This study aimed to investigate the feasibility of apical resection combined with retrograde filling and sealing of the root canal system without root canal therapy and to study the survival rate, success rate and related clinical manifestations. The retention rate of 22 transplanted teeth included in this study was 100%, and the success rate was 81.8%, which was basically consistent with the traditional operation. However, the study has some shortcomings such as small sample size and insufficient follow-up time. More clinical cases and longer follow-up time are needed to verify the treatment plan. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first study in which an external apical excision combined with retrograde filling was performed without endodontic treatment.
The results of a retrospective analysis of external apical resection for revascularisation of ATT showed that the 35 patients with a mean age of 13 years (range: 8–28 years) had a survival rate of 91.4% after a mean follow-up of 3.4 years, and 62.5% had no potential adverse findings, with a higher failure rate (72.7%) in the molar group than in the premolar group (17.6%) and the canine group (25%). ([8]) In Skoglund's animal studies, the removal of the apical root through the external mouth did not increase the chance of revascularisation[9]. Our study mainly focused on the tooth transplantation in the molar region. The donor teeth had multiple fused roots or irregular root canal morphology, and the diameter of apical hole required for the revascularisation of mature ATT after apical resection was hard to obtain; the teeth with apical diameters of 0.5–1.0 mm attained the highest clinical success rate[10]). The results of the present study show that 5 of the 7 mature molars showed post-operative symptoms or failure without revascularisation after apicectomy.[8]
Interestingly, based on the comparison of the merged roots of ATT (9 cases), single root with single root canal of ATT (2 cases) and multiple root of ATT success rate (11 cases), found in the ATT of adverse clinical and imaging findings : 3 cases were the ATT with fused roots group, only 1 case came from the ATT multiple roots group. this finding might be related to the low identification or high variation of the root canal of the fused root, suggesting that methylene blue staining combined with preoperative CBCT may be used to effectively distinguish the root canal orifice after root resection and thus achieve complete apical closure.
Perfect root canal therapy is a sufficient and necessary condition for the successful transplantation of mature permanent teeth. For donor teeth with fully developed roots, root canal therapy is usually started within 1–2 weeks after the operation to prevent the inflammatory absorption of root caused by pulp necrosis and effectively protect the periodontal membrane. [3] The main donor teeth for ATTs are wisdom teeth, whose root canal system may exhibit several anatomic variations[11]. General dentists may find it difficult to complete the filling ,which may restrict the promotion of ATT technology. Intraoperative apical resection and iRoot BP Plus backfilling were performed, which are simple to operate and could well seal the root canal orifice.
IRoot is a bioactive ceramic material based on calcium silicate. Its main components are calcium silicate, calcium carbonate, zirconia and tantalum oxide. iRoot BP Plus is paste, and it is non-toxic to pulp and periodontal tissue, has good biocompatibility, induces osteogenesis, promotes the regeneration of periodontal tissue, and has good sealing, antibacterial property, and adhesion ability[12]. In comparison with MTA, it can be used in the anterior teeth without changing the color of teeth, and it is not necessary to deploy when using, which can shorten the time of donor teeth in vitro.
Approximately 10% of the third molars with multiple roots have auxiliary root canals that communicate with periodontal tissue, which may be detrimental to our surgical method[13]. However, no adverse results caused by such reasons have been found in our cases in clinical and imaging examinations, thus requiring regular postoperative follow-up.
In one patient, external absorption occurred in the ATT and was communicated with the pulp cavity, which occurred near the root section. Moreover, periodontal membrane cells were considered to be damaged during root resection. The protection of periodontal membrane cells is one of the keys to the success of transplantation. During transplantation, the new 3D printed guide plate can reduce the number of trial implantation and the risk of iatrogenic injury. In addition, aseptic operation during the operation, gentle extraction method, control of a short time outside the mouth, and no pressure implanted in the compression area, are also important methods to protect periodontal membrane cells.
Necrotic pulp may cause endodontic absorption after root resection and retrograde filling, which is not present in our case so far. The American Society of Endodontics defines absorption as a physiological or pathological process that results in the loss of dentin, cementum, or bone tissue.Pathological absorption in tooth points to normal pulp tissue granulation denaturation, cause pulp cavity inside tooth body hard tissue absorption, and gradually to the pathological changes of the dentin layer around the progress.[17] Considering that the energy source required by cell activity cannot be separated from the supply of surrounding tissues, as long as no accessory root canal is connected with periodontal tissue, the occurrence of infection can be avoided in theory.
Among the 22 ATTs of 22 patients, 18 crowns remained intact, 4 had received root canal treatment caused by apical inflammation but no crown repair was carried out, and no tooth fracture or obvious hidden crack was found in all patients. Dehydration and root canal treatment do not change the physical and mechanical properties of dentine. The increased incidence of tooth fracture after root canal treatment is caused by the loss of dental structural integrity related to pathways preparation. Restorations that improve structural integrity will improve the outcome of root canal treatment. The integrity of dental crowns can improve its mechanical properties and greatly reduce its treatment cost.[18]
Tooth pulp necrosis results in crown discoloration, and the main cause of crown discoloration is tooth trauma and bacterial infection caused by pulpitis.[19] For molars and premolars, the teeth are not in the aesthetic zone, and even though crown discoloration has limited effect on the patient. The front teeth are in the aesthetic area. If the discoloration of the crown obviously affects the patient’s life, the patient may consider veneer repair or bleaching to meet their needs.
According to the chewing efficiency test and questionnaire survey, most of the patients think that their ATTs can chew normally (90%) and can chew hard objects (e.g., nuts and peanuts: 63.6%), and they will not actively avoid the use of ATTs (72.7%). Moreover, the chewing efficiency has been remarkably improved (81.8%), and it has recovered to 82.0% of the healthy side. Although 45.5% of the patients experienced symptoms of food impaction during chewing, the majority of patients were satisfied or very satisfied with the ATTs (90.9%). For the symptoms of food impaction, the conservative approach is to teach the patient to use dental floss to solve the problem, and dental treatment methods include full crown repair or orthodontic adjustment. However, after the restoration of mandibular arch with implant-supported prosthesis, both bite force and chewing efficiency of all subjects increased and were comparable to that of matched completely dentate subjects after 3 months[20]. This finding might have been obtained, because the crown shape of the ATT does not match the original molar of the donor tooth position, and the contact area between the ATT and its counterpart tooth is reduced, thus remarkably decreasing the chewing efficiency[21].