The study established a novel aged obese rat model which exhibited certain clinical features reminiscent of humans SO and sets the basis for further studies into the disorder. The animal model exhibited certain clinical, histological, and etiological phenotypes of human sarcopenia, accompanied with elevated intra-muscular and visceral fat accumulation. In addition, aged obese rats showed a series of glucose and lipid metabolism disorders, as well as insulin resistance, which have also been observed in humans with SO.
1. Similarities Of The Model With Human Sarcopenia
Sarcopenia is defined as a progressive decline in skeletal muscle mass and function with ageing[13]. In the latest definition and diagnostic consensus for sarcopenia by the European Working Group on Sarcopenia in Older People, low muscle strength, which is the most reliable measure of muscle function, became a primary parameter of sarcopenia[14]. Hence, muscle mass and strength are key indicators for the diagnosis of sarcopenia in human beings[14]. In the present study, obese 20-month-old rats exhibited decreased quadriceps CSA/BW and forelimb grip strength with age, which is in accordance with the sarcopenia phenotype in humans. It is worth noting that the quadriceps CSA assessed by MRI of the 20-month old rats fed a HFD was elevated compared with age-matched rats receiving a standard diet in our study, and there was a close positive correlation between weight gain and increment of the quadriceps CSA. Kob et al. reported similar results in a female rat sarcopenia model induced by a HFD[15]. We speculated that the gain in skeletal muscle CSA due to the increment in body weight might be extraordinary muscle changes that occur in the context of obesity. In line with this finding, a study reported that 12 weeks of high-fat feeding increased muscle fibre area in young mice[16]. Several studies have also reported a larger diameter of muscle fibres in human obese adults[7]. In the current study, an increased myofibre CSA was also noted in aged obese rats.
The histological parameters for sarcopenia are not standardised in humans, but fatty infiltration, fibrosis, and inflammatory cell infiltration are probably the most obvious histological phenotypes that need to be considered when defining muscle pathology in sarcopenia[17]. Ramy et al. reported that aged female wild-type C57/BL6 mice exhibited enhanced connective tissue infiltration, reduced capillary density, and reduced myofibre numbers in the gastrocnemius muscle[18]. Merritt et al. verified that chronic inflammation induced by various factors in ageing reduced muscle strength and function by increasing macrophage infiltration into skeletal muscle in ageing humans[19]. Furthermore, excessive apoptosis in skeletal muscle cells leads to increased degradation of muscle proteins, resulting in sarcopenia[20]. Our results showed that the aged obese rats showed reduced number of myofibres accompanied by enhanced connective tissue and inflammatory cell infiltrations, which are in line with the histological phenotype of sarcopenia, and that the apoptotic index of myocytes in the quadriceps was pronounced, which is identical to the pathological features of SO.
It is generally accepted that changes in mitochondrial structure and dysfunction have been identified as core mechanisms in skeletal muscle ageing and sarcopenia[21] and as candidate molecular markers of the condition[22]. In addition, peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor γ coactivator-1α (PGC-1α) may be a major regulator of mitochondrial biogenesis in age-dependent reduction in mitochondrial mass[23]. In the present study, a TEM study reported a large number of swollen mitochondria, and a decrease in IFM number accompanied by reduced plasma PGC-1α levels in the quadriceps muscle of aged obese rats compared to that in non-obese aged animals. Together with the results reported here, our model is compatible with sarcopenia in humans. Yasuda et al.[24] and Ramy et al.[18] reported similar results in aged Saenorhabditis elegans and mice. Previous studies have verified that muscle mitochondrial function or number in skeletal muscle is reduced as people age[25, 26] and plays a role in the onset of sarcopenia in humans[21].
Moreover, our study elucidated the effects of age on muscle mass and grip strength by comparing changes in muscle parameters between 12- and 2-month-old rats that received a standard diet for 28 weeks. Relatively old rats (20-month-old) showed typical ageing phenotypes as follows: decreased quadriceps CSA/BW and forelimb grip strength, a reduction in CSA and number of myofibres, increased apoptosis of myocytes, accompanied by swollen mitochondria, and decreased IFM and PGC-1α levels. Overall, these results are consistent with the inevitable deterioration of skeletal muscle cell structure and biological function with age increased[27]. Interestingly, these indicators were even more prominent in obese aged rats in the present study, which could be explained by the fact that ageing is accompanied by a progressive decline in skeletal muscle mass, strength, and function, which may be accelerated in some elderly people in the context of obesity.
In summary, the state of sarcopenia induced by age and HFD in middle-aged rats in the current study represents certain clinical, histological, and etiological phenotypes of human sarcopenia.
2. Similarities Of The Model With Human So
SO is characterised by a combination of obesity and sarcopenia[28]. It is a unique clinical condition owing to negative clinical interactions between sarcopenia and obesity, leading to a synergistically higher risk of metabolic disease and functional impairment[29, 30]. Therefore, the criteria for successful SO animal models should include at least the basic features of sarcopenia and obesity, as well as the metabolic disorder and functional impairments produced by a synergy of both conditions.
In the obese aged rats in our study, body weight gain and a pronounced increase in body fat ratio were found, and fat accretion was mainly observed in the intramuscular and visceral anatomies. The increased intra-muscular fat within the quadriceps muscle correlated well with the sarcopenia model reported by Fellner et al.[11]. Garcia-Contreras et al. also reported visceral fat accumulation in aged swine models of SO[9]. In addition, elevated intramuscular and visceral fat have also been observed in humans with SO[7]. Based on these findings, we verified that the aged obese rats in our study presented the typical fat distribution features of SO. Furthermore, we noted a pronounced negative correlation between forelimb grip strength and visceral fat content in rats. Pasdar et al. also reported a strong relationship between hand grip strength and visceral fat in a cohort study of the population, which was significant in both sexes (p < 0.001)[31]. Previous studies have reported that visceral fat might impair muscle strength through various mechanisms, such as lipotoxicity[32], chronic inflammatory activation[33], and IR[34]. From these results, it is clear that an excessive amount of visceral fat tissue could be a probable contributor to the accelerated loss of muscle strength. It may also be a pathological manifestation of SO[29].
Aging-related increases in visceral fat favour the development of dyslipidaemia and IR in humans[35]. In the present study, aged obese rats showed a cluster of metabolic disorders, such as abnormal glucose tolerance and hyperinsulinaemia, followed by dyslipidaemia. Meanwhile, the assessment of glycaemic indices in our study showed a higher HOMA-IR index, ISI, and lower HOMA-β index, suggesting the occurrence of IR in aged obese rats. Overall, these findings were in accordance with the findings reported in old Iberian swine with SO, which showed a series of glucose and lipid metabolism disorders, as well as IR[9]. A further novel finding was that the increase in plasma FFA levels in obese aged rats was the greatest and earliest change among the lipid profiles. A similar conclusion was reached by Laurentius et al., who verified that HFD-induced muscle loss in aged male SD rats was associated with more significant deposits of FFA and was further reinforced by long-term consumption of an HFD[36]. Previous studies have also confirmed that excessive serum FFA can be deposited in the viscera and muscles, causing muscle loss and fat accumulation through IR. As discussed, there were reasons to doubt that FFA might be an initiating factor for changes in body composition and IR associated with age-related muscle loss and fat accumulation. In summary, these results established that the aged obese rats represented certain metabolic features of SO in humans.
Furthermore, it is worth noting that SO could be considered a unique clinical condition, different from sarcopenia or obesity alone[28]. Several previous studies have reported that SO causes greater deterioration of healthy lifespan than sarcopenia alone [4, 5]. In the current study, by comparing muscle parameters and metabolic indices in obese and non-obese aged rats, we found that aged obese rats exhibited remarkable glycolipid metabolic disorders and IR, compatible with a more prominent loss of muscle mass and muscle strength, whereas in aged non-obese rats, no glycolipid metabolic disorders were present, although a decrease in muscle mass and strength was observed. In summary, the aged obese rats in our study represent the special clinical state of human SO.
This study has some limitations. 1) Lack of gender control: There are significant gender differences in fat distribution between rats and humans, and female rats receiving a high-calorie diet showed resistance to IR and muscle loss compared to male counterparts[37]. Therefore, female animals should be included in future studies. 2) There is still a lack of reports on the diagnostic cut-off point for animal SO. This potential limitation is apparent in many studies, and we should attempt to overcome it in the future.