3.1 Principles for Water Sensitive Urban Design
The main objective of Water Sensitive Urban Design is to design urban environments closer to water and nature, where human activities can take place without causing environmental deterioration of the city. To this end, it is necessary to establish basic principles to serve for the definition of a planning methodology.
The basis for the design of Water Sensitive Cities is under constant review, given the recentness of this approach. According to Wong and Brown (2009), these foundations can be summarized as the cities should:
- Take advantage of different sources of water supply and at different scales.
- Provide ecosystem services.
- Promote water-sensitive communities.
On this basis, the following principles are proposed for the application of the Water Sensitive Urban Design principles to urban planning:
- Cities must be planned to take advantage of the water resources they generate. The high impermeability of urban environments generates a large amount of water that, instead of being considered a threat, can be seen as a potential and a resource. Thus, rainwater harvesting is the first requirement in Water Sensitive Cities, so that the city must be designed to retain, infiltrate and reuse rainwater.
- Cities must provide ecosystem services to the natural environment, so that they contribute to the functions of the hydrological cycle. In this sense, urban morphology can contribute to naturalizing the behavior of water in the city. Street networks can be planned to generate paths that transport surface water to places where it can infiltrate and/or be reused, thus calming the torrential rainfall and considerably reducing the probability of flooding.
- Cities must promote the creation of water-sensitive communities. The involvement of the different urban social agents is a necessary condition for Water Sensitive Urban Design to become a reality in our cities. The paradigm shift that Water Sensitive Cities imply in city design requires establishing collaborative strategies with stakeholders so that they are involved in decision-making.
3.2 Scales of planning
Urban plans at these scales in Spain, France and Italy have been analyzed in order to identify the possibility of applying the proposed methodology in these countries. The scales of intervention in urban planning are generally the following:
- Municipal, city or metropolitan area. At this scale, the different land uses, large green spaces, infrastructures, facilities... are planned. In Spain, the plan developed at this scale is called 'Plan General de Ordenación Urbana' -P.G.O.U.- or 'Plan de Ordenación de la Aglomeración Urbana' in the case of metropolitan areas -P.O.T.A.U.- (urban agglomeration spatial plans). In France it is called ‘Plan Local d'Urbanisme’ -P.L.U.- or ‘Plan local d'urbanisme intercommunal’ –P.L.U.i. for several urban areas (urban development plans). In Italy they are named ‘Piano Regolatore Generale Comunale –P.R.G.C.- (municipal master plans).
- Neighborhood or district. At this scale, residential and commercial areas, streets, squares, parks and public spaces are planned in more detail. In Spain, at this scale the plan is called ‘Plan Parcial' -P.P.- (partial plans), in France ‘Plan Directeur de Quartier’ -P.D.Q.- (neighborhood management plans) and in Italy ‘Piano di quartiere’ o ‘Piano di lottizzazione’ –P.D.Q.- (neighborhood management plans).
- Street and plot. At this scale, urban elements are designed in projects with as much detail as possible, defining the slopes of streets, pavements, trees and vegetation, areas around houses... In Spain, the urban project at this scale is called ‘Proyecto de Urbanización' -P.U.- (urban development projects), in France ‘Project d'Aménagement Urbain’ -P.A.U.- (urban project plans) and in Italy ‘Progetto di Disegno Urbano’–P.D.U.- (urban design projects).
Therefore, the integration of the SuDS in urban planning will be proposed at the 3 defined scales; city, neighborhood and street-plot. The proposed methodology can be integrated into the plans of each of the countries mentioned above at the appropriate scales.
3.3 How to integrate SuDS into urban planning
The following table shows the proposed methodology to integrate the SuDS in urban planning; scales, actions and urban plans where they must be implemented. The actions have been divided into 3 phases; the analysis to be carried out, the proposed measures and the possible regulations to be implemented in urban planning. These actions are detailed in the following sections.
Table 1. Methodology for integrating SuDS in urban planning
SCALE
|
ACTIONS
|
APPLICATION IN URBAN PLANS
|
City
|
ANALYSIS. Realize an urban hydrological study.
|
Spain: P.G.O.U.
France: P.L.U.
Italy: P.R.G.C.
|
MEASURES. Locate large green areas and multifunctional spaces in water collection and flooding areas.
|
REGULATIONS. Establish a minimum ratio of m2 of permeable area per m2 of new built-up area.
|
Neighborhood
|
ANALYSIS. Realize a runoff water study and identify ‘river and lake streets’.
|
Spain: P.P.
France: P.D.Q.
Italy: P.P.
|
MEASURES.
Locate infiltration and retention SuDS respectively.
Plan and connect green and blue corridors to convey runoff to infiltration and retention areas.
Incorporate stakeholders into the decision-making process.
|
REGULATIONS. Establish a minimum percentage of infiltration of urban runoff generated by new built-up areas.
|
Street-Plot
|
ANALYSIS. Realize a slopes study.
|
Spain: P.U.
France: P.A.U.
Italy: P.D.U.
|
MEASURES. Design road and pavement slopes to convey water to infiltration surfaces. Convert building roofs into green roofs.
|
REGULATIONS. Establish a reuse a minimum percentage of the collected runoff water.
|
3.3.1 City planning scale
One of the main problems of Mediterranean cities is that they have a climate with torrential rainfall, where a large volume of water is precipitated in a very short time. This phenomenon is being aggravated in recent years due to the effects of climate change. This is why infiltrating runoff by increasing the permeability of urban spaces should be a main objective in urban planning.
So, at the analysis phase, a hydrological study must first be carried out in order to know the urban drainage network and identify those areas where there is a risk of runoff accumulation. At present, in Spanish city plans (P.G.O.U.) it is compulsory to realize a flooding study whenever there is a river in the city, in order to prevent construction in flood-prone areas. However, in cities where a river is no present, the urban hydrological network and the risk of flooding caused by the accumulation of runoff are not studied.
After that, at the measures phase, main green areas and multifunctional spaces should be located in the runoff accumulation areas in order to infiltrate as much water as possible. Multifunctional areas are those that are usually used for urban purposes (squares, car parks,...) and that when it is raining, can infiltrate rainwater given their high degree of permeability. In the lower parts of the city, uses that are permeable it is a priority, as these will be the areas with the highest risk of flooding. On the other hand, it is necessary to incorporate stakeholders into the decision-making process so that the proposed measures are agreed by all to ensure the success of the proposals.
Finally, at the regulations phase, the plan will establish a minimum permeable surface ratio, in order to ensure a minimum infiltration of new urban areas. In built areas, repaving projects should be carried out at the neighborhood planning scale to improve infiltration.
All these actions will reduce the probability of flooding, improve the functioning of sewage networks and lower the temperature of the city.
3.3.2 Neighborhood scale
Another characteristic of Mediterranean cities is the steep slope of the cities, with large differences in elevation between the higher and lower parts. This fact further aggravates the torrential nature of rainfall, so it is very important to take actions to retain runoff water too, thus mitigating the effects of urban climate and topography.
For this, at analysis phase, it is necessary to carry out a runoff water study to identify the streets with the steepest slopes ('river streets') and the streets with a low slope that do not allow the evacuation of water generating flooded areas (‘lake streets’) (Fig. 1).
At the measures phase, in the river streets specific SuDS for water retention should be implemented (retention ponds, detention basins, bioretention strips, wetlands…) and in the lake streets SuDS for water infiltration (permeable pavements, rain gardens, infiltration trenches, soakaways…).
On the other hand, street networks should be planned to generate water paths that increase the runoff circulation time in the streets ('blue corridors') and lead it to areas where it can finally infiltrate ('green corridors') (Fig. 2). For planning blue corridors, street crossings must be modified so that water follows the longest path through runoff interceptors (Fig. 3), thus increasing runoff retention. Green corridors should be connected to blue corridors so that the conveyed water is infiltrated.
At the regulations phase, a minimum percentage of runoff infiltration must be established, in relation to the runoff water generated without the implementation of SuDS. For example, it could be agreed that neighborhoods would infiltrate at least one third of the runoff generated without the integration of SuDS.
All these actions will enable cities to provide ecosystem services to the natural environment and contribute to the functions of the hydrological cycle.
3.3.3 Street-Plot
Mediterranean cities are also characterized by the difficulty of maintaining vegetation in the streets due to long and intense dry periods. This is why it is essential to reuse rainwater to maintain green areas throughout the year, recharging the aquifer and ensuring soil moisture.
For this purpose, at the analysis phase it is necessary to carry out a slope study to indicate where the runoff is directed, in order to lead it to the infiltration areas and not to the sewerage system.
So, at the measures phase, it is necessary to design the slopes of the streets and squares to convey runoff to the infiltration surfaces designed for this purpose. For example, sidewalks and pavements should infiltrate runoff into rain gardens and parking areas should convey water to infiltration trenches. Also, converting roofs to green roofs will help maintain vegetation on buildings. At the regulations phase, the plan will establish a reuse a minimum percentage of the collected runoff water in green areas to promote the creation of vegetated areas in the streets and squares.
All these actions will serve to reduce pollution and temperatures in the city, making urban areas better places to live.