3.1 Effect of inducer on triterpenoid content of I.hispidus
The triterpenoid content in I.hispidus treated with 50 µmol/L MeJA, 3% oleic acid ,formulation(2% oleic acid and100umol/L MeJA)increased significantly compared with that in the CK. Among them, the triterpenoid content in I.hispidus treated with formulation was the highest.
3.2 RNA‑seq and De Novo Assembly of I. hispidus Reference Transcriptome
RNA-seq on I.hispidus with different treatments was performed using the Illumina HiSeq 4000 sequencing platform, which resulted into four samples named CK and MeJA(S1),Oleic acid(S2),formulation(S3) with a total of 12 sequencing libraries. After filtering out the low-quality reads, the results in Table 1 showed that a total of 82,680,165 clean reads in CK、82,271,188 clean reads in the S1、91,676,834clean reads in the S2 and 96,148,730 clean reads in S3 were obtained. A total clean base number of 24.64G (CK) ,24.51G(S1),27.33G(S2) and 28.62G(S3), was obtained respectively. The percentage of Q30 was 92.98% or higher, and the percentage of GC was approximately 52%.
Table 1
Summary of Illumina HiSeq 4000 sequencing data
sample
|
Clean reads
|
Clean bases
|
Q30
|
GC
|
CK-1
|
28,043,969
|
8.35G
|
94.15
|
52.01
|
CK-2
|
27,100,025
|
8.07G
|
94.32
|
51.96
|
CK-3
|
27,536,171
|
8.22G
|
94.21
|
51.87
|
S1-1
|
30,910,974
|
9.21G
|
94.21
|
51.92
|
S1-2
|
25,327,950
|
7.55G
|
94.07
|
51.78
|
S1-3
|
26,032,264
|
7.75G
|
94.31
|
51.91
|
S2-1
|
34,705,547
|
10.36G
|
94.29
|
51.82
|
S2-2
|
27,883,532
|
8.30G
|
94.60
|
51.87
|
S2-3
|
29,087,755
|
8.67G
|
94.14
|
51.85
|
S3-1
|
32,483,363
|
9.66G
|
94.09
|
51.81
|
S3-2
|
30,986,102
|
9.22G
|
92.98
|
51.94
|
S3-3
|
32,679,265
|
9.74G
|
94.17
|
51.91
|
I.hispidus clean reads were assembled from 12 libraries using Trinity software to obtain 300,423 transcripts. The average read length and N50 length were 3407.04 and 4385 bp, respectively. (Table 2) By continuing to assemble these transcripts using Trinity, a total of 24306 unigenes were spliced, with an average read length and N50 length of 1096.06 and 2687 bp, respectively. Among them, 9520 (39.17%) were 200–300 bp, 4738 (19.49%) were 300–500 bp, 3067 (12.62%) were 500-1 kb, and 2784 (11.45%) were 1–2 k bp. 4197 (17.27%) are longer than 2 k bps.
Length_interval
|
200–300 bp
|
300–500 bp
|
500 bp–1 kbp
|
1 kb–2 kbp
|
> 2 k bp
|
Total
|
Table 2
Summary of splicing transcripts
Number of transcripts
|
10947
|
7551
|
12949
|
56309
|
212667
|
300423
|
Number of unigenes
|
9520
|
4738
|
3067
|
2784
|
4197
|
24306
|
3.3 Functional annotation and classification
In order to obtain comprehensive gene function information, all the assembled unigenes were successfully annotated using eight public databases. (Nr, Nt, Pfam, KOG, COG, Swiss-prot, KEGG, GO). As shown in Table 3, out of 19429 unigenes. The annotation success rate of unigenes was 6537 in COG (33.65%), 6884 in GO (35.76%), 6640 in KEGG (33.5%), 11968 in KOG (62.17%), 12430 in Pfam (63.98%), 8355 in Swiss-prot (43%), 17914 in eggNOG (92.2%), and 12754 in NR (65.60%). The functions of the predicted unigenes were classified in KOG, GO and KEGG.
Database
|
Number of unigenes
|
Percentage
|
Table 3
Function annotation of unigene
Annotated in COG
|
6537
|
33.65%
|
Annotated in GO
|
6884
|
35.76%
|
Annotated in KEGG
|
6640
|
33.5%
|
Annotated in KOG
|
11968
|
62.17%
|
Annotated in Pfam
|
12430
|
63.98%
|
Annotated in Swiss-prot
|
8355
|
43%
|
Annotated in eggNOG
|
17914
|
92.2%
|
Annotated in NR
|
12754
|
65.60%
|
Total unigenes
|
19429
|
100%
|
The species distribution of the Nr annotation showed that 36.22% (4606) of the unigenes had the highest homology to genes from Sanghuangporus baumii,13.72% (1744) to Fomitporia mediterranea, 2.62% (333) to Basidiobolus meristosporus, and 2.56% (325) to Spizellomyces punctatus. (Fig. 2)
KOG results show a total of 13,272 unigenes divided into 25 categories (Fig. 3a). Among these genes, the cluster “General function prediction only” cluster represented the largest group (R) (1797, 15.02%), followed by Posttranslational modification, protein turnover, chaperones (O) (1670, 13.95%), Translation, ribosomal structure and biogenesis (J) (1080, 9.02%), and Signal transduction mechanisms(T) (1077,9%). In addition, 418 (3.49%) unigenes were associated with secondary metabolites biosynthesis, transport and catabolism, and 105 were associated with defense mechanism unigenes (V).
According to sequence homology, 39274 unigenes were classified into three GO categories: biological process (14511,36.95%), cellular component (16952,43.16%), and molecular function (7811,19.89%) (Fig. 3b). The most popular terms in the biological process category were “metabolic processes (3868)”, “cellular processes (3778)” and “single-organism process (2406)”. In the cellular component category, the most common terms were “cell (3831)”, “cell parts (3811)”. and “organelle (2758)”. In the molecular function category, the main terms were “catalytic activity (3505)” and “binding (3124)”, suggesting that this study may provide clues to understanding genes involved in secondary metabolite synthesis pathways. Transcripts associated with binding GO terms were more common in the molecular functional category.
Comparing Unigenes with standard metabolic pathways in the KEGG database to better understand the biological pathways of I.hispidus leaves(Fig. 3c). The 6640 Unigenes are divided into 4 KEGG categories and 117 sub categories: “metabolism”, “genetic information processing”, “environmental information processing” and “cellular processes”. In the KEGG secondary metabolic pathways, most unigenes were classified into “Biosynthesis of antibiotics” (606 unigenes, ko01130), “Ribosome” (499 unigenes, ko03010), “Carbon metabolism” (364 unigenes, ko01200) and “Biosynthesis of amino acids” (324 unigenes, ko01230).
3.4 Identification and analysis of DEGs
241 up regulated DEGs and 112 down regulated DEGs were identified in the group ‘CK vs S1’, 635 up regulated DEGs and 443 down regulated DEGs were identified in the group ‘CK vs S2’, 529 up regulated DEGs and 364 down regulated DEGs were identified in the group ‘CK vs S3’ (Fig. 4a.b.c). A total of 162 core DEGs (co-upregulated or co-downregulated in all three exogenous inducers treated samples) were obtained in the three comparison groups. Furthermore, overlapping studies found that there were 150, 296 and 126 unique genes in the S1, S2 and S3 (Fig. 4d)
3.5 Enrichment analysis of DEGs
To compare the unigenes from different inducer treated I.hispidus, a Venn diagram was constructed. The results showed that 6777 unigenes were shared by four sample. A total of 54, 61,44 and 43 unigenes were specific to CK, MeJA, Oleic acid, formulation treated I. hispidus, respectively, with the MeJA treated samples having the highest number of unique unigenes. (Fig. 5a)
KEGG pathway analysis of all DEGs was performed to characterize the complex biological behaviors. The enriched pathways are presented in Fig. 5, and reflected the preferential biological functions of samples from different inducer treated samples. In ‘CK vs S1’, genes involved in “Ribosome”, “DNA replication” and “Cell cycle – yeast” were overexpressed (Fig. 5b). Hierarchical clustering of all DEGs indicated that part unigenes enrichment characteristics were similar between the ‘CK vs S2’ and ‘CK vs S3’comparisons, with genes involved in “Ribosome”, “Peroxisome” and “ABC transporters” over-expressed (Fig. 5c.d). The major GO enrichment terms of the 162core DEGs were shown in Fig. 6a, including “translation”, “ribosome” and “structural constituent of ribosome” etc. The KEGG pathway enrichment analysis showed that the most of core DEGs were significantly enriched in Ribosome pathways (Fig. 6b).
3.6 Putative genes involved in triterpenoid biosynthesis
Triterpenoids are widely found in nature (Da et al. 2015). In plants, sesquiterpenoids are typically synthesized via mevalonate(MVA)and 2-methyl-d-erythritol 4-phosphate (MEP) biosynthetic pathways(Biswas et al. 2019). Although the MVA and MEP pathways are located in different intracellular regions, the two pathways are not separated. Additionally, there may be unknown interference between certain devices. It is generally believed that triterpenes and sesquiterpenes are synthesized through the MVA pathway, while monoterpenes and diterpenes are synthesized through the MEP pathway (Li et al.2020). IPP and DMAPP are catalyzed by the sequential conversion of geranyl diphosphate synthase (GPPS), clopyridine diphosphate synthase (FPPS), squalene synthase (SS) and squalene epodase (SE). It is an important intermediate for the oxidation of 2,3 squalene (Hyeonbae et al.2020; Pu et al.2021).
After annotating 117 pathways using the KEGG database, 29,13and 7 unigenes were found to be associated with the Terpenoid backbone biosynthesis(ko00900), Ubiquinone and other terpenoid-quinone biosynthesis(ko00130) and Sesquiterpenoid and triterpenoid biosynthesis(ko00909) pathways respectively. Comparing the NR database, a total of 29 unigenes that may be involved in the triterpene synthesis pathway of I.hispiduswere found (Table.4).
Gene
|
Gene number
|
Gene ID
|
Table 4
Unigenes involved in Biosynthesis of Triterpenoid.
SS
SE
AACT
HMGR
|
2
6
4
3
|
c7497.graph_c0、c14961.graph_c0
c16422.graph_c0、c15729.graph_c0、
c24729.graph_c0、c20215.graph_c0
c61.graph_c0、c19680.graph_c0
c8971.graph_c0、c16837.graph_c0
c7417.graph_c0、c18532.graph_c0
c12846.graph_c0、c17445.graph_c0
c18037.graph_c0、
|
FPPS
|
2
|
c3736.graph_c0、c67.graph_c0
|
FPS
|
2
|
c67.graph_c1、c10924.graph_c0
|
PMK
|
2
|
c13594.graph_c0、c22627.graph_c0
|
SM
|
1
|
c25144.graph_c0
|
HMGS
|
5
|
c10205.graph_c0、c16013.graph_c0
|
|
|
c26810.graph_c0、c20761.graph_c0
|
|
|
c27696.graph_c0
|
DMD
|
1
|
c9873.graph_c0
|
FT
|
1
|
c15553.graph_c0
|
SS: squalene synthase ,SE: squalene epoxidase, AACT: Acetyl−CoA acetyltransferase, HMGR: 3−hydroxy−3−methylglutaryl coenzyme A reductase, FPPS: Farnesyl pyrophosphate synthase, FPS: farnesyl−diphosphate synthase, PMK: Phospho mevalonate kinase, SM: squalene monooxygenase ,HMGS: hydroxymethylglutaryl−CoA synthase, DMD༚Diphospho mevalonate decarboxylase, FT༚farnesyl transferase
3.7 Analysis of CYP450 defense genes
CYP450 play important roles in plant defense through their involvement in phytoalexin biosynthesis, hormone metabolism and the biosynthesis of some other secondary metabolites (Qiu et al.2021; Zhang et al.2020). However, the systematic identification of CYP450 has not been reported in I.hispidus. By searching the annotation results of the transcriptome database of I.hispidus, we found that a total of 90 unigenes were annotated as CYP450, of which 66 CYP450 unigenes were annotated into the ‘defense mechanisms’. We speculate that due to the addition of exogenous inducers, I.hispidus causes defense response and promotes the synthesis of triterpenes. Most CYP450 annotated to the “defense mechanisms” also illustrate this view. After the addition of inducer, 1, 10 and 9 CYP450 genes were up-regulated in S1, S2 and S3 groups, respectively. Therefore, in this study, it can be speculated that the up regulation of CYP450 promotes the synthesis of triterpenoids, which will help to reveal its regulatory mechanism in the terpenoid synthesis pathway of I.hispidus.
In transcriptome sequencing data of I.hispidus, we found 2 SS, 6 se, 2 FPPS and other terpene related genes. Cytochrome P450 plays an important role in the terpene biosynthesis. Monoterpenes, sesquiterpenes, and diterpenes can be substrates of P450(Yu et al.2021). For example, Guo (2016) showed that CYP76AH3 and CYP76AK1 are involved in the tanshinone biosynthesis. In this study, 66 CYP450 genes were found in the defense pathway,among them, 1, 10 and 9 up-regulated genes were in MeJA, oleic acid and formulation groups respectively. Therefore, the accumulation of the triterpenoid content in I.hispidus might be due to exogenous inducer treatment, which activated and improved the CYP450 expression.
3.8 Analysis of defensive Enzymatic defense genes
As a traditional Chinese medicinal fungus, I.hispidus has been studied for its antitumor(Yang et al.2019) ,bacteriostatic(Angelini et al.2019) and other efficacy in the past. Elicitation is one of the most effective ways to increase the activity of plant compounds such as triterpenes (Tan et al.2021). The SOD, CAT and POD are important cytoprotective enzymes that eliminate reactive oxygen species in plants. Its activity may reflect plant adaptation to abiotic stress. (Xu et al.2014; Nguyen et al.2012). Exogenous inducers can affect the secondary metabolism of plants by altering the metabolism of reactive oxygen species (ROS), resulting in an increase in secondary metabolites (Ye et al.2013). Naeem.et al (2021) showed that salicylic acid can induce reactive oxygen species burst, up-regulate artemisinin gene expression, and increase artemisinin production. In transcriptome sequencing data of I.hispidus, 34 genes annotated as POD, 7 genes annotated as CAT and 5 genes annotated as SOD. However, we found that only three POD genes were up-regulated in the ‘CK vs S1’, others are normal genes. MeJA elicits rapid defense responses changes metabolic processes dramatically toward energy supply (Benevenuto et al.2018). Therefore, under the MeJA treatment of I. hispidus, the increase in the antioxidant enzyme activity was promoted through POD upregulation to regulate the biosynthesis of secondary metabolites, such as triterpenoid. However, how oleic acid stimulates metabolism needs further exploration.