3.2. The solubilization of tricalcium and rock phosphates (TCP and RP) in liquid medium
Phosphate solubilizing activity of P. oxalicum on a PVK solid medium was confirmed, so P. oxalicum should be tested for its ability on and liquid medium in the presence of RP and TCP [40, 41].
Data presented in Table 4 present the amount of solubilized P (µg/ml) in PVK liquid medium containing TCP or RP and RP (equivalent to 100 mg P2O5/100 ml). P. oxalicum has demonstrated the ability to solubilize P in a liquid media. The inorganic, insoluble phosphate had been efficiently transformed into a soluble form by P. oxalicum. The acid phosphatase activity for P. oxalicum was determined and recorded in Table 5. The maximum phosphatase activity released, varied between the isolates from 3rd to 9th day. The amount of phosphatase released by P. oxalicum ranged from (200 to 310 EU ml− 1) either in presence of RP or TCP. It was seen that the production of phosphatase decreased from 3rd to 5th day. This proves that the P. oxalicum produced a high amount of phosphatase on 9th day (310 and 300 EU, in TCP, and RP respectively).
After 1 week of incubation, the fungal mycelium was filtered and dried at 45°C followed by measuring its dry weight and pH. The results showed that Increasing P solubilization resulting a significant decrease in PH value and no relation between dry way and p solubilization (Table 4).
Table 4
Phosphate solubilizing ability of P. oxalicum in PKV broth supplemented with TCP or RP on day 7th of incubation
TCP
|
RP
|
pH
|
P-released in medium (mg P ml-1)
|
Mycelium DW (g 50ml-1)
|
pH
|
P-released in medium (mg P ml-1)
|
Mycelium DW (g 50ml-1)
|
3.90 ± 0.9
|
396 ± 13
|
0.225 ± 0.023
|
4.24 ± 0.04
|
295 ± 7
|
0.355 ± 0.83
|
Values are Mean ± SD (n = 3) DW: dry weight TCP: tricalcium phosphate RP: rock phosphate
Table 5
production of phosphatase activity (µg PNP ml− 1 l h− 1) in PKV liquid medium after different incubation periods (day).
Incubation periods (day)
|
|
3
|
5
|
7
|
9
|
TCP
|
240
|
200
|
240
|
310
|
RP
|
210
|
200
|
225
|
300
|
3.3. Phosphate solubilization in liquid medium under salt stress
From the results of clearing zone, pH, phosphatase activity, and phosphatase activity in a liquid medium, P. oxalicum showed its ability of p solubilization. Now P. oxalicum can be applied in a liquid medium under different salinity levels. Pe. oxalicum was tested in Pikovskaya’s medium when different concentrations of NaCl as a source of salinity (0, 2, 4, 6, and 8%) were used at 30°C for 5 days. The calculation of variance revealed that salt had a significant effect on the isolates' ability to solubilize phosphate and that the isolates differed in their ability to do so (Table 6). P. oxalicum demonstrated a slower rate of solubilization at the highest concentration of NaCl (8%). P. oxalicum gave the best results at a concentration of NaCl (2%), which was (78.73 mg/ml). When the concentration of NaCl is increased, the activity decreases. This is owing to salt-reduced solubilization efficiency by suppressing cell multiplication, lowering solubilization efficiency, or chloride ions (Cl-) sequester or neutralizing protons or acids produced in the media. [42]. The solubilization of phosphate in the liquid media was usually accompanied by a drop in the pH of the medium. For all isolates, the analysis of variance noted there is a significant effect on pH medium reached to (P < 0.01) (Table 6).
After 1 week of incubation, the fungal mycelium was filtered and dried at 65 °C followed by measuring their dry weight. P. oxalicum exhibited an increase in the dry weight at 8% NaCl, (Table 6 and Fig. 2). The solubilization of phosphate and the decreasing pH of the medium had a negative significant correlation reached to (r = -0.6758) (Table 6).
Table 6
Amounts of solubilized phosphate (µg ml− 1) in Pikovskaya’s medium under different concentrations of NaCl (%).
parameters
|
NaCl concentration (%)
|
0
|
2
|
4
|
6
|
8
|
Amounts of solubilized phosphate (µg ml-1)
|
64.75 ± 4.06a
|
78.73 ± 5.67a
|
75.80 ± 8.57a
|
45.67 ± 1.31b
|
43.50 ± 1.10b
|
pH
|
5.17 ± 0.09b
|
5.15 ± 0.06b
|
5.22 ± 0.11ab
|
5.14 ± 0.08b
|
5.72 ± 0.38a
|
Dry weight
|
0.580 ± 0.06b
|
0.580 ± 0.05c
|
0.615 ± 0.08b
|
0.595 ± 0.04a
|
0.470 ± 0.05b
|
phosphatase activity (µg PNP ml-1 l h-1)
|
290
|
340
|
300
|
260
|
230
|
Means amounts of P205 ± the SD. Figures in the same Row followed by the same letters are not significantly different (p > 0.05) based on Duncan’s multiple range tests
Table 7
The correlation coefficient between salinity, phosphate solubilization, and pH.
Source of variation
|
Df
|
P2O5 (mg ml-1)
|
pH
|
r2
|
Salinity(S1)
|
4
|
9798.11912**
|
2.09014**
|
-0.6758**
|
Strains (S)
|
9
|
3193.41812**
|
1.71681**
|
S1xS
|
36
|
1240.80964**
|
0.26392**
|
Error
|
90
|
63.49535
|
0.05576
|
3.4. Characterization [P. oxalicum/P2O5 + Ca3(PO4)2]BHC.
3.4.1. Raman spectrum of [P. oxalicum/P2O5 + Ca3(PO4)2]BHC thin films.
The other active Raman bands were attributed to P–O stretching (1016 cm− 1 and 988 cm− 1), P–O–P deformation (460 cm− 1 and 377 cm− 1), absorption bands at 959 and 974 cm− 1 throughout the spectra. The ν1symmetric stretching mode of PO4 ions causes these bands, whereas antisymmetric ν3 vibrations cause bands of intermediate strength at 1020 and 1082 cm− 1[43]. Mono substituted benzene near appears 1003 − 999 cm− 1 stretching band. In [P. oxalicum/P2O5 + Ca3(PO4)2]BHC Raman band appears at -999 cm− 1 which is assigned to trigonal ring breathing mode [44]. weak beak appears at 339 and 397which is assigned to C-C aliphatic chain and 530 cm− 1 which is attributed to S-S. The medium band appears between 490–660 which is attributed to C-I. Medium bands appear in [P. oxalicum/P2O5 + Ca3(PO4)2]BHC at 800–950 cm− 1 which attributed to C-O-C [45]. The little deviation between experiential and stimulation is that the studied calculation was done in a vacuum, Although the calculations of experiential were done in a solid-state. Because the ligands analyzed contain complicated vibrational modes, and ring modes degrade at the same rate as imitative modes, they contribute to low symmetry, making it harder to assign to torsion and all plane modes.. [17].
3.4.2. Geometry study for [P. oxalicum/P2O5 + Ca3(PO4)2]BHC as an isolated molecule
The most stable highest occupied and lowest unoccupied molecular orbitals (HOMO and LUMO) in the ground gaseous state were determined using M062X/6–31 + G(d,p) calculations. and presented in Fig. 4. The difference in energy between the fragment molecular orbitals theory (FMOs) determines the equilibrium state of the molecule, which is important for determining the electrical conductivity and grasping electricity transit. Isolated compounds are stable if their entropy values are completely negative [46]. An aromatic compound electrophilic sites may be deduced using the observed FMOs. When dimer molecule bonds (DMB) grew and bond length reduced, the Gutmann at variance technique was used on the DMB sites to enhance the HOMO energy (\({E}_{H}\)) [47]. These properties were determined by looking at the optimized energy gap (\({E}_{g}^{Opt})\), as well as the reactivity and stability of the molecular system. Softness and hardness are the most critical factors in determining the stability and responsiveness [48, 49]. From the calculated electronegativity equation (χ) \(= ({E}_{H}+{E}_{L})/2\), and the energy bandgap which explains the link between charge transport in the molecule were demonstrated in Table 8.
The HOMO level is frequently found on Ca3(PO4)2 which are prime targets for nucleophilic attacks. From Fig. 4, we observed that the HOMO energy of [P. oxalicum/P2O5 + Ca3(PO4)2] BHC in gaseous state is-5.738 (which is an extremely large value), respectively. This value indicated high excitation energies and, high stability for [P. oxalicum/P2O5 + Ca3(PO4)2]BHC. On the other hand, the lower value energy LUMO= -2.796 eV can be due to the softer and more polarizable which concentrated on πfor [P. oxalicum/P2O5 + Ca3(PO4)2]BHC in a gaseous state, respectively. Because soft molecules can supply electrons to an acceptor, they are referred to as reactive molecules rather than hard molecules. The most intriguing descriptor is the quantified compounds index electrophilicity (ω). As the device absorbs external electronic charges, it predicts energy stability [50, 51].
There were numerous conformers studied for the ground state geometry in quantum-chemical calculations and the conformer with the lowest energy was selected, which was validated by the harmonic vibrational frequency. The dimer's binding energies were adjusted for the basis set superposition error using the counterpoise correction technique BSSE. The binding energies of [P. oxalicum/P2O5 + Ca3(PO4)2]BHC dimers and single molecules are − 5,023.472 and − 2494.236 kcal/mol [52]. The binding energies (\({\Delta }{\text{E}}_{\text{b}}\)) of dimers were calculated using the following formula at the same level of theory: \({\Delta }{\text{E}}_{\text{b}}={E}_{dimer}-2{E}_{monomer}\). To gain a better understanding of the nature of intermolecular interactions, the TDDFT/DMOl3 approach was used on the examined compounds and their dimers. [53]. Figure 5 illustrates the examined molecule's intermolecular interactions, which include ionic and coordinated bonds, Ca----P, Ca—O, and O—P. The lengths of the lowest different type bonds are 3.645 Å, 4.50 Å, and 4.418 Å for O—P, Ca----P, and Ca—O for [P. oxalicum/P2O5+Ca3(PO4)2]BHC dimers, respectively. On the other hand, the centroid lengths of the dimer are 1.493 Å, 1.704 Å, and 2.088 Å for biohybrid nanocomposite dimers [54, 55]. Because the intermolecular distance between the two dimers is greater than 3.50 Ả, the rings of both molecules are unable to rotate around the single bonds. Whereas the centroid length of the dimer is less than 3.50 Å, the molecule rings rotate around the centroid point [56]. The dihedral angles (\(\varTheta\))of (O-P-Ca), (O-P-O), and (O-Ca-O) for [P. oxalicum/P2O5 + Ca3(PO4)2]BHC dimers isolated molecule is \(67.246^\circ \le \varTheta \le 112.955^\circ\). It has been concluded that when two isolated molecules are attached (as polymerization case) by π bonding in phenylene diamine moiety, the lengths bond, centroid lengths, centroid angle, and dihedral angle [57].
Table 8
Calculated \({E}_{H}\), \({E}_{L}\), global hardness (η), chemical potential (µ), electronegativity (χ), global softness (S), and global electrophilicity index (ω), \({N}_{max}\) and σ for [P. oxalicum/P2O5 + Ca3(PO4)2]BHC as an isolated molecule.
Compound
|
\({E}_{H}\)
|
\({E}_{L}\)
|
\(\varDelta {E}_{g}^{Opt.}\)
|
χ (eV)
|
µ (eV)
|
η (eV)
|
S (eV)
|
ω (eV)
|
\({\varDelta N}_{max}\)
|
σ(eV)−1
|
\({\left({\Delta }{\text{E}}_{\text{b}}\right)}^{}\)
|
[1]
|
-5.738
|
-2.796
|
2.942
|
4.267
|
-4.267
|
-1.471
|
-0.340
|
-6.189
|
-2.901
|
-0.680
|
35
|
Dimer
|
-5.251
|
-2.345
|
2.906
|
3.798
|
-3.798
|
-1.453
|
-0.344
|
-4.964
|
-2.614
|
-0.688
|
|
[1]= [P. oxalicum/P2O5 + Ca3(PO4)2]BHC
3.4.3. Optical properties of [P. oxalicum/P2O5 + Ca3(PO4)2]BHC.
Understanding the basic absorption edge in the UV region is critical to our film's transition and band structure. Figure 6 indicates the recorded experimental absorption spectra of the thin [P. oxalicum/P2O5 + Ca3(PO4)2]BHC where two bands at 378 nm and 465 nm as the main peak, and 517 nm as minor peak were observed. As can be observed, absorption reduces significantly as the UV wavelength increases [58]. This drop might be due to the observed decrease in the crystallinity of the films in this condition [59]. The TD-DFT analysis was used to examine the theoretical optical response of [P. oxalicum/P2O5 + Ca3(PO4)2]BHC as an isolated molecule at 250 > λ(nm) > 600. The TD-DFT/CASTEP findings were used to compare the absorption bands of the fabricated thin films with a thickness of 100 ± 5 nm developed at 298 K is indicated in Fig. 6. The theoretical and experimental photo-absorption spectrum showed the main absorption attributed to π–π* electronic transitions in phenylene diamine matric structure [60–62].
3.5 Pot experiment:
After 60 days of seeding, the effect of PSF inoculation on canola was assessed by evaluating different growth characteristics such as shoot and root lengths, as well as their fresh and dry weights (Tables 5 and 6). PSF inoculation in the presence of TCP and RP increased plant growth parameters more than commercial SSP alone. The canola plants, on the other hand, had a considerable increase in growth parameters when TCP was used as the phosphate source, which was comparable to the SSP treatments. When RP was used as a phosphate source, the canola plants showed an increase in all parameters, but not as much as the SSP and TCP treatments. P. oxalicum as SPF cultures has the potential in enhancing the growth parameters of canola in the presence of TCP and RP.
3.5.1. Soil sample physiochemical analyses.
Some physical and chemical parameters of soil used in the pot experiment were studied as salinity, Electric conductivity (EC), pH, Total P, and Available P as in Table 9.
Table 9
Some chemical, physical and microbiological properties of soil used with various treatments
Treatments
|
pH
|
EC (dS m− 1)
|
Total P. (%)
|
Available P. (%)
|
T.C. (x106)
|
T.F (x103))
|
PSF (x104)
|
Control
|
7.80
|
2.6
|
0.156
|
0.048
|
1.50
|
3.5
|
1.5
|
Salinity
|
7.40
|
3.74
|
0.236
|
0.051
|
0.15
|
11.0
|
2.5
|
RP
|
7.70
|
3.28
|
0.266
|
0.082
|
3.50
|
12.0
|
2.0
|
TCP
|
7.70
|
3.25
|
0.182
|
0.074
|
3.5
|
19.5
|
1.0
|
SSP
|
7.70
|
4.11
|
0.158
|
0.096
|
3.00
|
8.0
|
1.0
|
3.5.2. Effect of RP and TCP on canola height.
In the presence of diverse phosphor sources as TCP, RP, and SSP, the effects of P. oxalicum inoculation with the presence of NaCl as a source of salinity on root and shoot length were found to be substantial (Table 5). Furthermore, significant differences with the root and shoot length of canola were observed among the treatments at 60 DAP due to various composite inoculation treatments. The plant height, shoot, and root length of canola plants increased significantly with dual inoculation with fungal supernatant and fungal spore suspension compared with single inoculation and control at 60 days after planting. IT was observed the highest plant height and shoot length were noted in the treatment RP inoculated with P. oxalicum (148and 120 cm, respectively), whereas slight differences were recorded between other treatments. Meanwhile, a non-significant rise was found in the treatments either in root length or canola height, but there is a significant increase in the presence of SSP. In general, the results of this study demonstrate that salinity stress affects some physiological processes in canola. The enhancement of salinity decreased shoot and root length for control plants (Table 10). It is founded that salinity appears to have a greater impact on root length than on shoot length. The extract of P. oxalicum yielded the shortest shoot and root lengths compared to P. oxalicum and P. oxalicum + its extract.
Table 10
The influence of PSF on plant height, shoot, and root length of canola plants fertilized with various sources of P after 60 days of sowing.
Treatments
|
Control
|
SSP
|
TCP
|
RP
|
(A)
|
(B)
|
(C)
|
(A)
|
(B)
|
(C)
|
(A)
|
(B)
|
(C)
|
(A)
|
(B)
|
(C)
|
|
Control
|
46e
|
10e
|
50f
|
106b
|
27a
|
133a
|
70e
|
18b
|
88e
|
76f
|
50d
|
15c
|
|
P. oxalicum
|
83b
|
23a
|
106b
|
105b
|
22b
|
127c
|
102a
|
27a
|
129a
|
120a
|
28a
|
148a
|
|
EX P. oxalicum
|
60d
|
12d
|
72e
|
56d
|
15e
|
71e
|
68e
|
14c
|
82f
|
58e
|
11d
|
69f
|
|
P. oxalicum + EX
|
87b
|
20b
|
107b
|
110a
|
22b
|
132a
|
89c
|
25a
|
114c
|
103c
|
21b
|
124c
|
|
(A): Shoot length (cm); (B): Root Length (cm) and (C): Plants height (cm), Mean was done and there is not significantly different at P = 0.05 (Duncan's test) the same letter within columns.
3.5.3. Effect of RP and TCP on canola dry weight.
Due to P.oxalicum incubation, significant differences in shoot and root dry weight of the Canola plant were identified among the treatments. (Table 11). The inoculation treatment with P. oxalicum + Ex in presence of TCP is (52.59 g) and gives the maximum shoot dry weight. followed by P. oxalicum + Ex (52.59 g) in presence of SSP (43.19g) followed by P. oxalicum (43.19 g) in presence of TCP and then by P. oxalicum + Ex (52.59 g) in presence of RP. The overall dry matter content of canola plants was also increased following root and shoot growth. Table 11 shows the results of the R:S ratio as a function of P. oxalicum inoculation treatments at 60 DAPs. The highest R:S ratio is noted in the control treatment in the combined inoculation treatment (P. oxalicum + Ex (0.27)). The extract of P. oxalicum recorded the lowest R:S ratio (0.08 and 0.08) with SSP and TCP, respectively. (Fig. 7).
Table 11
Effect of PSF on a shoot, roots dry weight(g), and R:S ratio of canola plants fertilizer with different sources of phosphate after 60 days of sowing
Treatments
|
CONTROL
|
SSP
|
TCP
|
RP
|
A
|
B
|
C
|
A
|
B
|
C
|
A
|
B
|
C
|
A
|
B
|
C
|
Control
|
19.70d
|
3.00d
|
0.32a
|
42.68
|
3.47
|
0.08
|
28.43
|
3.06
|
0.11
|
31.92
|
4.68
|
0.15
|
P. oxalicum
|
24.56b
|
4.25bc
|
0.17d
|
38.53b
|
5.47
|
0.14
|
43.19
|
6.41
|
0.15
|
35.76
|
6.72
|
0.19
|
EX P. oxalicum
|
14.90f
|
3.20d
|
0.22c
|
27.54
|
2.78
|
0.10
|
27.11
|
2.20
|
0.08
|
23.58
|
3.13
|
0.13
|
P. oxalicum + EX
|
22.15c
|
6.00a
|
0.27b
|
45.84c
|
5.53
|
0.12
|
52.59
|
5.46
|
0.10
|
42.84
|
5.82
|
0.14
|
A): Shoot dry weight (g); (B): Root dry weight (g) and (C): R:S ratio dry weight (g), (A): Shoot length (cm); (B): Root Length (cm) and (C): Plants height (cm), Mean was done and there is not significantly different at P = 0.05 (Duncan's test) the same letter within columns.
3.5.4. Effect of RP and TCP on Canola P. Content and uptake.
Data of Canola P content and uptake illustrated in (Table 12) which showed that the single inoculation with P. expansum or with extract of P. expansum in presence of SSP or RP or TCP noted the highest important value of P content in the plant of canola compared to uninoculated control. Single inoculation treatment with P. oxalicum in the presence of RP or TCP fertilizer P uptake in comparison to all other treatments was substantially higher. The P-uptake, on the other hand, was lowest in the uninoculated control group.
Table 12
Effect of PSF on Canola P. content (%) and P uptake (mg plant− 1) fertilized with different sources of phosphate
Treatments
|
CONTROL
|
SSP
|
TCP
|
RP
|
|
P content
|
P uptake
|
P content
|
P uptake
|
P content
|
P uptake
|
P content
|
P uptake
|
Control
|
0.062d
|
19.89c
|
0.125b
|
57.69c
|
0.098d
|
30.89
|
0.118a
|
43.19e
|
P. oxalicum
|
0.108a
|
31.12b
|
0.109d
|
47.74d
|
0.115b
|
57.04
|
0.115b
|
48.85d
|
EX P. oxalicum
|
0.071c
|
12.85e
|
0.078e
|
23.65e
|
0.104c
|
30.48
|
0.099d
|
26.44f
|
P. oxalicum + EX
|
0.109a
|
30.68b
|
0.113c
|
58.05c
|
0.114b
|
66.18
|
0.119a
|
57.91c
|
Mean was done and there is no significant difference at P = 0.05 (Duncan's test) the same letter within columns. |
3.5.5. Total phosphate solubilization microorganisms (PSM).
Table 13 shows that inoculation with P. oxalicum in the form of spores, supernatant, or both significantly raised total PSM counts for all mineral phosphate fertilizer sources. When comparing uninoculated control plants to inoculated control plants, the acquired data demonstrated an increase in counts in inoculated pots in the duration of planting from 28 to 45 days. These increases in the T.C. of P. oxalicum populations could be attributed to the isolated fungi's ability to survive under NaCl stress (Tables 13, 14, and 115) (the experimental soil is saline), as well as their potential effect on phosphorus solubilization (Tables 13, 14, and 15). The stimulation, on the other hand, varied depending on the source of P used. This was true both in the beginning and later stages of growth development. P. oxalicum, in particular, in the fertilization with RP or TCP compared to SSP fertilizer, enhanced the improvement in counts. After 60 days of planting time, the differences between those two treatments and the uninoculated control could be seen. The average rise was around 67.05 percent in TCP and 60.57 percent in the RP. In general, the increased population of PSF in all treatments, both inoculated and uninoculated, reached their peak almost on the 30 days then declined at 45 days (Table 14) and stability to 60 DAP (Table 15). The introduced PSF increased its population in treatments inoculated with singly or with superintend. However, the population of PSF in the inoculated with superintending of P. oxalicum treatments did not exceed that in the uninoculated treatments.
Table 13
Effect of inoculation canola plants with PSF on the total count of bacteria, fungi, and phosphate solubilizing fungi (x104 g− 1 dry soil) after 28 days from sowing
Treatments
|
Control
|
SSP
|
TCP
|
RP
|
|
T.B
|
T.F
|
T. PSF
|
T.B
|
T.F
|
T.PSF
|
T.B
|
T.F
|
T. PSF
|
T.B
|
T.F
|
T. PSF
|
Control
|
130c
|
43c
|
28c
|
118a
|
15d
|
44f
|
90d
|
20bc
|
10f
|
210a
|
17de
|
23de
|
P. oxalicum
|
163a
|
89a
|
47b
|
80c
|
39a
|
22a
|
153a
|
17cd
|
12d
|
106e
|
30b
|
41b
|
EX P. oxalicum
|
100d
|
25e
|
21d
|
63e
|
32b
|
90e
|
87d
|
32a
|
22b
|
120d
|
14f
|
26d
|
P. oxalicum + EX
|
150b
|
82ab
|
157a
|
76d
|
9e
|
107c
|
127b
|
30a
|
25a
|
153b
|
20cd
|
52a
|
Mean was done and there is not significantly different at P = 0.05 (Duncan's test) the same letter within columns |
T. B = total bacteria, T.F.= total fungi, PSF = Phosphorous solubilizing fungi
Table 14
Effect of inoculation canola plants with PSF on the total count of bacteria, fungi, and phosphate solubilizing fungi (x104 g− 1 dry soil) after 45 days from sowing
Treatments
|
Control
|
SSP
|
TCP
|
RP
|
|
T.B
|
T. F
|
T. PSF
|
T. B
|
T. F
|
T.PSF
|
T.B
|
T. F
|
T. PSF
|
T.B
|
T. F
|
T.PSF
|
Control
|
3
|
20
|
1
|
8
|
15
|
2
|
15
|
10
|
2
|
3
|
10
|
1
|
P. oxalicum
|
1l
|
26
|
2
|
10
|
70
|
13
|
52
|
29
|
5
|
23
|
4
|
4
|
EX P.oxalicum
|
2
|
11
|
3
|
12
|
16
|
2
|
53
|
5
|
1
|
15
|
3
|
2
|
P. oxalicum + EX
|
4
|
16
|
4
|
19
|
57
|
16
|
12
|
6
|
4
|
74
|
7
|
4
|
T. B = total bacteria, T.F.= total fungi, PSF = Phosphorous solubilizing fungi |
Table 15
Effect of inoculation canola plants with PSF on the total count of bacteria, fungi, and phosphate solubilizing fungi (x104 g− 1 dry soil) after 60 days from sowing
Treatments
|
Control
|
SSP
|
TCP
|
RP
|
|
T.B
|
T.B
|
T.PSF
|
T.B
|
T. F
|
T. PSF
|
T.B
|
T.F
|
T.PSF
|
T.B
|
T.F
|
T. PSF
|
Control
|
3c
|
23c
|
18c
|
118a
|
15d
|
4f
|
9d
|
4bc
|
3f
|
2a
|
4de
|
2de
|
P. oxalicum
|
10a
|
89a
|
14b
|
8c
|
39a
|
12a
|
33a
|
7cd
|
5d
|
16e
|
3b
|
4b
|
EX P. oxalicum
|
2d
|
25e
|
16d
|
13e
|
32b
|
4e
|
27d
|
5a
|
2b
|
20d
|
4f
|
2d
|
P. oxalicum + EX
|
5b
|
82ab
|
17a
|
16d
|
9e
|
17c
|
12b
|
7a
|
5a
|
53b
|
6cd
|
5a
|
Mean was done and there is not significantly different at P = 0.05 (Duncan's test) the same letter within columns |
T. B = total bacteria, T.F.= total fungi, PSF = Phosphorous solubilizing fungi
3.5.6. Acidic phosphatase activity, available P, and pH in the rhizosphere of canola plants.
Data listed in Tables 16, 17, and 18 illustrated that a slight reduction in pH was noticed after 60 days of the final harvest. Furthermore, in all P sources, the final pH did not drop to extremely acidic values. In contrast, accessible P. rose in soils with fungal inoculums as compared to soils that were not inoculated. (Tables 16, 17, and 18). Plants inoculated with PSF gave a significant amount of available P in soil rhizosphere fertilizer with TCP or RP treatments compared to control. Higher values of soil available P were obtained at 45 days after planting (Table 17) and decreased to lower values at 60 days after planting (Table 18). Acidic phosphatase activity was detected in all PSF, but activities varied among the isolates (Tables16, 17, and 18). The activity of acid phosphatase in all inoculated treatment soils was higher than the uninoculated soil.
Table 16
Effect of different treatments of fungi on phosphate activity, available P, and pH value of soil after 28 days from sowing fertilizer with different sources of phosphate (28 days from sowing).
Treatments
|
Control
|
SSP
|
TCP
|
RP
|
|
P. ase
|
AP
|
pH
|
P. ase
|
Av P
|
pH
|
P. ase
|
AP
|
pH
|
P. ase
|
AP
|
pH
|
Control
|
6.14e
|
2.53d
|
7.81a
|
9.49c
|
4.70c
|
7.46a
|
11.96e
|
4.00f
|
7.20c
|
17.16c
|
4.18e
|
7.22f
|
P. oxalicum
|
14.27c
|
5.88b
|
7.55bc
|
24.53f
|
3.40cd
|
7.14ab
|
30.62a
|
10.57c
|
7.20a
|
33.83d
|
11.40c
|
7.41f
|
EX P. oxalicum
|
6.79d
|
2.00a
|
7.59cd
|
10.13f
|
7.30ab
|
7.21c
|
16.31a
|
5.67b
|
7.20a
|
17.00f
|
5.95cd
|
7.30ab
|
P.oxalicum + EX
|
15.45b
|
6.00a
|
7.44d
|
25.66c
|
7.90d
|
7.0ab
|
33.20f
|
11.44c
|
7.30a
|
36.45cd
|
11.66c
|
7.30cd
|
Table 17
Effect of inoculation with PSF on rhizosphere soil phosphatases activity, available P. and pH of canola(45 days from sowing).
Treatments
|
CONTROL
|
SSP
|
TCP
|
RP
|
|
P. ase
|
AP
|
pH
|
P. ase
|
Av P
|
pH
|
P. ase
|
AP
|
pH
|
P. ase
|
AP
|
pH
|
Control
|
3.53e
|
1.43d
|
7.61a
|
7.49c
|
4.70c
|
7.30a
|
8.11e
|
2.00f
|
7.10c
|
11.15c
|
2.18e
|
7.12c
|
P. oxalicum
|
10.47c
|
3.35c
|
7.39c
|
20.70a
|
3.40d
|
7.12c
|
20.74d
|
7.70ab
|
7.15b
|
29.90ab
|
7.90c
|
7.11c
|
EX P. oxalicum
|
4.62d
|
1.85d
|
7.41bc
|
6.05cd
|
7.30ab
|
7.11c
|
8.61e
|
3.27d
|
7.20a
|
7.80e
|
4.00d
|
7.30a
|
P. oxalicum + EX
|
12.75b
|
4.50a
|
7.35d
|
21.69a
|
7.90a
|
7.00d
|
27.60a
|
8.00a
|
7.10c
|
30.15a
|
9.00b
|
7.20b
|
* Mean was done and there is no significantly different at P = 0.05 (Duncan's test) the same letter within columns
SSP = superphosphate, TCP = tricalcium phosphate, RP = Rock phosphate, AV = available phosphate, P.ase = phosphatase
Table 17
Effect of inoculation with PSF on rhizosphere soil phosphatases activity, available P. and pH of canola
Treatments
|
CONTROL
|
SSP
|
TCP
|
RP
|
|
P. ase
|
AP
|
pH
|
P. ase
|
Av P
|
pH
|
P. ase
|
AP
|
pH
|
P. ase
|
AP
|
pH
|
Control
|
3.53e
|
1.43d
|
7.61a
|
7.49c
|
4.70c
|
7.30a
|
8.11e
|
2.00f
|
7.10c
|
11.15c
|
2.18e
|
7.12c
|
P. oxalicum
|
10.47c
|
3.35c
|
7.39c
|
20.70a
|
3.40d
|
7.12c
|
20.74d
|
7.70ab
|
7.15b
|
29.90ab
|
7.90c
|
7.11c
|
EX P. oxalicum
|
4.62d
|
1.85d
|
7.41bc
|
6.05cd
|
7.30ab
|
7.11c
|
8.61e
|
3.27d
|
7.20a
|
7.80e
|
4.00d
|
7.30a
|
P. oxalicum + EX
|
12.75b
|
4.50a
|
7.35d
|
21.69a
|
7.90a
|
7.00d
|
27.60a
|
8.00a
|
7.10c
|
30.15a
|
9.00b
|
7.20b
|
(45 days from sowing).
SSP = superphosphate, TCP = tricalcium phosphate, RP = Rock phosphate, AV = available phosphate, P.ase = = Acidic phosphatase. Mean was done and there is not significantly different at P = 0.05 (Duncan's test) the same letter within columns
Table 18
Effect of inoculation with PSF on rhizosphere soil phosphatases activity, available P (mg g-1 soil), and pH of the rhizosphere of canola plants fertilizer with different sources of phosphate (60 DAP)
Treatments
|
CONTROL
|
SSP
|
TCP
|
RP
|
|
|
P. ase
|
AP
|
pH
|
P. ase
|
Av P
|
pH
|
P. ase
|
AP
|
pH
|
P. ase
|
AP
|
pH
|
Control
|
2.75e
|
1.01f
|
7.60a
|
5.31c
|
3.55c
|
7.30a
|
5.11f
|
2.00e
|
7.10c
|
9.65c
|
2.18e
|
7.12c
|
P. oxalicum
|
8.52c
|
2.79c
|
7.38c
|
18.35a
|
2.89d
|
7.11c
|
18.88d
|
5.79b
|
7.15b
|
27.51a
|
8.00b
|
7.11c
|
EX P. oxalicum
|
3.66d
|
1.21d
|
7.40bc
|
4.51cd
|
6.45ab
|
7.11c
|
6.96e
|
3.01d
|
7.20a
|
5.99d
|
3.51c
|
7.30a
|
P. oxalicum + EX
|
10.95b
|
3.89a
|
7.33d
|
18.90a
|
6.10a
|
7.00d
|
26.11a
|
7.11a
|
7.11c
|
27.19a
|
9.30a
|
7.19b
|
SSP = superphosphate, TCP = tricalcium phosphate, RP = Rock phosphate, AV = available phosphate, P.ase = = Acidic phosphatase * Mean was done and there is no significantly different at P = 0.05 (Duncan's test) the same letter within columns |