Isolation of CO2-requiring mutants KO-60 and KO-62
To obtain mutants defective in the induction of the CCM, we constructed a mutant library and isolated CO2-requiring mutants, such as the cas mutant H82, which could not grow under CO2-limiting conditions. First, we constructed a random insertional mutant library by transforming a wild-type (WT) strain, C9, with an aphVII cassette conferring hyg-resistance, yielding ~72,000 transformants. Next, because the mutant H82 showed a significantly reduced growth rate under LC conditions with air containing 0.04% (v/v) CO2 (Wang et al., 2016), we evaluated the growth rate of the mutants on agar plates under LC conditions as a first screening and selected two strains, KO-60 and KO-62.
To further evaluate the growth under multiple CO2-acclimated conditions, growth of C9, H82, KO-60 and KO-62 under 5% CO2, 0.04% CO2 or 0.01% CO2 conditions was examined at pH 6.2 (HCO3–/CO2 = 0.71), 7.0 (HCO3–/CO2 = 4.46), 7.8 (HCO3–/CO2 = 28.18) and 9.0 (HCO3–/CO2 = 446.68) (Fig. 1a). Under 5% CO2 conditions, there were no significant differences in growth rates among strains. In contrast, under LC conditions, growth rates of KO-60 and KO-62 were reduced at pH 6.2, 7.0, and 7.8 and severely reduced at pH 9.0. Furthermore, under VLC conditions, KO-60 and KO-62 showed severely reduced growth at all tested pH conditions, as was the case for H82.
To evaluate the induction of the CCM under LC conditions, the photosynthetic affinity for Ci was evaluated by measuring the rates of photosynthetic oxygen (O2) evolution. The K0.5 (Ci) values, the Ci concentrations required for half of the maximal rate of O2-evolving activity (Vmax), in KO-60 (554 ± 130 µM) and KO-62 (471 ± 40 μM) cells were 4.4 and 3.7 times higher than that of C9 cells (126 ± 34 µM) at pH 9.0, respectively (Fig. 1b). Even at pH 6.2, 7.0 and 7.8, the K0.5 (Ci) values of KO-60 and KO-62 were over 1.5 times higher than that of C9 cells. The K0.5 (Ci) values of H82 cells were also higher than those of C9 cells at all tested pH conditions (Wang et al., 2016). At pH 6.2, 7.0, and 7.8, the Vmax of KO-60 and KO-62 were 69–84% of that of C9 (Fig 1c). At pH 9.0, the Vmax of KO-60 and KO-62 were 47–61% of that of C9. These results showed that both KO-60 and KO-62 had reduced Ci-affinity and Vmax. On the other hand, the Vmax of H82 cells is not significantly different from C9 at any pH condition (Wang et al., 2016). These results showed that KO-60 and KO-62 had reduced Ci-affinity regardless of pH conditions.
Protein levels of Ci transporters decreased in KO-60 and KO-62
To elucidate the cause of the impaired growth and reduced Ci-affinity of KO-60 and KO-62, we examined the accumulation levels of CCM-related proteins – including Ci-transporters (HLA3, LCIA, and LCI1), CAs (LCIB, CAH1, and CAH3), and regulatory factors (CCM1 and CAS) – in C9, ccm1-2 (a newly generated ccm1 mutant with a C9 background made using the CRISPR/Cas9 system; Fig. S1a-c), H82, KO-60, and KO-62. CCM1 and CAS were not detected in ccm1-2 and H82, respectively, and CAH3 was detected in all strains.
After shifting conditions from HC to LC, C9 induced the accumulation of HLA3, LCIA, LCI1, LCIB, and CAH1, while ccm1-2 showed little or markedly reduced accumulation. On the other hand, KO-60 and KO-62 showed little accumulation of HLA3, LCIA, and LCI1 as in the case of H82, even though CAS was accumulated at the same level as in C9 (Fig. 2a).
To determine the insertion site of the aphVII cassette in KO-60 and KO-62, thermal asymmetric interlaced (TAIL)-PCR was performed. In KO-60 and KO-62, the aphVII cassette was inserted in the 10th and 15th intron of the SAGA1 gene, respectively (Supplemental Fig. S1d and e). To confirm that SAGA1 is defective in KO-60 and KO-62, we examined the number of pyrenoids in C9, KO-60, and KO-62 cells by introducing a plasmid expressing Venus-tagged Rubisco small subunit 1 (RBCS1-Venus). Although a single fluorescent signal was observed in the C9 background, multiple fluorescent signals were observed in KO-60 and KO-62 background cells (Supplemental Fig. S1f), as in the case of the original saga1 mutant (Itakura et al., 2019), indicating that KO-60 and KO-62 were loss-of-function mutants of SAGA1.
Next, to further investigate whether the reduced accumulation of Ci transporters was due to the SAGA1 disruption, we also examined the accumulation of the above CCM-related proteins in the original saga1 mutant (Itakura et al., 2019). As in the case of KO-60 and KO-62, HLA3, LCIA, and LCI1 were not accumulated in saga1 compared to the parental strain, CC-5325. Furthermore, the complemented strain recovered the accumulation of these Ci transporters (Fig. 2b), suggesting that changes in pyrenoid morphology due to the disruption of SAGA1 are responsible for the reduced accumulation of Ci-transporters.
Decrease in the mRNA levels of CCM1-dependent genes in the saga1 mutants
To examine the effect of pyrenoid morphological changes caused by the SAGA1 mutation on nuclear gene expression, C9, KO-60, CC-5325, saga1, and complementary strain cells were cultured while bubbling with ordinary air for 2 h, and the respective transcriptome profiles were compared by RNA-seq analyses. Comparison of the transcriptomes of C9 and KO-60, and CC-5325 and saga1, showed that the expression levels of 2,288 and 3,633 genes, respectively, were significantly reduced (FDR [false discovery rate] < 0.01; Figs. 3 and S2a). Of the genes down-regulated as a result of SAGA1 mutations in KO-60 and saga1, 532 were recovered in the saga1 complemented strain (Supplemental Dataset S1).
To assess whether changes in pyrenoid morphology in saga1 mutants affect the expression of CCM-related genes, we compared the 532 genes down-regulated in KO-60 and saga1 but recovered in the complemented strain with those that are induced under CO2-limiting conditions and regulated by CCM1/CIA5 (Fang et al., 2012). The expression levels of 41 CCM1-dependent genes were decreased in KO-60 and saga1 (Table 1). In particular, among the 13 genes regulated by CAS (Wang et al., 2016), the expression levels of 10 genes (HLA3, LCIA, LHCSR3.1, LHCSR3.2, CAH4, CAH5, CCP1, CCP2, LCID, and DNJ31) decreased in both KO-60 and saga1 and recovered in the saga1 complemented strain (Fig. 3). The expression of LCI1 was not significantly reduced in KO-60 but was reduced in saga1 and recovered in the complemented strain. These results indicate that the changes in pyrenoid morphology caused by the SAGA1 mutation affect the expression of most CAS-dependent genes.
In addition to CAS-dependent genes, CCM1-regulated LCIE and DNJ15 were also downregulated more than four-fold. LCIE is a homolog of LCIB (Yamano et al., 2010) and DNJ15 has a domain that acts as a chaperone that may interact with LCIB and LCIC (Mackinder et al., 2017).
Next, focusing on genes with upregulated expression in the saga1 mutants, we compared the transcriptomes of C9 and KO-60, and CC-5325 and saga1, and found that the expression levels of 2,352 and 3,725 genes were significantly induced in KO-60 and saga1, respectively (Fig. S2b). Of the genes upregulated in the saga1 mutants KO-60 and saga1, 570 were recovered in the saga1 complemented strain (Supplemental Dataset S2). When comparing those 570 genes with CCM1/CIA5-dependent genes, the expression levels of STA2, BST1, and BST2 were increased in KO-60 and saga1. STA2 is localized in the starch sheath (Mackinder et al., 2017), and pyrenoid morphology is altered in the sta2 mutant (Delrue et al., 1992). BST1 and BST2 are anion channels localized in the thylakoid membrane close to the pyrenoid (Mukherjee et al., 2019).
CAS and LCIB were dispersed throughout the chloroplast in the saga1 mutants
Given that CAS-dependent gene expression was impaired in the saga1 mutants and that CAS re-localizes into the pyrenoid upon CCM induction, abnormal pyrenoid formation may affect CAS localization. To test this hypothesis, we examined CAS localization in the saga1 mutants using an indirect immunofluorescence assay. Previous studies showed that CAS dispersed throughout the chloroplast stroma moves to the pyrenoid along the pyrenoid tubules under CO2-limiting conditions (Yamano et al., 2018). In C9, CC-5325, and the complemented strain, CAS was localized inside the pyrenoid as a distinct wheel-like structure, whereas in KO-60 and saga1, CAS was dispersed in the chloroplast (Figs. 4a and S3).
To assess the effect of abnormal pyrenoid formation on another pyrenoid peripheral protein, we also examined the localization of LCIB. Because the localization changes of LCIB are strictly controlled by CO2 concentration with ∼7 µM as the boundary (Yamano et al., 2022), the CO2 concentration in the medium was calculated with the observation of LCIB localization. Although LCIB was localized around the pyrenoid in C9, CC-5325, and the complemented strain during aeration with air containing 0.04 % (v/v) CO2 for 12 h, it was dispersed in the chloroplast in KO-60 and saga1 under VLC conditions (Figs. 4b and S4). These results suggest that the abnormal pyrenoid morphology caused by SAGA1 mutations impairs the localization of CAS and LCIB under CO2-limiting conditions, resulting in defective CAS-dependent expression of CCM-related genes and a reduced Ci-affinity due to the lack of LCIB-based capture of CO2 leaking from the pyrenoid.