In the present study we demonstrate that H1 antagonist desloratadine decreases viability of glioblastoma cells in culture, through various mechanisms, including increase in reactive oxygen species production, induction of apoptosis and autophagy. Aside from a report that other H1 antagonists can induce apoptosis and autophagy [3, 6, 13, 14], this is the first study clearly demonstrating desloratadine induced activation of Akt/mTOR-dependent cytotoxic autophagy in tumor cells.
Keeping in mind that glioblastoma is an aggressive tumor that has the highest rate of mortality among all malignant brain tumors [26] there is an huge requirement to identify novel target molecules to which more effective therapeutic approaches can be developed. It was already shown that H1 antagonists can exert cytotoxic effects through the induction of both, apoptosis and autophagy [3, 6, 13, 14, 27]. Even the histamine deficiency can induce apoptosis [28] suggesting the role of histamine receptor activity in cell survival. In the current study we investigated the potential cytotoxic effects of H1 receptor antagonist, desloratadine, on glioblastoma cell line and primary human glioblastoma cell culture.
Glioblastoma cells express great chemoresistance [29] that can be supported by a presence of membranous ABC (ATP-binding Cassette) superfamily of efflux pumps located on blood-brain barrier [30]. Also, genetic instability caused with numerous mutations, deletions and genetic amplifications contributes its’ chemoresistance[31]. Having in mind all this complex glioblastoma characteristics that lead to their great biological diversity, there is a need for combined therapeutic approaches, targeting more than one signalling pathway. The results of our study contribute to this approach, since desloratadine affected both, apoptosis and autophagy, as two different programmed cell death mechanisms. In addition to already known desloratadine cytotoxic effect against cutaneous T-cell lymphoma cell lines, EJ and SW780 cells [9, 27] our results clearly shown dose dependent cytotoxic activity of desloratadine against U251 cell line. Nevertheless, the obtained IC50 value for desloratadine is in accordance with its cytotoxic activity on non small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) cell lines [10]. Its cytotoxic effects are, even partially, achieved through the induction of ROS overproduction which is a well-known trigger that could induce cell death [32]. Moreover, we found that desloratadine induced the externalization of phosphatidylserine in cell membrane, together with an increase in caspase activation, both hallmarks of apoptosis. Given data are in accordance with studies taken by Plekhova et al., and Ma et al., where Ann + macrophages as well as bladder cancer EJ and SW780 cells were detected after desloratadine treatment, respectively [27, 33]. Also, it was shown that desloratadine can induce apoptosis in cutaneous T-cell lymphoma cell lines through inhibition of STAT3 and c-Myc activities. Additionally, caspase dependent proapoptotic activity was previously reported for other H1 antagonists such as diphenhydramine and meclizine [5, 7].
It is known that autophagy in tumour cells can either promote apoptosis or serve as mechanism of programmed cell death type II. Several reports provided evidence that spontaneous autophagy is reduced in glioblastoma [32, 34] suggesting that this could be responsible for its considerable malignant potential. In contrast, there are data that show autophagy as a prosurvival mechanism that protects cancer cells from apoptotic or necrotic cell death induced by different anticancer drugs [17]. In the light of all the foregoing considerations we were interested to examine this process using glioblastoma cell line.
We have shown that desloratadine induces autophagy in U251 glioblastoma cells through increased expression of acidic cytosolic vesicles, both qualitatively and quantitatively. Given data are additionally confirmed with increased expression of autophagosome-associated LC3II protein. Ma et al., also impaired expression of autophagy-related proteins, such as Beclin 1, p62 and LC3I/II in EJ and SW780 cells after treatment with desloratadine [27]. After diphenhydramine treatment acidic vacuoles were detected in astrocytes, whitch is confirmed with increased LC3-I to LC3-II conversion[13] Autophagy followed with increased expression of LC3II protein was also reported for some other H1 antagonists [6, 14]. Furthermore, we looked towards the intracellular signalling pathway underlying autophagic process of U251 glioblastoma cells induced by desloratadine. AMPK is one of the positive regulators of autophagy that stimulates autophagy in response to energy depletion (increased AMP/ATP ration) [35] and that way connecting cellular energy homeostasis and autophagy. Beside AMPK, we looked toward activity of AMPK downstream target, mTOR, as well as prosurvival signalling molecule Akt involved in stimulation of protein synthesis and cell proliferation. Akt signalling pathway is usually regarded as independent signalling route from AMPK signalling pathway, and as alternative pathway that regulates autophagy [36]. In our experimental model we observed the up regulation of AMPK and down regulation of mTOR and Akt indicating that desloratadine induced autophagy of U251 cells is mTOR/AMPK dependent. Astemizol is the other histamine antagonist that induced autophagy in breast cancer cells [14]. Beside autophagy and similarly to desloratadine, astemizol also induced apoptosis through caspase activation and increased production of ROS. On the other hand, there are data indicating that antihistamine deptropin blocked basal autophagy which is experimentally confirmed through increased LC3II expression while Akt,AMPK, vacuolar protein sorting 34 (VPS34) and Atg7 expression was not changed after treatment in human hepatoma cells[20] Having in mind that autophagy could be either prosurvival or cell death mechanism, using simultaneous treatment with different autophagy inhibitors and desloratadine, we have shown that the autophagy in glioblastoma cells induced by desloratadine is cytotoxic. Together with previously reported finding that glioblastomas cells have reduced spontaneous autophagy, this induction of cytotoxic autophagy with desloratadine could be of great importance in modulation of current chemo-radiation treatment. The effect of autophagy modulation on glioblastoma radio sensitivity was intensively investigated previously [37] and, even still not completely clear, it is evident that autophagy modulation offers a promising, novel approach to glioblastoma treatment.
In addition to desloratadine effects observed in U251 glioblastoma cell line, we showed also similar patterns of desloratadine action against human glioblastoma primary cell culture. Its cytotoxic effect was performed through induced ROS production that, possibly initiated autophagy verified through an increase in number of acidic vesicles as well as an increase in LC3II autophagosome-associated protein.
The observed results clearly demonstrate that desloratadine induces apoptosis accompanying with cytotoxic mTOR/AMPK dependent autophagy. This dual antitumor potential of desloratadine is particularly important for tumor cells that express great antiapoptotic potential, such as cells of glioblastoma.