In this study, the variation rate of left superior pulmonary artery system was the highest in both pulmonary arteries. Cory and Valentine[8] assessed the anatomical variation of pulmonary artery tree in 426 patients between 1955 and 1959. 513 patients underwent anatomical pneumonectomy. They analyzed 524 pulmonary lobes or pulmonary arterial and vascular systems in detail. They observed 29 variant types of arteries through 107 resections of the left upper lobe of the lung. They believed that there were almost no real arterial types in the left upper lobe of the lung and that there were 2–7 vessels in the number of arteries, just like the result of Table 2, we found 43 types of arteries in 200 cases of three-dimensional reconstruction of left superior pulmonary artery. The total number of types 3, 5, 10 and 13 accounted for 42.5% (n = 85), which was similar to the results of Cory and Valentine's study. There were almost no real arterial types in left superior pulmonary lobe. Maciejewski[9] studied 100 pairs of stained, injected or corroded cast lungs in 1900 and described the characteristics of the left superior pulmonary artery. He believed that the left superior pulmonary artery was mostly supplied by four arteries (49%). Just like the result of Table 3, our results were consistent with that (50.5%). Fourdrain[10] Through three-dimensional reconstruction of the arteries by CT angiography in 44 patients who underwent surgery, it was found that the lingual segmental artery was supplied by two common arteries (77.3%), which was different from our results (61.5%) and by two separate lingual arteries (37%). We also observed three lingual arteries (n = 3). We observed that the lingual artery (24%) with mediastinal origin (originating from the anterolateral wall of the first artery in the left upper lobe of the lung) was more common than Fourdrain (15.9%). This lingual artery was the only source of the lingual segment (11%) than Fourdrain (2.3%).
The arterial system of the left inferior lobe is simpler than that of the left upper lobe. Cory and Valentine[8] found four main types of arteries in the left lower lobe of the lung. The main types of arteries were one apical segment artery and two common trunk basilar arteries. Eight types of arteries were observed in the left lower lobe. We observed that four basilar arteries (n = 2) could be separated from the left lower lobe basilar artery trunk, and extended from the upper lingual artery to the basilar artery (n = 1).
Fourdrain[10] observed the presence of one superior segment artery (65.9%), two superior segments (27.3%) and three superior segments (6.8%) and the occurrence rate of one superior segment artery (79.5%) was more common than Fourdrain. The occurrence rate of two (19.5%) and three (1%) superior arteries was lower than that of Fourdrain. For basilar artery, we observed two common trunks of basilar artery (anterolateral trunk and posterolateral trunk) accounting for 52.5%, which was similar to the result of Fourdrain (50%). The occurrence rate of three basilar arteries (17%) was less common than that of Fourdrain (50%).
We chose to use the terms Cabrol and Corner for the right superior lobe arterial system. The first artery of the right pulmonary artery is usually called the mediastinal artery of the right upper lobe. It has a strict mediastinal origin. The main reason is that the right pulmonary artery originates from the left ventricle, which leads to a longer walking path in the mediastinum. The French Encyclopedia of Surgery describes the anatomical structure of the right pulmonary artery tree as follows: one mediastinal artery, one or two middle lobe arteries, the upper and basal segments of the right lower lobe (the right lower lobe is divided into four segments). Murota[11] used three-dimensional reconstruction of pulmonary artery tree and MPR imaging to make the recognition rate of pulmonary artery branches of right superior pulmonary artery 97.2% and 99.7% respectively.
In our study, there were 24 types of arteries in the right upper lobe of the lung. Because two types of arteries accounted for 78%, i.e. one mediastinal artery and one dorsal mediastinal artery, the main difference between different types of arteries was the different segments of the branches of the mediastinal artery. In addition to the mediastinal artery, 78% (n = 156) had one additional artery, which was similar to the result of Fourdrain (70.5%). In addition, there were two or three additional arteries. We found that the superior lobe artery originating from the dorsal side of the plane of the right middle lobe could supply both anterior, posterior or bifurcated segments simultaneously. We also observed the co-trunking of the superior right lower lobe artery with this artery.
Right middle lobe pulmonary artery
The supply of the right middle lobe artery was relatively fixed, similar to that described by Fourdrain and Corey and Valentine, with two segmental middle lobe arteries or a common middle lobe artery. Cory and Valentine found five types of arteries in the right middle lobe of the lung, of which 49% (n = 25) were supplied by two middle lobe arteries and 45% (n = 23) were supplied by one single middle lobe artery. Six types of arteries were observed in the middle lobe of the right lung. Two middle lobe arteries (64%) were more frequently supplied than Cory and Fourdrain (54.5%). The supply of one middle lobe artery (30.5%) was less than that of Cory and Fourdrain (45.5%). We also observed three middle lobe arteries (n = 10) and the middle lobe arteries (n = 1) from the basilar artery, which were consistent with the findings of Cory and Valentine.
5.5 Right inferior pulmonary artery
The right inferior pulmonary lobe artery is divided into upper segment artery and basilar artery. Cory and Valentine found six types of arteries. We observed seven types of arteries. The difference between right inferior pulmonary artery types was the number of vessels in the upper and basilar arteries. In our study with Cory and Valentine, the vasculature of the right lower lobe is similar, in most cases, to a superior inferior lobe artery and a basilar artery trunk (two or three basilar arteries separated). It is difficult to compare the vasculature of basal segments in different anatomical studies. Maciejewski[12 13]and others described the "dense" division of the four segmental arteries and the gradual "dendritic" division of the arteries supplying the basal segments. Cory and Valentine[8] describe only basal segmental arteries divided into two or three branches. We observed that 37% (n = 74) and 38% (n = 76) of the right inferior lobe basilar artery trunk were divided into anterior internal basilar artery trunk and posterolateral basilar artery trunk, which was similar to the results of Fourdrain's study. We observed that dense or progressive dendritic division accounted for 16.5% (n = 33). At the same time, we also found that there were arteries extending from the superior segment to the basal segment (n = 9); the superior inferior segment artery and the superior segment artery located on the back of the middle lobe artery plane (n = 8); we first observed that there were additional posterior segment arteries (n = 9) at the bifurcation of the basal trunk, which were divided into four types of basilar artery. When there are more than two upper segment arteries in the right lower lobe, the second upper segment arteries emit more than the bifurcation of the basal trunk (51.2%).
Although we try to minimize the errors through standardized operation and strict physician observation, there are still some limitations in our research: 1. The study of single-center samples may lack the representativeness of corresponding multi-centers; 2. The small number of samples leads to the enlargement of corresponding errors. So further research is still needed.