LUMO resides around the coumarin moiety and carbonyl of the 3-substituted ester functionality. Therefore, the ICT from the N,N-dimethyl to the coumarin moiety is highly feasible. Upon complexation with the carbonyl groups of the coumarin and ester functionalities, an overall decrease in the orbital energies occurs, facilitating the strong spectral shift and rapid, naked-eye colour change upon Hg2+ complexation. Calculations were conducted once the most energetically preferred conformer of AD1 was calculated (Figure S.15).
3.2.1. Selectivity studies
Owing to the unique bathochromic shift and visible colour change of AD1 upon Hg2+ complexation, selectivity studies with competing cations in acetonitrile were conducted. The effects of the competing cations (10 equiv.) on the interaction of AD1-Hg2+ complexation is shown in Fig. 4. The UV-Vis spectra revealed that the presence of competing cations had little effect on the absorbance intensity of Hg2+ at 520 nm. Moreover, complexation of AD1 with Hg2+ remained reasonably unperturbed when all competing cations were present in solution. The competition between Hg2+ with competing cations displayed the characteristic red/pink colour of AD1 with Hg2+ alone. Furthermore, AD1 displayed remarkable selectivity towards Hg2+ post competing metal complexation, whereby the colour induced upon initial competing metal complexation changed to the characteristic pink/red colour when 1 equivalence of Hg2+ was added. Sensor AD1 displays promising chemosensing application towards mercuric cations.
3.2.2. Titration studies
UV-Vis spectrophotometric titration experiments were carried out with the sequential addition of analyte. As illustrated in Figure 5, upon the incremental addition of Hg2+ (0.98-98 µM) to the solution of AD1 (10 µM), a new absorption band appeared at 520 nm. Conversely, the absorption band at 422 nm subsequently decreased upon Hg2+ addition, forming a clear isosbestic point at 470 nm. This isosbestic point characterizes the appearance of the new AD1-Hg2+ complex as a single, stable coordination species.39
3.2.3. Binding stoichiometry, association constant, and detection limit (LOD)
Job’s plot analysis was applied to determine the binding stoichiometry of the AD1-Hg2+ adduct. For this experiment, the total molar concentration for AD1 and Hg2+ was fixed at 16 µM in acetonitrile. Variation in the absorbance value at 422 nm was used for plotting the Job’s plot of absorbance versus mole fraction of Hg2+ (Fig. 6a). The highest absorbance was observed at 0.5 mole fraction Hg2+, a clear indication of 1:1 biding stoichiometry. The association constant (Ka) was calculated by means of the Benesi-Hildebrand (BH) equation (Eq. 2) (Fig. 6b). The plot of 1/(A0-A) vs 1/[Hg2+] resulted in a linear relationship with an R2 value of 0.99.
The linear relationship of the BH plot supports the 1:1 stoichiometric binding ratio as seen from Job’s plot analysis.72 The value for the association constant was determined by the ratio of the intercept to the slope of the double reciprocal plot.73 The association constant was calculated to be 8.9 x 104 M-1. The appreciable value for the association constant supports the strong binding affinity observed between AD1 and Hg2+. The sensitivity of the recognition process is an important characteristic for successful analyte detection systems. This is quantified as the detection limit (DL) or limit of detection (LOD) which refers to the lowest concentration of analyte a system can accurately detect. Thus, the lower the limit of detection, the better the sensor. Herein, the detection limit was calculated in accordance with equation 1 and determined to be 2.4 x10-7 M or 0.24 µM. This detection limit is lower than what is stipulated as an acceptable level of mercury in drinking water as reported by the WHO and U.S. EPA.30,74,75
3.2.4. Reversibility of AD1 towards Hg2+
The ability of a chemosensor to bind reversibly with a selected analyte is an important feature for practical applications. The reversibility of the AD1-Hg2+ complex was elucidated by UV-Vis analysis in acetonitrile at room temperature. Experiments were conducted by adding a single aliquot of Hg2+ and monitoring the absorbance response. Upon sensor-metal complexation, hexadentate chelating ligand EDTA was sequentially added to the solution of AD1 with Hg2+ and the absorbance response monitored. Figure 7a shows the reversible absorbance response of AD1 upon EDTA titration. Evidently, the complexation of AD1 with Hg2+ Figure 8. Variation in absorbance of AD1 at 520 nm with respect to differing pH solutions.
displayed appreciable reversibility. The reversible nature of the complexation was characterised by the increase in the optical density at 422 nm. Upon EDTA addition, abstraction of the Hg2+ cation from the coumarin and ester carbonyl binding sites occurs, resulting in the increase in electron density of the N,N-dimethylaniline derivative which facilitates the ICT process. Furthermore, upon sequential addition of EDTA to the sensor-metal complex, a colour change from red to yellow was observed (Figure 7b). This could be repeated for several cycles with high absorbance efficiency and repeated colour changes between red and the original yellow of AD1 (Figure 7c). The result exhibited the visible and measurable reversibility of sensor AD1 towards the recognition of Hg2+. The cyclic reversibility of the chemosensor towards Hg2+ suggested usability towards molecular mimicking devices.
3.2.5. pH studies
The influence of pH on sensor-mercury cation binding was conducted by measuring the absorbance intensity at 520 nm before and after Hg2+ addition. Different solutions with pH ranging from 2-14 in water were used for analysis. Figure 8 shows the effect of pH on the absorbance intensity of AD1 before and after Hg2+ addition. Evidently, the solvent medium and pH of the solution effects the absorbance response of the sensor upon the introduction of the Hg2+ cations. Solutions for analysis were prepared in water whilst spectroscopic and sensing properties were evaluated in acetonitrile at the original pH. Acetonitrile is a polar aprotic solvent; therefore, the likelihood of free-floating protons is improbable and are unlikely to affect the sensing and absorbance response. Conversely, water is a polar protic solvent which could cause the sensing and binding discrepancies seen between AD1 and Hg2+.
3.2.6. Complexation site of AD1 with Hg2+
The complexation site was determined experimentally by 1H NMR, 13C NMR, and FT-IR spectral analysis, and verified by Molecular Modelling studies. To better understand the mechanism of the interaction between the sensor and analyte, 1H NMR titration studies of AD1 with gradual addition of Hg2+ in deuterated acetonitrile is shown in Figure 9. Before addition, the free-sensor showed two signals assigned to the protons from the two methyl groups (Ha) and two adjacent protons of aromatic ring (Hb) of the N,N-dimethylaniline substituent at 3.1 and 6.84 ppm respectively. After a single aliquot of Hg2+ was added, the signal peaks of Ha and Hb became far less resolved and appear to have disappeared. Additionally, the two Hb proton signals display a minimal shift downfield. This result would have suggested the hydrogen-bond interaction between AD1 and Hg2+. However, modelling studies indicated the unlikelihood of hydrogen-bonding in this complexation scenario. Thus, theoretical calculations to model the effect of the counterion (NO3-) toward Hg2+ complexation was conducted. Results suggest that the NO3- counterion is capable of interacting with the N,N-dimethylaniline substituent, specifically the protons from the two methyl groups. Had complexation occurred between AD1 and Hg2+ at this donor site, a hypsochromic or blue-shift in absorbance wavelength would be expected.
The 13C NMR titration analysis of AD1 with Hg2+ supports the complexation of Hg2+ with the substituted ester and coumarin carbonyl, and the nitrate counterion with the N,N-dimethylaniline substituent (Fig. 10). The analysis was conducted after 16 µL of the Hg(NO3)2 solution was added in the 1H NMR titration. Upon complexation, a minor shift in most of the peak signals was observed, however, four signals related to carbon atoms on the coumarin, and tertiary aniline derivatives displayed notable shifts. The signals relating to the aniline methyl groups in AD1 are observed as a single peak at 40 ppm. Upon coordination with NO3−, a downfield shift to 48 ppm is observed. This deshielding of these respective methyl signals may be attributed to the hydrogen-bonding between the nitrate-oxygen and the methyl-proton atoms, thus withdrawing electron density from these carbon atoms. Conversely, the carbon signal related to the C-N bond observed at 154 ppm has experienced an upfield shift to 133 pm. This indicates a migration in electron density towards this carbon atom, facilitating this observed shielding. Electron density is postulated to be drawn away from the two neighbouring hydrogen atoms, resulting in the observable shift and decrease in resolution seen in the 1H NMR titration experiments. The two signals for the azo C-N connectivity from the coumarin scaffold and substituted aniline derivative are observed at 150 and 148 ppm respectively. Upon complexation, both signals appear to merge into a singular peak at 149 ppm. Had complexation of Hg2+ occurred on the azo N = N bond, a greater shift in these respective signals would be expected. The involvement of the carbonyl functionalities towards Hg2+ complexation was observed by the deshielding and subsequent shift in both peak values from 157 and 163 ppm to 163 and 174 ppm respectively. The comparatively small shift in ppm value suggests that coordination with Hg2+ is assisted by solvent and water molecules. The observed deshielding is indicative of the shift in electron density from the carbonyl oxygen atoms to the Hg2+ orbitals. It is postulated that the lone pair of electrons on the oxygen atoms are involved in coordination, resulting in a less noticeable shift than donation from the C = O π-bond.
FT-IR spectral analysis of the solid AD1-Hg2+ complex confirmed the involvement of the carbonyl functionalities towards Hg2+ complexation, and the coordination of NO3- with the N,N-dimethylaniline substituent (Figure 11). Furthermore, the FT-IR showed evidence of a tautomeric form of AD1 by which the C-N connection of the dimethylaniline derivative can isomerize between a single- and double-bond via the lone electron pair on the nitrogen atom. As a result, the % transmittance of the signal pertaining to the C=N tautomer decreases drastically upon NO3- addition due to the involvement of the nitrogen lone pair towards coordination. In AD1, the signals at 1740 and 1694 cm-1 are due to the C=O vibrations. The tautomeric C=N vibration of the dimethylaniline derivative is observed at 1599 cm-1. The azo N=N stretching is assigned at 1355 cm-1 whilst the C-N vibrations of the azo nitrogen connectivity to the Figure 12. Computational calculations showing the optimized and most preferred binding site of Hg2+ and NO3- with AD1. The Hg2+ cation is encircled in purple.
coumarin and aniline derivatives, and the C-N vibration from the aniline derivative is registered at 1235 cm-1. Upon complexation, the signals pertaining to the C=O and C=N functionalities showed a drastic reduction in % transmittance. This suggests analyte coordination which greatly prohibits characteristic bond vibrations by “locking” atoms and functionalities in place and preventing tautomerism in the aniline derivative. The two new absorbance bands between 3000-3500 cm-1 and 1000-1500 cm-1 are suggested to arise due to the absorption of water, acetonitrile, and nitrate onto AD1.76 Additionally, the new signal observed at 522 cm-1 is indicative of metal-oxygen ν(M-O) interactions.44,77,78
Computational analysis confirmed the proposed binding site of Hg2+ and the NO3- counterion with AD1. Calculations of the most preferred binding site agree with what has been shown in the NMR and FT-IR experiments. The most preferred binding site of both ions are shown in Figure 12. The most energetically preferred conformer of Hg2+ complexation involves the coumarin and ester carbonyl oxygen atoms; with complexation supported by nitrate and solvent molecules. The binding of NO3- with the dimethylaniline substituent was confirmed, accounting for the observable changes in the 1H & 13C NMR and FT-IR spectral analysis.
3.3. Extended applications
3.3.1. Molecular logic gate based on the reversible nature of AD1
Processing input signals by logic gates is one of the focal points in information technology. In recent years, an expanding number of exploratory efforts have been invested to the development of molecular logic gates owing to their practicality.38 Molecular logic gates are molecules able to execute logical responses by receiving one or more physical or chemical input signals and yielding a singular output. Such input and output responses may include chemical processes, such as ionic recognition and with output signals based on spectral response.39 The cyclic reversible nature of AD1 to Hg2+ upon sequential additions of EDTA illustrates the digital action of the sensor and thus it was applied towards a Boolean function molecular logic gate. The two chemical inputs, “input 1” (Hg2+), and “input 2” (EDTA) were defined as binary ‘1’ and ‘0’ states representing their presence and absence, respectively. The appearance and disappearance of the absorbance peak at 422 nm was considered as “output” for the logic gate and assigned as binary states ‘1’ and ‘0’ respectively. AD1 exhibited a UV-Vis absorption peak at 422 nm thus the output is designated as ‘1’. After the addition of Hg2+ (input 1 = 1; input 2 = 0) the absorbance decreased to the final absorbance Figure 14. Absorbance output for AD1 corresponding to the six possible ordered input combinations at 422 nm. Experiments conducted in acetonitrile.
value (output=0) (Figure S.16). However, upon the introduction of EDTA to the sensor-analyte complex, the absorbance increased to its initial intensity. Considering the other input combinations ((0,0), (0,1), and (1,1)), the output is equal to ‘1’. This established a clear “on-off-on” input/output spectral response of AD1 in the presence and absence of Hg2+ and EDTA imitates the IMPLICATION type logic gate at molecular level. In other words, the Boolean function provides and output of ‘1’ in all situations, except for the case where one input is ‘1’ (described here as Hg2+). The proposed logic circuit together with the truth table is shown in Figure 13.
3.3.2. Molecular keypad lock
The molecular or chemical computing keypad lock systems have been utilized as a modern strategy for information security and data-restriction applications.29,79 In the present work, the proposed molecular model was used to construct a sequence-dependent molecular keypad lock based on the appreciable selectivity and reversibility of AD1 with Hg2+ and EDTA. Herein, AD1, Hg2+, and EDTA are introduced as the three chemical inputs (labelled A, H, and E respectively). The six possible ordered input combinations are AHE, AEH, HAE, HEA, EAH, and EHA. The specific ordered combination of chemical compounds that can produce the same absorbance response at 422 nm of AD1 in the absence of Hg2+ is able to “unlock” the system, much like a combination lock. The combination ‘AHE’ produced the identical absorbance response compared to that of AD1 alone, whereas contrasting output was unveiled for the remaining five combination inputs (Fig. 14). Although other input signals attain an absorbance intensity in reach of AD1 alone, they do not achieve the correct “turn-on” absorbance response able to “unlock” the system.
3.3.3. On-site assay studies
Portable sensing methods for mercury detection and/or quantification warrants detection technologies that can be easily interpreted and manipulated by inexperienced personnel and general population. Given the many ways in which information can be related, optical readouts are among the easiest to interpret. Accordingly, detection based on a naked-eye colorimetric responses using inexpensive and disposable paper substrates are an attractive alternative to conventional analyte detection methods.80 Cellulose, a large constituent of paper, contains numerous hydroxyl and carboxyl groups; thus, the surface of commonly used filter papers contains negatively charged adsorption sites. Therefore, they exhibit sorption potential for heavy metals.81 However, there is a clear technological advantage of the laboratory environment over on-site assay methods, however, they are usually hefty and non-portable. Therefore, techniques which are bound to the laboratory environment are at a disadvantage if to consider environmental monitoring and widespread on-line and on-site sensing. To investigate the practical capabilities of AD1 towards on-site naked-eye Hg2+ determination, a cellulose paper-strip method has been applied. To do this, strips of Whatman filter paper is exposed to a solution of AD1 (0.001 M) and then dried in air. A constant aliquot of different molar concentrations of Hg2+ (ranging from 3.7-37 µM) was added sequentially to individual test-strips. The prepared paper strips were orange in the absence of Hg2+. Upon Hg2+ addition, visible naked-eye colour change from orange to pink was observed. The intensity of the colour increased as the concentration of the Hg2+ solution used increased. A visible colour change was observed from an Hg2+ concentration as low as 3.7 µM. Therefore, this solid- and liquid-state sensing method offers simpler, cost-effective methods for naked-eye on-site detection of Hg2+ (Figure 15).
3.3.4. Quantitative determination of Hg2+ in real-world water samples
The reliability and practical applicability of AD1 was studied by collecting various water samples from different areas of the ‘Swartkops’ river system in the Eastern Cape Province of South Africa. Samples were collected from three different sites in the system, namely the upper, middle, and estuary (mouth) (Figure S.17). The system is bordered by different residential suburbs, one of which is an informal settlement named Motherwell. Additionally, the river flows adjacent to numerous industrial sites and wastewater treatment works (WWTW’s) located further upstream from where sampling occurred. The introduction of competing cations, anions, and pollutants by anthropogenic and industrial activities into the water system has been investigated for many years. Poorly maintained WWTW’s, polluted stormwater runoff and solid waste have all contributed to the deterioration in the water quality of the Swartkops river and estuary. It has been reported that elevated levels of heavy metals in the sediment can be a good indication of anthropogenic activities. Studies have found concentrations of chromium, lead, zinc, titanium, manganese, strontium, copper, iron, and tin in the sediments of the Swartkops. Results indicated that the highest heavy metal concentrations (in both the river and mouth) were recorded where the runoff from the surrounding informal settlements and industrial sites entered the system.82,83 The ‘Motherwell Canal’, which runs into the river, has been identified as a major source of nitrogen (particularly as NH4+). The river has also been found to contain phosphorus, with excessive inputs from the cumulative effect of three wastewater treatment plants upstream.84
Spike and recovery method was used to evaluate the concentration of Hg2+ in these three water samples. To conduct this experiment, a standard curve was calculated by spiking the solution of AD1 with Hg2+ (0.94–7.5 µM) and measuring the resulting optical density. Absorbance values were determined in a 50:50 mixture (by volume) of CH3CN:H2O (Figure S.18). The suspended and insoluble particles were removed from the collected samples by means of a syringe-filter. To ensure a steady-state system, 50:50 (by volume) of the environmental water sample and acetonitrile was used for the recovery experiments. Increasing concentrations of Hg2+ were added to the samples and the resulting absorbance intensity recorded. For each location (A, B, C) from which samples were collected, three duplicate spike and recover analyses were tested under analogous conditions. The real water sample analysis data is shown in Table 1. The calculated recovery for the known amount of Hg2+ added was between 98–100%. Results indicate that AD1 shows remarkable selectivity towards Hg2+ regardless of the presence of competing cations, anions, and soluble pollutants described above. Furthermore, the increase in salinity from upstream location ‘A’ to mouth location ‘C’ had little to no effect on the sensing capabilities and selectivity of AD1 towards Hg2+. Henceforth, chemosensor AD1 shows promising applications for mercury determination in real-world samples.
Table 1
Detection of Hg2+ in real-world water samples using AD1.
Sample
|
Hg2+
spiked (µM)
|
Hg2+
recovered (µM)
mean (a), ± SD(b)
|
% Recovery
|
A
(Upper)
|
0.95
|
0.948 ± 0.005
|
99.84
|
2.82
|
2.812 ± 0.002
|
99.71
|
4.94
|
4.929 ± 0.003
|
99.79
|
6.56
|
6.559 ± 0.003
|
99.99
|
B
(Middle)
|
0.95
|
0.945 ± 0.006
|
99.53
|
2.82
|
2.796 ± 0.006
|
99.17
|
4.94
|
4.926 ± 0.003
|
99.71
|
6.56
|
6.546 ± 0.002
|
99.79
|
C
(Estuary)
|
0.95
|
0.940 ± 0.01
|
98.99
|
2.82
|
2.818 ± 0.012
|
99.96
|
4.94
|
4.938 ± 0.006
|
99.97
|
6.56
|
6.491 ± 0.023
|
98.95
|
a Mean of three measurements, b Standard deviation. |