Most testicular tumors are malignant germ cell tumors [3,4]; thus, biopsy is generally not an option for testicular tumors this technique can lead to a higher recurrence rate. Therefore, radical orchiectomy is generally performed directly for testicular tumors, which will inevitably lead to some benign tumors and lymphomas being mistakenly cut from the testis. Non-neoplastic lesions of the testis generally do not require surgery. Benign tumors of the testis generally only require tumor enucleation, while lymphoma requires a comprehensive treatment that does not require surgery, mainly involving chemotherapy and radiotherapy. Therefore, the pathological diagnosis of testicular tumors by preoperative ultrasound (and not just a diagnosis as being benign or malignant) is of significant value in guiding surgery and preserving the testis of some patients. In this study, we found that CEUS accurately identified benign and malignant testicular lesions and also allowed the preliminary diagnosis of different pathological types of testicular tumors, including testicular focal infarction, epidermoid cysts, spermatogenic tumors, SLTC and lymphoma.
1. Testicular non-neoplastic lesions
Testicular non-neoplastic lesions include some focal infarcts and hematomas. The diagnosis of testicular hematoma is easier in the presence of a history of testicular trauma. However, a spontaneous testicular hematoma without a history of trauma is difficult to diagnose and is easily misdiagnosed as a testicular tumor [8]. In this study, one case of spontaneous hematoma had dull pain in the testis after bathing. Conventional ultrasound identified irregular hypoechoic signals in the right testis. Because there was no history of trauma, this was considered to be a malignant tumor. CEUS showed no enhancement in the mass and a diagnosis of spontaneous hematoma was made. Ultrasound-guided aspiration was used to draw out blood and the mass was gradually absorbed and reduced during ultrasound follow-up; this was consistent with changes associated with a hematoma. Testicular necrosis resulting from complete testicular torsion is relatively easy to diagnose [9]. Focal testicular necrosis secondary to a history of orchitis or vascular injury can also be diagnosed by ultrasonography [10,11]. Spontaneous testicular segmental infarcts are easily misdiagnosed as tumors in the absence of a relevant medical history, thus leading to unnecessary surgical resection [12–14]. In this study, two cases of segmental infarction showed solid echoes on conventional ultrasound. Because there was no relevant medical history, conventional ultrasound could not determine whether these were tumors or not. CEUS showed no enhancement, consistent with typical infarction. Due to the large infarct size, the infarct was resected. Therefore, for a spontaneous hematoma or segmental infarction with solid echoes on ultrasound, CEUS typically shows no enhancement, and can be clearly diagnosed as a non-neoplastic lesion, thereby avoiding unnecessary surgery.
(2) Testicular epidermoid cysts
Testicular epidermoid cysts are a rare form of benign tumor that account for only 2.1% of all testicular tumors [15]. In recent years, testicular epidermoid cysts have been classified as prepubertal teratomas [16]. Usually these are asymptomatic or represent a palpable painless testicular mass. Unlike testicular malignancies, epidermoid cysts can be cured with only local excision [17]. However, it is still difficult to differentiate epidermoid cysts from malignant testicular tumors on imaging [18]. The conventional ultrasound appearance of a typical epidermoid cyst is an "onion skin-like" echo [19] with a well-defined circular non-homogeneous echo with no blood flow signals on CDFI. In this study, only one case was diagnosed with an epidermoid cyst due to an "onion skin-like" echo (no blood flow signal was seen). The remaining four cases were diagnosed as malignant tumors by conventional ultrasonography because of internal blood flow signals (possibly misdiagnosing the ‘twinkling artifact’ as blood flow). The “twinkling artifact” tends to occur behind irregular crystals (epidermoid cysts contain keratin and cholesterol crystals). If CEUS shows no enhancement, then the diagnosis is an epidermoid cyst. CEUS can help inexperienced sonographers identify twinkling artifacts to accurately diagnose epidermoid cysts and perform testicular-sparing local excision of the mass.
(3) Malignant germ cell tumors.
Malignant germ cell tumors mainly include seminomas, embryonal carcinomas, spermatocytic tumors and mixed germ cell tumors. Such tumors account for most testicular tumors and require radical orchiectomy [1,4]. In this study, we found that malignant germ cell tumors were larger in size; this was due to their rapid growth rate. These are difficult to detect when tumors are small in the early stages; they can only be detected when tumors have undergone enlargement. The main clinical manifestation is painless swelling of the scrotum; however, this is also a common feature of testicular tumors and has no specificity. Studies have shown that AFP and HCG have certain values in the judgment of testicular tumor types [1,3], Seminomas and spermatocytic tumors generally express normal tumor markers and a small number of seminomas have slightly elevated levels of HCG. AFP is known to be elevated in embryonal carcinomas and yolk sac tumors. This study showed that one case of seminoma had elevated HCG, one case of embryonal carcinoma had elevated AFP, and two cases of mixed germ cell tumors had elevated AFP and HCG (both cases featured embryonic carcinoma, yolk sac, and seminoma). It has been suggested that AFP and HCG have a certain value for embryonal carcinoma and mixed germ cell tumors but have limited value for most seminomas and spermatocytic tumors; however, seminoma is the most common form of testicular tumor. Malignant germ cell tumors show malignant features on conventional ultrasound (mostly with well-circumscribed hypoechoic and rich blood flow signals) but have similarities with lymphomas and SLCT. All cases in this group were diagnosed as malignant by conventional ultrasound, although the specific type was difficult to identify. Of these, five cases with malignant germ cell tumors showed perforating vessels; these tended to be diagnosed as lymphoma. Because of the obvious necrosis of embryonal carcinomas and mixed germ cell tumors, CEUS showed heterogeneous hyperenhancement. Furthermore, obvious necrotic areas were seen inside; this differed from lymphoma and SLCT. Seven cases of seminoma showed heterogeneous enhancement, and three cases of uniform hyperenhancement were easily misdiagnosed as lymphoma. The age of the patients with such homogeneously enhanced seminoma did not exceed 48 years, and the median age of patients with primary testicular lymphomas was approximately 70 years [20]. The minimum age of the lymphoma patients in this group was 55 year. Thus, age can be used as a distinguishing feature. Spermatocytic tumors are a rare form of malignancy and account for 0.61% of all testicular germ cell tumors [21]. Spermatocytic tumors and seminomas have similar cytological appearances; thus, it is difficult to differentiate between seminoma and lymphoma with conventional ultrasound [22]. However, the performance of CEUS is different. Spermatocytic tumors are the only tumors with sparse and low enhancement (with obvious necrotic areas within) among all forms of enhanced tumors and can be regarded as the characteristic manifestation of spermatocytic tumors. This manifestation of spermatocytic tumors is related to myxoid degeneration, edema, hemorrhage and necrosis [23].
(4) SLCT
Most SLCTs are benign tumors [24]. To preserve the endocrine function of the testis, the general choice of treatment is enucleation of the testicular mass [25,26]. Tumors are generally small, asymptomatic and are mostly detected by ultrasonography. A small number of patients present with gynecomastia and infertility although when tumors are larger, they present with painless enlargement of the scrotum [27,28]. In this study, no endocrine symptoms were detected in five cases (testosterone and estradiol assays were not performed), three cases were referred for a painless testicular mass, and two cases were found incidentally by ultrasound. Ultrasound findings were well-defined, round-like, isoechoic or hypoechoic, with abundant blood flow, similar to those of lymphoma and seminoma. In our study, peripheral annular blood flow was only seen in SLCT; therefore, this can be regarded as a characteristic manifestation. Accordingly, three cases were diagnosed with SLCT. CEUS has characteristic manifestations: all patients showed uniform high enhancement without necrosis, fast forward and slow backward. Comprehensive judgment can be made in combination with testosterone and estradiol measurements [28,29].
(5) Testicular lymphoma
Primary testicular lymphomas are a rare form of extranodal lymphoma that accounts for 1 − 9% of all testicular malignancies [30,31]. The age of onset is generally over 50 years and the median age at diagnosis of primary testicular lymphoma was reported to be 70 years [20]. The clinical manifestation was painless enlargement of the scrotum; this was a consistent observation throughout this study. Lymphoma requires ultrasound-guided needle biopsy for diagnosis, followed by comprehensive treatment with chemotherapy and radiotherapy. Conventional ultrasonography of testicular lymphoma presents as a well-demarcated, round-like hypoechoic region with abundant blood flow. This condition can be easily misdiagnosed as seminoma. It has been reported in the literature that perforating vessels (testicular long blood vessels run normally in the mass) have certain value in the diagnosis of testicular lymphoma [32]. However, in this study, only 37.5% (3/8) of lymphomas had perforating vessels, and five cases of malignant germ cell tumors had perforating vessels; thus, the diagnostic value of these perforating vessels is limited. With regards to c-enhanced ultrasound, except for one case with high enhancement and significant necrosis (perforating vessels in CDFI), the remaining cases showed uniform high enhancement (with no necrotic areas), fast forward and fast backward. Testicular lymphoma was considered if the mass was larger and no necrotic area was evident, fast forward and fast rewind, older age and negative tumor markers.
The present study had some limitations that needed to be considered. First, this was a single-center retrospective study with a small sample size; further research with a multi-center design and a large sample size is now required. Second, this study was limited by its retrospective design and differences in matched models; we did not perform CEUS-based quantitative analysis. Third, the testicular lesions selected in this study were accompanied by pathological results. Therefore, many suspected non-neoplastic testicular lesions that did not undergo surgery were not included; this may have led to some selection bias. Fourth, because of the extremely high accuracy of the diagnosis of testicular tumors by the professional andrology sonographers in our center, they have won the trust of andrologists. Most testicular tumors have not undergone magnetic resonance examination; consequently, there is no other images available for comparative analysis.
In conclusion, CEUS could accurately distinguish between benign and malignant testicular tumors and could diagnose specific pathological types (such as testicular focal infarction, epidermoid cysts, spermatocytic tumors, SLTC and lymphomas). Different pathological types of testicular tumors had different treatment options. Accurate preoperative diagnosis was of great significance and could guide the surgical selection of appropriate treatment options.