Hybrid two-dimensional nanomaterials composed of subwavelength scale holes milled periodically in an opaque metal film have achieved optical transmission in selective wavelengths [27-29]. These plasmonic metamaterials are highly tunable in a broad wavelength range with the resonance peak and bandwidth controlled by engineering the period and diameter leading to nanophotonic devices filtering in the visible light [30-34]. There is limited literature available to extend this technology to other spectral bands specific across the LWIR region of the electromagnetic spectrum [35-39]. In this work, we develop resonant filters in the LWIR range that can be tuned laterally by engineering subwavelength geometry for integration in infrared optoelectronic systems. An aluminum plasmonic pixel of pitch size, 17 µm (that of a standard bolometer pixel size) with a hexagonal hole lattice sandwiched between Ge dielectric layers is schematically illustrated in Figure 1(a)-(b). Upon illumination, selective filtering is exhibited due to multimodal excitation and surface plasmon resonances in the metal film. Theoretical modelling of the transmission peak wavelength is given in Figure S1 in the Electronic Supplementary Material (ESM).
To comprehend the transmission mechanism in proposed plasmonic structures, the numerical simulation technique of finite element method on COMSOL Multiphysics® is used. A variable-control method is adopted to optimize structural parameters like film thickness and lateral periodicity for enhanced selectivity in the normal incidence of light. Our simulations revealed that Al plasmonic array on the Ge substrate has a broad spectrum of transmission with FWHM ≥ 2 µm. Adding the top layer of dielectric material (Ge) to realize dielectric-metal-dielectric (DMD) design has reduced the number of peaks and improved the transmission with FWHM ≤ 1.5 µm. From the obtained computational results, the metal film thickness is chosen as 50 nm which is around three times the skin depth to ensure no coupling in the top and bottom dielectric layers for preserving surface plasmon resonances at the metal-dielectric interface. The thickness of a top dielectric layer is optimized to be 300 nm for ease of fabrication. This reduces the non-uniformity in the Germanium film height over hole and metal film layers to 16%. The hexagonal arrangement of the metal hole array (MHA) increases the relative aperture area, which increases the efficiency of the device. Further, circular structures are easier to fabricate than square or other polygon-shaped holes. A hexagonal MHA with an aspect ratio (hole diameter: pitch) of 0.6 exhibits narrow linewidth and sufficient dip depth, along with having high transmission (60%), and angle-independent operation.
We systematically analyze the filter spectral response with respect to the geometrical configuration of hexagonal MHAs in terms of pitch size, angle of incidence, aspect ratio, and optical properties of constituent materials. Figure 1(e) highlights the linear shift in the peak transmission spectra as a function of pitch. Figure 1(f) shows how the angle of light incidence on the DMD filter does not affect the transmission spectra. Enhancement in the transmission peak and the FWHM with an increase in the diameter at a fixed pitch (i.e., increasing the aspect ratio) is demonstrated in Figure 1(g). Since the narrower and sharper spectral transmission filters are ideal candidates, the aspect ratio is fixed at 0.6 in this work. The selection of dielectric constituting the DMD filter is also an important factor. Figure 1(h) plots transmission peak relations with the refractive index for infrared materials with Al as a metal layer. The plots show that lower index materials are better dielectric choices with enhanced spectral sensitivity to realize the filter array.
Based on the simulation results, the filters are fabricated using standard lithography, metal deposition and lift-off processes [40]. Three plasmonic filters with pitch sizes, 2.5, 3, and 3.5 µm respectively are fabricated into a 5⨯5 mm2 area each using a single lithography step – full fabrication details are described in the Methods section. To characterize the filters, scanning electron microscopy (SEM) imaging and spectral responsivity measurements, are performed and illustrated in Figures 1(c)-(d) respectively. Detailed scanning electron micrographsof the fabricated filters are given in Figure S2 in the ESM. Each fabricated filter will be placed in tandem with the silicon-based lens and vanadium oxide microbolometer detector array of FLIR Lepton camera (80⨯60 pixels, λrange ~8 – 14 μm) while imaging the target scene as demonstrated schematically in Figure 2(a). We have 3D printed a lightweight, rotating wheel and a supporting base to incorporate the monochrome camera and the three filters as illustrated in Figure 2(b). Each filter slot is a perforation extended to 6⨯6 mm2 in the wheel, and the multispectral camera measures 8⨯6 cm2 in size. More snapshots of the real device along with detailed measurements are shown in Figures 2(c)-(e).
We utilized the optical system to acquire radiometric data of the target scene in three LWIR wavelengths, 10, 12, and 14 µm by rotating the wheel to mount each filter sequentially. The spectral radiance flux, Fxy for the signal acquired when light, I of certain temperature, (t) impinges on the optical system with filter responsivity, S(λ) and detector responsivity D(λ) is given by
where . The input signal is received from a selective band due to the filtering effect while the noise, is captured across the λrange of the microbolometer detector. Surface temperature gradients and filter offsets corrupt the target measurements by propagating to the parameters of interest. Further, Ge transmittance is non-monotonic midway through the LWIR at λ~11.5 μm – which could complicate radiometric measurements. Hence, target images are corrected for non-uniformity at each pixel using a dark reference frame to eliminate spectral noises by filter and optics. Since the FLIR Lepton camera’s 80⨯60-pixel resolution is already suffering from pixelation and imaging artifacts, any further degradation in the signal quality due to the filter will be another challenge. To improve the signal reconstruction capability and system sensitivity, we performed radiometric characterization using a blackbody instrument (by LumaSense technologies) to determine the filter’s imaging capability. The radiometric temperatures were measured from the blackbody source in the temperature range of 50-200 oC using the LWIR multispectral camera. A calibration curve is generated to map the filter-acquired temperatures with reference to the source temperature as shown in Figure 2(f). Corresponding monochrome and multispectral images of blackbody are displayed in Figures 2(g) and 2(h)-(i) respectively.
Imaging experiments are performed using our multispectral imaging system prototype (Figure 3). Four spectral images of a tree are taken with a cloudy background in monochrome, band-1, band-2, and band-3 modes of the filter wheel as displayed in Figures 3(a)-(d) respectively. The resulting multispectral image acquired by combining three bands plotted in Figure 3(e) illustrate finer details as compared to the conventional monochrome image. In addition, a new differencing metric function is defined, Normalized Temperature Variation Index (NTVI) analogous to Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) in near-infrared counterparts to measure temperature variations and extract some additional information from the spectral images.
To address the low resolution of thermal image sensors, we demonstrate deep learning-based radiometric superresolution to improve the performance of the optical system. A deep learning-based residual dense network is implemented to increase the image resolution. As there are not enough thermal image datasets and the few available ones are in low resolution, a fusion network pre-trained to learn how to get a high-resolution RGB image from an image with a lower resolution is adopted to learn from thermal data for faster and better superresolution. This is consistent with the studies by Choi et al. [41] that demonstrated RGB-guided networks to show good enhancement. Figure 4 shows a visual comparison of the results using the superresolution algorithm. See Figure S5 in the ESM for the representative images acquired using a visible camera. The results of superresolution images in three bands were evaluated using a no-reference image metric, Naturalness Image Quality Evaluator (NIQE) [42]. The images illustrate that algorithmic enhancement of the resolution contributes to the recovery of fine details by improving the signal quality. Note that human features like nose and fingers are better distinguishable in the superresolution image of a human holding a coffee. We applied our algorithm to the multispectral image of an in-house electronic nose with nine gas sensors integrated on a PCB board (Figure 4). Superresolution images of the electronic nose enhanced the visibility to identify the discrete sensors that are heated to a constant temperature. These images have a slight specular noise even after flatfield correction due to high Ge reflectivity at room temperature. As the temperature increases, specular noise is suppressed, and edges are reconstructed efficiently with less pixelation. The superresolution efficiency could be further increased to retrieve more accurate details by introducing the RGB information using a visible camera alongside a thermal multispectral camera, or by acquiring the target scene in time-series continuously with a thermal spectral camera at the expense of frame rate.
Taken together, the deep learning enabled LWIR multispectral imager with plasmonic MHA and the monochrome camera is a practical and cost-efficient solution. In addition, we were able to use the camera to acquire the fine spectral features of a target in the scene which weren’t visible with a monochrome camera. Therefore, we have provided proof of concept for the LWIR multispectral imager with plasmonic filters. These plasmonic filters with resonant hexagonal MHAs can be easily fabricated in a fast, up-scalable method with one patterning-coating cycle followed by metal-dielectric deposition for any number of spectral bands. Our fabrication-efficient design reduces complexity and scalability costs to suit imaging and other commercial large-area applications. Our design principle is scalable to multiple wavelengths in the thermal LWIR range or other regions of the electromagnetic spectrum with atmospheric transmittance to enable non-destructive spectral analysis. As mentioned previously, realizing plasmonic nanostructures with increased thermal sensitivity can improve wavelength selectivity. This could be achieved with a low-index dielectric layer like Barium Fluoride or Potassium Bromide instead of Germanium, or other metal films like Copper and Nickel. Spatial multiplexing of several spectral filters into a single filter mosaic by varying pitch size (lateral periodicity) can further increase the spectral resolution; several joint demosaicing and superresolution algorithms can be implemented to recover missing information with finer details. Nanooptoelectronics and deep learning can thus be combined to recover rich thermal spectral information. More importantly, such a low-cost hyperspectral thermal LWIR camera enables advanced imaging and spectroscopy applications.