Optical properties and coupling effects of the Janus textile
Objects on the Earth emit infrared radiation through the atmospheric transmission windows (mainly within 8–13 µm) to the cold higher sky, and daytime sub-ambient cooling can be achieved with zero energy consumption when most solar radiation can be reflected21,22. Although daytime sub-ambient radiative cooling has been achieved in multilayer photonic emitters8,9,15, nannoporous polymer membranes10,12−14 and even woods11, few wearable textiles that can realize sub-ambient daytime radiative cooling have ever been reported16,17. To achieve effective daytime radiative cooling in hot climates with high solar irradiance, the textiles should have a high solar reflectance (> 0.94) in practice considering variation in atmospheric conditions across different geographic areas8. Polymer nanofibers can scatter sunlight if the fiber diameters are carefully designed to allow their Mie resonance wavelengths to match the solar spectrum13,23. However, in previous polymer nanofiber designs, the refractive index n of polymers, an important intrinsic optical property, is always overlooked, hindering the pursuit of solar reflectance of > 0.95. Here we selected PES that has one of the highest refractive index n of 1.68 among polymers to produce sub-ambient radiative cooling textiles24,25. The extinction coefficient k of PES is zero in the visible region, indicating its negligible absorption (Supplementary Fig. 1). Besides, PES is widely used in water filtration and feeding bottles and proved to be harmless for human health26–28.
The PES nanofiber-based textile was fabricated by the electrospinning technique (Fig. 2a). The textile consists of nanofibers with smooth surfaces (Fig. 2b). The higher-magnification scanning electron microscope images show there exist nanopores in fibers, which are formed while solvent dries out and air penetrates into fibers (Supplementary Fig. 2)29. The very white color of the textile indicates its strong reflection to visible light. Referring to the Mie’s scattering theory, both the refractive index and the fiber diameters are the two key factors that dominate the Mie scattering efficiency of nanofibers. With the increase of the fiber diameter, the Mie resonance peak redshifts to longer wavelengths. To determine the optimal range of PES fiber diameters, we defined the average scattering efficiency \(\overline {Q}\) weighted by the AM1.5 G solar spectrum (see Supplementary Eq. 5). The calculated results show that PES fibers with a diameter in the range of 0.5-1.0 µm have maximum scattering efficiency to the sunlight (Fig. 2c and Supplementary Fig. 3). By carefully controlling the electrospinning process, the textile with a desired fiber size distribution centered at 0.6 µm was successfully obtained, matching
the high \(\overline {Q}\) (Fig. 2c). Furthermore, the influence of the refractive index n on \(\overline {Q}\) was also investigated (Fig. 2d). The results indicate that the \(\overline {Q}\) of polymer nanofibers strongly depends on their n, and nanofibers with larger n typically produce stronger solar scattering. For instance, a PES nanofiber (n = 1.68) of 0.6 µm has a \(\overline {Q}\) of 2.64, which is 32% higher than that (\(\overline {Q}\)= 2) of a polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF) fiber (n = 1.42) of the same diameter. In short, compared with most polymers (PVDF, PLA, etc., see Supplementary Table 1 for refractive index), PES nanofibers have higher average scattering efficiency over a wide diameter range. The origin of light scattering on scattering centers (such as fibers or particles) is attributed to the difference in n between the scattering centers and the environment (the air in this case). The PES fibers produce a high refractive index contrast (\(\Delta n={n_{PES}} - {n_{Air}}=1.68 - 1=0.68\)) across the fiber-air interfaces, leading to strong solar scattering. As a result, a solar reflectance \({\bar {r}_{0.3 - 2.5\mu m}}\) of 0.97 was achieved in a 600-µm-thick PES-based textile, which is the highest value ever reported in textiles and is competitive compared with the record of radiative cooling paints and films (Fig. 2e). The high refractive index n also makes PES textile more scattering to visible light and opaquer to human eyes compared with cellulose acetate (CA, n ~ 1.47) textile in wet state (Fig. 2f), which benefits privacy protection. The influence of nanopores inside fibers on the scattering efficiency was also explored. These nanopores with a comparable size range to UV light (10 to 400 nm) can enhance the averaged scattering efficiency of fibers in the UV range (Supplementary Fig. 4).
It is well-known that light will experience strong resonant absorption if the frequency of the light matches the vibrational frequency of the chemical bonds30. Thus, PES, which has plenty of C-O (1324 − 1239 cm− 1) and S = O (1144 − 1100 cm− 1) bonds in its backbones (Supplementary Fig. 1), is an effective emitter material31,32. As shown in Supplementary Fig. 5, the spectrally averaged emittance of the electrospun PES textile within 8–13 µm (\({\bar {\varepsilon }_{8 - 13\mu m}}\)) is 0.81, and there are four absorption drops centered at 9.5, 10.2, 10.8, and 13.0 µm, respectively. To enhance the \({\bar {\varepsilon }_{8 - 13\mu m}}\) of the textile, we incorporated Al2O3 nanospheres (20 nm in diameter) with a broad absorptance band centered at 880 cm− 1 into PES nanofibers to construct a PES-Al2O3 composite textile33,34 (5 wt.%, elemental mappings see Supplementary Fig. 6). It can be seen from Supplementary Fig. 5 that the emittance of the PES-Al2O3 textile in the range of 10–13 µm increases notably compared to the pure PES textile. As a result, the \({\bar {\varepsilon }_{8 - 13\mu m}}\) is improved to 0.91 (Fig. 2e). It should be mentioned that the Al2O3 additives in this work are only beneficial for enhancing the MIR emission. It almost has no effect on the solar reflection due to its very low concentration and small size.
For the warming side, Ti3C2Tx MXene nanoflakes were coated on one side of the PES-Al2O3 textile using a vacuum-assisted filtration method to serve as solar-absorbing materials (Fig. 2a Inset, see Supplementary Fig. 8 for its SEM image). The resultant black side embraces a high solar absorptance \({\bar {\alpha }_{0.3 - 2.5\mu m}}\) of 0.85 and a low emittance \(\bar {\varepsilon }\) of 0.22 in the mid-infrared (MIR) range (Fig. 2g). Moreover, owing to the high electrical conductivity of Ti3C2Tx, the warming side can provide heat via Joule effect that is a reliable complement for solar heating. To keep the body warm in cold environments, the low MIR emittance (i.e., high MIR reflectance) is highly desired because of reduced thermal radiation to the surroundings and outer space. When paired with the radiative cooling side, it also enables the warming side (Ti3C2Tx) to reflect the unabsorbed portion of the incident MIR light strongly, which can be re-absorbed by the textile (see the inset of Fig. 2h). Thus, the cooling side and the warming side optically couple with each other instead of simply stacking, which enhances the optical path length of IR light and the \({\bar {\varepsilon }_{8 - 13\mu m}}\) of the cooling side remarkably (Fig. 2h). For instance, the \({\bar {\varepsilon }_{8 - 13\mu m}}\) of the Janus textile with a smaller thickness of 150 µm (0.83) is very close to that of the PES-Al2O3 textile with a thickness of 300 µm (0.85). Such an optical coupling effect helps the textile own a satisfactory MIR emittance with a thinner thickness, which improves the overall performance, including cooling effects, breathability, and light weight, of the textile to achieve better wearing comfort.
Sub-ambient Cooling And Skin Cooling Performance
Field tests were conducted to evaluate the cooling performance of our Janus PES-Al2O3/Ti3C2Tx textile in both daytime and nighttime (Fig. 3a). The tests were performed on summer days (July 2021) in Hong Kong (22°16′50′′ N, 114°10′20′′ E), a tropical and coastal city with a total precipitable water (TPW) value of ~ 60 mm. Since the textiles target at personal thermal management, the samples were directly exposed to the ambient air without any solar
shading or convection cover to mimic the real practical scenario. A weather station was used to monitor the climate data near the samples in real-time. T-type thermocouples were attached on the backside of the samples placed on the EPS foam with a density of 25 kg m− 3 (Fig. 3b). Promisingly, sub-ambient cooling of 0.5–2.5°C was achieved at noon under a solar irradiation of 900–1000 W m− 2 (Fig. 3c,d and Supplementary Fig. 9a). In the afternoon, our textile can achieve ~ 3.4°C maximum temperature drop (ΔT) relative to the ambient with a RH of ~ 50%. To the best of the authors’ knowledge, this was the first time for textiles directly exposed to the ambient to achieve sub-ambient cooling in subtropical coastal regions under strong solar irradiation and high RH. During the nighttime, a larger ΔT of ~ 4.7°C was achieved with RH of more than 80% (Fig. 3e,f and Supplementary Fig. 9b). These results validate the superior all-day sub-ambient cooling performance of our textile even under weather conditions of high RH and strong solar irradiation.
Further, a simulated human skin was used to assess the cooling performance of the textile as clothes (Fig. 3g). The simulated human skin is composed of a silicone rubber heater and a 3M tape20 (3M micropore 1533-1), which has quite similar spectral characteristics within 0.3–16 µm to real human skin (Supplementary Fig. 10 and Supplementary Table 2). The input power of the silicone rubber heater was set to 100 W m− 2 referring to the human basal metabolic rate (BMR)35. White cotton, which has better radiative cooling performance (\({\bar {r}_{0.3 - 2.5\mu m}}=0.68\), and \({\bar {\varepsilon }_{8 - 13\mu m}}=0.90\)) than other common textiles, such as spandex, chiffon, and linen16. was also measured as a reference (see Supplementary Fig. 11a and Supplementary Table 3 for its optical performance). During the daytime measurement, the temperature of the simulated skin covered with our textile is 3–10°C lower than that covered with white cotton due to its higher \({\bar {r}_{0.3 - 2.5\mu m}}\) and \({\bar {\varepsilon }_{8 - 13\mu m}}\) (Fig. 3h and Supplementary Fig. 9c). The highest temperature difference of 10.2°C was observed at noon with peak solar irradiation of ~ 1000 W m− 2. Moreover, the temperature difference between our textile and the bare simulated skin was 10–19°C during the daytime, showing remarkable cooling effects. This skin cooling performance exceeds those in previous literature16,20. To demonstrate the performance of the large-size textile in real scenarios, we sewed a PES-Al2O3 textile and a white cotton T-shirt together (Fig. 3i). A body model with uniform temperature distribution was designed and prepared for the field test (Supplementary Fig. 13). The model dressed in the T-shirt was placed on the rooftop under direct sunlight (solar intensity ranged from 630 W m− 2 to 930 W m− 2). The IR image shows the surface temperature of the PES-Al2O3 textile is ~ 4°C below that of the white cloth under solar irradiation of ~ 700 W m− 2 (Fig. 3i). The skin temperature under the PES-Al2O3 textile is 2.1–5.4°C lower than that of the other side covered by the cotton cloth (Supplementary Fig. 14). This experiment verifies that the cooling textile is more comfortable to wear outside with strong sunlight compared to conventional white cotton.
Solar Heating Performance
The solar heating performance of the warming side of the Janus textile was tested on the simulated skin in an environmental control room (Supplementary Fig. 15, L×W×H, 8×4×3 m3, accredited by ISO/IEC 17025:2017) under different ambient temperatures and solar intensities. Commercial black cotton with both high sunlight absorptance (0.65) and high IR emittance (0.90) was also tested for comparison. As shown in Fig. 4a and Supplementary Fig. 16, the surface temperature of our textile was 6–21°C higher than that of the black cotton when the solar intensity changed from 0.2 to 0.8 sun (1 sun = 1000 W m− 2). The calculated net heating power of the black cotton is 41–53% lower than that of the Janus textile (Supplementary Fig. 18, see Supplementary Note 2 for the heat transfer model). Unlike black cotton, the temperature of the simulated skin covered with our textile can be maintained above 33°C (normal temperature of human skin) under most test conditions (Fig. 4b and Supplementary Fig. 19). For example, a solar intensity of 0.4 sun (a typical value in sunny winter days) is sufficient to keep the skin temperature at 35°C at the ambient temperature of 5°C. The climatic data of Hong Kong and Shanghai (31°10′0″ N, 121°29′0″ E) in winter are marked as red points and blue points in Fig. 4b and Supplementary Fig. 19 for reference36,37. Our textile can keep human bodies warm in both places while one wearing black cotton will have the risk of frostbite and hypothermia in Shanghai because the skin temperature is only 22°C. The outstanding solar heating performance of our textile is attributed to the great spectral selectivity and therefore high solar-thermal energy conversion efficiency of Ti3C2Tx (ηsolar−th = 79.1% under 0.8 sun, T = 55°C, and T0 = 15°C in real condition of this work).
Warming Performance
As mentioned before, most garment manufacturers only focus on convection suppression but overlook heat loss by thermal radiation of human bodies. For our textile, the low IR emittance of the warming side (\(\bar {\varepsilon }=0.22\)) can help human bodies reduce thermal radiation to the cold surroundings and outer space. The warming performance of the Janus textile was also investigated in the environment control room without solar irradiation. The required set-points of the ambient temperature for different samples to maintain the skin temperature at 33°C were measured, of which a lower value indicates better warming performance. Besides black cotton, sweater and Mylar blanket were also tested for comparison. It is manifest from Fig. 4c that the set-point of the Janus textile is 4.3 and 2.7°C lower than those of the sweater and the cotton, respectively. In addition, the Janus textile has a thermal insulation performance comparable with the Mylar blanket. To intuitively demonstrate the low emittance of the warming side in our Janus textile, all the samples were attached on a hot plate with a constant temperature of 35°C and characterized by a thermal imager (the default emissivity was set as 0.95 in this work). As shown in Fig. 4d, our textile appears much colder than the cotton and the sweater.
Electric Heating Performance
Solar heating will be less effective at low ambient temperatures and weak solar irradiation. In this condition, the warming side of the Janus textile can still keep the body warm via Joule heating effects because of the excellent electrical conductivity of Ti3C2Tx (8000 S cm− 1 in this work). We can see from Fig. 4e that the skin temperature with our textile can be retained in the thermal comfort zone (33 ± 2°C)38 or slightly higher than 33°C with a safety input below 5 V even at the ambient temperature of 5°C. The heat flux could exceed 66 W m− 2 during the tests. Such small DC voltage can be easily supplied by dry batteries or mobile power in real applications. Compared with other conductive membrane heaters such as carbon-based coatings, the input power of our textile can be smaller owing to the low emittance of Ti3C2Tx MXene, which reduces radiative heat dissipation. As a result, the combination of solar heating and electric heating can protect one from cold injury and hypothermia efficiently most of the time.
Wearability
Besides the thermal performance tests, the wearability of textiles is also of great importance in reality. Firstly, we tested the mechanical properties of our textile. As shown in Fig. 5a, the tensile strength of our textile is around 9.0 MPa, which is as high as that of cotton. Then the folding resistance of the textile was evaluated by a folding test machine. After 10,000 times folding, the absorption/emission spectra of the two sides keep the same as before (Fig. 5b,c). Thirdly, textiles used for clothes should be water vapor permeable for body comfort because sweating happens all the time. Therefore, we also measured the water vapor transmission rate (WVTR) of the Janus textile, as well as cotton and Mylar blanket. As shown in Fig. 5d (data see Supplementary Fig. 20), the WVTR of our textile is 12 mg cm− 2 h− 1 and a bit lower than that of cotton (13 mg cm− 2 h− 1). Both meet the requirement of the sweat rate of an adult at rest (about 10 mg cm− 2 h− 1)39. In contrast, Mylar blanket is almost impermeable to water vapor because of its dense polyester film with a metallic coating. From the concern of safety, textiles with good thermal stability will be more useful. It is reported that Ti3C2Tx can keep stable at temperatures as high as 400°C40. As for PES, it has a high glass transition temperature of ~ 230°C and a melting point over 400°C (Supplementary Fig. 21). Unlike conventional cotton textiles and PE textiles, PES has outstanding flame retardancy of UL94V-0 (0.46mm)41, which eliminates the safety risk when one is exposed to fire. In addition, the washability of our textile was also investigated. Raw Ti3C2Tx coating is hydrophilic (Supplementary Fig. 22), resulting in poor durability during water washing. In our Janus texitile, we used a simple fluoroalkylsilane (FAS) treatment to make the Ti3C2Tx coating hydrophobic with a water contact angle of 145° with negligible change in the spectrum (Supplementary Fig. 8). To demonstrate the washability of our textile, firstly, we placed the textiles coated with hydrophilic Ti3C2Tx and hydrophobic Ti3C2Tx under water flushing for 1 minute (volumetric flux q = 3.6 m3 s− 1 m− 2). The hydrophilic Ti3C2Tx coating without treatment faded a little while the hydrophobic Ti3C2Tx was quite stable. Further, we immersed our textile with hydrophobic Ti3C2Tx in a water tank with water spinning for half an hour. The optical performances of the Janus textile appear unchanged after washing (Fig. 5e,f). Lastly, the UV durability test of the Janus textile was carried out using a UV weathering test machine. The reflectance spectrum remains the same after UV exposure for 2 equivalent months, suggesting the excellent UV resistance of our textile (Supplementary Fig. 23).