We identified 3,946 people with a first diagnosis of Spinal Muscular Atrophy and Related Syndromes (G12) from 2015 to 2018, of which 3,447 were excluded for lack of medical records 1 year prior to and 1 years after the index diagnosis. The remained 480 people with ALS (G12.2) and 400 non-ALS patients, hitting a total of 880 people (Figure 1) as the study population, were matched by age, gender, ethnic group, geographic region, length of stay, year of diagnosis.
Demographic characteristics
The mean ± S.D. (range) age of ALS patients in our study was 57.37 ± 15.09 (7-92) years old at the index date. Male or female patients accounted for 61.88% or 38.12%, respectively. We depicted demographic factors including gender, age, ethnic group, marital status, pre-admission conditions, blood type (ABO & Rh), insurance type among ALS patients and matched controls (Table 1). Interestingly, in terms of ABO blood type, type-O took the highest proportion, 20.21% in ALS groups, in contrast to a mere 7.00% in control groups. As rare blood types, proportions of Rh negative in ALS patients (10.63%) were far higher than that of the controlled cases (0.50%).
Medical costs in ALS
Within the specific three-character category G12, we compared the number of patients and corresponding medical cost between its subcategories, where G12.2 (motor neuron disease) took the largest proportion of the medical expenses, 12,852 CNY (Fig. 2-A). Further, we carried out an analysis on geographical characteristics of ALS patients via their birthplace codes in county areas in China, which showed that major ALS patients came from Shaanxi (65), Chongqing (44), Hebei (37), Shandong (28), Jiangsu (23), Sichuan (21) (Fig. 2-B). As for medical cost per patient, Guizhou, Guangdong, Henan reported higher medical cost than the rest provinces and regions, with a total of 117,665 CNY, 85,040 CNY, and 69,281 CNY, respectively (Fig. 2-C).
Figure 2D shows the annual total medical costs per patient among ALS patients and controlled patients during peri-diagnosis period (1 year before versus 1 year post). The median cost of ALS patients was about two-fold higher 17,087 CNY (Interquartile Range (IQR) 8,623 CNY - 41,584 CNY), during the index year than 1 year before, 7,859 CNY (IQR 2,477 CNY - 25,703 CNY). We further investigated the annual cost of following medical insurance system UE, URR, FMC or SPMC. Specifically, the median cost of medical care increased highest at SPMC groups, by 3.41-fold during the year following ALS diagnosis, from 7,633 CNY (IQR 2,646 CNY - 19,291 CNY) to 26,083 CNY (IQR 7,232 CNY - 63,241 CNY) the year after diagnosis. The average cost for UE, URR or FMC increased by 2.29, 1.86, or 1,51-fold respectively (Figure 2E). For reference, the annual healthcare cost of non-ALS controls was almost constant between 1 year before (17,676 CNY (IQR 9,518 CNY - 42,856 CNY)) and 1 year post 17,498 CNY (IQR 8,909 CNY - 38,495 CNY) (Figure 2D). We further analyzed the structure of medical cost for ALS patients, where drug cost took up a large proportion of the medical expenses, with median of drug cost climbing from 3,615 CNY (IQR 929 CNY - 10,410 CNY) to 7,709 CNY (IQR 3,098 CNY - 22,207 CNY) during the year after diagnosis. In comparison, the consultation fee increased, about 11-fold, from 305 CNY (IQR 188 CNY - 623 CNY) to 3,400 CNY (IQR 1,700 CNY - 6,600 CNY) (Figure 2F), highest among all the factors.
Healthcare utilization in ALS
On the basis of estimating medical cost, we further determined healthcare utilization parameters at the index date and 1 year before, respectively. Compared with the year prior to the index date, utilization parameters, like hospitalizations, EMG, NCV, MRI, increased markedly during the following year among ALS patients, which were not observed in controlled group. The largest increase in utilization(cumulative events) for ALS patients was hospitalizations, 4.67-fold, followed by EMG, 4-fold, NCV, 2.77-fold. The OR and 95% Confidence Interval (CI) for hospitalizations, EMG, NCV or MRI were 4.26 (3.52, 5.15), 4.14 (2.37, 7.22), 3.26 (2.23, 4.77), or 2.29 (1.77, 2.95) respectively. However, imaging tests and ultrasound showed minimal increase (OR=0.83, 95% CI 0.68, 1.00) (Table 2).
Figure 3 demonstrates the utilization ratio among URR, UE, FMC or SPMC patients with ALS compared with matched controls. Patients experienced large increase of hospitalizations for UE (6.23-fold) and SPMC (6.60-fold) patients, but relatively mild increase for URR (2.84-fold), FMC (2.18-fold) 1 year after ALS diagnosis when compared with 1 year prior to indexed date. As vital ALS diagnosis tools, URR, UE, FMC or SPMC patients with ALS reported 3.29, 5.97, 4.67, or 2.79-fold increase of EMG tests, 4.38, 4.22, 4.00, or 2.72 increase of NCV tests, respectively.
v