The study investigated the psychological status including anxiety and depression symptoms among 112 DTC patients before RAI therapy during the period of the COVID-19 epidemic. Overall, 41.08% had symptoms of anxiety and 33.93% had symptoms of depression. We also explored the influencing factors of demographic and clinical characteristics on psychological health status, showing that being female, having ever suffered RAI therapy were potential factors associated with poorer psychological health.
Cancer patients not only have physical symptoms due to the disease itself and treatment process, but also suffer from psychological distress caused by economic burden and social factors(34). Thus, cancer patients probable were in varying degree negative psychological states, such as anxiety and depression(39–42). Psychological symptoms including anxiety and depression could cause the declined of treatment adherence in cancer patients. Furthermore, anxiety and depression in cancer patients are associated with poorer quality of life(43, 44) and unfavorable prognosis(3, 45). Radiotherapy, chemotherapy and other treatments can further increase the psychological burden of cancer patients(46–48). Therefore, the psychological health of cancer patients before and during the treatment process must be valued.
Pre-COVID-19 studies have prompted that anxiety and depression are common in patients with thyroid cancer(14, 15, 17). During the COVID-19 period, the psychological burden of cancer patients further increased(27, 28). Data from a survey of Chinese thyroid cancer patients showed that during the COVID-19 crisis, thyroid cancer patients had higher levels of psychological symptoms, such as anxiety and depression, than Chinese cancer patients before the COVID-19 epidemic(32). This finding demonstrated that COVID-19 epidemic has significantly negative impact on the psychological health in thyroid cancer survivors. Currently, RAI therapy is one of the commonly used treatments for patients with high risk of thyroid cancer and can improve survival rate in advanced or metastatic patients(32), but whether some patients need RAI therapy and the dose of RAI are controversial(22). In addition, some side effects caused by radiation exposure caused due to RAI therapy cannot be ignored, such as radiation salivary gland damage(21). As a result, thyroid cancer patients who are preparing for RAI treatment may experience higher psychological distress due to the unknown course of treatment and the fear of adverse effects for radiation exposure. Although previous a few studies have investigated the association between mental health and RAI therapy in thyroid cancer patients, the results were contradictory. Wu, HX, etc(49) and Yoo, SH, etc(50) suggested that psychological and behavioral interventions for thyroid patients receiving RAI may improve their psychological status, while Seyedshahab, Banihashem, etc(51) thought that psychological interventions might be limited. After a comprehensive literature search, there were few studies on the psychological state of DTC patients before RAI therapy, especially during COVID-19 pandemic.
In the present study, our results clearly showed a higher incidence of these psychological symptoms including anxiety and depression, suggesting that DTC patients prior to RAI therapy may be more prone to psychological symptoms during the COVID-19 epidemic. We believed that this phenomenon is not only related to the increased psychological burden of DTC patients due to RAI therapy itself, but also to the fact that patients stop thyroid hormone supplementation before RAI therapy, and patients in the status of hypothyroidism might lead to psychological symptoms. However, some studies suggested that there is no significant relationship between hypothyroidism and depression or anxiety(52, 53). Therefore, anxiety and depression in these patients are more likely to be related to fear of RAI therapy.
The result in this study showed that gender was an independent factor associated with anxiety and depression, which was consistent with previous studies that female patients with DTC bear more psychological burden(54). Previous studies have shown that being female is an important risk factor for the decline of quality of life in the diagnosis and treatment of thyroid cancer(15). The thyroid is an endocrine organ, and both progesterone and estrogen may be involved in the occurrence and development of thyroid cancer(55, 56). Therefore, the levels of estrogen and progesterone may lead to female thyroid patients more prone to poor psychological state. In addition, many previous publications have indicated that female cancer patients seem to be more vulnerable(57). Thence, it may be universal that female cancer patients are more likely to develop psychological problems.
Interestingly, we found that ever-experienced RAI therapy was an independent factor of anxiety and depression in DTC patients, which was rarely reported in previous studies. Generally, multiple times RAI therapies mean higher risk in DTC patients with tumor progression, recurrence or distant metastasis, poor treatment effect, or even refractory to RAI therapy(18). Importantly, previous research suggested that anxiety in thyroid cancer patients may depend not only on the real threat of thyroid cancer itself, but also on subjective assumptions about the threat of cancer(14). We proposed that anxiety and depression in these patients are associated with fear of thyroid cancer progression, metastasis, and recurrence, leading to lower confidence in disease recovery, resulting in greater psychological pain. Moreover, financial burden, self-cognitive dissonance, and lack of social support may also be important factors that significantly negatively modulate the psychological state of patients receiving multiple times RAI therapy. Together, we found independent factors associated with symptoms of anxiety and depression, so that patients at higher risk for psychological distress could be identified earlier and more accurately in the future. It is necessary to screen and identify DTC patients with higher levels of mental health problems in the COVIN-19 epidemic. During the COVIN-19 crisis, in addition to current public health interventions, psychological nursing and intervention should be implemented to support people with thyroid cancer in coping with depression and anxiety.
This study has some limitations. First of all, although GAD-7 scale and PHQ-9 scale are common approaches to evaluate patients' anxiety and depression, these two scales have certain limitations, and it is also limited to evaluate anxiety and depression with only the single scale. The patient’s psychological symptoms and their severity can be more reliably reflected if multiple recognized and valid psychological scales are used simultaneously. Secondly, the long-term psychological health and associated influencing factors of DTC patients after RAI therapy should be further investigated in followed up studies. Finally, since this study was a single-institution study with a small patient sample size, a larger sample size and multi-center study may be required for a more representative prospective study.