Themes and definitions
Three distinct thematic areas emerged during data analysis: patient themes, clinician themes, and themes of the dyadic experience. Themes are presented by group in table 1 below to illustrate how themes were conceptualized and provide definitions for themes.
Table 1.
Thematic Area
|
Theme
|
Definitions for Themes
|
Patient
|
Unexpected and Unprepared
|
Describes the menopausal symptom experience women are communicating with their providers. They were unprepared to experience the symptoms and the menopausal symptoms were unexpected.
|
|
Distressed, Disrupted, Disturbed
|
Describes the functional and emotional impact that menopausal symptoms have on women. This theme encompasses the recurring topic of loss of womanhood in the data.
|
Clinician
|
Clinical Insensitivity
|
This theme describes the indifferent and unempathetic clinical language used to describe menopause and its symptoms. Initiation of menopause was frequently described in clinical terms.
|
|
Missed Opportunity for Management and Empathy
|
Describes the nature of clinician reaction to management of menopausal symptoms. During the discussions, women would describe significant symptoms, and clinicians would move on without addressing the management of those symptoms.
|
Dyad
|
Use of Humor and Colloquial Language
|
During discussions about menopausal symptoms, laughter was transcribed. The dyad used humor when discussing menopausal symptoms and the menopausal symptom experience.
|
Patient Themes
Unexpected and Unprepared
It became clear early in codebook development that there was a pattern of patients who were unprepared for the initiation of menopausal symptoms with their chemotherapy treatment. Often, women would express surprise at the development of these symptoms, surprise about their periods stopping, and surprise that chemotherapy was responsible for all these symptoms. However, women also often advocated for themselves by asking questions about what they could expect, how they could prepare, and what menopausal symptoms to look for.
Example One:
Patient: “Well, I have a question.”
Clinician: Yeah.
Patient: Will my periods start again? Like, will I have to go through menopause again?”
The examples below illustrate how women would engage in conversations with their providers about the initiation of symptoms, or symptoms continuing. The way women were posing questions at times made it seem like they were trying to prepare themselves for what symptoms were to come. There was also an indication that these were symptoms that might not have been discussed or, if symptoms were discussed, patients did not always remember these discussions.
Example Two:
Patient: “Um, will… will my period just stop? ‘Cause – like I probably should be expect—like if it was going to come, it would be maybe next week or something. But don’t expect it?”
Example Three:
Clinician: “How about periods? Are you…
Patient: Uh, it’s like the craziest thing!
Clinician: What’s going on with them?
Patient: It’s like, “am I having a period, or am I not having a period? Am I have a period…”
Clinician: Spotty, or what’s going on?”
Distressed, Disrupted, Disturbed
There is an inextricable relationship between our identified patient themes. Women who are unprepared and experiencing unexpected symptoms will experience distress as a result of these symptoms. Because these symptoms are unexpected, women’s lives are disrupted as a result. Although these themes are inextricable, they are also two distinct themes. Women expressed their distress, disruption, and disturbance in ways that are unique and independent of their expression of unpreparedness and unexpectedness. All examples below are taken from patients.
Example One:
“And sometimes at night, I mean, it’s just like, I’ll wake up 10 times just in a sweat. Is that, I mean – “
Example Two:
“Sleeping isn’t really that great. I don’t know why, but I can’t sleep. I keep getting hot.”
Example Three:
“The trouble – I either have trouble going to sleep, or once I get to sleep, staying asleep, and it’s like you’re waking up every two hours, and then you’re so hot. It’s just ugh. [whispers] (I’ll get nasty?) I’m a troop—[clinician laughs] I’m a trooper, I’m a survivor.”
Clinician Themes
Clinical Insensitivity
Our analysis found that the language clinicians used to describe the initiation of menopausal symptoms and cessation of menopausal symptoms often did not reflect empathic communication. Additionally, the clinical nature of the language used might have risen to the level of clinical “jargon” making the explanation poorly understood by patients.
Example One:
Clinician 1: The muscle pain, joint pains. [unintelligible] done, dear, you may also be experiencing that we’ve, we’ve shut down your periods. What we’ve done is your ovaries…
Patient: And I think it did come on around that time, [unintelligible]—
[talking over one another]
Clinician 2: Yeah, your ovaries are shutting down, your ovaries are now shutting down. So you’re starting to get old lady bo—aches and pains.
Patient: Mm-hmm.
Clinician 2: ‘Cause, you know, the – one of the things that the chemo has done, is shut your ov—is shutting your ovaries down. You won’t have periods pretty soon.
Patient: Oh OK, yeah. ‘Cause I did come on around that time.
Clinician 2: Yeah, and I think that’s what it is, dear.
Patient: They’re shutting down. That’ll work for me. [laughs]
Clinician 2: That’s – that’s a side effect, dear. That’s what’s going on.
Patient:[talking over clinician 2] Well, it is a hormone change, I mean, you know, ‘cause…
Clinician 2: Yeah, yeah.
Patient:…you know, vaginal dryness, I’m starting to experience, (you know,?) down there, so.
[talking over interviewee] clinician 2: (No, no, no?). Yeah, yeah. We are putting you into menopause, dear.
Patient [laughs] Menopause.”
Example Two:
"Patient: And my hot flashes are getting worse, I think.
Clinician: Are they?
Patient: I think so.
Clinician: Have you had any periods since you started chemo?
Patient: Nope.
Clinician: OK. So it may or may not be sending you into menopause at this point, but there’s not really a way to know. Even if it gets rid of your periods, it doesn’t necessarily mean that you’re in menopause, so. But it can give you all the side effects like (those like?) hot flashes, night sweats, mood swings…
Patient: [talking over Interviewer] Yeah.
Clinician: …all that kind of stuff. [laughs] So you can get all the downsides of it at the same time [unintelligible].
Patient: (Oh?).
Clinician: Yeah. [laughs]"
Missed Opportunity for Management and Empathy
There was a distinct pattern of women initiating menopausal symptom discussions, or reporting menopausal symptoms, and clinicians exhibiting little empathy and dismissing the symptoms, without further assessment or intervention.
Example One:
Patient: “have hot flashes now again…
Clinician: Yeah yeah.
Patient: …from the meds, so I don’t know what that’s about.
Clinician: It’s stress.
Patient: I know.
Clinician: Stress will… stress aggravates hot flashes. So that’s, um… how is your range of motion? Yeah, OK, but you’re feeling the tightness all along there. Yeah.”
Example Two:
Clinician: “Like hot flashes?
Patient: Probably… I’m assuming, ‘cause they just – they took my ovary out, and…
Clinician: Yeah, right.
Patient: Between that and the chemo, I just—
[talking over clinician] Clinician: Yep.
Patient:…it’s covers off, covers on, covers off.
Clinician: Yeah, it’ll do it. Any mouth sores?”
Example Three:
Clinician: Well, the biggest side effect is menopausal symptoms. Menopause.
Patient: And I’m already having hot flashes, like – not a ton, it – actually it coincides when I’m anxious, like when I get anxious or, you know, I’ll have a hot flash, but I can’t say that always happens. But they’re not ridiculous hot flashes – I mean, sometimes at night they are, but like, I mean, really, they just go away, they’re fine, but.
Clinician: I mean, that’s the biggest thing: menopause, menopause, men—and the osteo – we can talk about it at a later time, I don’t want to…
Patient: OK.
Clinician: …(unintelligible), but I just want you to start thinking about contraception.”
Dyadic Theme
Use of Humor and Colloquial Language
We discovered in our analysis that there would often be a humorous dialogue between women and their providers regarding menopause, and menopausal symptoms overall. Often, laughter was transcribed, and colloquial language was seemingly used to lighten the mood or topic of conversation.
Example One:
Clinician: ...And no fevers, right? You haven’t had any fevers?
Patient: No. I’ve had hot flashes – it’s just like a fever, so. [Interviewer laughs] I don’t know what the difference is – no, I’m
just teasing. I would know. I would know. I think so, at this age. [laughs]
Clinician: [laughs] Go ahead and lie back for me.
Patient: [unintelligible]… oh goodness.
Example Two:
Patient: Um, how can I tell? If I’m going through the change, like I wouldn’t say it’s new, but I can…
Example Three:
Clinician: Yeah, probably the… oh, OK. Yeah – well, chemo and perimenopause…
Patient: So I’m just having – sometimes I have a personal summer. [laughs]