In this study, we used state-of-the-art analytical tools to investigate the composition of appendicoliths, which are commonly found obstructing the lumen of the appendix at the time of appendectomy. Our analysis of five appendicoliths collected from children undergoing appendectomy for acute appendicitis revealed several interesting findings.
First, we found that palmitic acid and stearate are the most common fatty acids within appendicoliths. Palmitic acid is the most common saturated fatty acid found in the human body and can be provided in the diet, or synthesized endogenously from other fatty acids, carbohydrates and amino acids16. Full fat cheeses, red meat, butter, corn oil, and palm oil (frequently added to processed foods) contain large amounts of palmitic acid17. Interestingly, palmitic acid has been identified as a major component of gallstones, and diets high in palmitic acid have been associated with increased gallstone formation in animal models18,19. Stearate, in contrast, is a fatty acid food additive, typically present as a magnesium, sodium, zinc, or calcium salt compound, that is nearly insoluble in water20. It has multiple industrial applications including as an additive in soaps, rubber, plastics, and concrete. It is a common ingredient in pharmaceutical tablets, candy, chewing gum, and baked goods, and can be added for anticaking, emulsifying, and binding properties. Of note, was that some of the stearate within appendicoliths exists in crystalline form—identified by polarized light microscopy and confirmed by X-ray crystallography. Understanding more about the chemical composition of these crystals, the environment which allows them to form, and their physiological consequence should be an area of future research. Whether dietary palmitic acid and stearate are a primary cause of appendicoliths or if they accumulate within the lumen of the appendix because of diminished gastrointestinal motility is also unknown.
Second, we observed that there is an increased ratio of omega-6 to omega-3 fatty acids within appendicoliths. This may be of clinical importance as dietary fatty acids have a role in mediating gastrointestinal inflammation21–23 and have been linked to inflammatory bowel disease and colorectal cancer24,25. Importantly, an elevated ratio of omega-6 to omega-3 fatty acids in Western diets has been hypothesized to be a cause of the relatively high rates of inflammatory conditions, cardiovascular disease, obesity, and cancer in high-income countries26. In our analysis, two omega-6 fatty acids, docosatetraenoic acid, and eicosadienoic acid were the most elevated. Docosatetraenoic acid, also known as adrenic acid, is a naturally occurring polyunsaturated fatty acid formed through a 2-carbon chain elongation of arachidonic acid27. Eicosadienoic acid (Δ11,14–20:2; EDA) is a rare, naturally occurring n-6 polyunsaturated fatty acid (PUFA) found mainly in animal tissues28. EDA is elongated from linoleic acid (LA and can also be metabolized to dihomo-γ-linolenic acid (DGLA), arachidonic acid (AA), and sciadonic acid (Δ5,11,14–20:3; SCA). Of note, when macrophages are exposed to lipopolysaccharide (LPS), EDA decreases the production of nitric oxide (NO) and increases the production of prostaglandin E(2) (PGE(2)) and tumor necrosis factor-α29. Whether omega-6 fatty acids, specifically docosatetraenoic acid and eicosadienoic acid, have a role in appendicolith formation and in acute appendicitis will require further study.
Third, we discovered that appendicoliths contain a distinct pattern of minerals and metals. Calcium and phosphorus are the most common elements found in appendicoliths, the former likely explaining their radiopaque nature (Fig. 1b). As the calcium occurs in approximately the same ratio as the phosphorus, we suspect it likely occurs as calcium phosphate—a family of minerals containing calcium ions (Ca2+) together with inorganic phosphate anions. Unexpectedly, we also found multiple other metals present in appendicoliths. Some of these metals are redox-active, especially manganese, iron, and zinc. As such, they could potentially undergo redox cycling reactions resulting in the production of reactive oxygen/nitrogen species (RNOS). For example, in Fenton's reaction, iron reacts with hydrogen peroxide to produce hydroxyl free radicals, one of the most reactive RONS molecules30. Excess intracellular RONS can disrupt the intracellular redox state and energy production resulting in oxidative stress, which manifests itself in the modification of cellular biomolecules, such as DNA, lipids, and proteins, the dysfunction of mitochondrial respiration, protein folding, DNA repair processes, endoplasmic reticulum (ER) stress, inflammation, autophagy, and/or apoptosis. Similar cellular phenotypes are frequently observed in other human diseases31–33. The source and physiological consequences of the multiple trace metals (e.g., titanium, nickel, strontium) found in appendicoliths is unknown.
Fourth, and perhaps most important, we found that appendicoliths contain identifiable human and bacterial proteins. Enrichment analysis of the human proteins that were common to the appendicoliths studied showed antioxidant activity and a variety of neutrophil pathways to be of importance. Interestingly, our analysis showed appendicoliths contain relatively high concentrations of several S100 calcium-binding proteins (A8/A9). In agreement with our findings for appendicoliths, a prior gene array study of expression in the inflamed appendix found S100A8 and S100A9 to be highly upregulated34. S100 calcium-binding proteins are abundant in neutrophils, are well-known pro-inflammatory markers and previously have been proposed as diagnostic serum biomarkers for appendicitis35,36. Higher fecal levels of these proteins have also been correlated with the severity of disease in inflammatory bowel disease37,38. Whether the antioxidant activity and activation of neutrophil pathways relate to dietary factors (e.g., fatty acids, food additives), redox-active metals, changes in the microbiome, or some combination of these is unknown, but our protein data clearly implicate the involvement of neutrophils, a rich source of reactive oxygen species, in this condition.
Considered together, our findings suggest that oxidative stress has a role in the formation of appendicoliths and possibly in the etiology of acute appendicitis (Fig. 4). This hypothesis is a synthesis of our protein mass spectroscopy data showing enrichment of neutrophil activation and antioxidant pathways within appendicoliths, identification of substances known to cause oxidative stress (fatty acids and redox-active metals), and the existing literature on the biological consequences of oxidative stress on cellular function. Oxidative stress can cause mitochondrial damage, oxidation of DNA, lipids, and proteins, and dysregulation of calcium homeostasis39,40, the latter of which might explain the accumulation of calcium and phosphorus in appendicoliths. Based on our findings we propose that acute appendicitis occurs when neutrophil-induced oxidative stress exceeds the capacity of appendix antioxidant defenses to protect against reactive oxygen species. If not recognized and treated promptly, the resulting tissue damage can progress to necrosis and perforation of the appendix. We have identified the neutrophil as a key cell type involved in this pathology, which is consistent with the observation that infiltration of neutrophils is the hallmark of the histopathological diagnosis of acute appendicitis41. Further, our oxidative stress model can potentially explain several recent, seemingly unrelated observations on acute appendicitis. First, two genome-wide association studies (GWAS) have shown appendicitis to be associated with the rs2129979 locus at 4q2542,43. The gene nearest the association signal is PITX2, which encodes the transcription factor Paired-Like Homeodomain 2. The PITX2 gene has a role in intestinal development44–46 but postnatally may mediate oxidative stress47–49. Second, the use of metformin, an antidiabetic drug, is associated with a reduced risk of appendicitis50. Metformin is thought to exert anti-inflammatory and antioxidant effects51. Third, low mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) copy number and reduced mtDNA integrity, as evidenced by the formation of 8-hydroxyl-20-deoxyguanosine (8-OHdG), have been demonstrated in severe appendicitis52. The amount of 8-OHdG accumulated in mtDNA is considered an index of cellular oxidative damage53.
Our study has some limitations. Foremost is that the number of appendicoliths analyzed was small. Despite the small number, we have confidence in our results as the major findings were consistent across all samples. Another limitation is that appendicolith specimens were collected from pediatric patients. It is possible that samples from adults might have yielded different results. In addition, we are uncertain the extent to which our findings are due to mechanical trauma to the appendiceal mucosa from the appendicolith, or if our pathway findings relate solely to the inflammation associated with acute appendicitis. Finally, we did not analyze bacterial proteins found within the appendicoliths. With interest in the role of the intestinal microbiome in the pathogenesis of acute appendicitis growing54–56, this would be a fertile area for future research.
In conclusion, using state-of-the-art analytical techniques we show that appendicoliths have unique biochemical properties. These biological properties when considered together suggest oxidative stress may have a role in the formation of appendicoliths. Future work is needed to confirm these preliminary findings and to better understand how dietary factors such as food additives, omega-6 fatty acids, redox-active metals, and the intestinal microbiome contribute to the oxidative load within the appendix. Understanding the complex interplay that exists between these environmental factors and genetics could provide important insight into appendicolith formation and the etiology of acute appendicitis, and ultimately lead to novel prevention strategies for this common disease.