Animals
The study protocol was approved by the Medical Ethical Committee of Hospital of Stomatology, Hebei Medical University (Approval Number: 2020012),The three female beagle dogs were purchased from Beijing Fangyuanyuan Farm (Beijing, China), ages 12–18 months, weight 10 kg, with complete dentition and healthy periodontal tissue, were reared in the Animal Center of Hebei Medical University, and the experiment was conducted after 1 week of adaptive feeding. This study conformed to the Arrived guidelines.
Preparation of CGF
Beagle dogs took supine position, with their limbs fixed on the operating table. We prepared the skin and collected blood 9 mL from the small saphenous vein of the hind limb after disinfection. Immediately we placed the sterile blood collection tube into the Medifuge centrifuge and started the concentrated growth factor preparation procedure. After centrifugation 15 min, the blood was divided into three layers: the top layer was the serum layer, the middle layer the CGF fibrin layer, and the bottom layer the erythrocyte layer. The upper serum was poured out and the sterile ophthalmic scissors were used to cut off the junction of the middle layer and the bottom layer. The CGF gel was placed on the inside of the double-layer of bovine acellular dermal matrices membrane (Fig. 1) , then the CGF gel was pressed with a special tool to make a membrane for operation.
Preparation of BADM
BADM (Haiao biofilm, ZH-Bio, China) is an absorbable collagen membrane derived from calf skin. The spatial structure of natural collagen fibers is preserved, which has two distinct surfaces: dense surface (UP side) and loose surface. We trimmed BADM to a suitable size, prepared 8-10 holes with aseptic mucosal needles, and then placed them in normal saline(Fig. 1a).
Preparation of collagen sponge
Collagen sponge (KejibangⓇ, Wuxi Biot Biology Technology Co., Ltd.), extracted from bovine Achilles tendon, is a spongy freeze-dried product of high purity collagen. We trimmed the collagen sponge to a suitable size.
Preparation of AADM
AADM (Beijing JayyaLife Bio-tissue Engineering Co. Ltd., Beijing, China), derived from human cadaveric tissue donated by the Charity Federation, with removed cellular components of epidermis and dermis, has two distinct surfaces: basement membrane surface and dermal surface. The dermal surface is conducive to the rapid vascularization of acellular dermal matrix after grafting, and the basement membrane surface is conducive to rapid epithelialization. We trimmed AADM to a suitable size, and then prepared 8-10 holes with aseptic mucosal needles. (Fig. 2)
Experimental grouping
Twelve augmentation areas on the labial side of bilateral upper and lower canines in three beagle dogs were randomly divided into three groups. Group A: double-layer AADM; Group B: BADM combined with CGF membrane; Group C: BADM combined with collagen sponge. Grafts size: 15 mm × 10 mm× 1.6 mm-1.8 mm (length × width × height).
Surgical procedure
Three beagle dogs were anesthetized with intramuscular injection of Xylazine Hydrochloride Injection 0.1 ml/kg (JiLing, China) and fixed on the operating table with lateral recumbent position. Then 0.5% iodophor was used to disinfect perioral skin and oral mucosa, and the sterile towels were spread. After local infiltration anesthesia with articaine hydrochloride, and epinephrine tartrate injection (Produits Dentaires Pierre Rolland, Merignac, France) on surgical site, a mesial vertical subepithelial incision was made on the attached gingiva at the canine area, then a microsurgical blade was inserted into the incision line and the attached gingiva was tunneled in a mesiodistal direction with a split-thickness flap. Subsequently, the tunnel was augmented with three groups of different soft tissue substitutes. In the double-layer AADM group, AADM was folded one time, with the dermal side in contact with gingiva and periosteum, while the basal side was inside the double-layered matrix. Then the graft was inserted and the mesial vertical incision was closed using resorbable sutures (Fig. 3). In the BADM combined with CGF group, BADM was placed on both sides of CGF, and CGF was pressed into a membrane with a special tool, forming BADM-CGF-BADM "sandwich" composite membrane, which then was inserted and the incision was tightly sutured. In BADM combined with collagen sponge group, BADM was placed on both sides of collagen sponge to form BADM-collagen sponge-BADM "sandwich" composite membrane, which then was inserted and the incision was tightly sutured.
Postoperative procedure
Beagle dogs were reared in separate cages after awakening from the operation, and 1.6 million units of penicillin (Shandong, China) were injected intramuscularly once a day for 3 days. They were given liquid diet and the oral cavity was rinsed routinely with normal saline every day to keep the surgical area clean.
Thickness measurement
The attached gingival thickness was measured before operation and after 1, 2, 3, and 4 months. It was measured at the point of 19 mm from the apical to the root along the central longitudinal axis of canine. We used the sterile needle with a stop to penetrate the attached gingival surface vertically, gently pressed into the soft tissue to the surface of the hard tissue, and then moved the stop to gently contact the attached gingival surface. Then carefully taking out the sterile needle, we used Vernier caliper with 0.02 mm resolution to measure the penetration depth (the distance from the tip of the sterile needle to the stop), which is the thickness of attached gingiva. The thickness was measured repeatedly by the same examiner for 3 times, and the average value was taken as the measured thickness of the attached gingiva (Fig. 4).
Histological analysis
After 4 months, under anesthesia, excision of gingival tissue from the augmentation area was made. The samples were fixed with 4% paraformaldehyde for 24 h and the sections were embedded with paraffin. Then HE and Masson staining were performed for descriptive histological analyses.
Statistical analysis
Spss21.0 software was used for statistical analysis. The mean difference and standard deviation were used to describe the attached gingival thickness and the thickness augmentation. Shapiro-Wilk test was used for normal analysis. If the data showed normal distribution, paired t-test was used to evaluate the change of attached gingival thickness before and after operation. One-way ANOVA was used for comparison among the three groups, LSD-t test was used for pairwise comparison. If the data showed non-normal distribution, rank sum test was used. All statistics were treated with bilateral test. (p < 0.05)