Application Effect of Reading List in Teaching of Temporal CT Reading

doi:10.21203/rs.3.rs-19117/v1

PDF

Research article

Application Effect of Reading List in Teaching of Temporal CT Reading

https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-19117/v1

This work is licensed under a CC BY 4.0 License

Version 1

posted 30 Mar, 2020

You are reading this latest preprint version

Background

Temporal CT is the most commonly used imaging data in the clinical work of otology. How to cultivate and improve the ability of residents to read images has become an important focus in clinical teaching. Our aim is to explore the application effect of reading list in the reading teaching of temporal CT for resident otologists.

Methods

The resident otologists were selected as subjects and randomly divided into a Group A and a Group B. Group A adopted reading list of temporal CT while Group B did not adopted reading list. The ability of student to read temporal CT was tested and evaluated.

Results

The scores and identification proficiency of temporal CT in Group A were significantly better than those in Group B after training. The evaluation in the learning interest, prediction ability of surgical risk, prevention of missed diagnosis and misdiagnosis risk, doctor-patient communication ability, standard organization of reading, self-confidence in reading, self-learning of reading, and satisfaction degree with reading teaching methods in Group A were better than those in Group B.

Conclusion

Application of reading list can improve the ability of resident otologists to read temporal CT and predict surgical risk, and help students cultivate the standard reading habits and enhance their interest in learning.

Nuclear Medicine & Medical Imaging

temporal CT

resident

teaching

questionnaire

Temporal imaging data is very important in the clinical diagnosis and treatment of otology. High-resolution thin-layer CT/MRI of temporal bone has a high diagnostic positive rate for otological diseases, and what’s more, it provides guidance for otological surgery, including determining surgical scope, selecting surgical approach, designing surgical incisions and predicting surgical complications, etc. Therefore, otological surgeons must have good reading ability of temporal images, and how to cultivate and improve the ability of residents to read images has become an important focus in clinical teaching.

Previous studies mainly focused on the role and significance of temporal images in middle and inner ear surgery[1, 2], but how to conduct teaching of temporal images for otologists and improve their ability to read images from the focus and perspective of otological surgeons has not been reported in literature. Although there were some commonalities in reading teaching between otology and other specialties such as imaging and orthopedics[3–5], it is necessary to explore the teaching methods suitable for the characteristics of otological surgery due to the different teaching procedures and characteristics of each specialty.

Temporal CT is the most commonly used imaging data in clinical work of otology. During this study, we conducted reading teaching of temporal CT by using the method of reading list to explore the application effect of this method.

Subjects

Students who participated in the standardized training of residents in the ENT Department at the First Affiliated Hospital, Sun Yat-sen University, from January 2018 to December 2019 were selected as subjects and randomly divided into an experimental group (Group A) and a control group (Group B). All students had been informed the contents of this study and had signed informed consent form.

Implementation of teaching

Group A adopted mixed teaching as the reading teaching mode: the reading list was not used in the initial stage of training, and the reading teaching was carried out with reference to CT reports of the Imaging Department; the reading list was used in the middle stage of training, and the reading of temporal CT was completed according to the contents of list. Group B did not adopt reading list in reading teaching: the reading teaching was carried out with reference to CT reports of the Imaging Department throughout the training. Combined with the relevant literature and the actual situation of otological teaching[6, 7], this study drew up a reading list of preoperative temporal CT for common otological diseases based on the principle of simplicity, comprehensiveness and easy operation (Table 1). After reading, students analyzed the precautions and risks of surgeries and formulated the surgical plans.

Table 1. Reading list of temporal CT

Reading Type	Observation Focus	Surgical Risk and Accident Evaluation
Patient Data	Consistent Name	---
CT scanning parameters and anatomical variations of middle and inner ear in coronary and transverse position Middle cranial fossa Sigmoid sinus wall Bulb of jugular vein	Identification of bone window and soft tissue window; scanning range Drooping Advanced or superficial High position, bone deficiency	--- Cerebrospinal fluid otorrhea Bleeding Bleeding
Scope of Lesion
Scope of soft tissue shadow Degree of temporal gasification Ossicular chain structure Facial nerve bone canal	Mastoid process, tympanic antrum, middle and upper tympanum Gasification, diploe, sclerosis, mixed Integrity of malleus, incus, and stapes; incudomalleolar joint and incudostapedial joint Integrity of vertical segment, tympanic segment and labyrinth segment; bone destruction	Scope of Surgery Difficulty and duration of surgery Hearing loss Facial nerve injury
Cochlea, vestibule, semicircular canal Deformity and bone destruction Sensorineural deafness Other important structural conditions Damage of meninges and carotid arteries Cerebrospinal fluid otorrhea, bleeding

Methods of evaluation

Self-evaluation of identification proficiency of middle ear structure CT: before and at the end of the training, Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) was used to evaluate the identification proficiency of middle and inner ear structure CT of students in two groups. Each item ranged 0 - 10 points: 0 point as completely unskilled, 1 - 3 points as unskilled, 4 - 6 points as generally skilled, 7 - 9 points as skilled, and 10 points as extremely skilled.

Temporal CT reading test: in the initial and middle stage and at the end of the training, the reading test of temporal CT was conducted in students. The total score was 100 points, and the test contents included the identification of middle and inner ear structure CT, the analysis of middle and inner ear lesions, and the characteristics of CT for common otological diseases, etc.

Questionnaire: at the end of the training, students in two groups were investigated by anonymous questionnaire to understand the implementation effect of the two teaching modes. The evaluation items of the questionnaire included learning interest, prediction ability of surgical risk, prevention of missed diagnosis and misdiagnosis risk, doctor-patient communication ability, standard organization of reading, self-confidence in reading, self-learning of reading, and degree of satisfaction with teaching method of reading. The evaluation results were divided into dissatisfied, neutral, and satisfied.

Statistical analysis

SPSS 22.0 software was used in this study for statistics. The measurement data were expressed as ±ѕ and tested by t test for inter-group and intra-group comparisons. The enumeration data were expressed as number of cases and percentage and tested by Fisher or χ² test, the ranked data were tested by nonparametric rank sum test (Kruskal-Wallis Test), and the difference was statistically significant if P < 0.05.

General data of subjects

There were 34 residents in Group A, including 19 males and 15 females with an average age of 26.4 ± 1.6 years; there were 30 residents in Group B, including 18 males and 12 females with an average age of 25.8 ± 1.5 years. There was no significant difference between the two groups in terms of sex, age, education, pre-training otological work time and scores of basic theory (Table 2). Each otological training period was 6 months, and the middle stage of training was 3 months. Senior attending otologists and deputy chief otologists served as teachers.

Table 2. Characteristics of subjects in Groups A and B

Item

Group A (n=34)

Group B (n=30)

t value

P value

Gender

Male

Female

Age (Yrs.)

Education

Undergraduate

Postgraduate

Doctor

Pre-training otological working time (practitioners)

0 year

0～1 year

>1 year

Pre-training scores of basic theory of otology (points)

19(55.9%)

15(44.1%)

26.4±1.6

11(32.4%)

20(58.8%)

3(8.8%)

26(76.5%)

6(17.6%)

2(5.9%)

65.4±5.2

18(60.0%)

12(40.0%)

25.8±1.5

10(33.3%)

18(60.0%)

2(6.7%)

23(76.7%)

5(16.7%)

2(6.7%)

64.8±6.5

0.11

1.54

Fisher

0.41

0.73^*

0.13

0.95^**

0.99^**

0.68

Note: ^*usingχ² test;^** using Fisher test.

Scores of identification proficiency of middle and inner ear structure CT

After an otological training period, the identification proficiency of the two groups for the middle and inner ear structure in temporal CT was greatly improved. Notably, there was no significant difference in the proficiency scores between the two groups before training (P > 0.05), but there was a significant difference in the proficiency scores between the two groups after training, of which the identification proficiency for each structure of middle and inner ear in CT in Group A was better than that in Group B (P < 0.05), indicating that the mixed teaching with reading list could help students improve their ability to identify the anatomical structure in temporal CT (Table 3).

Table 3. Identification proficiency of middle and inner ear structure CT before and after training - VAS scores (points, ±ѕ )

Proficiency Type

Group A (n=34)

Group B (n=30)

P value

Temporal CT reading

Before training

After training

Overall middle and inner ear structure

Before training

After training

Ossicle structure

Before training

After training

Vestibular window and round window

Before training

After training

Facial nerve and bone canal

Before training

After training

Hypotympanum, tympanic opening of auditory tube

Before training

After training

Scute, tympanic sinus, facial nerve recess

Before training

After training

Cochlea, vestibule, semicircular canal

Before training

After training

Sigmoid sinus, bulb of jugular vein, carotid canal

Before training

After training

Middle cranial fossa, posterior cranial fossa, vestibular aqueduct

Before training

After training

3.8±0.6

7.5±0.5

3.4±0.5

7.9±0.6

4.1±0.5

8.6±0.5

2.7±0.6

8.1±0.5

3.1±0.6

6.8±0.7

4.3±0.5

8.7±0.5

4.5±0.5

7.8±0.4

2.2±0.6

6.4±0.5

3.1±0.5

6.8±0.6

2.6±0.5

7.3±0.4

3.6±0.6

6.2±0.7

3.6±0.4

6.4±0.6

3.9±0.6

7.1±0.4

2.5±0.5

7.1±0.6

3.3±0.4

5.5±0.6

4.4±0.6

7.8±0.6

4.3±0.6

5.6±0.6

2.3±0.5

5.1±0.4

2.9±0.5

5.3±0.4

2.7±0.4

5.8±0.5

0.19

<0.01

0.08

<0.01

0.15

<0.01

0.16

<0.01

0.13

<0.01

0.47

<0.01

0.15

<0.01

0.48

<0.01

0.12

<0.01

0.38

<0.01

Scores of temporal CT reading test

The scores of reading in the two groups showed escalation trend in the initial and middle stage and at the end of the training (P < 0.01), indicating that both teaching modes could promote the students’ identification of temporal CT. However, it is worth noting that there was no significant difference in the scores of temporal CT reading test between the two groups in the early and middle stages of the training; at the end of the training, there was a difference between the two groups: the scores (84.2 ± 7.1 points) of Group A were significantly better than those (76.2 ± 6.4 point) of Group B (t = 4.71, P < 0.01). The results further demonstrated that the scores of Group A were better than those of Group B due to the application of teaching mode with reading list after the middle stage of the training (Tables 4 - 6).

Table 4. Scores of CT reading test in two groups during training (point, ±ѕ )

Group

Cases

Initial Stage

Middle Stage

Completion

GROUP A

GROUP B

55.4±5.3

56.2±6.5

71.4±6.2

72.3±5.5

84.2±7.1

76.2±6.4

t value

P value

---

-0.54

0.59

-0.61

0.54

4.71

<0.01

Results of questionnaire

In this study, a total of 64 questionnaires were sent out, a total of 64 effective questionnaires were recovered, and the recovery rate of effective questionnaires was 100%. The results of questionnaires showed that the evaluation in the learning interest, prediction ability of surgical risk, prevention of missed diagnosis and misdiagnosis risk, doctor-patient communication ability, standard organization of reading, self-confidence in reading, self-learning of reading, and satisfaction degree with reading teaching methods in Group A were better than those in Group B (P < 0.05), indicating that the use of reading list achieved good teaching effect (Table 7).

Table 7 Evaluation of two teaching modes of temporal CT reading by students

Evaluation Item

GROUP A (n=34)

GROUP B (n=30)

Chi-square value

Pvalue

Question 1 Beneficial to increasing interest in learning

Question 2. Beneficial to improving prediction ability of surgical risk

Question 3 Beneficial to avoiding missed diagnosis and misdiagnosis

Question 4. Beneficial to improving doctor-patient communication skills

Question 5 Beneficial to improving standard organization of CT reading

Question 6 Beneficial to improving self-confidence in CT reading

Question 7 Beneficial to self-learning of CT reading

Question 8 Satisfaction with teaching mode

3(8.8%)

5(14.7%)

26(76.5%)

1(2.9%)

5(14.7%)

28(82.4%)

1(2.9%)

8(23.5%)

25(73.5%)

4(11.8%)

7(20.6%)

23(67.6%)

0(0%)

7(20.6%)

27(79.4%)

2(5.9%)

6(17.6%)

26(76.5%)

3(8.8%)

9(26.5%)

22(64.7%)

0(0%)

4(11.8%)

30(88.2%)

7(23.3%)

10(33.3%)

13(43.3%)

4 (13.3%)

10(33.3%)

16(53.3%)

7(23.3%)

10(33.3%)

13(43.3%)

7(23.3%)

11(36.7%)

12(40.0%)

5(16.7%)

10(33.3%)

15(50.0%)

7(23.3%)

11(36.7%)

12(40.0%)

7(23.3%)

12(40.0%)

11(36.7%)

6(20.0%)

18(60.0%)

7.03

6.40

7.40

4.61

7.28

9.04

5.38

7.68

<0.01

0.01

<0.01

0.03

0.01

<0.01

0.02

<0.01

Common otological diseases, such as chronic suppurative otitis media and cholesteatoma of middle ear, need surgical treatment after definite diagnosis and temporal CT examination before surgery. Temporal CT could clearly show whether the mastoid process, tympanic sinus, and tympanum have lesions involving middle cranial fossa, sigmoid sinus, bulb of jugular vein, facial nerve and other anatomical variations[8, 9], providing important preoperative reference for otologists and guiding surgical operations. However, the teaching of temporal CT reading from the perspective and focus of otological surgeons has not been reported in the field of clinical teaching. Our previous surveys found that, during the otological training period, teachers were not organized and systematic in the teaching of temporal CT reading, and did not have suitable reference contents or forms; students had low interest in learning and insufficient self-confidence in reading, and were prone to missed diagnosis and misdiagnosis, seriously affecting preoperative evaluation and intraoperative judgment. As a result, it is necessary to strengthen the teaching of temporal CT reading in the clinical otological teaching.

Simplicity of complex processes in clinical medical work in the form of lists was an emerging practice in recent years [10]. The use of lists helped physicians at all levels reduce errors in diagnosis and treatment, especially for inexperienced junior physicians [11, 12]. It was reported that good results were achieved by using the diagnostic list of chest X-ray in imaging students for reading teaching[6]. The reading list of temporal CT used in this study was made with reference to the relevant literature and the actual situation of otological teaching from the perspective of otologists. The contents included the common abnormalities of anatomical sites of middle and inner ear, the range of lesions and the precautions, which were not found in the previous literature. By using the reading list of temporal CT, students could systemically learn reading and check the missing and errors, so as to reduce the rates of missed diagnosis and misdiagnosis and stimulate their interest in learning. In addition, the repeated application of reading list could also help students remember the contents of list and cultivate the standard reading habits of temporal CT. We found that the results of reading in Group A using reading list of temporal CT were significantly better than those in Group B, the reading efficiency, organization and self-confidence of students in Group A were significantly improved, and the satisfaction with the teaching mode of reading list in Group A reached 88.2%.

For common otological diseases, the focus of preoperative reading of CT is the anatomical variation of middle and inner ear and the range of lesions, which determines the surgical difficulty and the potential complications. When using reading list of temporal CT during teaching, according to the anatomical variations of middle and inner ear and intratemporal lesions, the complexity and complications of surgery can be predicted. Residents can have a clear gasp of situation when communicating with patients and their families before surgery, which is beneficial to improve the doctor-patient communication ability. The results of our questionnaire showed that the use of reading list of temporal CT improved residents' ability to predict surgical risk and their doctor-patient communication capability.

To sum up, in the teaching of temporal CT reading, the application of reading list can help residents cultivate standard and systematic reading habits, enhance their interest in learning and their ability to read temporal CT. Because of small sample size in this study, teaching practice can be carried out in multiple clinical centers in the future to expand the sample size. In addition, the contents of reading list of our temporal CT needs to be further improved, so as to promote its application in clinical teaching.

computer tomography ;

MRI

magnetic resonance imaging ;

VAS

visual Analogue Scale ;

Ethics approval and consent to participate

This study was approved by the Sun Yat-sen University Ethics Committee for Research and Publication.

Consent for publication

Not applicable.

Availability of data and materials

All data are available upon request from the authors.

Competing interests

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.

Funding

The study was supported by grants from the Natural Science Foundation of China

(81902753), the Natural Science Foundation of Guangdong Province

(2019A1515010620, 2017A030313700), 2018 Research Project on Teaching Reform of Sun Yat-sen University Otolaryngology Teaching Team Construction Project（80000-18823601）and 2018 Undergraduate Teaching Quality Construction Project of the First Affiliated Hospital of Sun Yat-sen University（80000-1884250）.

Authors’ contributions

All of the authors were involved in the conception and design of the study, the analysis and interpretation of data, and the revision of the manuscript and have approved the final manuscript.

Acknowledgements

Not applicable.

Yu Z, Wang Z, Yang B, Han D, Zhang L: The value of preoperative CT scan of tympanic facial nerve canal in tympanomastoid surgery. Acta Otolaryngol 2011, 131(7):774-778.
Yu Z, Han D, Gong S, Wang Z, Zhang L: The value of scutum erosion in the diagnosis of temporal bone cholesteatoma. Acta Otolaryngol 2010, 130(1):47-51.
Bell LTO, Dick O, Ali N, Little D: Undergraduate radiology education: foundation doctors' experiences and preferences. CLIN RADIOL 2019, 74(6):480-486.
Murakami T, Tajika Y, Ueno H, Awata S, Hirasawa S, Sugimoto M, Kominato Y, Tsushima Y, Endo K, Yorifuji H: An integrated teaching method of gross anatomy and computed tomography radiology. ANAT SCI EDUC 2014, 7(6):438-449.
Denney BD, Ray PR: Systematic method for initial rapid analysis of maxillofacial computed tomography scans for surgeons in training. ANZ J SURG 2016, 86(3):184-187.
Ely JW, Graber ML, Croskerry P: Checklists to reduce diagnostic errors. ACAD MED 2011, 86(3):307-313.
Czerny C, Turetschek K, Duman M, Imhof H: [Imaging of the middle ear. CT and MRI]. RADIOLOGE 1997, 37(12):945-953.
Lo AC, Nemec SF: Opacification of the middle ear and mastoid: imaging findings and clues to differential diagnosis. CLIN RADIOL 2015, 70(5):e1-e13.
Juliano AF, Ginat DT, Moonis G: Imaging review of the temporal bone: part I. Anatomy and inflammatory and neoplastic processes. RADIOLOGY 2013, 269(1):17-33.
Haynes AB, Weiser TG, Berry WR, Lipsitz SR, Breizat AH, Dellinger EP, Herbosa T, Joseph S, Kibatala PL, Lapitan MC et al: A surgical safety checklist to reduce morbidity and mortality in a global population. N Engl J Med 2009, 360(5):491-499.
Sibbald M, De Bruin AB, van Merrienboer JJ: Finding and fixing mistakes: do checklists work for clinicians with different levels of experience? Adv Health Sci Educ Theory Pract 2014, 19(1):43-51.
John SD, Moore QT, Herrmann T, Don S, Powers K, Smith SN, Morrison G, Charkot E, Mills TT, Rutz L et al: The Image Gently pediatric digital radiography safety checklist: tools for improving pediatric radiography. J AM COLL RADIOL 2013, 10(10):781-788.

PDF

Version 1

posted 30 Mar, 2020

You are reading this latest preprint version

Application Effect of Reading List in Teaching of Temporal CT Reading

Status:

Version 1

Abstract

Introduction

Methods

Results

Discussion

Conclusion

Abbreviations

Declarations

References

Status:

Version 1