Research Article
Perioperative blood loss factors associated with decreased level of postoperative hemoglobin in stable femoral pertrochanteric fracture groups treated with PFNA.
https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-2093763/v1
This work is licensed under a CC BY 4.0 License
posted
You are reading this latest preprint version
AO classification
pertrochanteric fractures
postoperative hemoglobin
hemoglobin drop
stable fractures
Strengths and limitations of the study:
As the elderly population is soaring, so is the number of fragility hip fractures, which has been estimated to reach 4.5 million by the year 2050 [1]. In the 65-and-older population group, PTFs comprise 42 % of all hip fractures [2]. PTFs constitute also more than 75% of all extracapsular hip fractures [3]. Intracapsular fractures are known to cause less bleeding, mostly because the restricted area of articular capsule within blood can extravasate [4].
These fractures can be treated successfully either with intramedullary (Gamma nail, PFNA) or extramedullary (DHS) fixation. Recently developed low-invasive device PFNA poses lower risk of blood loss in comparison to the implementation of DHS and Gamma nail [5–6]. Regardless of surgical strategy, hemoglobin drop (HbD) during surgery is inevitable. Higher blood loss is associated with greater mortality and poorer functional recovery after hip surgery. [7] Additionally, higher blood loss is correlated with higher rate of allogenic blood transfusions, which may generate procedure-related complications such as infections and supplementary costs [8]. In regard of the fact the increased mortality among patients suffering from hip fractures, previous attempts have strived to establish the protocol for hip fracture management. [9] However, closer investigation of the phenomenon of HbD as the vital factor affecting overall mortality was neglected in the trials. In recent years a few risk factors (sex, type of fracture, hemoglobin on admission, the use of anticoagulants, longer duration of surgery) have been correlated with an increased need for perioperative blood transfusions [10–11]. The correlation between type of fracture and blood transfusion was further expanded into presurgical blood transfusion promptness due to greater HbD in unstable fracture group [12]. However, no detailed data indicates the impact of the particular type of fracture regarding Modified AO/OTA 2018 classification was provided. Forasmuch as hemoglobin upon admission and HbD may elevate the risk of mortality and morbidity in patients undergoing the surgery for PTFs, it is essential to predict and prevent postoperative anemia. Therefore, this study was focused on the comparison between simple PTFs AO31-A1.2 and PTFs with the detachment of lesser trochanter AO31-A1.3 along with the risk factors of perioperative blood loss in terms of their impact on postoperative hemoglobin.
All patients with unilateral PTFs included in this retrospective analysis were treated with PFNA between May 2015 and March 2021. All patients gave informed consent to participate in the study. Inclusion criteria enclosed the presence of unilateral, stable PTFs classified as AO31-A1.2 or AO31-A1.3, PFNA augmentation, blood parameters inspected preoperatively and postoperatively. Exclusion criteria were as follows: bilateral fractures, multiple trauma, different nailing technique, other types of proximal femur fractures, patients transfused before first postoperative blood examination, patients with missing data (Fig. 1). In accordance with both the inclusion and exclusion criteria, 334 of the initial 575 patients suffering from proximal femur fractures treated with PFNA were examined at the Department of Traumatology and Orthopaedics.
Pursuant to the medical history, all patients were admitted to the hospital ward on the day of the injury. After a thorough medical inspection patients were subsequently qualified for the surgery. PTFs are known to be of a substantial risk of bleeding, especially among patients with ongoing anticoagulant treatment. Thus, all patients on blood thinners had their therapy withdrawn in line with preoperative anticoagulation management guidelines [13]. Standardized surgery protocol required three doses of intravenous second-generation cephalosporin antibiotic prophylaxis, along with omission of low-molecular-weight heparin thromboprophylaxis on the day of surgery, if introduced preoperatively.
All surgeries were performed under fluoroscopic guidance by two orthopedic surgeons, one of whom was always a senior surgeon. Surgical technique was convergent with manufacturer’s directions. Fracture reduction was achieved through a longitudinal traction on a traction table. No drains were introduced. No antifibrinolytic drugs were used.
The patients’ characteristics were obtained through an electronic medical record system. The following variables were extracted: age, sex, occurrence of blood transfusions, admission to surgery time, operative time, Hb level on admission, first Hb level after surgery. The operative time was measured from the time of skin incision to skin closure. Hemoglobin on admission (Hb0) was the first level of Hb recorded on admission to the hospital, while hemoglobin after surgery (Hb1) was the first level of Hb recorded immediately after the surgery (Fig. 2). HbD was calculated by subtracting the level of Hb0 from Hb1.
The preoperative anteroposterior and lateral radiographs of proximal femur fracture were evaluated independently by two of the authors twice. Apart from the allocation of fracture regarding AO classification, angle of fracture gap and the presence of fracture gap displacement were assessed. Angle of the fracture gap was defined by the line connecting lateral and medial split of the cortex and the line perpendicular to anatomic axis of the femur (Fig. 3). Fracture gap displacement was defined as any gap visible to the naked eye on AP or lateral radiograph. In case of any discrepancies, a third expert was consulted to reach consensus. No masking was used.
Continuous variables were presented as mean and standard deviation or median and interquartile range. The Shapiro-Wilk test was used to verify the normal distribution of continuous variables. The Mann–Whitney U-test was performed to compare two groups in case of large departures from normal distribution of continuous variables. The Student’s t-test were used to compare two groups for normally distributed variables. The Levene’s test was applied to assess the homogeneity of variances. The qualitative variables were presented as the number and corresponding percentages. The Fisher’s exact test or the chi-squared test was used to compare qualitative variables between the two groups. The predictors of hemoglobin levels after operation was assessed by the multivariable linear regression model. The coefficient of determination for the resulted model was close to 53%. The Durbin-Watson test was used to detect autocorrelation. The significance level for the two-sided tests was assumed to be below 0.05. The package R [14] and Statistica 12.5 software ® (StatSoft Inc., Tulsa, Oklahoma, United States) were used to conduct the analyses.
The study was approved by the local ethical institutional review board (Ethical approval number KBKA/42/O/2022).
A total of 334 patients meeting all inclusion criteria were analyzed. Out of the initial 575 patients, we excluded 190 patients recognized with different types of fracture, 7 patients with unlike fixation technique, 39 patients transfused preoperatively or perioperatively, 4 patients with missing data and 1 patient with multiple trauma. Eventually, according to AO classification 205 patients with AO31-A1.2 type of fracture and 129 patients with AO31-A2.1 type of fracture were identified (Fig. 1).
The investigated group comprised 247 women (73,9%) and 87 men (26,1%), with median age of 84. The median operative time is 45 minutes. The mean preoperative and postoperative Hb levels for all fractures were 12 g/dl and 9.52 g/dl, respectively. The median interval between admission to hospital and surgery was 10.3 hours, while the median interval between surgery and Hb1 measurement was 14.6 hours.
PTFs with the detachment of lesser trochanter (AO31-A1.3) were associated with both greater HbD (p = 0.011) and lower postoperative hemoglobin level (p = 0.078) (Fig. 4). Those fractures pose also greater risk of postoperative blood transfusion (p = 0.038). The presence of the fracture gap displacement was noticed more frequently in the AO31-A1.3 group (p < 0.0001) as well as the greater angle of gap fracture (p < 0.0001). Patients’ characteristic in the reference to type of fracture is shown in Table 1.
On the grounds that the gender of patients was not far from reaching statistical significance (p = 0.15), one has decided to formulate similar characteristics, but with regard to the sex of patients (Table 2). As presented, females in the study were significantly older than men (85 vs 80 years; p < 0.0001). Both blood transfusion risk (42.9% vs 24.1%; p = 0.002) and HbD (2.6 g/dl vs 1.9 g/dl; p < 0.0001) were noticibly greater, while the level of postoperative hemoglobin (9.31 g/dl vs 10.1 g/dl; p < 0.0001) was considerably lower in women’s group compared to men’s group (Fig. 5).
Multiple linear regression analysis was conducted with the level of postoperative hemoglobin as the dependent variable and perioperative blood loss factors as the independent variables (Table 3). The results indicated that age, gender, type of fracture, preoperative hemoglobin level and angle of fracture gap had affected the postoperative level of hemoglobin (p < 0.05). AO31-A1.2 type of fracture presented with 0.33 g/dl lower Hb1 than AO31-A1.3 type holding other predictors constant. The level of postoperative hemoglobin was 0,54 g/dl lower for women whereas others factors were held constant. The presence of fracture dislocation lowered the level of Hb1 by 0,74 g/dl while other independent variables remained unchanged. One unit (1g/dl) of preoperative hemoglobin (Hb0) developed increase in postoperative level of Hb1 by 0.63 g/dl with others parameters constant. All the changes have been found to be statistically significant.
The results of the present study has confirmed greater HbD (median 2,6 vs 2,2 g/dl, p = 0.011) and the higher percentage of postoperative blood transfusions (p = 0.038) in PTFs with the detachment of lesser trochanter (AO31-A1.3) than in simple PTFs (AO31-A1.2). Both types of investigated PTFs (AO31-A1.2, AO31-A1.3) are generally considered stable [2].
Additionally, the analysis has demonstrated other statistically significant factors affecting the level of postoperative hemoglobin in those groups. Aforementioned factors are as follows: age of patients, gender of patients, type of fracture, admission Hb level, angle of the fracture gap and fracture gap displacement. With such preponderance of elderly patients suffering from those PTFs (58% of all unilateral femoral fractures at our faculty), patients are put under a very serious threat of limitation of disability and death. The peril of 30-day mortality due to intertrochanteric fracture surgery exceeds 7% of the initial population [3]. Thus, regarding the AO classification of PTFs, it is of paramount importance to foresee and prevent plausible blood loss originating from different types of pertrochanetric fractures. As it is commonly known that unstable PTFs lead to more blood loss than the stable PTFs [15], little is known about the factual perioperative blood loss differences within the stable fracture group [16].
There are a few factors that have an impact on total blood loss after PTFs management. The use of PFNA is associated with the least blood loss compared to DHS, Gamma Nail or InterTan [4, 17]. Secondly, the extension and severity of trauma, which is limited in our study to patients with unilateral PTFs. Thirdly, a vast meta-analysis concluded that patients on OACs (oral anticoagulants) experience increased surgical blood loss compared to those not anticoagulated [18, 19]. In order to downsize that effect, any case of ongoing anticoagulant remedy was withdrawn before surgery and patients awaited surgical intervention according to preoperative anticoagulation management guidelines [13]. Worth highlighting is the fact that the majority of the patients were initially free from anticoagulants and the remedy did not influence the time between admission to the hospital and surgery between groups significantly (p = 0.76).
Furthermore, authors hypothesized that primary dislocation of cortex would intensify loss of blood because of the fracture-induced disruption of the network of both cortical and medullary vessels. Fracture gap displacement caused by avulsion mechanism of iliopsoas muscle was significantly more often observed in AO31-A1.3 fractures (99,2% vs 84,4%, p < 0.0001), which were followed by greater HbD. The results confirmed this hypothesis, so that displaced fractures had on average 0,74 g/dl lower postoperative hemoglobin than the intact ones. Despite such a huge dissimilarity in the level of postoperative hemoglobin, there is still a paucity of research examining the impact of primar cortex dislocation on perioperative loss of hemoglobin.
All fractures were classified independently by two of the authors in line with the 2018 edition of the AO/OTA classification [20]. In the context of previous studies, this classification retains a similar interobserver reliability for subgroup classification, but is characterized with reduced interobserver reliability for group categorization in comparison to previous classification from 1990 [21–23]. To minimize the bias, the group assignment was performed twice and in case of any discrepancies a third expert was consulted.
Hidden blood loss comprises the major part of total perioperative blood loss [24], so just the sole measurement of visible blood loss may be considered inadequate. In order to depict comprehensive blood loss, the researchers have decided to make use of hemoglobin, as the fluctuation of the level of hemoglobin is known to be of greater predictive value for anemia assessment than the level of Hct [25].
The level of preoperative hemoglobin did not differ between the groups (12.0 g/dl vs 12.0 g/dl, p = 0.92). The findings are in line with Haidong Cui et al. preoperative level of hemoglobin, which was 11.82 g/dl in the stable group. [12]. On the other hand, admission Hb may differ between population groups and the initial level was 1g/dl lower within the stable group presented by Luo Xiangping et al. [26].
As the exact level of postoperative hemoglobin varied on the verge of statistical significance (p = 0.078), authors introduced another parameter of interest - HbD. From the results, it is clear that despite similar time from admission to surgery and longer time from surgery to postoperative hemoglobin measurement (15.1 hours vs 13.5 hours, p = 0.056), AO 31-A1.2 simple PTFs lost 0,4 g/dl less blood than fractures with the detachment of lesser trochanter (p = 0.011).
Much attention has been drawn to divergence between blood loss in stable and unstable PTFs groups. Previous studies have documented considerably more bleeding associated with AO31-A2.2 – AO31-A3.3 types, which are generally considered unstable [10, 24, 26, 27]. This research, unlike others, reveals intra-stable-group disproportions in terms of surgery-associated. As a consequence, AO31-A1.3 fractures are more often expected to be transfused postoperatively (45% vs 33,7%, p = 0.038). This finding was observed regardless of the fact that both types of fractures are considered stable. Our observation is in consonance with Torres et la. statement that each type of fracture should be analyzed individually to anticipate potential perioperative blood loss [28].
Another promising finding was that females are more prone to suffer from greater perioperative blood loss. Attainable reports are incoherent with the explanation of the influence of gender on total blood loss. Jiqi Wang et. La found women are associated with blood transfusion [29], on the other hand Junfei Guo et la. and Xiangping Luo et la. indicated that men as the risk factor for blood transfusion [26, 30]. In our study, a possible explanation of gender influence may be provided with respect to the primal age and group size differences.
Measurement of the angle of gap fracture was possible, as the medial point of secant line was largely oriented towards the base of lesser trochanter. The bigger the angle of fracture, the lower postoperative level of hemoglobin. Researchers deem that this correlation is the result of simultaneous increase in cross-sectional area and angle of fracture. Fractures with the lateral fracture line placed more proximally were susceptible to greater blood loss.
Duration of the surgery bore no correlation with the postoperative level of hemoglobin, which is consistent with other studies and diminishes the influence of surgeon bias [27].
The most significant advantage of our study is that the studied population with a total of 334 patients identified with either AO31-A1.2 or AO31-A1.3 type of fracture was much more sizeable than so far studied. Population was not age-restricted, so there is a good applicability of the results to the entire population of patients suffering from those fractures. Additionally, researchers have not identified any prior research investigating differences in blood loss between stable intertrochanteric fracture.
However, our study has several limitations. Firstly, the retrospective character of this study precludes randomization of patients. Secondly, authors restricted the number of parameters investigated in this study to relatively small extent. Moreover, the time from admission Hb (Hb0) measurement to the surgery and then the time from the surgery to following Hb (Hb1) measurement may differ between orthopedic wards, so that presented results should be adopted respectively with caution. On top of that, researchers did not follow patients post hospitalization.
In conclusion, the finding suggests that simple pertrochanteric fracture (AO31-A1.2) treated with PFNA is burdened with lower perioperative blood loss than the pertrochanteric fracture with the detachment of lesser trochanter (AO31-A1.3). Main factors affecting postoperative level of hemoglobin are: age, sex, type of fracture, fracture gap displacement, angle of fracture gap and preoperative level of hemoglobin. As those fractures represent the most common types of PTFs, more attention should be paid to the intra-stable group perioperative blood loss differences. We believe that presented results will assist surgeons in predicting postoperative anemia.
Overall (N = 334) |
AO 31-A1.2 (N = 205) |
AO 31-A1.3 (N = 129) |
p-value |
|
---|---|---|---|---|
Age |
0.67 |
|||
Median [Q1, Q3] |
84 [77–88] |
84 [77–89] |
84 [78–88] |
|
Gender |
0.15 |
|||
Women |
247 (74.0%) |
146 (71.2%) |
101 (78.3%) |
|
Men |
87 (26.0%) |
59 (28.8%) |
28 (21.7%) |
|
Blood transfusion |
0.038 |
|||
No |
207 (62.0%) |
136 (66.3%) |
71 (55.0%) |
|
Yes, post-Hb1 |
127 (38.0%) |
69 (33.7%) |
58 (45.0%) |
|
Duration of surgery [min] |
0.35 |
|||
Median [Q1 - Q3] |
45 [35–60] |
45 [35–60] |
45 [35–60] |
|
Fracture gap displacement |
< 0.0001 |
|||
No |
33 (9.9%) |
32 (15.6%) |
1 (0.8%) |
|
Yes |
301 (90.1%) |
173 (84.4%) |
128 (99.2%) |
|
Hb0 (g/dl) |
0.92 |
|||
Mean (SD) |
12.0 (1.66) |
12.0 (1.61) |
12.0 (1.75) |
|
Hb1 (g/dl) |
0.078 |
|||
Mean (SD) |
9.52 (1.64) |
9.64 (1.69) |
9.32 (1.55) |
|
HbD = |Hb1-Hb0| (g/dl) |
0.011 |
|||
Median [Q1 - Q3] |
2.3 [1.6–3.3] |
2.2 [1.5–3.1] |
2.6 [1.9–3.4] |
|
Angle of the fracture (°) |
< 0.0001 |
|||
Median [Q1 - Q3] |
52 [44–58] |
49 [40–56 |
55 [50–60] |
|
Time from admission to surgery [h] |
0.76 |
|||
Median [Q1 - Q3] |
10.3 [3.8–25.6] |
10.3 [4.3–28.1] |
9.5 [3.6–22] |
|
Time from Hb0 to surgery |
0.5 |
|||
Median [Q1 - Q3] |
9.4 [3.9–21.4] |
9.8 [4.1–24.8] |
8.6 [3.7–17.4] |
|
Time from surgery to Hb1 |
0.056 |
|||
Median [Q1 - Q3] |
14.6 [9.9–19.7 |
15.1 [10.3–20.7] |
13.5 [9.4–18.6] |
Overall (N = 334) |
Women (N = 247) |
Men (N = 87) |
p-value |
|
---|---|---|---|---|
Age |
< 0.0001 |
|||
Median [Q1, Q3] |
84 [77–88] |
85 [79–89] |
80 [67–87] |
|
Type of fracture |
0.15 |
|||
AO 31-A1.2 |
205 (61.4%) |
146 (59.1%) |
59 (67.8%) |
|
AO 31-A1.3 |
129 (38.6%) |
101 (40.9%) |
28 (32.2%) |
|
Blood transfusion |
0.002 |
|||
No |
207 (62.0%) |
141 (57.1%) |
66 (75.9%) |
|
Yes, post-Hb1 |
127 (38.0%) |
106 (42.9%) |
21 (24.1%) |
|
Duration of surgery [min] |
0.92 |
|||
Median [Q1 - Q3] |
45 [35, 60] |
45 [35, 60] |
45 [35–60] |
|
Fracture gap displacement |
0.87 |
|||
No |
33 (9.9%) |
24 (9.7%) |
9 (10.3%) |
|
Yes |
301 (90.1%) |
223 (90.3%) |
78 (89.7%) |
|
Hb0 (g/dl) |
0.54 |
|||
Mean (SD) |
12.0 (1.66) |
11.9 (1.65) |
12.1 (1.69) |
|
Hb1 (g/dl) |
0.0001 |
|||
Mean (SD) |
9.52 (1.64) |
9.31 (1.62) |
10.1 (1.59) |
|
HbD = |Hb1-Hb0| (g/dl) |
< 0.0001 |
|||
Median [Q1 - Q3] |
2.3 [1.6–3.3] |
2.6 [1.7–3.4] |
1.9 [1.3–2.8] |
|
Angle of the fracture (°) |
0.64 |
|||
Median [Q1 - Q3] |
52 [44–58] |
52 [44–59] |
52 [44–58] |
|
Time from admission to surgery [h] |
0.032 |
|||
Median [Q1 - Q3] |
10.3 [3.8–25.6] |
9.5 [3.6–22.1] |
15.1 [4.5–43.3] |
|
Time from Hb0 to surgery |
0.098 |
|||
Median [Q1 - Q3] |
9.4 [3.9–21.4] |
8.6 [3.7–19.9] |
12.1 [4.3–31.2] |
|
Time from surgery to Hb1 |
0.6 |
|||
Median [Q1 - Q3] |
14.6 [9.9–19.7 |
14.7 [9.6–19.9] |
14.2 [10.2–19.5] |
Table 3: Multivariable linear regression model.
Dependent variable: postoperative level of hemoglobin (Hb1)
Competing interests: All authors declare that they have no competing interest.
Authors’ contributions
Bartłomiej Juszczak was responsible for the concept of the study, data extraction, project administration, development of methodology, visualization and original draft writing.
Elżbieta Broniatowska was responsible for formal analysis, methodology, tables visualization as well as software and data validation.
Tomasz Pardała was responsbile for the concept of the study, administration of the project, review and editing and supervision of the manuscript.
Critical study revision, final study approval and certainty about integrity and accuracy of all parts of work were executed together.
Funding: This research received no specific grant from any funding agency in the public, commercial or not-for-profit sectors. The submission fee was funded by the Andrzej Frycz Modrzejewski University, Cracow, Poland.
Availability of data and materials: The datasets analysed in the current study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.
Level of evidence : III
Article focus:
No competing interests reported.
posted
You are reading this latest preprint version