Synthesis and characterization of distibene 2 and stibinidene 4
Firstly, we tested the reduction of antimony(III) dichloride 1 (Supplementary Information Fig. S1), supported by the hydrindacene ligand MsFluidtBu with 2 molar equivalents of KC8 in THF at room temperature. However, distibene 2 was isolated as purplish crystals in 46% yield from the reaction mixture (Fig. 2a). Compound 2 contains a Sb=Sb double bond with a distance of 2.7223(5) Å as revealed by single-crystal X-ray diffraction (SC-XRD) analysis (Supplementary Information Fig. S2), which is the longest one among the reported distibenes28-32. The flanking fluorenyl substituents are highly twisted to adopt a suitable orientation that allows the interaction between the two Sb atoms. We thus reasoned that increasing the steric hindrance at the fluorenyl moieties might prevent the formation of the Sb=Sb double bond and permit the access of the corresponding free stibinidene.
Accordingly, we synthesized the antimony(III) precursor MsFluind*-SbBr2 3 with a slightly more steric hindered ligand. To our delight, debromination of 3 with 2 molar equivalents of KC8 in THF at room temperature afforded stibinidene 4 as yellow crystals in 11% yield (Fig. 2a). When Jones’ magnesium dimer LMgMgL (L = CH(MeCNMes)2; Mes = 2,4,6-Me3C6H2) was used as a reducing agent33, a higher yield of 31% was obtained. Compound 4 is moderately soluble in benzene and n-hexane, but highly soluble in toluene and THF. It is highly air-sensitive, but is quite stable in solution and the solid state under an inert atmosphere at room temperature. Moreover, no decomposition was observed after heating at 80 oC for 1 hour in deuterated benzene solution, demonstrating the high thermal stability. The range of 1H and 13C chemical shifts for 4 increases dramatically (δ –2.25-14.49 and –31.5-277.3 ppm for 1H and 13C{1H,13C} NMR spectra, respectively) in comparison to those of diamagnetic compounds, suggestive of a paramagnetic nature. To rule out the presence of hydrogen atoms at the Sb center in 4, we synthesized MsFluind*-SbH2 4H2 through the reaction of 3 with 2 molar equivalents of Li[BEt3H]. Contrastingly, the 1H and 13C{1H,13C} NMR spectra of 4H2 exhibit signals at the normal diamagnetic windows, and the proton signals of the SbH2 moiety is observed at δ 1.82 ppm. Moreover, the Fourier transform infrared spectrum of 4H2 shows a stretching band at 1886 cm–1 for the Sb–H bond, which is close to that in ArSbH2 (1875 cm–1; Ar = 2,6-Trip2-C6H3; Trip = 2,4,6-iPr3C6H2)34, while no band is observed in this region for 4. These results unambiguously show that no hydrogen atom is attached to the Sb atom in 4.
SC-XRD characterization of 4
Molecular structure of 4 was determined by SC-XRD analysis (Fig. 2b). It crystallizes in monoclinic space group C2/c, and features C2v symmetry. In comparison, 4H2 crystallizes in monoclinic space group P21/c (Supplementary Information Fig. S3). The Sb atom in 4 is only bound to the C atom of the central phenyl ring of the supporting ligand, and resides in the center of the ligand pocket well-shielded by the two flanking fluorenyl moieties. The Sb1–C1 distance (2.148(3) Å) is comparable to that in TerpMesSb=SbTerpMes (2.169(4) Å; TerpMes = 2,6-Mes2-C6H3)11, suggesting its single bond character. Noteworthy, there is no noticeable intermolecular Sb•••Sb interaction in the solid state, and the Sb atoms are well-separated by the ligand backbones. The closest distance between the Sb center and the C atom of the flanking flurorenyl moieties is as long as 3.250(3) Å, which is far beyond the sum of the single bond covalent radii for the C and Sb atoms (2.15 Å)35, but shorter than the sum of the van der Waals radii (3.76 Å)36,37, indicative of the presence of noticeable non-covalent bonding interactions. Therefore, compound 4 can be described as a free stibinidene containing a one-coordinate antimony atom.
Magnetic characterization of 4
To explore the electronic structure of 4, we carried out variable-temperature (T) magnetic susceptibility (χ) measurements on a solid sample with a superconducting quantum interference device (SQUID). As shown in Fig. 2c, the χT product increases with temperature, and does not become saturated even at 300 K. The observed variation of χT with respect to T cannot be interpreted as the temperature-independent paramagnetism of a singlet ground state (Supplementary Information Fig. S4). Therefore, it can be concluded that 4 has a triplet ground state, although its magnetic property is distinctly different from those usually measured for S = 1 complexes. As elaborated in Supplementary Information Fig. S5, this peculiar behavior is due to the presence of a gigantic zero-field splitting (ZFS) in 4. For the same reason, its isotropic g factor (giso) cannot be accurately determined, as χT at the high-temperature saturation limit is proportional to . In view of the fact that triplet nitrenes and phosphinidenes typically features giso = 2.038, we thus fixed giso to be 2.0 in the simulation of the SQUID data using a standard S = 1 spin Hamiltonian. The rhombicity parameter (E/D) was fixed to be 0, because 4 possesses a bonding situation similar to those of closely related Sb diatomic molecules (see below) and hence effective axial symmetry. A reasonable fit gave an axial ZFS parameter of D = 1030±20 cm-1, comparable to those measured for SbH (655 cm-1), SbF (816 cm-1), and SbCl (796 cm-1)39. Furthermore, D was found to be not very sensitive to giso; when giso varies from 2.00 to 1.90, D slightly decreases from 1030 to 930 cm–1.
Theoretical calculations of 4
To shed more light on the bonding of 4, we first carried out noncovalent interaction (NCI) analyses40 with DFT calculations employing the scalar relativistic second-order Douglas-Kroll-Hess Hamiltonian41. The NCI plot (Supplementary Information Fig. S6) showed that the interactions between the Sb center and the flanking fluorenyl functionalities of MsFluid* primarily originate from van der Waals interactions. We then performed completely active space self-consistent field (CASSCF)/second order N electron valence perturbation theory (NEVPT2) computations on simplified model 4ʹ in which the substituents on the supporting ligand were replaced by hydrogen atoms. To properly describe the covalent bond between the Sb atom and the central phenyl (Ph) moiety in 4, the active space was chosen to distribute 12 electrons into 11 orbitals including Sb–C σ and σ*, Sb 5s and 5p, and six Ph π and π* orbitals. As shown in Fig. 3a, theoretical results revealed that the triplet ground state of 4ʹ features a leading electron configuration of (Sb 5s)2(Ph π1,2,3)6(Sb–C σz)2(Sb 5px)1(Sb 5py)1(Ph π*4,5,6)0(Sb–C σ*z)0 that accounts for 86% of the wavefunction, and is 15.7 kcal/mol below the lowest-energy S = 0 state that represents the corresponding closed-shell singlet with either Sb 5px or 5py orbitals being doubly occupied. Therefore, for the S = 1 ground state there exists only one σ-bond formed by the Sb 5pz and ipso C 2pz atomic orbitals, congruent with the estimated Mayer Sb–Cipso bond order of 0.94, while the remaining Sb 5px and 5py orbitals are essentially nonbonding and nearly degenerate. These findings reflect that the interaction of the Sb 5px with the Ph π system is almost negligible. As such, according to the first Hund’s rule, 4ʹ energetically favors a triplet ground state, in analogy to diatomic Sb molecules (SbH, SbF, and SbCl)39. Following this reasoning, the Sb 5px and 5py orbitals contribute almost equally to the total spin population, thereby leading to donut-like positive spin density around the Sb center (Fig. 3b). Consequently, the Sb center was computed to possess a spin population of 1.97, whereas that of the entire phenyl ring is merely 0.01. Of note, the negative spin population (–0.11) found for the ipso C atom stems from the spin polarization of the Ph π system and Sb–Cipso σ bonding orbital induced by unpaired electrons populating the Sb 5px and 5py orbitals. The ab initio calculations gave giso = 1.96, D = 940 cm–1 and E/D = 0.02 for 4ʹ. Given the estimated giso factor being slightly different from that employed in the simulation, the predicted D value is in reasonable agreement with the experiment. Finally, the diradical nature deduced for 4 rationalizes why the formation of 2 via a dimerization process of the species generated by dehalogenation of 1 has a great driving force of ~50 kcal/mol and no detectable activation barrier (Supplementary Information Fig. S7).
Reactivity studies of 4
To have a better understanding of the chemical property of 4, we further performed experimental reactivity studies (Fig. 4). Firstly, we carried out the reactions with a Lewis acid and a Lewis base to probe the ambiphilic character. Mixing of 4 with Fe2(CO)9 in n-hexane at room temperature afforded a deep brown solution immediately, and stibinidene-iron complex MsFluid*-Sb→Fe(CO)4 (5) was isolated in 30% yield. Complex 5 features a singlet ground state as shown by NMR spectroscopy. The stabilization of the singlet state by coordination to transition metal fragments has also been observed for phosphinidene complexes, attributing to the substantial stabilization of the unoccupied pπ acceptor orbital through π-back-donation from the transition metal centers as rationalized by theoretical calculations42. The reaction of 4 with 1,3,4,5-tetramethyl-imidazolin-2-ylidene (IMe4) afforded base-stabilized stibinidene 6. The complexation to both Lewis acid and base reveals the ambiphilic nature of 4. Furthermore, the reactions with unsaturated substrates have also been examined. 4 smoothly reacted with 2,3-dimethyl-1,3-butadiene and 4-tetrabutylphenylacetylene to furnish antimony-substituted five-membered and three-membered heterocycles 7 and 8 via [1+4] and [1+2] cycloadditions, respectively, reminiscent of the reactivity of transient phosphinidene species43,44.