AML treatment focuses on targeted treatment strategies with a higher degree of affinity and reduced toxicity to gain increases in improved survival and recovery rates (Kayser, Levis, 2018); thus epigenetic therapeutics particularly seems to be an efficient candidate in this area (Zhao et al., 2020). This study aimed to evaluate the cellular effects of the newly discovered BRD4 inhibitor Plx51107 and the HDAC inhibitor Vorinostat, on the acute myeloid leukemia model HL60 cells and non-leukemic control cells, in vitro. Also, the hypothesis that a combination of Plx51107 and Vorinostat might have resulted in more remarkable outstanding and anticancer effects in AML when compared to either agent single usage for HL60 leukemic cells was tested. This seems to be the first study revealing the cellular effects of the Bet inhibitor Plx51107 and HDAC inhibitor Vorinostat combination treatment in AML to the best of our knowledge and literature research.
The Bet inhibitor Plx51107 was reported to be effectively combined with an anti-PD-L1 inhibitor to delay tumor growth in melanoma cells (Nikbakht et al., 2019); whereas, we evaluated the cytotoxic effects of it upon AML cell line HL60 for the first time. As the determined IC50 value of Plx51107 was 6.68 µM at 72nd hours for HL60 cells; the widely studied BET inhibitor JQ1 caused a dose-dependent decrease in cell viability with an IC50 of ∼500 nmol/L for OCI-AML3, RAGİ, and K562 cells. (Stewart et al., 2013). So, it can be concluded that Plx51107 exhibited a higher dose of IC50 for AML cells compared to the JQ1 inhibitor. As for vorinostat treatment, a 4.3µM IC50 dose was detected in HL60 cells at the 48th hour; and similar results were reported as 1.52 ± 0.07umol/L in HL60 cells (Ge et al., 2019) and less than 10µM in both HL60 and MCF-7 cells (Wen et al., 2014). The IC50 values determined for Plx51107 and vorinostat in NCIBL2171 healthy control cells were 1.24 µM and 2.01 µM at 72nd hours, respectively, and lower than HL60 leukemic cells as expected. The combination treatments of Plx51107 and vorinostat in HL60 cells seemed to be the first one in the literature, and we detected a synergistic effect only for HL60 cells since the combination IC50 dose was reduced to 3.26 µM; that led us to conclude that sensitization to the agents was accelerated in leukemic cells. Also, it was reported that OTX015-one of the BET inhibitors- also caused synergistic growth inhibition of KASUMI-leukemic cells, and the combination of vorinostat with JQ1 synergistically suppressed tumor growth (Ramadoss, Mahadevan, 2018).
Following cytotoxicity assays, apoptotic analyses were performed and detected that control NCIBL2171 cells showed very low apoptosis rates about ~ 1.5% for Plx51107 and Vorinostat IC50 doses. But leukemic cells exhibited very high rates of apoptosis either with mono or combination doses of the agents; but superior for mono dose treatments. It was reported that mono and combination treatments of JQ1 with Nutlin increased apoptosis in OCI-AML3 cell lines, and the combination was more effective (Stewart et al., 2013). In another study, JQ1 inhibitor was reported to increase the apoptotic cell rate from 6–48% in leukemia and lymphoma cell lines(Mertz et al., 2011). Vorinostat increased apoptosis in mouse bone marrow (Attia et al., 2020), also while causing an apoptotic rate of 5% in HL60 cells, it was increased to 20% in combination with decitabine (Young et al., 2017). So, we detected higher apoptosis rates reaching ~ 98% rather than in the literature. Based on the results, it is possible to say that single doses and combination doses induce apoptosis at similar rates.
Then, the effects of treatments on the cell cycle were analyzed, and detected that either vorinostat or Plx51107 caused G0/G1 arrest in NCIBL2171 cells. Both Plx51107 and vorinostat mono treatment doses induced G0/G1 phase arrest. It is observed that Plx51107 caused an increase in G0/G1 arrest and vorinostat causes arrest in G2/M. When two agents were used together, this caused G0/G1 arrest. Based on these results, when our data were compared with the literature, it was observed that treatment of HL60 cells with vorinostat caused G2/M arrest and a dose-dependent reduction of cells in the G1 and S phases. This suggested that our results were consistent with the vorinostat dose (Silva, G., et al., 2013). In another study, it was concluded that JQ1 treatment, which is a BET inhibitor, decreased cell viability with G0/G1 cell cycle arrest in myeloid leukemia cell lines, and it was consistent with our results (Pericole, F. V., et al., 2019).
Anti-tumor activities of BET Bromodomain inhibitors have been demonstrated in different preclinical models from hematological or solid tumors, and BET Bromodomain inhibitors reduce the transcription of genes regulated by “super-enhancers-activators” such as MYC and other genes essential for neoplastic cells. BET bromodomain inhibitors are in ongoing oncology/hematology phase I clinical trials (Boi et al., 2015). Since these agents prevent the expression of some growth-promoting genes in leukemic cells, induce apoptosis, and inhibit proliferation in tumor cells by overexpressing bromodomain proteins, next we checked some target genes’ differing expression profiles. As for the apoptotic genes, Plx51107 down-regulated anti-apoptotic Bcl-x and pro-apoptotic Bax genes in HL60 cells; whereas vorinostat caused down-regulation of other apoptotic genes except for Casp8; and combination treatments caused down-regulation of all apoptotic genes. In a current study, the effect of chidamidine in combination with decitabine was reported to be induced tumor cell apoptosis through up-regulation of Bax and Casp-3 and down-regulation of Bcl-2 in AML cell lines (Mao, J et al., 2018). Although the cell lines were the same, the used drugs were different; similar results were obtained. HDAC inhibitors and BET inhibitors have been shown to suppress Bcl-2 genes in leukemia cells and cause a decrease in expression (Ramadoss, Mahadevan, 2018). In our study, it was observed that Bcl-2 was down-regulated in the AML cell line HL60; whereas we observed compatible results.
As for cell cycle regulation-related genes’ expressions, CDKN2A was up-regulated in NCIBL2171 cells via vorinostat treatment; whereas it was down-regulated in Plx51107 and vorinostat combination in HL60 cells. Since cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitors accelerate cell cycle transition by suppressing CDKN2A and CDKN2B and activated mitogen-activated protein kinase signaling (Chaturverdi et al., 2013), the combination treatment acted similarly in leukemic cells. An expressional increase was observed in the ATM gene in HL60 cells following PLX51107 and vorinostat treatment; whereas ATM expression was reported to be down-regulated in AML cell lines and the bone marrow of AML patients (Sun Y. et al., 2019). We also detected that both agents caused an expressional decrease in the CCND1 in HL60 cells. Since Chen et al. had shown that high expression of CCND1 caused a poor prognosis for fusion AMLs (Chen et al., 2019), combination treatment still indicated a therapeutic approach. These results suggest that mono and combined usage of these two agents for induced cell cycle arrest were in line with expressional regulations of these genes.
JAK/STAT family seems to be highly correlated with leukemia pathogenesis (Fasouli ES, Katsantoni E., 2021); then the expressional changes were detected. Similarly, STAT1 was down-regulated due to Plx5107 and Voriostat treatment in leukemic cells. In chronic myeloid leukemia, the tyrosine kinase inhibitor Imatinib caused inhibition and decreased expression of the STAT1 gene (Čokić, V. P. et al., 2015), leading to a therapeutic approach. Besides, STAT3 - a potent oncogene- exhibited increased expression in AML cell lines compared to control cells; as being a predictor of AML risk (Huang, C. S et al., 2019). There was an expressional decrease in the STAT3 gene at the Plx51107 IC50 dose and the combination 2 dose in HL60 cells; so both STAT1 and STAT3 were downregulated in leukemic cells. When another transcription factor GATA1-regulator of erythropoiesis- (Iacobucci I., 2016) expression was evaluated, a decrease was detected with each agent treatment in leukemic cells. GATA1 knockdown was reported to be an accelerator of leukemic stem cells to undergo functional alterations due to exposure to chemotherapeutics (Shimizu R, Yamamoto M., 2016). So, GATA1 down regulation points out a therapeutic approach to leukemia. As RUNX1 is highly expressed in all cancer cells; but especially in the acute myeloid leukemia cells (Sun et al., 2019), we analyzed its expression and detected a decrease in HL60 leukemic cells following either Plx51107 or vorinostat treatment, indicating a novel therapeutic approach.
When epigenetics-related genes’ expressional regulations were evaluated, a significant downregulation was detected in DNMT3a in HL60 cells by treatment with PLX51107, vorinostat, and their combinations. Similarly, Stewart et al have reported that DNMT3a isoforms showed selective down-regulation in acute myeloid leukemia cells (Stewart et al., 2015). Other major players of epigenetics in the case of chromatin remodeling; IKZF1 and IKZF3 genes’ expressions were highly and significantly decreased in leukemia cells. It was reported for multiple myeloma cells that their growth was inhibited by ubiquitination and degradation of the IKZF1 and IKZF3 genes (Krönke et al., 2017). Finally, we checked BRD4 expression both at mRNA and protein levels; expressional down-regulations were detected. In a study that used similar agents as ours; it was revealed that the bromodomain inhibitor JQ1 and the HDAC inhibitor Nutlin-3 impaired the BRD4-mediated transport of p53 to chromatin regions which caused apoptosis. In addition, suppression of BRD4 resulted in cell cycle arrest, senescence, p21 upregulation, and cell death (Stewart et al., 2013). Also, Coudé et al. reported that another BET inhibitor OTX015 caused an expressional decrease in BRD2 and BRD4 in most cell lines (Coudé et al., 2015). A recent study designed by Shilei Liu et al. showed that BRD4 inhibitor and histone deacetylase inhibitor inhibited the proliferation of gallbladder cancer synergistically in vitro and in vivo ( Shilei Liu et al., 2019). We also detected that our Bet inhibitor Plx51107, Vorinostat, and their combined treatments downregulated BRD4 expression, achieved cell cycle arrest, and induced apoptosis in leukemic cells. Overall, our data showed for the first time that the usage of a new BET inhibitor PLX51107 selectively targeted leukemic cells and it could be a potential novel therapeutic agent in cancer therapy.