Literature search results
A total of 327 articles were initially identified (Fig. 2); 43 from PubMed, 112 from Cochrane, 172 from Google Scholar, and 0 from APA PsycINFO. A total of 87 articles were selected after the initial title and abstract screening and removal of duplicates. After manual searches and a full-text review, 37 articles were selected. The reference lists of all the included studies were examined to identify any additional studies that would meet the inclusion criteria. Twenty-one articles were included for final data extraction. All studies were labelled by the first author and year of first publication. The year of publication ranged from 2004 to 2021.
Characteristics of included studies
Study characteristic details are in Table 1. Most of the studies were conducted in the United States (n=5), followed by the United Kingdom (n=3), Australia (n=3), Netherlands (n=2) and Sweden (n=2), Germany (n=2), Denmark (n=1), Greece (n=1), Ireland (n=1) and Nigeria (n=1). Thirty-eight percent (n=8) of studies were cross-sectional in design, followed by other designs comprising 14.2% (n=3) qualitative design, 14.2% (n=3) retrospective, 9.5% (n=2) prospective, 4.76%(n=1) randomized controls trials, 4.76% (n=1) population-based cohorts, 4.76% (n=1) retrospective 4.76% (n=1) case-control, 4.76% (n=1) pilot study. The SF-36 (n=5) followed by FAOS (n=4) were the main instruments used to assess QoL. All articles were rated from moderate to high-quality; no study scored lower than 7 points. Sixteen articles were classified as high quality, and five studies (23.8%) were moderate.
Table 1
Study characteristics
References
|
Country
|
Study design
|
QoL instrument
|
Sample size
|
Mean Age
|
Gender distribution
|
Symptoms’ duration
|
Plinsinga et al
|
Australia
|
Case-control
|
EQ-5D, hospital anxiety and depression scale, TSK
|
75
|
AT: 45.7, Control: 41
|
AT: M: 17, F: 13, Control: M: 6, F:5
|
|
Ceravolo et al
|
Australia
|
Exploratory study
|
AQoL-8D
|
92
|
|
M: 49, F:43
|
|
Turner et al
|
Australia
|
Qualitative, interpretive description design
|
Semi-structured telephone interviews VISA-A
|
15
|
45.2, (n = 15)
|
M:8, F:7
|
8 months
|
Nørregaard et al
|
Denmark
|
|
Modification KOOS
|
53
|
42
|
|
28.5 months
|
Petersen et al
|
Germany
|
Prospective Randomised Study
|
SF-36
|
100
|
42.5
|
M:60, F:40
|
7.4 months
|
Knobloch et al
|
Germany
|
Cohort Study
|
FAOS
|
86
|
|
M:38, F:25
|
7 months
|
Dedes et al
|
Greece
|
Cross-sectional
|
UoP-PFQ
|
130
|
|
M:60, F:70
|
|
Mc Auliffe et al
|
Ireland
|
Qualitative interpretive description design
|
Semi-structured telephone interviews, VISA
|
8
|
40
|
M:6, F: 2
|
20.5 months
|
Opdam et al
|
Nether-lands
|
Retrospective
|
FAOS
|
59
|
50
|
M:18, F:27
|
45 months
|
Sleeswijk et al
|
Nether-lands
|
Cross-sectional
|
EQ-5D
|
80
|
50
|
M:39, F:41
|
15.7 months
|
Aiyegbusi et al
|
Nigeria
|
Cross-sectional
|
VISA-A
|
345
|
30.3
|
M:257, F:45
|
|
Roos et al
|
Sweden
|
Randomised study
|
FAOS
|
44
|
46
|
M:21, F:23
|
5.5 months
|
Alfredson et al
|
Sweden
|
Pilot study
|
SF-36
|
24
|
M:45, F:50
|
M:13, F:11
|
18 months
|
Deans et al
|
UK
|
Prospective case series
|
FAOS
|
26
|
45.77
|
M:10, F:16
|
|
Maffulli et al
|
UK
|
Cross-sectional
|
VISA-A, EQ-5D
|
82
|
53.18
|
M:52, F:30
|
|
Mallows et al
|
UK
|
Qualitative interpretive description design
|
Semi-structured interviews
|
|
49.2
|
M:6, F:4
|
12.9 months
|
Martin et al
|
US
|
Cross-sectional
|
SF-36
|
44
|
58.2
|
M: 18, F:26
|
|
Chimenti et al
|
USA
|
Retrospective
|
SF-36
|
34
|
52.2
|
|
18 months
|
Corriga et al
|
USA
|
Cross-sectional
|
VISA-A
|
53
|
54.5
|
M:35, F:18
|
7 months
|
Phen et al
|
USA
|
Retrospective
|
SF-36
|
37
|
<60: 49.1, >60: 66.8
|
<60: M:5, F:16, >60: M:2, F:15
|
|
Chimeti et al
|
USA, Australia GermanyIndia, New Zeland, UK
|
Cross-sectional
|
TSK-11
|
442
|
36.3
|
M:191, F:251
|
|
AT: Achilles Tendinopathy; M: Male; F: Female; EQ-5D: EuroQol 5 dimensions; TSK: Tampa Scale for Kinesiophobia; AQoL-8D: assessment of the quality of life-8-dimension; VISA-A: Victorian Institute of Sport Assessment- Achilles questionnaire; KOOS: Knee Injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score; SF-36: Short Form 36; FAOS: Foot and Ankle Outcome Score; UoP-PFQ: University of Peloponnese Pain, Functionality and Quality of Life Questionnaire; TSK-11: Tampa Scale for Kinesiophobia-11
Characteristics of AT patients
The total population diagnosed with AT was 1772, of which 51.8% (n=918) were men and 48.2% were women. All the articles included in this review included both men and women. The mean number of AT patients per study was 84.3, with a sample size varying between 8 (13) and 442 (14). The mean age of patients included in the articles ranges from 30 to 66.8. Five articles investigated midportion AT, and four investigated insertional AT, three included patients with both midportion and insertional AT, and seven did not specify the location of AT. Concerning laterality, nine studies included both unilateral and bilateral AT, only one included unilateral AT, and eleven did not specify.
QoL in patients with AT versus Demographic Factors
Age showed a significant impact on AT patients’ QoL (15). Knobloch et al. (16) found that results were unfavourable among women older than 50. Weight, height and BMI did not show a significant impact. Compared with the control population, QoL was reported to be worse, especially in the physical function, role-physical, bodily pain, and social functioning domains (17–20) and all EQ-5D domains except self-care. Additionally, AT patients reported similar or worse QoL than individuals with other musculoskeletal diseases such as Rheumatoid Arthritis (RA), Osteoarthritis (OA), and fibromyalgia (2). Moreover, lower QoL was associated with one or more comorbidities, specifically, low back pain, high blood pressure, and diabetes (21). Chimenti et al. (14) found that patients identified as Hispanic or Latino presented higher kinesiophobia levels compared to the group identified as Caucasian. Concerning gender, women with AT reported worse QoL and did not benefit from eccentric or stretching training as much as men (16, 22). Conversely, one study found no difference between genders (23).
QoL in patients with AT versus Psychosocial Factors
Mc Auliffe et al. (13) found that AT affected patients as they felt a loss of self-esteem. Moreover, patients reported frustration as practitioners could not explain AT and had different opinions. AT patients also complain about their condition disrupting their daily activities, which affects their well-being and QoL (13, 24).
QoL and Physical Activity
It has been reported that AT is common in those who participate in sporting activities. However, it also affects less-active individuals. The studies included in this review show that QoL affects both patients with low and high activity levels as both groups show higher degrees of kinesiophobia. The loss of ability to exercise was reported to have a significant impact (25). However, being active in sports before AT has been reported significantly impact QoL after non-interventional treatment (26).
QoL and Educational Programs
Mallow et al. (25) conducted an interview and found that therapist understanding and empathy were essential for patients. Moreover, education was considered crucial, as well as good management of pain during exercise and a personalised approach with respect and understanding of each patient personal social circumstances and lifestyle. Patients also reported how AT has negatively impacted their self-identity and well-being and has caused body perception disturbance (27).
QoL and conservative and Surgical Interventions
Some studies showed that surgical intervention and its impact on QoL depended on demographic variables and only improved physical components. Chimenti et al. (14) reported that only the physical component showed improvement after a percutaneous ultrasonic tenotomy, while no significant changes were found in the mental component. Similarly, Deans et al. (2012) showed that although the physical domain improved after Autologous-conditioned Plasma (ACP) injections combined with exercise and therapeutic ultrasonography, patients’ QoL did not show significant improvement as patients reported that they had not been able to resume the activities they were used to before the injury. Patients with bilateral AT showed similar improvements after endoscopic treatment to unilateral patients except for activity in the daily living domain (28). Phen et al. (29) reported that patient satisfaction was lower among patients older than 60 years of age compared to younger patients.