2.1. Study area
To assess the efficiency of the best management practices in Iran, 11 paired catchments were uniformly established across the country. Capturing natural processes and tradeoffs in the real world and pathways to control the surface runoff generation, enhance the groundwater systems and vegetation cover support along with soil conservation were the primary targets. The plausible results including from trend analysis across the mentioned sections will therefore apply to figure pathways to support the sustainability of a regional economy, ecology and society. The Heris Paired Catchments exemplify dynamics across a larger region located in Maragheh city territory, the southwest altitudes of Sahand Mountain, north-western of Iran served as case study in this research (Figure. 1). The larger catchment, named the Representative, includes Heris Paired Catchments within. The Heris Paired Catchments involve two catchments with similar features in terms of topographic characteristics, climate condition, geographic location, and vegetation cover where the Treatment catchment is subjected to best management practice while the Control one remained under human activities.
The main topographic information of the studied catchments is presented in Table 1. Three hydrologic stations are embedded at the outlet of the individual catchments to record the water stage corresponding to the individual rainfall events (Fig. 1). Moreover, the catchments, paired catchments, benefit three sites to capture the soil erosion and each of them includes three Wishmayer-smith standard plots (Fig. 1). The soil loss from the ground surface along with the generated runoff volume are the two assessing parameters within the triple sites.
Table 1
Main topographic characteristics of the studied catchments
Factor
|
Catchment
|
Treatment
|
Control
|
Area (ha)
|
185
|
144
|
Elevation (m)
|
max
|
2350
|
2300
|
min
|
1939
|
1939
|
Perimeter (m)
|
8175
|
7058
|
Mean slope (%)
|
18.58
|
18.65
|
Main stream length (m)
|
2533.28
|
2081.75
|
Drainage Density (km/km2)
|
6.56
|
6
|
Table 2
The area of various land-use types across the basins
Land use
|
Area
|
Treatment
|
Control
|
(ha)
|
(%)
|
(ha)
|
(%)
|
Orchards
|
5.33
|
2.97
|
3.56
|
2.51
|
Dry farming
|
1.45
|
0.81
|
9.83
|
6.94
|
Rangeland
|
151.79
|
84.72
|
108.75
|
76.82
|
Bare soil
|
15.5
|
8.65
|
17.8
|
12.57
|
Flood path
|
5.1
|
2.85
|
1.62
|
1.14
|
Figure 2 illustrates the monthly precipitation distribution in the Heris Paired Catchments. According to this figure, the maximum and minimum precipitation occurred in February and August, respectively. According to the meteorological statistics obtained from the meteorological station, located adjusted to the basins as presented in Fig. 1, the catchments received approximately 430 mm annual average precipitation.
The land use map, developed by Google Earth Engine across the Heris Paired catchments in 2020, was presented in Fig. 3. Five land use types including orchards, dry farming, bare soil, flood path, and rangeland were detected across the catchments. According to this figure, the rangeland is the stretched land use types across both catchments where it covers approximately 84.72% and 76.82% of the whole Treatment and Control catchments, respectively (Table. 2). It is worth noting that socioeconomic development is currently undertaken in both catchments simultaneously.
2.2. Data
A distinct precipitation event time series along with the corresponding hydrologic captured data were used to assess the hydrologic behavior of the catchments and at the same time the effectiveness of the constructed biomechanical measures (check dams and vegetation intensification). Accordingly, the hydrologic response of the catchments was assessed related to the recently occurred precipitation event. Therefore, we applied precipitation data from the Heris meteorological station which was recorded regularly within 10-minute intervals. It is worth noting that the other 14 climatic parameters such as wind properties, temperature, soil moisture, air pressure, pan evaporation, and radiation rate are also recorded at this station. All the devices embedded in the meteorological station are electrical and manufactured by Lambrecht Company, Germany. Table 3 presents the properties of the studied precipitation event in terms of its intensity, duration, and amount.
Table 3
Properties of the studied precipitation event in terms of its intensity, duration, and amount
Date
|
Time (min)
|
Precipitation (mm)
|
08.01.2021
|
00:50 am
|
0.4
|
08.01.2021
|
01:00 am
|
0.3
|
08.01.2021
|
01:10 am
|
5.5
|
08.01.2021
|
01:20 am
|
2.3
|
08.01.2021
|
01:30 am
|
1.7
|
|
|
10.2
|
The recorded water stages at the Treatment and Control hydrologic stations were the second group of the applied data in this study. Since the biological components associated with the employed management approaches at a basin determine the basin potential in provisioning water and the volume of water that reaches the outlet (Shirmohammadi et al. 2020a), the recorded water stages data across the outlet of the catchments were considered as an indicator to measure the effectiveness of the best management practices in the Treatment basin compared to the control one which represents the catchment without management measures. However, the climatic condition is considerably drives the hydrologic process, the catchments here received the same precipitation because of their small area and similar geographic location. Therefore, the recorded water stage within 5-minute intervals across the hydrologic stations was applied as the indicator in this study. Moreover, we assessed the efficiency of the electronic stream gauges in capturing the hydrological behavior of catchments in surface runoff generation under a distinct precipitation event.
2.3. Paired catchments
The application of data-driven techniques is usually time-consuming and often requires a deep understanding of human-nature interactions as well as the hydrologic, biophysical, and topographical processes (Van Loon et al. 2019). These methods are developed to give an indication of pathways that the natural systems work and human activities affect their functions using limited data. To address these challenges, paired catchments approach has been developed to be connected with the observation-based methods. The paired catchments approach involves two catchments with similar features in terms of topographic characteristics, climate condition, geographic location, and vegetation cover where one of them is subjected to treatment while the other one remains under human activities. These methods enable researchers to assess the impacts of human-induced activities as well as the different management approaches on ecosystem delivery services (Zhao et al., 2017). This way the plausible mitigation measures will be practically accomplished and studied, therefore, it would result in adaptation strategies (Yazdi et al., 2018). For instance, hydrological analysis through paired catchments enables us to assess the effects of any disturbance in the flow regime (Bosch and Hewlett 1982; Li et al., 2019; Yuan et al., 2022) and soil erosion (Zhang et al., 2014; Yuan et al., 2019; Tang et al., 2020). This approach has been widely used to assess the effects of human-induced activities and treatment on hydrology (Best et al. 2003; Brown et al. 2005; Brown et al. 2013; Folton et al. 2015; Van Loon et al. 2019; Li et al., 2019; Yuan et al., 2022). Therefore, using paired catchment approach will likely result in the safe design, sustainable development, and support ecosystem services, maintain water supply and demand, soil conservation, enhanced groundwater system, flood control and figure out how current management approaches will hold up during natural disasters. It becomes exceedingly important in recent years since stream flow variation depicts the ecosystem's health, and low-impact and sustainable development (Shirmohammadi et al. 2020a,b).
Accordingly, the paired catchments have primarily developed in Iran to assess human activities as well as treatment effects on hydrology and soil erosion. Totally, 11 paired catchments in Iran were settled up in a way that they could be a good exemplifier of the whole country. While the challenges are still reminded mainly in terms of hydrology-related measurements, this study opened a new approach regarding the importance of the paired catchments. Accordingly, we went beyond looking at how the check dams along with vegetation intensification can incorporate disaster risk reduction and subsequently ecosystem sustainability into climate change adaptation.
2.4. Biomechanical measures
Assessing the effects of best management practices and approaches concerning ecosystem delivery services was the primary purpose of paired catchments establishment in Iran. Due to the extensive land use and climate changes the use of paired catchment will be an important approach to assess different mitigation strategies to fulfill human well-being and ecosystem sustainability simultaneously. Biomechanical measures including check dams along with vegetation intensification were the two assessed mitigation strategies to deal with the surface runoff generation mainly flood. It is worth noting that this assessment was conducted across paired catchments where one of them was subjected to treatment while the other one remained under human activities which were named as Treatment and Control catchments in this study, respectively. Since the Heris Paired Catchment is not calibrated yet, therefore the check dams along with vegetation intensification were the two accomplished measures in the Treatment catchment. Figure 4 shows the schematic comparison of the Heris Paired Catchments in terms of the implemented check dams in the Treatment catchment versus the Control one.
Check dams were constructed to deliver generated surface flow by a delay at the basin outlet however they probably reduced sediment load into the drainage system.