3.1 Microstructure and hardness
The original 35CrMo seamless steel pipe is generally produced by the hot rolling, which will generate a large amount of residual stress during the forming and crystallization process. In order to improve the uniformity of the microstructure and reduce the level of internal residual stress, the steel pipe is often subjected to quenching and tempering heat treatment. Based on the effect of structural continuity on magnetic and mechanical properties, the magnetic coercivity parameter of HL analysis at room temperature can be used for steel grade classification and even evaluation of quenching, tempering and annealing effects [21].
Figure 7 is the contour diagram of the coercive force on the surface (four meridional lines) of two 35CrMo cylinders in different state. Due to the original 35CrMo steel in the hot rolled state without any heat treatment, as shown in Fig. 7a, the original cylinder has a coercivity that ranges from 9.2A/cm to 11.5A/cm. It is obvious that the microstructure of 1# cylinder is not uniform, and there may be stress concentration zones (marked in Fig. 7a) locally. After quenching illustrated in Fig. 7b, the overall coercivity level is greatly improved to 19.6∼20.87A/cm. Although the variation range is narrowed, the distribution of coercivity is also uneven, there are still some areas of high stress in the cylinder (marked in Fig. 7b). This is due to the martensitic transformation by the quenching of 2# cylinder, resulting in a decrease in grain size and an increase in dislocation density. The interlacing of "needle" grain boundaries increases the resistance of the magnetic domain movement, so the coercivity level reaches the highest. After tempering at high temperature in Fig. 7c, the internal stress of 2# cylinder is released fully, so the coercive force level dropped to 12ཞ12.9A/cm, corresponding to a uniform microstructure with grain refinement. It should be emphasized that the coercivity of steels is strongly related to the microstructure. The above results are also validated by metallographic investigation of two cylinders investigated here.
Table 2 Microstructural features
No.
|
Ferrite content/%
|
Grain size/mm
|
State
|
1# cylinder
|
96.4~97.4
|
0.03
|
Original
|
2# cylinder
|
89.5~90.1
|
0.16
|
Heated/Cooled
|
As seen in
Table 2, the coarse-grained ferrite and pearlite microstructure are observed clearly in the original cylinder (
Fig. 8a). In the microstructure of 2# cylinder at quenched and tempered state, microstructural changes are clearly observed in comparison with as-received one. Due to the precipitation of supersaturated carbides, the tempered sorbite phase in
Fig. 8b is a mixture of ferrite and cementite essentially. However, due to large number of grain boundaries and dispersion of carbides, the movement of magnetic domain wall is still restricted, higher magnetic fields are required to overcome strong pinning sites and move domain walls
[22-23], the coercivity level of 2# cylinder is still higher compared to that of the original cylinder. Moreover, the coercivity values determined using digital measurements were compared with the results obtained by the traditional HL method
[24,34], a very good correlation was found between the two techniques (
Fig. 9).
After achieving the mean values from the hardness and magnetic coercivity measurements, Fig. 10 shows the coercivity and hardness distributions of 35CrMo cylinder in different states. As the most structure-sensitive magnetic parameter, coercivity is determined by the grain, inclusions, dislocation, inhomogeneities and defects of the crystal lattice [25]. For the as-quenched state, the hardness of the cylinder is characterized by the martensite hardness in the 35CrMo steel. Furthermore, the grain refinement, the phase hardening, the formation of supersaturated non-solid solutions and high dislocation density result in the difficulty of magnetic domain wall motion, the coercivity achieves its maximum. In some extent, the high coercivity of martensite has contributed by the higher magnetic anisotropy, due to the magnetic lattice structure and magnetoelastic effects [26]. Once tempered at high temperature, the hardness of the cylinder drops significantly, because the decay process of the martensite and residual austenite becomes more rapid. As the carbide particles merges, the pinning of large-angle boundaries is weakened. Moreover, the redistribution of dislocations, the smaller distortions of the lattice and the lower levels of internal stress lead to lower coercivity values [27]. Likewise, the formation of alloyed carbides can lead to secondary hardening phenomena, resulting in hardness peak compared to the original material.
The relationship between the hardness and coercivity of 35CrMo cylinders at each stage of its heat treatment is quantitatively characterized in Fig. 11. Compared to the original, the hardness and coercivity in quenching process increased by 90.7% and 90.4%, respectively. Although decreasing dramatically after tempering, the final increases in hardness and coercivity are 17.98% and 19.9%. Evidently, the level of coercive force is directly proportional to the hardness, which is agreed with previous researches [28–29]. Even, a reliable correlation between the hardness and the coercivity measurement can be established for nondestructive testing of mechanical properties.
3.2 Residual Stress
The potential energy barrier caused by residual stress or stress concentration can hinder the movement of magnetic domains, thereby causing significant changes in the magnetic BN signals [30]. One of the most important information from the envelope of the BN signal is the root mean square (RMS) value, which is strongly related to domain wall motion. By measuring the RMS values of the sample material with a known applied stress, a calibration curve can be obtained to evaluate the residual stresses of the components [31]. Fig. 12 shows the elastic stress dependency of the RMS values, and an increasing trend is observed. Therefore, the MBN values could be converted to the residual stress values indirectly via the calibration curve. Consequently, the magnitudes of the residual stresses of two cylinders during heat treatment were evaluated quantitatively on the BN measurement. Fig. 13 shows the residual stresses of the original, quenched and tempered states of the 35CrMo cylinders. Although the BN signals at different points fluctuate greatly, the variation trend of residual stresses is generally clear. In the hot rolling process of 35CrMo steel pipe, uneven forming or cooling generates large internal stress. If it is not normalized or annealed, the grains are usually coarse, and the homogeneity of the structure is poor, the initial residual stress level of the original cylinder is about 101.5 MPa. While quenching in water produces the martensitic transformation and hardening of the steels, resulting in a significant increase in the overall stress level (~171.68 MPa). The rapid cooling effect leads to finer grains, dislocation immobilization and local increased strain. Finally, tempering at high temperature releases the internal stress mostly, the magnitude of residual stresses decreases to the lowest level of 41.46 MPa. As expected, the almost uniform residual stress in the tempered cylinder obtained by the MBN analysis is consistent with the coercivity measurement in Fig. 6c. It is known that the microstructure and properties of the 35CrMo steel (AISI 4135) are similar to those of the AISI 4340 steel. Earlier studies [32] showed that residual stress values of AISI 4340 steel samples obtained by XRD measurements decrease with increasing tempering temperature. From Fig. 14, when the tempering temperature exceeded 450°C, the stress relief was significant and the stresses nature was reversed, resulting in compressive residual stress in both directions. Apparently, MBN and XRD methods gave the same tendency, the residual stresses behaviour of the 35CrMo steel cylinders is in good agreement with that of the AISI 4340 steel samples, except for some variation in stress magnitudes. This difference is mostly due to the different information depth of these two techniques, some additional factors such as microstructure changes, also affect the domain wall movements during MBN measurements [33-34]. Thus, the nondestructive MBN method has a fairly high sensitivity to estimate residual stresses in heat-treated steel cylinders. Further in production lines, the simultaneous use of coercive force and MBN method can adequately monitor the microstructure and properties changes of steel components after hardening heat treatment, avoiding significant costs for destructive testing and ensuring that all components can be checked quickly.