Study population
The clinical data of 554 patients with upper ureteral calculi and renal calculi who were treated by retrograde flexible ureteroscopy and holmium laser lithotripsy from February 2018 to September 2021 were retrospectively analyzed in our center. The included patients were those with non-incarcerated upper ureteral calculi or renal calculi who were successfully treated with unilateral, single flexible ureteroscopy and holmium laser lithotripsy and in whose cases, the cumulative calculi maximum length diameter (CMD) measured by CT scan was 10~20mm. The CMD was calculated by measuring the maximum length diameter of the stone according to the CT 3D reconstruction images. The following cases were excluded from this study, including patients with calculi complicated with ipsilateral ureteral stenosis, patients with calculi complicated with pyonephrosis or severe infection, patients with calculi of special types, such as horseshoe kidney, medullary sponge kidney, duplication kidney, transplanted kidney, ectopic kidney, and etc., and patients who had received radiotherapy for abdominal and pelvic tumors. Before operation, all patients received physical examination, urinalysis, urine culture, abdominal CT scan and urinary ultrasonography. The degree of hydronephrosis was judged by the results of ultrasonography. Hydronephrosis was classified into four types, i.e., no hydronephrosis, mild hydronephrosis, moderate hydronephrosis and severe hydronephrosis. All demographic characteristics and preoperative parameters were recorded. The stones characteristics, such as the CMD and CT value of calculi were also recorded. The mean CT values for calculi were calculated from the mean CT values for three different areas of the largest cross-section of the calculi in the CT scan. Complications including surgical complications and stent associated complications were graded retrospectively according to the modified Clavien-Dindo classification [10]. All patients signed informed consent and the study was approved by the Ethics Committee of The Second Affiliated Hospital of Soochow University.
The grouping principle was as follows. The patients were informed of the operation process and whether the Double-J stents were retained in the ureter before and after operation. With due respect of the patients’ willingness, they were divided into three groups. The group of postoperative Double-J stent free (Post-F) group consists of patients with pre indwelling Double-J stent (6Fr) before operation and no Double-J stent after operation. The Routine group consists of patients with the preoperative stenting and postoperative stenting of the Double-J stents (6Fr) both performed. The preoperative Double-J stent free (Pre-F) group consists of patients without preoperative stenting before operation and with indwelling Double-J stent (6Fr) after operation. In the preoperative Double-J stent free group, if it was found that the ureter diameter of the cases was thin and the flexible ureteroscopy delivery sheath could not be successfully inserted, a 6Fr Double-J stent would be retained in the ureter for 2 to 3 weeks, after which the flexible ureteroscopy operation would be performed. And correspondingly, cases of this type were excluded from the preoperative Double-J stent free group and assigned to the postoperative Double-J stent free group and the Routine group with due respect of the patients’ willingness.
Surgical Procedures
All procedures were performed by a deputy chief physician with extensive experience in flexible ureteroscopy. The patients were treated with general anesthesia and pendulum lithotomy position. Under direct vision, a 9.5Fr rigid ureteroscope was inserted from the external urethral orifice to the bladder. If the double J stent was placed preoperatively, it would be removed. By using a guide wire, a rigid ureteroscope was inserted into the ureter to the renal pelvis for routine examination. In the cases with upper ureteral calculi, the calculi would be pushed back to the renal pelvis, while the guide wire would be retained and the rigid ureteroscope would be withdrawn. A flexible ureteroscopy delivery sheath was inserted under the guidance of the wire and a constant pressure perfusion pump was connected or a hand-push syringe may be used for perfusion. The Olympus electronic flexible ureteroscope was inserted into the renal pelvis through the flexible ureteroscopy sheath, and the renal pelvis and all renal calyces were examined for calculi. A 200μm holmium laser fiber was used with laser energy and frequency set as follows (fragmentation mode: 1.2~1.5J/15Hz, pulverization mode: 0.8~1.0J/20~25Hz). The calculi was crushed to a diameter of less than 4mm. During the operation, the larger calculi fragments, especially which deposited in the lower group of renal calyces, would be removed with a stone retrieval basket. In the postoperative Double-J free group, a 5Fr ureteral catheter would be temporarily placed in the ureter at the end of the operation and removed 48-72 hours after the operation. In the preoperative Double-J stent free group and the Routine group, a new 6Fr double J stent would be placed in the ureter at the end of the operation and removed under cystoscope one month after the operation.
Postoperative Procedures and the Follow-up
All patients were followed up for 6 months. Ultrasonography and KUB (or abdominal CT scan) were performed at the end of time intervals of 1, 3 and 6 months after operation. All imaging data were compared with those before operation, and it would be regarded as a complete stone clearance if no stone was found or stone fragments found were no more than 2mm in diameter. The differences of demographic characteristics, preoperative parameters, stone characteristics, operative time, operative complications, double J stent associated complications, and stone free rate among three groups were compared.
Statistical Analysis
Continuous data were summarized using the mean ± SD and compared by one-way ANOVA test. Categorical variables were compared using the chi-square test or Fisher’s exact test. The statistical package for the social science (SPSS Inc, Chicago, Illinois, USA) version 19.0 was used for statistical analysis. P<0.05 was considered as having a statistical significance.