There is known to be overlap between the receptors responsible for pruritus and pain [10–12]. ICs that regulate the action potentials (APs) of nociceptive peripheral nerves include the following: Na1.6, Nav1.7, Nav1.8, Nav1.9, Kv1.4, Kv3.4, Kv7.2, KCa, TREK1, TRAAK, Cav2.2, Cav3.2, TREM16A, TRPV1, TRPA1, HCN2, TrkA, and Piezo2 [13]. Of these, Nav1.7, Kv7.2, TREK1, HCN2, TrkA, and Piezo2 were chosen for analysis. The reasons for their selection and a discussion of relevant findings are discussed below.
At least six voltage-gated sodium channel subtypes (Nav1.1, Nav1.3, Nav1.6, Nav1.7, Nav1.8, and Nav1.9) are upregulated in sensory neurons. In particular, Nav1.7 is predominantly expressed in peripheral sensory neurons. Nav1.7 is responsible for the rising phase of APs and plays a key role in setting the threshold for AP generation in primary sensory neurons [14]. Nav1.7 is important for pain and pruritus sensations in rodents and humans [15–17]. In this study, we found no significant difference in Nav1.7 expression between CKD-aP and non–CKD-aP patients. Despite the fact Nav1.7 is a key IC that contributes to the steep AP upstroke in pruriceptive neurons, our results did not support the hypothesis that differences in Nav1.7 expression were involved in CKD-aP pathogenesis. Our results warrant further study to examine the relationship between other Nav subtypes (e.g., Nav1.6 and Nav1.9) and CKD-aP.
Potassium channels control neuronal excitability by influencing the duration, frequency, and amplitude of APs [18]. K2P channels give rise to leak (also called background) K+ currents, causing resting potassium conductance and preventing excessive neuronal activation [19, 20]. K2P channels are expressed in the central and somatic peripheral nervous systems, as well as in a number of non-neuronal mammalian tissues and organs [19]. TREK-1 (K2P 2.1) belongs to a novel family of mammalian K2P channels and is highly expressed in peripheral dorsal root ganglion neurons. The main role of TREK-1 is to control cell excitability and maintain the membrane potential below the depolarization threshold [21, 22]. Our study showed that the cutaneous TREK1 expression level was significantly elevated in CKD-aP patients compared with non–CKD-aP patients. Elevated TREK1 expression suggests the suppression of neural excitability, depolarization, and neuronal firing. In our previous study [7], we found that BKCa, a known mediator of hyperpolarization, was expressed at significantly higher levels in CKD-aP patients than in non–CKD-aP patients. Similar to the role of BKCa in promoting hyperpolarization, increased expression levels of TREK1 were found to contribute to hyperpolarization of pruriceptive terminals in CKD-aP patients.
M-type (Kv7, KCNQ) potassium channels control the resting membrane potential of many neurons, including peripheral nociceptive sensory neurons [23]. M-channels are voltage-gated potassium channels that are formed by KCNQ2, KCNQ3, and KCNQ5. Neuronal KCNQ channels (KCNQ2, 3, 5) exhibit the M-current (IM), a slowly activating, non-inactivating outward rectifying potassium current that can be inhibited by muscarinic stimulation [24]. Notably, KCNQ2 has been identified in the somatosensory system [24]. The potassium channel subunits Kv7.2 and Kv7.3 play a key role in stabilizing neuronal activity [25]. However, Kv7.2 transcripts were not detected in the skin samples of CKD-aP and non–CKD-aP patients, suggesting that Kv7.2 does not play a major role in the pathogenesis of pruritus.
HCN channels are permeable to both K+ and Na+ and are responsible for voltage-gated inward rectifying (Ih) currents that are activated during hyperpolarization [26, 27]. HCN channels underlie the depolarization modulating the rhythmic generation of APs, and they also contribute to the resting membrane potential and modify the waveforms of propagated synaptic and generator potentials in peripheral sensory neurons that mediate pain sensation [26, 28]. The HCN ion channel family comprises 4 isoforms (HCN1 to HCN4). HCN2 modulates the AP firing rate in nociceptive neurons and plays a critical role in all modes of inflammatory and neuropathic pain [27, 29, 30]. The binding of cAMP to HCN2 channels shifts the activation curve in the positive direction as a function of membrane voltage, and thereby increases the Ih current [29, 30]. Our results showed that skin HCN2 expression was significantly lower in CKD-aP patients than in non–CKD-aP patients. Lower expression levels of HCN2 suggested a reduced Ih current amplitude, which could possibly delay the return to the resting potential from the undershoot during the refractory period.
Nerve growth factor (NGF) is a well-known neurotrophic factor that also acts as a mediator of pain, pruritus, and inflammation [31]. The NTRK1 gene encodes TrkA, a receptor tyrosine kinase for NGF (NGF–TrkA system) [32, 33]. Human skin, including nerves and sensory corpuscles, displays immunoreactivity to low-(p75) and high-affinity (TrkA-like) NGF receptors [34]. Our results showed no significant differences in TrkA transcript expression between CKD-aP and non–CKD-aP patients, suggesting that the NGF–TrkA system did not have a major impact on CKD-aP pathogenesis.
Piezo is a mechanosensitive cation channel responsible for stretch-mediated Ca2+ and Na+ influx in multiple types of cells. Piezo1 mediates shear stress and stretch-induced transmembrane currents, mainly in nonneuronal cells, whereas Piezo2 is predominantly expressed in primary sensory neurons, where it mediates proprioception, touch perception, and detection of noxious mechanical stimuli [8]. In disease states (e.g., aging or dry skin), innocuous mechanical stimuli can provoke pathologic sensations such as allokinesis (mechanical itch), a phenomenon modulated at least partly by Piezo2 [8, 35]. Feng et al. showed that cutaneous Piezo2 channel–Merkel cell signaling is critical in modulating the conversion of touch to itch [35]. The current study showed that CKD-aP patients had significantly elevated expression levels of skin Piezo2 than non–CKD-aP patients, suggesting that CKD-aP patients were more likely to develop allokinesis.
Overall, the RT-PCR analyses of skin ion channels reported here showed that CKD-aP patients had significantly higher TREK1 and Piezo2 expression levels and significantly lower HCN2 levels than non–CKD-aP patients. Moreover, no significant differences were noted in Nav1.7 or TrkA expression levels, and Kv7.2 transcripts were not detected in either group. In combination with our previous findings [7], these results indicate that CKD-aP skin samples had significantly higher TREK1, Piezo2, Cav3.2, BKCa, and anoctamin-1 expression levels and significantly lower HCN2 and TRPV1 expression levels than non–CKD-aP skin samples. Moreover, no significant between-group differences were observed in Nav1.7, TrkA, Cav2.2, or ASIC expression levels, and Nav1.8, Kv1.4, Kv7.2, and TRPA1 transcripts could not be detected in either group.
Assuming that IC expression levels in peripheral nerves correlate with those in other skin cells, our results suggest that elevated levels of TREK1, BKCa, and anoctamin 1 increase the afterhyperpolarization amplitude, defined as the absolute difference between the resting potential and the minimum membrane potential attained during repolarization. In addition, lower HCN2 expression levels observed in CKD-aP patients suggested that compared with non–CKD-aP patients, these patients had a smaller Ih current amplitude and the membrane potential required a longer time to return to the resting state during the hyperpolarization period. We previously reported that the skin expression levels of the calcium-activated chloride channel anoctamin 1 were significantly upregulated in CKD-aP patients [7]. Unlike the neural cells in dorsal root ganglion, the neural cells at peripheral nerve endings are considered to be mature neurons, so the concentration of intracellular chlorine seem to be low. Given that mature neuronal and other excitable cells generally have low intracellular chloride concentrations [36], the activation of anoctamin 1 may enhance hyperpolarization of the peripheral sensory nerves. While much remains to be discovered about the role of TRPV1 in shaping the action potential waveform, TRPV1 is likely to contribute to depolarization because it facilitates transmembrane sodium and calcium ion influx. Consequently, our finding that TRPV1 was downregulated in CKD-aP patients suggested that APs had a longer rising phase in these patients. Overall, this study suggested that compared with non-CKD-aP patients, CKD-aP patients had a longer AP cycle due to upregulation of ICs that induced a greater afterhyperpolarization amplitude (Fig. 1).
Many studies reported that chronic pain downregulated Kv1.4 and BKCa and upregulated other peripheral nociceptive nerve ICs [37–41]. Moreover, a study of a chronic pain model showed that BKCa blockade suppressed afterhyperpolarization [42], and a separate study showed that pruritus-related pathways were associated with a lower AP frequency than pain pathways [43]. In light of these findings, the results of the present study suggest that pruritus and pain pathways are electrophysiologically mediated by ICs that promote hyperpolarization and depolarization, respectively. A variety of receptors involved in AP generation help discriminate between pain and pruritus sensations, possibly depending on their spatial locations, distribution patterns, morphology, and other properties. Our findings suggest that temporal discharge patterns of APs are key components underlying pruritus, thereby supporting the spatial contrast theory [44]. Differential expression of ICs is likely to contribute functional diversity to sensory neuron signaling.
Cav3.2 may play a key role in AP generation in CKD-aP. The activity of Cav3.2 depends not only on the membrane potential but also on various neurotransmitters and intracellular second messengers. Zinc ions and hydrogen sulfide facilitate pruritus processing by enhancing Cav3.2 activity [37]. We previously reported that Cav3.2 was overexpressed in CKD-aP patients [7]. The overexpression of Cav3.2 activates voltage-gated sodium channels by elevating the membrane potential, which in turn increases the frequency of AP discharge. The potentially key role of Cav3.2 in CKD-aP may be further supported by the finding that the expression of Cav3.2 on peripheral nerve terminals is upregulated in chronic pain [37]. TRPV1 may also play a major role in AP generation because it can activate voltage-gated sodium channels. However, given our previous finding that TRPV1 was downregulated in CKD-aP patients, this possibility is unlikely.
The mammalian olfactory system possesses receptors that discriminate various odorant molecules. It employs a combinatorial receptor coding scheme to differentiate odor identities [45]. Various combinations of olfactory receptor activation produce different generator potential patterns, which are rectified to generate APs that are transmitted to the central nervous system. Similarly, pruritus sensations are often perceived and described in a variety of ways. Typical sensory descriptors of pruritus include crawling (formication), prickling, wriggling, tickling, tingling, stinging, burning, and pinching. These distinct perceptions may be attributable to different activated combinations of peripheral sensory nerve ICs, which deliver different afferent signals to the central nervous system. Certain descriptors of pruritus, such as crawling and tickling, are apparently related to tactile sensations, suggesting the involvement of Piezo2.
Our series of RT-PCR analyses using beta-2 microglobulin as an internal control did not detect transcripts encoding Nav1.8, Kv1.4, Kv7.2, or TRPA1. Because of their relative nature, our results may allow for multiple interpretations. One is that the functionalities of Nav1.8, Kv1.4, and Kv7.2 are of greater importance in pruritus pathogenesis than their expression levels, similar to the case for the nonselective cationic IC TRPA1 [46].
Regarding ICs whose expressions were confined to cutaneous sensory nerve endings, TREK1 and Cav3.2 were significantly upregulated and HCN2 was significantly downregulated in CKD-aP patients compared with non–CKD-aP patients. No significant between-group differences were noted for Nav1.7, TrkA, Cav2.2, or ASIC. Overall, our results suggest that new therapies for pruritus might include TREK1 or Piezo2 antagonists, HCN2 agonists, and their combinations. Moreover, our findings indicate the potential utility of developing new agonists and antagonists that either suppress hyperpolarization-inducing ICs or activate depolarization-inducing ICs.
This study had several limitations. First, the sample size was small. The small sample size might lead to a very high potential bias of the presented results. It is necessary to increase the number of skin sample and to examine the ICs again. Second, because the immunocytochemistry analyses of ICs were not performed, we have not confirmed whether ICs were actually expressed in peripheral nerves. Third, we did not isolate peripheral nerves innervating human skin, which would have enabled us to focus on ICs expressed only on peripheral nerve terminals. To address this issue, double immunofluorescence staining of ICs and use of a neuronal marker (e.g., protein gene product 9.5) may be beneficial. Forth, not only the expression of ICs but also the function of ICs electrophysiologically between CKD-aP and non–CKD-aP patients should be investigated. Our results warrant further investigation of other ICs. Additional research should also focus on the intracellular signaling pathways upstream of ICs.