In recent years, the prognostic significance of TILs has been well-documented. Infiltrating TILs, composing of different lymphocyte subtypes, into the TME represent the immune response status between host immune cells and tumors 30. Previous studies have shown that the infiltration of TILs correlates with tumor development, clinicopathological features of patients, clinical outcome, and survival in several cancers, including CRC 31. Among them, Kasurinen et al. investigated the prognostic value of different combinations of CD3 + and CD8 + immune cells in patients with CRC and demonstrated that the infiltration of a large number of CD3 + and CD8 + inflammatory cells in tumor tissue correlated with an improved survival, in many types of cancers 32–34. In the present study, regarding the importance of memory (CD45RO+) and cytotoxic (CD8+) lymphocytes in eradication of tumor cells, we attempted to delineate the presence of CD3+, CD8+, CD45RO + TILs and the expression of LAG3 as a novel inhibitory marker in both IM and CT of CRC tissues and then assessed their correlation with clinical outcomes with focus on tumor location. Our results showed that CD45RO + lymphocytes followed by CD3 + lymphocytes were the most frequent subsets in both areas of CRC tumor tissues, while LAG3 + cells showed the lowest frequency.
CD45RO is generally thought to be a marker of memory T cells which represent effector activity and rapid reaction in TME and can also affect the outcome of the disease 17. Our survival analysis revealed that high score of CD45RO in IM was associated with better OS. Similar results were reported in several other cancers such as renal cell carcinoma, gastric cancer, breast cancer and ovarian carcinoma 35–38. In these studies, CD45RO + TILs were also positively associated with DFS and OS. The protective role of CD45RO + T-cell in anti-tumor responses and their association with better prognosis in most cancers might be explained by providing a pool of effector cells or direct killing effect of these cells in TME that repress the proliferation and migration of tumor cells. Additionally, it has been showed that CD45RO + T cells could decrease the production of high-mobility group box 1 (HMGB1) in CRC, and since HMGB1 accelerates cell growth, invasion, and angiogenesis in cancer tissues, CD45RO + lymphocytes might subsequently suppress the proliferation and migration of colorectal tumor cells 39.
In the next step, to investigate the role of primary tumor localization in CRC outcomes, we classified the study population into two groups of right-sided and left-sided tumors. To best of our knowledge, none of the previous studies have examined our target markers expressions in CRC and their effects on prognosis based on primary tumor location. Our survival analysis showed that CD45RO score in IM in right-sided tumors was directly associated with better survival. Moreover, high score of CD8 in IM was associated with better OS in these patients. These findings further supported previous evidence suggesting that proximal and distal CRC may represent different immunological entities as they also showed differences in epidemiological, pathological, and clinical properties 40.
Apart from survival, we examined the association between the score ofCD45RO in CT and IM, with clinicopathological properties in CRC, as well. We observed that low score of CD45RO in CT was correlated with no lymph node metastasis and earlier TNM stages (I/II) in both entire cohort and right-sided tumors. There was also a trend for high score of CD45RO and lesser tumor size. A study by Hu et al. on patients with lung adenocarcinoma was demonstrated that CD45RO + TILs are negatively correlated with tumor size and lymph node involvement 30. However, controversially, they observed that high density of CD45RO + lymphocytes was correlated with earlier TNM stages. Although the reasons for this discrepancy remain unknown, a larger scale study is needed to reach a more definitive conclusion.
Thus, in this study, we examined the association of LAG3 score in both IM and CT of CRC with survival. Beside effector functions, some subpopulations of T cells express LAG3 and exert inhibitory functions to regulate immune responses. Overall, although there was a trend for high score of LAG3 in CT and improved OS we observed no statistically significant association between LAG3 expression and OS. Consistently, most studies including a meta-analysis on NSCLC ,renal, ovarian, gastric and a few other cancers have shown that expression of LAG3 is associated with better survival 41. In a study on patients with stage I–IIIB NSCLC, Hald et al. also showed that LAG3 expression on TILs was correlated with improved survival 42. The presence of LAG3 + TILs was also associated with longer Disease-specific survival in breast cancer patients, as well 29. Despite these results, some studies reported that LAG3 expression is associated with poor survival. Chen et al. in a study on CRC demonstrated that patients with high percentage of LAG3 + cells in their tumor tissues had shorter survival compared with those with a low percentage of LAG3 + cells 43. Considering that LAG3 is an inhibitory immune checkpoint that elicits suppressive immune responses and facilitates tumor escape, such a correlation between the expression of this marker and improved survival may be paradoxical. One hypothesis could be that the low level of LAG3 expression may lead to an exhausted phenotype, but up-regulation of LAG3 may initiate negative feedback of inhibitory signals that creates an active immune environment in the tumor and improve prognosis 44. However, most previous studies mainly focused on the role of LAG3 in T cell immunity, but a recent study suggested that LAG3 expression correlated with NK-mediated cytotoxicity pathways, activation of B-cells, B cell-mediated immunity, and B cell receptor signaling pathways 45. Another new aspect of the LAG3 marker is the expression of LAG3 on effector memory T cells with an activated phenotype. In this regard, Slevin et al. showed that LAG3 expression is elevated in the inflamed colonic mucosa of active ulcerative colitis and stimulated colonic LAG3 + T cells were able to produce IFNγ and IL-17A 46. This suggests that, at the active inflammation site, LAG3 + cells may have effector rather than suppressor phenotypes. Given this view and the importance of LAG3 expression on memory T cells, we also examine the effect of the simultaneous expression of LAG3 and CD45RO on TILs on survival, although the results did not show any statistically significant relationship (data not shown).
Regarding clinical features, our study results showed a relationship between high score of LAG3 in IM in and higher T-stage and larger tumor size. However, many studies have not found a significant correlation between expression and any of the clinical features in NSCLC, CRC and Hodgkin lymphoma 42, 44, 47, a similar result was reported by Que et al. which showed that LAG3 + T lymphocytes in tumor tissue were associated with larger tumor size in soft tissue sarcoma 48. We also found that high score of LAG3 in IM was significantly correlated with the absence of TLS formation. Similarly, a previous study on CRC also demonstrated that LAG3 + T lymphocytes in tumor tissue were associated with higher invasion depth and metastasis 43. Whilst, in CT of left-sided tumors, low score of LAG3 was associated with no metastasis and no recurrence. Controversial to survival analysis, our results may be suggest that the presence of LAG3 on lymphocytes infiltrated into tumor tissue may trigger suppressive immune responses and facilitates tumor cell proliferation, resulting in disease progression and tumor recurrence or metastasis. This issue should be a topic that warrants further investigation in a larger population.
In conclusion, our results indicated that infiltration of CD45RO + cells in IM is an independent prognostic factor in right-sided colon cancer, but not in left-sided tumors. In addition, higher numbers of LAG3 TILs in IM correlate with higher T-stage and low score of LAG3 in CT correlated with the absence of metastasis and recurrence in left-sided colon tumors. These findings probably suggest that the interaction between TILs and tumor cells in TME varies depending on the tumor side. The results of this study need validation but may be clinically relevant, as they indicate that tumor location might be an important factor to take into consideration in therapeutic decisions according to the patients' immune status and give physicians a good idea of the prognosis and clinical outcomes of the disease