The results of the annual ANOVA of Corn characteristics under different irrigation methods, different sowing dates and sowing methods are given in Table 1. As it can be seen from Table 1, the effect of the irrigation methods is significant on the bush height and the protein content at the 5% significance level. However, this effect is not significant for other qualitative characteristics, including the ear yield and the height of ear formation. The effect of the sowing date on the ear yield, bush height, the height of ear formation is significant at the 1% level and for the protein content at the 5% level (Table 1). The maximum ear yield was obtained as 21970 kg/ha for the first sowing date. The higher ear yield in the first sowing date can be due to the favorable growth conditions (temperature) from the sowing to harvesting time. The maximum bush height and height of ear formation were 220.0 and 108.5 cm for the July 6 sowing date, respectively. It seems that the delay in the growth stages in the second sowing date increases in the bush height and height of the ear formation from the soil level. The maximum protein content for the second sowing date and the first sowing date was obtained 10.11% and 8.81%, respectively. It seems that in the first sowing date, the speed of the transfer of substances from leaves and stems to the ear is quicker, and the leaves fade and become yellow sooner. These factors can affect the protein content of the leaves and stems of forages. The effect of the sowing method was significant on the ear yield, height of the plant, and the height of the ear formation at the 5% significance level (Table 1). The maximum ear yield was obtained as 19265.5 kg/ha in transplantation. The results of previous studies have mainly shown the increase in the production and earlier flowering in transplantation of the corn. It seems that the early growth of corn in the nursery may result in sooner growth stages and flowering of the corn transplants in the field and these factors can affect the forage production and ear yield.
Table 1
The annual ANOVA results of the ear yield and other qualitative characteristics of the forage corn under different irrigation methods, different sowing dates and two sowing methods
|
|
Mean of square (M.S.)
|
S.O.V.
|
df
|
Ear Yield
|
Height of plant
|
Height of ear formation
|
Protein content
|
2016
|
2017
|
2016
|
2017
|
2016
|
2017
|
2016
|
2017
|
Irrigation system (Y)
|
2
|
63911233 ns
|
58932268 ns
|
144134*
|
213977 ns
|
2270 ns
|
1721 ns
|
2.73*
|
3.18*
|
Error
|
6
|
27073915
|
23457712
|
2391
|
13859
|
871
|
640
|
0.31
|
0.39
|
Sowing date (D)
|
1
|
146725980**
|
77715967**
|
31536**
|
31926**
|
1489**
|
1056**
|
2.63*
|
4.81*
|
(D*Y)
|
2
|
16288543 ns
|
12477391
|
4729 ns
|
4937 ns
|
248
|
212 ns
|
1.45 ns
|
2.71 ns
|
Error
|
6
|
8812371
|
4953217
|
1869
|
2193
|
94
|
54
|
0.36
|
0.52
|
Sowing method (P)
|
1
|
16345772*
|
39172668*
|
1454*
|
2571*
|
675*
|
379*
|
0.68 ns
|
0.93 ns
|
(P*Y)
|
2
|
7753211 ns
|
823461 ns
|
973 ns
|
1037 ns
|
144 ns
|
130 ns
|
0.72 ns
|
1.06 ns
|
(P*D)
|
1
|
7833520 ns
|
6391233 ns
|
739 ns
|
837 ns
|
87 ns
|
62.45ns
|
0.91 ns
|
1.3 ns
|
(P*Y*D)
|
2
|
5693778 ns
|
4336678 ns
|
835 ns
|
9357 ns
|
104 ns
|
93 ns
|
0.66 ns
|
0.82 ns
|
Error
|
12
|
2375626
|
3895259
|
260
|
325
|
81
|
50
|
0.23
|
0.42
|
* Significant difference at 1% level. ** Significant difference at 5% level. n s Non- significant. |
According to the annual ANOVA in 2016, the effect of the irrigation systems was not significant on the measured qualitative characteristics of corn except the protein content (Table 1). The effect of the sowing date on the ear yield, bush height and the height of ear formation was significant at the 1% level, and on the protein content was significant at the 5% level (Table 1). The maximum ear yield was 26403.1 kg/ha in the first sowing (Hadadi and Mohseni 2006). In the July 6 sowing date, the maximum bush height and height of ear formation were 238.3 and 122.8 cm, respectively. Due to delay in growth stages, bush height and height of ear formation may have increased in the second sowing date. Similar results have also been reported by other researchers (Tabatabaei and Dadashi 2013; Wang et al. 2018). The maximum protein content was greater than 10% on the second sowing date.
The effect of the sowing method on the ear yield, height of the plant and the height of the ear formation was significant at the 5% level (Table 1). The maximum ear yield obtained 22763.1 kg/ha in the transplantation treatment.
Please insert Table 1 here.
According to the two-year analysis of compound variance, the effect of the year on the ear yield, bush height and height of ear formation was significant at the 5% probability level. The maximum ear yield, bush height, and height of ear formation were obtained 21841 kg/ha, 228.4 cm and 114 cm, respectively in 2016. No significant difference was observed between the protein contents in both years (Table 2). The effect of the irrigation system was not significant on the ear yield, the height of the plant, and height of ear formation. In contrast, it had a significant effect on the protein content at the 5% level and the maximum protein content was obtained 9.83% and 9.68% in the sprinkler and tape irrigation methods, respectively (Table 2). According to the results of the two-year experiment, it can concluded that the ear yield was not significantly different in the three irrigation systems. The effect of the sowing method on the ear yield, height of the plant, and height of ear formation was significant at the 5% level (Table 1). The maximum ear yield was 21012.8 in the transplantation method (Table 2). It seems that in the transplantation method, the early growth of corn in the nursery may result in sooner growth stages and flowering in the field, and these factors can affect the forage production and ear yield. There are limited reports about comparing transplantation and direct sowing of corn, but these reports have mainly shown the increase in the production and sooner flowering in corn transplantation. The maximum bush height and height of ear formation were obtained 227.1 cm and 114.2 cm, respectively in direct (seeding) sowing (Table 2). The higher bush height and height of ear formation may be due to the longer growth period in the direct sowing method. There was a delay in flowering in direct sowing terraces (Fig. 1). Comparing the results of all test treatments in two years shows that the maximum ear yield obtained in the first sowing date under all three irrigation methods, and the minimum ear yield obtained in the second sowing date (Table 2). In the second sowing date, tassels and silk threads (ear) emerged mainly from the second half of September to the end of this month (Fig. 1), hence, growth continued during October. Temperature decreases in October compared to summer months in the region, so that the absolute minimum temperatures in October were 4 and 1.1°C, respectively in 2016 and 2017. Also, the average minimum temperatures in October were 6.7 and 4.8°C, in 2016 and 2017 respectively. Thus, it can be concluded that in this region, the continued growth of corn in October can result in slower growth and the danger of frostbite. So, one of the reasons for the decrease in the yield is the later sowing date on July 6 (the second sowing date), the continuance of growth in October and the low temperature. It is reported that the minimum basic temperature is 7 to 8°C for corn to form tassels and pollinate (Warrington and Kanemasu 1983). Also, Garcia et al. (2009) stated that the basic minimum temperature is about 7°C for the sweet corn (Garcia et al. 2009). Since corn is consistent with the warm climate and shows the high efficiency of dry matter production in suitable temperatures, it can be concluded that June 5 can be a suitable date to sow the corn with the variety 704 which results in desirable yield in the region of the study compared to July 6. Transplantation terraces provided the maximum ear production in the first sowing date among the treatments (Table 2). This superiority can be due to having a longer growing season, since the transplantation terraces grew more for two weeks compared to seeding method.
Table 2
The comparison of the average qualitative characteristics of the forage corn under different irrigation methods, different sowing dates and sowing methods in Chahartakhteh station during two years of experiment.
Treatment
|
Ear yield (kg/ha)
|
Height of plant (cm)
|
Height of ear formation (cm)
|
Protein content (%)
|
2016
|
2017
|
Mean
|
2016
|
2017
|
Mean
|
2016
|
2017
|
Mean
|
2016
|
2017
|
Mean
|
Irrigation
systems
|
Surface
|
18698 a
|
22573 a
|
20636 a
|
212 b
|
231 a
|
221 a
|
104.5 a
|
112.5 a
|
108.5 a
|
8.61 b
|
9.1 b
|
8.8 b
|
Tape
|
17706 a
|
21218 a
|
19462 a
|
210 b
|
224 a
|
217 a
|
100.5 a
|
110.0 a
|
105.3 a
|
9.51 a
|
9.8 ab
|
9.7 ab
|
Sprinkler
|
18603 a
|
21732 a
|
20168 a
|
224 a
|
225 a
|
224 a
|
102.3 a
|
118.3 a
|
110.3 a
|
9.63 a
|
10.1 a
|
9.8 a
|
Sowing date
|
05/Jun
|
21970 a
|
26403 a
|
24186 a
|
210 b
|
215 b
|
212 b
|
96.3 b
|
104.3 b
|
100.3 b
|
8.58 b
|
9.0 b
|
8.8 b
|
05/Jul
|
14702 b
|
17279 b
|
15991b
|
220 a
|
238 a
|
229 a
|
108.5 a
|
122.8a
|
115.7 a
|
9.91 a
|
10.3 a
|
10.1 a
|
Sowing method
|
Transplanting
|
19263 a
|
22763 a
|
21013 a
|
211 b
|
215 b
|
213 b
|
97.3 b
|
106.7 b
|
102.0 b
|
9.13 a
|
9.6 a
|
9.4 a
|
Seeding
|
17409 b
|
20919 b
|
19164 b
|
219 a
|
235 a
|
227 a
|
107.5a
|
120.5 a
|
114.2 a
|
9.36 a
|
9.6 a
|
9.5 a
|
Year
|
2016
|
|
|
|
|
|
213 b
|
|
|
101.4 b
|
|
|
9.3 a
|
2017
|
|
|
|
|
|
228 a
|
|
|
114.6 a
|
|
|
9.6 a
|
*Means within column that have the same letter are not significantly different at 5% level (DMR test). |
This issue can be the reason for the superiority of transplantation sowing compared to seeding, especially in the first sowing date when the limitations of temperature are less at the end of the season. Ghiasabadi et al. (2014) have also reported the superiority of corn transplantation on June 5 compared to sowing in July (in Mashhad, Iran). The maximum bush height and height of ear formation were observed in the second sowing date for seeding terraces (Table 2). As there is a delay in sowing corn in the region and the sowing date is postponed to July, the suitable growth conditions (temperature) may not be available, especially at the end of the growing season. It leads to a delay in the growth stages which can be accompanied by an increase in the bush height. This increase will be more than the transplantation method when sowing is by seeding in July. The maximum protein content was obtained by 10.1% for the second sowing date (Table 2). The maximum bush height and height of ear formation were obtained 235.3 and 120.5 cm in the direct sowing (seeding), respectively. The higher bush height and height of ear formation can be due to the longer growing period in direct sowing. In direct sowing terraces, flowering occurred later (Table 3). It seems that in the first sowing date, the transfer of substances is faster from the leaves and stems to the ear and the leaves become yellow sooner. These factors can affect the protein content of the leaves and stems of the forage. Also, it is reported that whatever the age of the plant increases, the cell wall becomes thicker, and fiber compounds increase. This issue can be inversely correlated with the protein content (Putnam et al. 2007). Therefore, because of one month delay in the second sowing date (July 6), it seems that the cells and the plant tissues have more protein and forages are less woody.
Table 3
The comparison of the two year means of different treatments of the sowing date, sowing method and irrigation method on the forage yield and other qualitative characteristics of the forage corn
Treatment
|
Ear yield (kg/ha)
|
Height of plant (cm)
|
Height of ear formation (cm)
|
Protein content (%)
|
2016
|
2017
|
Mean
|
2016
|
2017
|
Mean
|
2016
|
2017
|
Mean
|
2016
|
2017
|
Mean
|
Surface irrigation
|
|
T1
|
23156 ab
|
28030 a
|
25593 a
|
208 cd
|
216 defg
|
212 efg
|
94 g
|
100 d
|
97 fg
|
8.11 c
|
8.61 e
|
8.36 e
|
S1
|
21152 b
|
26570 ab
|
23861 b
|
210 cd
|
224 cde
|
217 defg
|
103 bcde
|
105 cd
|
104 cdef
|
8.28 c
|
8.78 e
|
8.53 e
|
T2
|
15942 c
|
19948 c
|
17945 c
|
214 b cd
|
234 bc
|
224 bcde
|
108 abc
|
114 b
|
111 bc
|
8.92 b
|
9.48 cd
|
9.2 d
|
S2
|
14542 c
|
15744 e
|
15143 d
|
222 ab
|
248 a
|
235 ab
|
113 a
|
131 a
|
122 a
|
9.12 b
|
9.45 cd
|
9.28 d
|
Tape irrigation
|
|
T1
|
22345 ab
|
26091 ab
|
24218 ab
|
20 d
|
208 fg
|
206 g
|
92 g
|
98 d
|
95 g
|
8.81 b
|
9.22 de
|
9.02 de
|
S1
|
20145 b
|
25693 b
|
22919 b
|
209 cd
|
211 efg
|
210 fg
|
98 defg
|
98 d
|
98 efg
|
9.12 b
|
9.34 cde
|
9.23 d
|
T2
|
15210 cd
|
17610 cd
|
16410 cd
|
212 bcd
|
226 cd
|
219 cdef
|
102 cdef
|
116 b
|
109 cd
|
9.9 a
|
10.32 ab
|
10.11 abc
|
S2
|
13124 d
|
15480 d
|
14302 d
|
214 bcd
|
250 a
|
232 abc
|
110 ab
|
128 a
|
119 ab
|
10.2 a
|
10.51 a
|
10.35 a
|
Sprinkler irrigation
|
|
T1
|
23675 a
|
26091 a
|
24883 ab
|
217 bc
|
207 f
|
212 efg
|
95 fg
|
109 bc
|
102 defg
|
9.12 b
|
9.87 bc
|
9.49 bcd
|
S1
|
21345 b
|
25944 b
|
23645 b
|
217 bc
|
221 cde
|
219 edef
|
96 efg
|
116 b
|
106 cde
|
9.25 b
|
9.51 cd
|
9.38 cd
|
T2
|
15246 c
|
18810 c
|
17028 cd
|
224 a
|
226 cd
|
225 abcd
|
105 bcd
|
115 b
|
110 cd
|
9.94 a
|
10.42 ab
|
10.18 ab
|
S2
|
14145 c
|
16085 c
|
15115 d
|
228 a
|
246 ab
|
237 a
|
113 a
|
133 a
|
123 a
|
10.21 a
|
10.32 ab
|
10.26 a
|
*Means within column that have the same letter are not significantly different at 5% level (DMR test). |
Please insert Table 2 here
Please insert Table 3 here