In this study, we used quantitative MRI measures for understanding the preclinical development of prion disease and assess which one would be easiest to translate into clinical practice. Indeed, we could detect early changes in MRI parameters which would facilitate early diagnosis of prion disease in humans. Such translational biomarkers might become increasingly important to facilitate translation of late-stage potential treatments from animal experiments to humans (see e.g. 11 for a recent review on drug development in PrP). In the RML mouse model we have used, clear evidence of abnormal brain function has been detected about 80 days post-inoculation, when subtle symptoms become apparent in prion-infected mice. Clinically this corresponds to phase 2 of prion propagation where the disease-related prion protein is well characterised throughout the brain 10. MRS measurements which report on neuronal function and metabolism in the brain show deficiencies throughout the disease course. In our experiments, the concentration of Ins, Glu, lactate and lipids were statistically different in all prion-infected mice. Furthermore, MTR abnormalities reporting on macromolecular concentration and composition were found to be reduced at the end-stage of the disease. These findings are discussed in more details below.
In vivo MRS changes
Changes in brain metabolite concentrations provide key insights about disease progression. Glu is the major excitatory neurotransmitter in the brain. Alterations in Glu concentration are indicative of imbalance in metabolic activity (Krebs Cycle) and a decrease in glutamate concentration is related to a reduced metabolism 12. It is believed that increased concentrations of mI in neurodegenerative diseases reflect an increase of glial cells, because it is primarily expressed in such cells. In prion-infected mice, an increase in mI might be also related to astrogliosis 13.
NAA represents a marker of neuronal density or neuronal function 14. Reduced NAA in prion-infected mice is indicative of neuronal loss, which is similar to evidence given by human studies 15. Other roles of NAA include involvement in lipid synthesis in myelin, both precursor and breakdown product of N-acetylaspartylglutamate, and as storage form of aspartate 16. Under conditions of anaerobic metabolism or inflammation, lactate levels become elevated and a characteristic peak at 1.3ppm overlaps with the lipid resonance 17. In prion-infected mice, our data indicate that both lactate and lipid levels are elevated. To date, limited MRS data have been obtained from individuals with CJD, with similar findings as presented here, in particular showing significant reductions in NAA levels 18, explained by neuronal cell death. Additionally however, a decline in NAA levels might be associated with a functional deficit through synaptic loss.
Changes in Glu, NAA, lactate and lipids were further correlated with astrogliosis in prion-infected mice. There is evidence that astrocytes are the cell type in which the abnormal form of the prion protein is first replicated in the nervous system. It is likely that the changes in astrocytes are due to the “stress” induced on these cells by the misfolded protein. In particular, an in vitro study showed that the presence of large numbers of astrocytes can accelerate the rate at which neurons are killed by the toxic peptide 19. Finally, since glial cells increase in number, and because glial cells are thought to produce primarily Lac, which is then used by neurons as primary fluid 20, then this should indeed lead to an increase in extracellular Lac in prion mice, if that increase is not matched by an increase in neuronal metabolism.
MTR changes
The MTR ratio was found to be significantly increased in 160-day-old mice, compared to that in 80-day-old mice. The increase in MTR could be attributed to decreased water content as a result of the accumulation of myelin, lipids, proteins, proteolipid-proteins, cholesterol and amino-acids. Furthermore, the findings – including MTR changes in healthy mouse brains and reduced MT values in the disease state – are in line with the literature of other neurodegenerative diseases such as Alzheimer’s disease or amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) 21, 22. Taking this into account, MTR might not likely be a characteristic biomarker of prion diseases as abnormalities have been described in other neurodegenerative disorders. However, in our previous studies, we showed that NOE* is decreased because of a decreased proteasome activity as a result of the accumulation of the aggregated PrP throughout the disease course in the prion-infected group 10 which further correlates with abnormal prion protein deposition and astrogliosis. Therefore, by combining both indices, a useful predictor of clinical disease onset might be established.
T1 and T2 relaxation changes
In all regions studied, T1 was found significantly different only at the end-stage of the disease in contrary to T2 which was significantly higher in thalamus throughout the disease course. These findings support the hypothesis that the early symptoms of the disease are more likely caused by molecular processes which affect normal brain function rather than its macrostructure. A big shortcoming of this study is that we haven’t included any diffusion based microstructural approaches because of the time limitations within of our experiment. Therefore, the extend at which DWI and its derived metrics could be useful in prion disease is discussed in reference with existing studies below. It is known that early stages of the pathology are related to synaptic loss resulting into the loss of neurons at the late stages of the disease. Additionally, at the end stage of the disease, extensive vacuolation and brain atrophy alter water distribution which might influence both relaxation times. According to the literature, increased T2 values were observed in prion-infected hamsters suggestive of increased tissue water content which might related to the presence of cell death 23. However, these are qualitative observations taken from T2-weighted images, which present with inherent confounds. In contrast, our data were obtained by quantitative methods and provide evidence for widespread degeneration of the brain integrity during the preclinical stages of the disease in this murine model.
Comparison with other neurodegenerative diseases
Next, we would like to discuss our findings in the context of other neurodegenerative diseases. MT contrast has been used as a novel approach to detect amyloid plaques in the brains of AD mice which are already present in the early stages of the disease. Unlike our results, the MTR was found to be significantly higher in the brains of APP/PS1 and BRI mice, modelling late- and early-stage AD respectively 24. Additionally, MT was found to exceed sensitivity compared to traditional T2 measurements. Similar findings were also reported in the Tg2576 mouse model of AD which exhibits increased amyloid beta deposition that eventually progresses into amyloid beta plaque deposition 25. However, in another study using Tg2576 mice quantitative MT failed to pass significance as no alterations in myelin content were observed 26. Interestingly, our results show similarities with patient specific biomarkers observed in AD patients such as hippocampal T2 prolongation and MTR reduction as a result of progressive demyelination and reduced capacity of the macromolecules to exchange magnetization with the surrounding water molecules 27.
Other forms of neurodegenerative diseases which are caused by misfolded proteins include Parkinson’s (PD) and Huntington’s disease (HD). In PD mice, the MTR was significantly decreased in the striatum and substantia nigra and it was significantly associated with an increase in the Glu/Cr ratio compared with the control group 28. Additionally, a tendency towards a reduction in T2 was measured in the model animals as compared to littermates 29.
In a separate study, MT imaging was used to discriminate symptomatic HD gene carriers from healthy controls and non-affected HD carriers 30, 31. The findings of this study suggest a relationship between disease severity and macromolecular load in caudate nucleus. In our study the absence of plaques or the formation of aggregated proteins at the early stage of the disease does not alter MT which is only relevant at the late stages of prion disease.
1H MRS in transgenic HD mice showed a reduction in NAA in the corpus striatum indicating diffuse neuronal loss 32, in other studies this was followed by lower levels of choline and phosphocholine in addition to an increase in glutamine, taurine and myoinositol 33, 34, 35. In accordance with our study, the R6/2 mouse model of HD, also exhibits a decrease in NAA and glutamate 36. In AD mouse models a decrease in NAA and glutamate was observed in addition to an increase in taurine 37. In the APPxPS1 AD model an increase in myo-inositol was also detected 38. Finally, in another study the decrease in NAA and Glu were correlated with the plaque burden 39.