The study scope is a historical consecutive cohort analysis. After the study had been approved by the Ethics Committee for Research Project Analysis, the medical records of patients registered at this Sports Medicine Group (GME) of the Institute of Orthopedics and Traumatology of Hospital das Clínicas - Universidade de São Paulo, between 01/01/2002 and 31/12/2016 were analyzed. The study focused on the records of patients complaining of pubic pain of myotendinous etiology diagnosed by clinical examination and imaging exams, when requested, and submitted to surgical intervention. For proper diagnosis, a standardized clinical-radiological evaluation was applied. The patients who did not improve after clinical treatment underwent surgery, and then were followed up by the responsible researcher [12].
Inclusion criteria
a) Active professional or amateur athlete regularly registered at GME at the time of the complaint onset.
b) Age between 18 and 40 years old;
c) Chief complaint of pain or functional limitation in pubic symphysis region, restricting or preventing the athlete's sports performance;
d) Athletic pubalgia of Myotendinous etiology diagnosis in conformity with GME protocol;
e) Presence of pain in pubic symphysis and tendon region of adductor thigh musculature in clinical-radiological evaluation, functional limitation when running or kicking, without restricted hip mobility, no signs of shortening lower limbs in imaging exams, femoroacetabular impingement or occult inguinal hernia;
f) Medical treatment and physical therapy failure after, at least, three months;
g) Surgery undergone at the institution.
Non-inclusion criteria
a) Athletic pubalgia diagnosis not related to myotendinous etiology (eg, stress fractures, tumors, inguinal hernias, hip diseases);
b) Neurological lesions on dorsolumbar spine;
c) Previous muscle injuries in: abdominal, lumbar, pelvic (or abductor) or adductor musculatures;
d) Joint instability or previous knee ligament injury;
e) Shortening of one of the lower limbs greater than 1(one) cm;
f) Previous fractures of dorsal and lumbar spine, pelvis or lower limbs;
g) Previous pubic and / or inguinal surgeries;
h) Psychiatric disorders that may interfere with the understanding of the proposed treatment or its follow-up;
i) Active infection or previous infections in pubic region;
j) Cases resolved after non-surgical treatment;
Exclusion criteria
a) Treatment abandonment;
b) Infection not related to the performed surgical procedure;
c) Bone tumor;
d) Lower limb muscle injury intervening in rehabilitation process;
e) Fracture of the dorsal and lumbar spine, pelvis or lower limbs;
f) Death not connected to intervention or loss of sequence before 6 months of follow- up.
A total of 52 cases met the inclusion criteria, 5 of them had incomplete medical 109 records, and 2 had no medical records. 45 patients underwent surgery from 2002 to 2016 110 111 and were included in this historical cohort.
Clinical criteria used for athletic pubalgia diagnosis
To reach diagnosis, clinical examinations were performed in all patients by the researcher in charge of GME ambulatory care [8,13].
The examinations included:
a) Inspection and palpation of the pubic symphysis in search for local or irradiated pain;
b) Measurement of lower limbs. Shortening lower than 1 (one) cm were not considered for non-inclusion;
c) Active, passive and resistance muscle maneuvers: iliopsoas, rectus abdominis, abdominal oblique, transverse abdominis, adductors, and hip abductors;
d) Research of hips and lumbar spine movement amplitude;
e) FADIR and FABER tests [14].
f) Inspection and palpation of the inguinal ligament region, followed by Valsalva maneuver to detect inguinal hernia;
g) Grava Maneuver [11].
h) Squeeze test [15].
The cases with pain complaints during direct palpation of the pubic symphysis and adductor muscles tendon along the symphysis were considered eligible for surgical treatment. So were those who tested positive for the Grava's Maneuver and Squeeze test. When a clinical examination was deemed insufficient for proper diagnosis, additional exams were requested.
The time to return to sport was obtained by comparing the date of the operation with the date of release for training. The date of the athlete's first unrestricted training was used as the definition of return to sport. The etiology was defined as being secondary to trauma occurring in sports activity or unrelated to trauma. Also, only infiltration performed with glucocorticoids in information collected from medical records of the GME were considered.
Imaging exams
Radiography
Radiography Radiographs were taken from the pelvis anteroposterior (AP) projection in dual support position and flamingo view (AP radiographs of the pubic symphysis alternating double-and single-leg stance positions on the right and left legs). Dunn, Lequesne or cross table incidences were also used when needed [16-19].
Ultrasonography
A 9-13 MHz linear transducer ultrasound examination was performed [20-22]. Concomitantly, the patient was evaluated with and without Valsalva maneuver.
Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI)
MRI was performed using two 1.5 T magnets (Aera, Siemens and HDX, General Electric Medical Systems). MRI sections and measurements are described in table 1.
Table 1 - Standardization of performed imaging exams
Radiography
|
AP projection of the pelvis in dual support: search for signs of hip impingement, discrepancies in limbs length, sacroiliac alterations, and other alterations with no clinical suspicion;
|
Flamingo view: pelvic instability.
|
Ultrasonography
|
Dynamic evaluation of true inguinal, femoral and sports hernias.
|
Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI)
|
- At least one T1-weighted sequence: morphological structural evaluation, bone marrow infiltrative processes (infection, tumors, etc.);
|
- Sagittal T2-weighted sequence with fat suppression (including femoral head): evaluation of labral lesions and rectus abdominis/adductor longus aponeurosis injuries.
|
- Coronal/axial T2-weighted sequence with fat suppression: bone (pubic osteitis) and soft parts edema, muscle and tendon injuries, rectus abdominis/adductor longus aponeurosis injuries, and other pelvic alterations;
|
- Oblique, axial, T2-weighted sequence: rectus abdominis muscle attachment and muscles origins of the adductor compartment;
|
- Coronal T2-weighted sequence with fat suppression (large FOV): reveals other conditions manifesting inguinal pain.
|
Isokinetic evaluation of the hip
The isokinetic tests were performed on the dynamometer (Biodex System 3 Pro® manual, 2014) of the GME Movement Study Laboratory.
SURGICAL TECHNIQUE
Patients were operated in supine frog-leg position with lower limbs in abduction, hips in lateral rotation, knee flexed and feet plantar lined and tape-fixed to the operating table. A 5cm thick squab cushion was placed below the patient's sacrum in order to lift the pubic symphysis, as shown in figure 1.
1) A Pfannenstiel-type median transverse incision about 10cm long is made directly over the pubic bone; figure 2.
2) After dissecting the subcutaneous planes, the spermatic cords are located and isolated;
3) As the pyramidalis muscle is identified, a transverse incision is made over the pubic symphysis using an electric scalpel;
4) The pubic symphysis is identified by placing a thick bevel needle (30x9cm) inside it to ensure its correct location and serve as anatomic and symmetric parameters for the procedures performed (figure 3).
5) After opening the fascia, the superficial portion of the rectus abdominis tendon is located, extending from the anterior pubis to the inguinal ligament. A prior disinsertion is done with the use of electrocautery, being careful to preserve both inferior and posterior pubic ligaments;
6) After the disinsertion, approximately 2cm of the proximal portion of the tendon is detached; (figure 4)
7) The same incision allows the bilateral visualization of the long adductor muscle tendon.
8) After opening the peri-tendon, a tendon hook is applied to separate the long adductor tendon from its muscle portion and other adjacent muscles; (figure 5)
9) Tenotomy with electric scalpel is performed while the assistant abducts the hip by pushing the ipsilateral knee down. The same procedure is performed on the contralateral tendon;
10) A meticulous hemostasis of the incision and dissection planes are made, as well as an exhaustive cleaning with saline. Subcutaneous planes and skin were closed after placement of a 3.2mm deep aspiration drain. The wound was occluded with a compressive dressing.
STATISTICAL ANALYSIS
Data was obtained from patients’ medical records and stored on an Excel® spreadsheet for MAC, for statistical analysis purposes. The spreadsheet was exported to 197 SPSS 23® for MAC.
Descriptive statistics was used for data analysis of all ordinal sample values (quantitative): mean, standard deviation, mean standard error, maximum value, minimum value, number of cases, plus absolute and relative frequency distribution (percentage) of nominal sample values (qualitative).
Categorical data was described based on their frequency and respective percentage of the total sample. Continuous data was mean-based, with 95% confidence interval, standard deviation, median, interquartile range, amplitude, minimum and maximum values, and all data was tested for normality distribution as per Shapiro-Wilk test.
The primary outcome was athletes’ return-to-sport time. The chosen time unit was the day, and the outcome was compared to several categories of sample collected by independent sampling. Moreover, the outcome was tested by a multiple linear regression model with (hypothetical) variables age, player position and time of symptoms’ existence, which are regarded as possible prognostic predictors. The accepted value for statistically significant difference was 5%.